StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Conflicting Views of the California High School Exit Exam - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
In California there is currently no easy answer for students and parents who wait to learn if they will be able to graduate. Some 47,000 students failed the California High School Exit Exam, which will currently prevent them from receiving a diploma. Arguments are mixed as to how the Supreme Court should rule…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.6% of users find it useful
Conflicting Views of the California High School Exit Exam
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Conflicting Views of the California High School Exit Exam"

Download file to see previous pages

First, what is the minimum education children should have to graduate Are there a set of standards which have to be met, and a certain level of proficiency achieved Secondly, what does a high school diploma symbolize If it is meant to suggest that a person has attended high school, than by all means drop the exam. However, if it is meant to suggest that this student has an education, and has learned and met minimum levels of ability, then the exam should stand. Otherwise the degree is devalued for all those who truly earned it.

Finally, can California make a clear case for discrimination, and prove that the exam is not fair to underserved children If so, then the results can not be validated. If they can prove that all children (while possibly not evenly served) have had enough opportunity to pass the exam, then the results should be upheld. By reviewing a brief history of the exam, and looking at both sides of the argument, it is clear that the exam should remain valid, and those 47,000 students should not be awarded their diplomas.

The California High School Exit Exam is a new and fairly untested program. Originally slated to count towards graduation for the class of 2004, the schools held off until 2006, after state wide improvements were made to the schools. The exam tests for proficiency in eighth grade level math, and tenth grade level English. A student must get a fifty-five percent or higher to pass, and has six chances to pass the test. All over California people are arguing about the California High School Exit Exam.

They claim that it is unfair, and that it expects too much of the students. Randy Dong, a California journalist suggests that it is not in the interest of education that these children are being tested, but rather in the interest of social promotion. He says "we are throwing algebraic and geometric problems at students who cannot even perform basic arithmetic" (Dong 2006). However, the exam only tests through eighth grade math and tenth grade reading (Washburn 2006). These children have twelve or more years of education, yet they can not pass proficiencies below their own level of academia.

While Dong is in the minority, arguing about content, his view is important. In reviewing what is at stake, it is important to ask how low United States citizens are willing to set the bar in education. What should be a minimum level or proficiency to have a diploma Where Dong argues that algebra is too high a standard for students graduating from high school, others argue that the standards set by the test are two low. In an editorial from the Press-Enterprise, it questions "Freedman decreed that requiring students in low-performing schools to answer correctly just 55 percent of the questions in eighth-grade math and 60 percent of the questions in 10th-grade English - even after six tries - is an arbitrary violation of the state constitution.

" For students whose education has respectively passed four and two years beyond those levels, those minimums seem low, not high. With six tries, and tutoring available, no child should be able to fail that test, and if they do, then why should they be allowed a diploma Judge Freedman ruled that denying students the diploma would negatively impact their self-esteem, but what about the devaluation of the

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Conflicting Views of the California High School Exit Exam Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1502291-conflicting-views-of-the-california-high-school-exit-exam
(Conflicting Views of the California High School Exit Exam Essay)
https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1502291-conflicting-views-of-the-california-high-school-exit-exam.
“Conflicting Views of the California High School Exit Exam Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1502291-conflicting-views-of-the-california-high-school-exit-exam.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Conflicting Views of the California High School Exit Exam

The Impact of Afterschool Programs within California High Schools

This paper makes a conclusion that doctors and psychologists concur that indeed at the high school age, the students have a young body and brain all of which are growing at a very fast rate.... It is a source of comfort that is effective in the restoration of sanity to the young minds of the high school students.... This essay the Impact of After School Programs Within california high Schools talks that students are often subjected to several different types of programs every day after the daily academic school programs and this element has met different reactions from different quarters of the world....
12 Pages (3000 words) Research Paper

School Profiler Assignment

In Language arts, the school performed well in RFEP in the category of language frequency with scores of 89% in 2011 and 87% in 2012 in the california high school exit exam (CAHSEE).... This discussion is a review and an analysis of various aspects such as major accountability indicators for K-12, CST, CELDT, CAHSEE, AYP and API among others at the Centennial high school.... Some grades performed better than others especially in the california English Language Development Test (CELDT)....
5 Pages (1250 words) Assignment

Clay Shirky - Wiki exam (group) vs Traditional exam (individual)

Instructor Course Submission date Clay Shirky - Wiki exam In the text here comes everybody suggests that group of are complex, in a way that make those group to form and hard to sustain.... This form of communication may come from the academic chair or workers representative this does not mean everyone has to shout to give the information it must pass in a simplified channel such as school representative from the student and the staff leaders in different sections....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Californias System of Public Higher Education

This research tells that California led the nation in the number of high school graduates who went on to college and earned degrees....  According to Douglass (2011), “California led the nation — and the world — in the number of high school graduates who went on to college and earned degrees.... The state of california was able to uphold its performance when it comes to financing education and providing access to education against other states....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Leadership Style, Organisational Climate, Resources and Skills

The purpose of this research is to identify to what extent creative and innovative practices are present in an organization.... It also wants to critically evaluate how they are stimulated, encouraged, and rewarded.... The selected organization is a human resource outsourcing company.... hellip; In today's competitive business environment, organizations seek ways of improving their products or services in order to sustain their competitiveness and survival....
13 Pages (3250 words) Research Paper

High School Dropouts

Section 4 cover methodology and finally, research site, sample, and sampling … The research covers students who have not graduated from high school or not currently enrolled in schools but have attained the age of 16 which is the statutory age for school leavers.... The aim of this paper is to conduct a qualitative research on school dropouts.... Those who leave school at age 16 before taking A-level exams are also included....  Due to time and resource constraints, research is conducted in a section of Britain school dropout has also been associated with consequences such as high crime rates, increased use of social services such as unemployment assistance and medical assistance, psychological problems, unemployment, limitation in career progression among others....
6 Pages (1500 words) Assignment

Inequality in California

The paper "Inequality in California" presents inequality gap which results from a small percentage of the population earning extremely high income while the rest get peanuts.... According to Doig et al (2011), California has high rates of malnutrition cases, benefiting from the Medicare service.... % which are not very high despite being higher than the rate of the nation which lies at 7.... Notably, consisting of large cities, California contains high tech investors specialized in various manufacturing industries....
7 Pages (1750 words) Assignment

The Chinese College Entrance Exam Is Harmful to Student Education

From the paper "The Chinese College Entrance exam Is Harmful to Student Education" it is clear that the Chinese entrance exam is a menace that should be curbed in order to realize the full benefits of education.... The exam, which is commonly referred to as Gakao and held annually, is the only determinant in deciding on whether the students can proceed to higher education and the schools they ought to attend.... Various scholars such as Renouf (62) also claim that the examination is at times confusing and vague, yet students are expected to respond appropriately to the set questions in case they wish to achieve high scores....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us