StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Case brefings on Mary Tiano vs Dillard store - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Dillard departmental stores had terminated the employment of one of employee, Mary Tiano, when she had gone on a ten days pilgrimage to Medjugorje, Yugoslavia. She had subsequently filed a case against them for religious discrimination under Title VII, 42 U.S.C. SS 2000e et seq…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.9% of users find it useful
Case brefings on Mary Tiano vs Dillard store
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Case brefings on Mary Tiano vs Dillard store"

ment of the fact Dillard departmental stores had terminated the employment of one of employee, Mary Tiano, when she had gone on a ten days pilgrimage to Medjugorje, Yugoslavia. She had subsequently filed a case against them for religious discrimination under Title VII, 42 U.S.C. SS 2000e et seq. on March 18, 1998 in San Francisco, California. The case was heard by the bench comprising of circuit judges Betty B. Fletcher, Charles Wiggins, and Pamela Ann Rymer. The judges found prima facie case of religious discrimination and ruled the case in favor of Mary Tiano.

They awarded Mary Tiano $16,445.65 in lost wages. Later, Dillards appealed the findings of religious discrimination which was later reversed. Issue The main issue of the case was termination of employment on the basis of religious discrimination whereby the Dillard Departmental Store did not find the need of Mary Tiano’s pilgrimage to Medjugorje, Yugoslavia as sufficient ground for legitimate leave of absence from work.Rule of law Title VII, 42 U.S.C. SS 2000e et seq. relates to the employment termination of an individual on the basis of their religious beliefs and states ‘to discharge any individual . . .

because of such individual’s . . . religion’ (S 2000e-2(a)(1)). Title VII also defines religion as ‘all aspects of religious observance and practice, as well as belief, unless an employer demonstrates that he is unable to reasonably accommodate to an employee’s or prospective employee’s religious observance or practice without undue hardship on the conduct of the employer’s business’ (S 2000e(j)). Analysis The case is relatively simple in its context as it involves just 3 main elements.

Firstly, the plaintiff, Mary Tiano was a bonafide employee of Dillard’s in 1988 who worked as salesperson in the women’s shoe department in its Park Central Mall, Arizona. She was a devout Roman Catholic which considerably influenced her life in general. Secondly, in 1988, the defendant, Dillard’s had an authorized policy of granting unpaid leave at management’s discretion. They also discouraged vacation leave during their peak season period between October and December and had specific vacation policy that particularly prohibited taking leave of absence during this time.

Thirdly, after a determination of religious discrimination was issued by the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, Mary Tiano had filed for damages under the said Title VII in the court of law. It can be argued that Dillard’s had basically denied leave because of its ‘no leave policy’ and also because it was not convinced of her urgency to meet her religious commitment or ‘pilgrimage’ at Medjugorje, Yugoslavia at that particular time only and in the case of any accommodation that would be made at that time, it would cause undue hardship to Dillard’s.

The plaintiff was awarded damages against the lost wages because Mary Tiano was unemployed for part of 1988 and through out the year 1989 as the plaintiff was employed from January 1990 onwards. In the review, charge of religious discrimination against Dillard’s was reversed because the court found that Mary Tiano had failed to prove the temporal mandate for religious discrimination. The district court had erred in establishing convincingly the temporal mandate which were based on Tiano’s statement that ‘she had to be there at that time’.

The review petition found that Tiano’s religious belief was limited to her going to Medjugorje on a pilgrimage, which could have been accommodated at a time other than this particular time which was the peak business time for Dillard’s. Therefore, it can be conclusively stated that there was no conflict of interest between the Tiano’s pilgrimage or religious beliefs and employment duties which were crucial ingredients of her prima facie case. Hence, the appeal for reversal of findings was upheld.

