StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Collective Bargaining Role in the Employment Relationship - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper "Collective Bargaining Role in the Employment Relationship" states the unwillingness of employers to grant the employee requests poses a big problem and might strain the employee-employer relationship. Without hearing both parties, a collective decision may render impossible to happen…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.5% of users find it useful
Collective Bargaining Role in the Employment Relationship
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Collective Bargaining Role in the Employment Relationship"

Collective Bargaining Section March 2007 ‘Collective bargaining is the most appropriate channel to redress the power imbalance within the employment relationship.’ Introduction Whether society likes it or not, employment relationship is bound to take an imbalance turn given that the needs of its manpower foundation is ignored or imparted with less attention. Take the case of Company A who is being asked by its employees to provide free dental insurance or allowance since the latter deemed that the former could very well provide for such simple benefit. On the other hand, Company B is being demanded by its employees to raise their income by 5% in view of the fact that the company administration failed to uphold the yearly income increase of 1% for the last five years. With the cases of Company A and B, such demands can be regarded as a non-issue since it is the right of every employee to be provided with their basic needs. However, the unwillingness of employers to grant the aforementioned requests pose a big problem, and might eventually strain the relationship between the management and its numerous employees. Without a proper venue to hear both parties, a collective decision may render impossible to happen. If this happens, employees would have no other choice but to go to the streets and hold the picket lines until other labour unions or government agencies get hold of their case. Hence, there is a need to emphasise the fact that every company or organisation must acknowledge the rights of their employees. And the only way to meet halfway through the conflict is through a collective bargaining agreement between the two parties involved (Cornell, 2007). Collective Bargaining In the UK alone, collective bargaining has been exercised by at least 15.5 million employees from a manpower population of about 17.5 million since 1945 (Cite filename: Personnel & HRM). British Academic Beatrice Webb was said to have coined such term in her 1891 book entitled ‘Cooperative Movement’ in an effort to provide an alternative movement from individual bargaining between a company and its individual employee. However, it was the definition made by Allan Flanders, as a ‘process of rule-making leading to joint regulation in industry,’ that further refined the meaning of collective bargaining (Wikipedia, 2007). He even expanded the significance of the term as not only limited to determining pay but as well as in the (cite filename: employee relations): …management acceptance of a style of employment relationship which is based on the legitimisation of the expression of the different interest within the organisation (conflict), on joint regulation (constraining the unilateral exercise of managerial authority over employees) and on the principle of employee involvement and influence in a range of organisational decision-making. Recent denotations of collective bargaining have been simplified and defined as (Cite filename: Personnel & HRM): …as the process whereby procedures are jointly agreed and wagers and conditions of employment are settled by negotiations between employers, or associations of employers, and workers’ organizations. On the other hand, Lewis (cite filename employee relations Philip lewis) further implied the meaning of the term as: …a voluntary, formalised process by which employers and independent unions negotiate, for specified groups of employees, terms and conditions of employment and the ways in which certain employment-related issues are regulated at national, organisational and workplace levels. From the word itself, collective bargaining emphasises the move for a ‘collective action’ and not an ‘individual action’ of various key players within the organisation. Furthermore, it is also concerned with developing and establishing rules, as well as the settlement of employment conditions through a compromising agreement to which both parties agree with. Indeed, certain disagreements between the two parties inevitably arise. But what makes collective bargaining distinct from the process of consultation is the fact that the former includes the element of negotiation (Boone & Davis, 1999). On the other hand, the latter settle issues and outcomes in a unilateral basis. Main Functions According to ___ (cite filename: HRM in contemporary approach), the collective bargaining process has three distinct functions such as: market or economic, decision-making and governmental function(s). The market or economic function involves the collective agreement on the price of labour and other related terms of agreement to which the employees will work for the employer. This issue has often been the case for most collective bargaining agreements as employees only hope for and strive for what they think they deserve to attain. On the other hand, the decision-making function offers an opportunity for employees to be able to partake, involve and contribute in policy-making procedures that shall be utilised as a formal work guideline in the organisation. Ideally speaking, this function should always be the case for all collective bargaining agreements. However, in reality, top-down organisations tend to delineate from this type of function as this provision further complicates the original organisational structure. And lastly, the governmental function establishes rules that govern the relationship between the employer and employee. This aspect emphasises that bargaining is a political process that ‘establishes a constitution.’ Realistically speaking, this function may only be true to its form in a continuous process, and not on a single collective bargaining agreement deal. Establishing the so-called constitution between the employer and employee is gradual, depending on how time has changed the needs and wants of its very people. Not unless the human resource arm of the company has already established some guidelines and procedures, connecting the thin line between the two parties is established through time (Miernyk, 1965). Strengths of Collective Bargaining Structurally speaking, collective bargaining is the strongest link that binds the organisation with its loyal employees, particularly in cases where it is registered in a Labour Court (ICTU, 2007). For cases that is not legally bonded, rest is assured that the goodwill and commitment of both parties in honouring the agreement. Furthermore, corporations and organisations would be able to lessen its staffing turnover rate, reduce cost of hiring new employees and further strengthen the loyalty base of its constituents. It is essential to note that a low staffing turnover rate implies that the organisation has a good management base. On the other hand, it also promotes democracy and greater equality among various trade unions and corporations (cite filename: HRM in contemporary approach). It had also been instrumental in implementing the necessary restructuring that is required for the industry to meet today’s modern times. Such restructuring may encompass in the company’s organisational structure, operational activities, production or other pertinent processes involved in resolving interest, enhancing organisational productivity and managing employment contracts. Since its implementation, more workers are now being consulted, informed and are allowed to voice out their opinions in every strategic step that the management will undertake such as performance appraisal, health and safety, staffing, hiring and firing and the like. In cases where management cannot grant the wishes of the trade unions, as previously mentioned in the text, the common venue allows both parties to rationally and objectively discuss the issue at hand. Employees would be able to better understand the current situation of the company, primarily the inability of the organisation to grant their needs, and re-adjust their demands according to the capacity of the management. With such compromising agreement, the company would be able to avoid considerable financial losses while employees are able to attain their needs. This win-win situation is the real essence of what collective bargaining is all about (cite filename employee relations Philip lewis). Criticisms relating to Collective Bargaining Despite the reported effectiveness of collective bargaining, surveys suggest that its utilisation has considerably declined in recent years. In effect, no effective alternative has been devised in order to address collective interest representation (cite filename: dynamic of employee relations 2004). If and when there exists some bargaining initiatives, employees are forced to agree and sign a contract with the following provisions (cite filename: hrm in contemporary approach): (a) that only one trade union would be recognised by the management, particularly in single-union deals; (b) trade unions are forced to fulfil the behavioural expectations of the management so as to attain their goals; (c) employees are also forced to comply with the no-strike clause in the collective bargaining agreement contract, such that union negotiators are denied of a threat of strike action in case of bargaining breakdown and the fact that employees are denied the option of withdrawing their labour independently; and (d) collective bargaining agreements in the UK fail to include a pendulum arbitrator that will act as a third party in settling the issues between management and employees. The Role of Collective Bargaining in Human Resource Management (HRM) Strategies Given the strengths and weaknesses of collective bargaining, the role of the management’s human resource arm has been crucial in developing high commitment between the management and the trade union (cite filename employee relations Philip lewis). With HRM strategies, employees are guided accordingly in the current capabilities of the management and make a compromise agreement based on the needs of the former. Furthermore, it also helps in regulating new working policies within the organisation, as mentioned in the bargaining agreement. For the part of the HRM, it can suggest policies what would improve and enhance the working relations within the organisation. Policy-making is essential in the overall structure of the company as it is in this aspect people rely for solutions in times of conflict or misunderstanding. Conclusion As a conclusion, the move to have a collective bargaining agreement, in accordance with the HRM strategies, would allow and enhance the role of employees in suggesting ways and means to improve current management practices. Through time, there will be less need for employees to join the picket lines as employers are able to make a clear and concise forecast of their needs and wants. Thus, collective bargaining will become only a thing of the past as the role and needs of employees are given the utmost priority within the organisational structure. References Cite all other references mentioned in the text.  Boone, L. E. & Davis, K. L. 1999, Contemporary Business, Tryden Press, Texas. Cornell.edu. ‘Collective Bargaining,’ Retrieved March 2007 from website: . ICTU. 2007, ‘Bargaining,’ Retrieved March 2007 from website: . Miernyk, W. H. 1965, The Economics of Labor and Collective Bargaining, Heath, Boston. Wikipedia: The Free Encyclopedia. 2007, ‘Collective bargaining,’ Wikipedia. Retrieved March 2007 from website: . Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Critically assess the proposition that collective bargaining is the Essay”, n.d.)
Critically assess the proposition that collective bargaining is the Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1539611-critically-assess-the-proposition-that-collective-bargaining-is-the-most-appropriate-channel-to-redress-the-power-imbalance-within-the-employment-relationship
(Critically Assess the Proposition That Collective Bargaining Is the Essay)
Critically Assess the Proposition That Collective Bargaining Is the Essay. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1539611-critically-assess-the-proposition-that-collective-bargaining-is-the-most-appropriate-channel-to-redress-the-power-imbalance-within-the-employment-relationship.
“Critically Assess the Proposition That Collective Bargaining Is the Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1539611-critically-assess-the-proposition-that-collective-bargaining-is-the-most-appropriate-channel-to-redress-the-power-imbalance-within-the-employment-relationship.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Collective Bargaining Role in the Employment Relationship

