StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Educational Policy Discourse on Choice - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The education policy discourse on "choice" is based on the theory that, if parents have the right to choice where their child is schooled, it would improve the quality of education. In theory, by creating a competition between school communities for students, it would create a freer and more competitive market, and thus the quality of all schools would be improved and parents would get better education for their children…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.9% of users find it useful
Educational Policy Discourse on Choice
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Educational Policy Discourse on Choice"

Download file to see previous pages

While the discourse on "choice" was positive for rich people in wealthy communities, it did not create a market standard that boosted the overall quality of education system wide. Good local schools became more competitive to enter, and while the middle and upper class were able to continue to search for good schools out of district, low class families were stuck, unable to provide the money to allow their children to be transported to a better school. This policy of "choice" made good schools more competitive, but it did not have the desired effect on the rest of the schools nationwide.

Good schools were supposed to become more accessible to all students thus creating a better education system. While debating the 1988 Reform Bill in the U.K., Norman Nebbit (1987) said "The Bill extends choice and responsibilityToday only the wealthy have choice in education and that must be changed." By creating this policy reformists thought to make the education more equitable. Like free market economics, "choice" education allowed the market to blindly move based on its will rather than following the desire of the state's politicians.

Parents choose the best schools, and those schools which are not as popular must be allowed to improve or close. Bureaucracy would not protect the schools from their unpopularity, with the euphemism of 'under-enrolment'; schools would be completely at the will of the parents or the consumer (Chubb & Moe, 1990, pp. 29-30). The good schools would expand to accommodate the needs of the students, in other words, it's a theory of survival of the fittest with the parents responsible for deciding who is the fittest.

Unfortunately, there are a few very serious problems with this theory; first and foremost, schools are not a business. Unlike a business that is constantly trying to increase in size to accommodate demand, schools have no such motivator. In fact it has been proven that smaller schools, and smaller class size are considerably more desirable, because they provide more individualized attention for the students (Bickel & Howley, 2000). Popular schools have no reason to expand their school to accommodate the influx in desired attendance provided by "choice" education policy.

Instead, they have the ability to become more selective in their acceptance of students (Edwards et al, 1989). Although this was not the intention, it is an outcome that is important to recognize in looking at the effectiveness of the policy. The exit of some students diminishes the chances of others to receive the same quality of education (Murnane, 1990).The second problem with this theory is overflow students. If the popular schools are not willing to accommodate the increased demand, the students have to be schooled elsewhere.

This inherently means that schools that are not as popular, and potentially not as good, will have the ability to recruit students and survive even in their inferior status. When demand is high and supply is low, people pay more or they choose not to get exactly what they want. The "choice" system works the same way. Parents are willing either to go further away from home to get accepted into a good school, or they

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Educational Policy Discourse on Choice Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1513137-educational-policy-discourse-on-choice
(Educational Policy Discourse on Choice Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words)
https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1513137-educational-policy-discourse-on-choice.
“Educational Policy Discourse on Choice Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1513137-educational-policy-discourse-on-choice.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Educational Policy Discourse on Choice

Why does communsim work in some developing countries and democracy in others

For example, some communist countries do not allow their citizens to practice certain religions, change jobs, or move to the town of their choice (Margonis, 1993).... It was the 19th-century German political philosopher Karl Marx who saw the wealth created by capitalism, but he also noted the poor working and living conditions of laborers in his time....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Relevant Topics on the Education of Youth and Their Search for Social Identity

The research process is conducted by adopting different methodological… It is assumed that the choice of methodology implies the researcher's belief in certain policy in relation to the subject of his research (Coffey, 2001).... One makes one's decisions regarding the choice of career based on the social and cultural context in which he resides and ‘it is part of a wider choice of lifestyle” (Hodkinson et al, 1996, p.... In each of the individual cases be it Luke and Jordan's case or Rees and Wayne's, he emphasizes on the fact that it is the social context and cultural orientation of each of them that have conditioned their attitudes and rules their choice of careers....
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay

The Interests of the Educated Individual, the Employer, and the Economy

In the line of public policy, education is always given priority because in one hand development of education system plays a modern role for sophisticating the society while on the other hand an improved educational system is expected to absorb the unemployment by providing educated, thoughtful, intellectual and innovative human resources.... In this policy, the Queensland government for the growth and development of the state in future has promoted innovative ideas in the field of scientific research and information and communication technologies....
7 Pages (1750 words) Assignment

Why White Kids Love Hip

In this regard, using the two discourse: Chang's It's a Hip Hop World and Kiwana's Erasing Blackness, the current essay hereby aims to present a comparative analysis of these literary works through a closer examination of the following elements, to wit: point of view, character, theme, and experiences.... The disparities lie in presentation of the literary work, as Chang's presentation could be deemed more effective in enticing pathos or emotional appeal through the use of carefully selected photographs the break the monotony of a long line of discourse (“Asian art: Graffiti is one of the original elements of American-style hip-hop that Chinas urban youth have made their own” (Chang 60); “Can't stop: A South Korean b-boy tears up Seoul with his acrobatic moves” (Chang 61); “Revisiting roots: Senegalese hip-hop artists tackle themes of poverty and oppression” (Chang 62))....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Stereotypical Interaction Styles

This paper, Stereotypical Interaction Styles, stresses that the individual reading an extract from a speech by politician Oona King in the House of Commons will see that despite the progress in women's rights, society still favors men more than women.... hellip; According to the study, in gender roles and gendered professions, these stereotypes may cause problems for a female authority with more male employees, for example....
11 Pages (2750 words) Assignment

The Link between Resilience and Complexity

esilience is a principal concept in regard to government policy understandings.... Currently, resilience is viewed as the ideal policy.... esilience has come to be recognized as central to international and domestic policy-making.... It has come to be seen as the guiding principle of policy governance and a key political category of our time.... In this discussion, a range of issues and questions will be analyzed in terms of resilience frameworks, from educational training in schools to global ethics and from responses to thrilling catastrophes....
14 Pages (3500 words) Essay

Social Psychoanalytic Perspective

In developmental psychology, the family unit has been used in previous studies to form the basis of the study of relational attachments, personality, intelligence, educational achievement, mental well-being as well as occupational and emotional success.... This assignment "Social Psychoanalytic Perspective" discusses in what ways a social psychoanalytic perspective aids our understanding of sibling relationships, the statement that attitudes are nothing but talk and how any social psychology of the body needs to take account of power relations....
6 Pages (1500 words) Assignment

The Kind of Social Class-Based Discourse Promoted

By adopting a liberal approach towards the discourse on sexuality and gender, the school succeeds in helping students develop their natural capabilities and achieve full potential in their professional and career lives.... The kind of social class-based discourse promoted In general, there are two perspectives on social classes in society.... The kind of gender discourse promoted In general, the Adelaide School of English promotes a liberal approach towards gender discourse....
4 Pages (1000 words) Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us