Conclusion I agree with the judgment and decisions made by the court basically because legally, Mary Tiano did not have a strong case of religious discrimination against Dillard’s and they were right in refusing to grant her leave at that particular time of the year because it was their busiest time and granting of leave would have caused them undue hardship as it did, eventually. She was justifiably awarded the damages for lost wages for the period of her unemployment.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Case brefings on Mary Tiano vs Dillard store Essay”, n.d.)
Case brefings on Mary Tiano vs Dillard store Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1547129-case-brefings-on-mary-tiano-vs-dillard-store
(Case Brefings on Mary Tiano Vs Dillard Store Essay)
Case Brefings on Mary Tiano Vs Dillard Store Essay. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1547129-case-brefings-on-mary-tiano-vs-dillard-store.
“Case Brefings on Mary Tiano Vs Dillard Store Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1547129-case-brefings-on-mary-tiano-vs-dillard-store.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Case brefings on Mary Tiano vs Dillard store

Dollar Tree - Store Concept in the United States

Dollar Tree case Study University Name Dollar Tree case Study Introduction Chains of discount stores have come and gone across America for decades.... case Challenge 1 The first challenge facing Dollar Tree rests in the reality that the company's initial growth was accomplished almost exclusively through acquisition.... case Challenge 2 Dollar Tree also faces the challenge moving forward of being able to continue to offer...
6 Pages (1500 words) Case Study

Wal-Mart Stores Discount Operations

The store managers had the liberty to set prices as compared to their counterparts that didn't have.... In the paper “Wal-Mart Stores' Discount Operations” the author answers the question: How historically has Wal-Mart been able to outperform its competitors?... Wal-mart has historically been able to outperform its competitors by applying outstanding measures of economies of scale....
3 Pages (750 words) Case Study

Internal Analysis of Wal-Mart

This paper studies the resources and capabilities of Wal-Mart the giant retail chain store and makes a report on how the company can take advantage of its internal strengths and the opportunities the industry offers.... Wal-Mart Stores is the number one retail store in the World in volume.... Com) The Company is the number one retail store in Canada and Mexico and owns 95 percent stakes in the largest Japanese retailer SEIYU.... he major complaint in the operation of the store is the increased average time that an...
6 Pages (1500 words) Case Study

Environment Management for Sustainable Development

The paper “Environment Management for Sustainable Development” seeks to evaluate Green Consultant, a non-governmental consultancy firm that deals with offering advice to firms and companies geared towards proper environmental planning and management activities.... hellip; The author states that over the years the firm has taken a deep interest in oil companies around the world with the intention of ensuring that these oil companies incorporate environmental management activities into their plans and programs....
10 Pages (2500 words) Case Study

Third Parties: The Wal-Mart Chain or Retail Store

A paper "Third Parties: The Wal-Mart Chain or Retail store" reports that the scandal involved the company's branch in Mexico, which hosts 1/5 of its stores worldwide.... hellip; This case study involves the scandal affecting one of the most successful companies in the world, The Wal-Mart chain or retail store.... Third Parties: The Wal-Mart Chain or Retail store This case study involves the scandal affecting one of the most successful companies in the world, The Wal-Mart chain or retail store....
2 Pages (500 words) Case Study

Dollar General - Todays Neighborhood Store

The Dollar General case notes the presence of other players such as Family Dollar and Dollar Tree in the market.... In this respect, the retail chain faces many and different forces in the business setting.... Political or legal forces constitute a critical factor in the success of any given… In its operations, Dollar General adheres to government rules, regulation, and terms of conducting business....
4 Pages (1000 words) Case Study

Big Box Stores Vs Mom and Pop Stores

The term big box store is generally meant for stores that are operating as part of a retail chain and have numerous products to offer.... This paper 'Big Box Stores vs Mom and Pop Stores" focuses on the fact that Big Retails Stores also known as Big Box Stores gained prominence in the last decade....
8 Pages (2000 words) Case Study

Food Prices in Stores Kroger and Giant Eagle

The highest difference in price is seen on Cat food and Tofu where the Kroger store sells the Cat food at 7.... The author of the paper "Food Prices in Stores Kroger and Giant Eagle" will begin with the statement that there has been an argument over time that there is always a change in prices of items depending on the location where one does their shopping....
6 Pages (1500 words) Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us