StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Managers Learn Better from Experience or Theory - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
From the paper "Managers Learn Better from Experience or Theory" it is clear that each manager has their unique characteristics in handling a situation based upon their learning. Learning is most effective when it is aligned with individual learning styles…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92% of users find it useful
Managers Learn Better from Experience or Theory
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Managers Learn Better from Experience or Theory"

? U58002 Introduction to Management work Individual essay Module leader: Debbie Witney My Safa Al Saleh Word Count 475 Managers Learn Better Through Experience. Theory Has Nothing to Offer Introduction The essence of the paper lies in the argument whether managers learn better from experience or theories play an important role. In today’s competitive world where managers are always under pressure to perform and achieve greater heights, it is of paramount importance that managers have some prior experience in a similar field of work so that they are better equipped to handle things around confidently. Hence, management development programmes are conducted by organisations to update the managers on any new managerial behaviour. In the competitive environment managers often have to face difficult situations in the workplace. To handle such kind of situations, it is extremely important for the manager to have sufficient knowledge backed by theories and prior experience behind him. But in the most difficult situation, bookish knowledge will help to some extent and practical experience and instincts of managers will become more effective in handling the situation with utmost care. But the importance of theory cannot be underestimated since it is the theory that will show the path for the manager, and the experience will pave the path. An organisation also needs to look at educating the present managers. It is expected that whatever may be their formal education requirement, it will not be able to meet the job demands during their tenure in the organisation. Hence, providing continuing education for the managers is important. Learning by doing matters for professional investors. Most of the organisations today believe in ELT, or experimental learning theory, which has been the foundation of management learning over the years. It has been seen that there have been improvements in the efficiency of the output produced from the existing technologies, though the inputs remain the same. It shows that inputs are an important determinant of total productivity. So the organisations have started realising that ‘on-the-job-training’, or learning by doing, is as important as formal education received, which forms the base of human capital. Discussion Every practice by managers is based on theory itself. Management theory gives an overall view of managers’ role and the competencies which the managers need. It acts as a guide to understand the process to help the managers learn (Mailick and Stumpf, 1998). But management practice is more specifically concerned with task selection and performance delivery, which defines the manager’s contribution to the organisation. Management practice basically utilises management theory to help managers determine the process which they need to follow in specific situations (Bell and Goldsmith, 2013). Every manager has their own way of handling things, which they might feel is the optimal and efficient one. But the real world does not go by that logic. It is only when they are faced with real world solutions that they realise that they need to change their strategy to come out with new solutions (Levitt, List and Syverson, 2013). For example, a sales manager must be able to handle the team under their leadership. Team dynamics is the most important factor which they cannot neglect. Team dynamics will vary with the composition of members in it. Each team has to be handled differently. Experiential learning theory (ELT) gives a holistic model of the learning process. Learning is best viewed as a process, not as an outcome. Hence, improving the performance of managers by engaging them will enhance their learning and performance. All learning is re-learning. It is a process through which the manager’s beliefs and ideas about a topic can be examined, applied and integrated to form more new refined ideas. Learning is a holistic process of adaptation. It involves the integrated functioning of thinking, perceiving, feeling and behaving apart from cognition. Learning is the result of synergetic transactions between the person and the environment. Learning is the process of creating knowledge (Moon, 2013). The Cycle of Experiential Learning According to ELT, learning is the process where knowledge is created by the transformation of experience. Knowledge is the result of the combination of grasping and transformation of experience. It consists of two related grasping experiences: concrete experience (CE) and abstract conceptualisation (AC), and two modes of transforming practices: reflective observation (RO) and active experimentation (AE). Experimental learning is the process of creating knowledge among these four learning modes, which are responsive to contextual demands (A. Kolb and D. Kolb, 2002). It helps the managers to touch all the bases such as reflecting, experiencing, thinking and acting. It is a recursive process that responds to a learning situation and what is being learnt. These implications can be actively tested, and act as guides for creating new experiences (Leberman, McDonald and Doyle, 2006). In the concrete experience stage, the managers physically experience practical situations. This experience forms the basis of observation and reflection through which they get to know whether their actions are working or not (reflective observation), so that they can improve in the next attempt of taking actions in a similar situation (abstract conceptualisation). Now every new attempt to take a