International and Comparative Employment Relations

Literature Review It is seen that the new approaches adopted in organizations are based on a wide range of HRM and employment relationship practices which are directed towards improving the skills and flexibility of the workforce within the organizational environment which thrives on communication, collaboration, trust and cooperation between managers, workers as well as their representatives.... This project highlights some of the major economic changes which have reflected through the employment relationships in organizations....
8 Pages (2000 words) Case Study

The Impact of Collective Bargaining

The paper "The Impact of collective bargaining" states that the disciplinary guidelines should be followed and the employees are given a chance to defend themselves instead of firing.... Public employees have collective bargaining with local governments and school districts dues are deducted through members' paychecks, unlike the NLRA which does not allow union dues to be deducted on member's paychecks unless an agreement is made.... Though at first, the employer had no obligation to engage in bargaining with public employee unions, it is now illegal as per the National Labor Relations Act (NLRA) to refuse to engage in collective bargaining with the union that represents employees....
9 Pages (2250 words) Assignment

Why is the employment relations system in the USA characterised by low levels of collective bargaining

Why Is the employment Relations System in the USA Characterized by Low Levels of Collective Bargaining?... The regulatory bodies in US affect the industrial and employee relation system in many ways such as: They provide the terms and conditions of the employment in details and directly.... An employee relation system involves maintaining and managing the employees in the organization and maintaining good relationship with them.... An employee relation system involves maintaining and managing the employees in the organization and maintaining good relationship with them....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

How Is the Employment Relationship in Australia Changing

the employment relationship in Australia has been an evolving one and the past couple of decades have observed a great deal of changes.... The inclination towards which workplace relationship have changed include from centralized to decentralized work regulation and employee relationship, from awards and jointly negotiated agreements to individual contract of employment, from full time permanent jobs to contingent workers, and from a pure pluralist employment system of employment relation to unitarist approach where collective bargaining powers of employees are diminished....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

The Arguements For and Against Collective Bargaining

The now popular term 'collective bargaining' was used for the first time by Sidney and Beatrice Webb in their works.... The organization of wage earners into labor unions and the growth of management organization - in a word, the emergence of collective bargaining - is basically a facet of these structural changes in the economy over the past century," says Dunlop and Healy(1953, p.... The American system of free collective bargaining is built on the relatively simple proposition that workers ought to have an uncoerced right to decide whether or not they wish to be represented by a trade union for the purpose of collective bargaining with their employer....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

HRM and Collective Bargaining

The paper 'HRM and collective bargaining' is an integrative study of employee relations emphasizing the concept of collective bargaining, and how this concept is applied in organizations.... It also discusses the collective bargaining to the Human Resources function.... It has been concluded from the study that collective bargaining is an established practice in economies where trade unions are legally recognized, and the certain degree of flexibility is to be exercised by both employers and employees to reach meaningful agreements, although rigidity may not necessarily result in failure for both parties....
17 Pages (4250 words) Assignment

How Business Environmental Changes over the Past Two Years

Literature ReviewIt is seen that the new approaches adopted in organizations are based on a wide range of HRM and employment relationship practices which are directed towards improving the skills and flexibility of the workforce within the organizational environment, which thrives on communication, collaboration, trust and cooperation between managers, workers as well as their representatives.... The underutilized and minimally legalized system of regulation coupled with fragmented collective bargaining system, growth of labour organizations, low degrees of centralization proved to be resistant towards attempts to change the system....
9 Pages (2250 words) Report

Term-Collective Bargaining and Term-Employee Involvement

the employment relationship is a term that refers to the legal notion used by various nations in explaining the relationship between employers and employees.... It is through the employment relationship that various rights and obligations are created between the employer and the employees.... Deery (1999) adds that the government interventions in legal and institutional frameworks for the labor relation have eroded the application of collective norms to the employment relationships and the regulatory role of the individual tribunals....
10 Pages (2500 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us