similar action in a similar situation will make them more informed through previous experience and reflection (active experimentation). Theories of John Dewey According to this theory, experience is the principal entity for all learning, and it emphasises the importance of the lifelong learning process. It postulates that learning will be most effective when it is done through hands-on experience. Another argument is that adult learning will not be effective unless the learner accepts the change in behaviour as a desirable feature. Subject to this theory there are three phases of the learning process where experience is the starting phase followed by reviewing and generalising the experience. The third phase is practicing the generalisation. These three phases lead to formation of a new cycle of experiences. Learning will be most effective when the content will be seen by managers as satisfactory to their needs. The essence of natural learning is making a connection between the action and its consequences. New learning must never be inconsistent with past learning and experience, and new learning must motivate the employees to warrant for change (Chen, 2006). Theories of Kurt Lewin According to this theory, behaviour is a function of a person’s experience and learning venue. Based on this model, learning takes place when experience is analysed to provide new insights. Learning is gained through observation, feedback and reflection. There is a five-element cycle consisting of abstraction, concrete implication, experience, observation feedback, and reflection. The last element – reflection – leads to reinforcement of learnt behaviour and a higher level of abstraction. Lewin proposed that learning requires one to go through the entire cycle, with learning taking place at each stage. The cycle can, though, start at any stage. Validation and reinforcement of learning will take place after completion of the next stage. But the ability to apply action is usually gained after the experience stage. Learning is then reinforced as one move through the observation, feedback and reflection stages. According to Lewin, change can be accomplished through successive learning experiences (Grippen, 2007). The Theories of Malcolm Knowles Knowles made a distinction between adults and young learners. He used the term ‘andragogy’ for adult learning theory and ‘pedagogy’ for children. Pedagogy uses passive learning approaches and simplified models (Powell, 2010). Pedagogy assumes that the learners have little experience to challenge whatever is taught to them. Hence, it is the level of experience and not the age that determines learning. It shows why most of the adults are not efficient or effective passive learners. According to Knowles, there is a four-element cycle for adult learning like Concrete experience, analysis of experience, derivation of explanatory concepts and models and concrete experience to test the models. Knowles derived four axes to analyse adult learners which are self-direction, experience, readiness to learn and apply and problem solving. Pursuant to this theory, the effectiveness of a management development programme depends on the values along the axes. Learning is based upon the use of the employee’s past experience and motivation to learn and the ability to solve problems. It is the andragogical theory that has contributed more greatly to the management development theory (Jarvis, Holford and Griffin, 2003). Conclusion Conclusively the thesis statement can be re-stated as managers do learn better from experience and the theories discussed above supports this statement. Learning theory is a general guide to design the processes which managers can learn and apply at their workplace. A theory is a useful invention, but it is a figment of imagination which can give partial explanation. Theory should be used cautiously and tested in the market. Importance should be attached to both learning theory and management theory. Each manager has their unique characteristics in handling a situation based upon their leaning. Learning is most effective when it is aligned with individual learning styles. An important task for an organisation is to correlate the theories of learning to the role of management. It has been seen that the experienced workers are better problem solvers because they have the capability to view the big picture. It is only through experience that they can suggest out-of-context tools for innovative use. Not every manager can possess this skill, but through experience they can easily deal with managerial problems effectively. Experienced workers foster work ethics that enhances the corporate values of any organisation. They can act as mentors to young hires and help to build a dynamic work team more easily. References Bell, C. and Goldsmith, M. (2013). Managers as Mentors: Building Partnerships for Learning. San Francisco: Berrett-Koehler Publishers. Chen, P. (2006). John Dewey on Theory of Learning and Inquiry: The Scientific Method and Subject Matter. New York: University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign. Grippen, M. (2007). From Lethargy to Leadership: The Effect of a Teacher-driven Professional Learning Community as Change Agent for Improving Staff Morale and School Culture. Ann Arbor: ProQuest. Jarvis, P., Holford, J. and Griffin, C. (2003). The Theory and Practice of Learning. London: Routledge. Kolb, A. and Kolb, D. (2002). Experiential Learning Theory: A Dynamic, Holistic Approach to Management Learning, Education and Development. [pdf]. Available at: http://weatherhead.case.edu/departments/organizational-behavior/workingpapers/wp-07-02.pdf. [Accessed on 9th November 2013]. Leberman, S., McDonald, L. and Doyle S. (2006). The Transfer of Learning: Participants' Perspectives of Adult Education and Training. Hampshire: Gower Publishing, Ltd. Levitt, S., List, J. and Syverson, C. (2013). Toward an Understanding of Learning by Doing: Evidence from an Automobile Assembly Plant. [pdf]. Available at: http://home.uchicago.edu/syverson/learningbydoing.pdf. [Accessed on 9th November 2013]. Mailick, S. and Stumpf S. (1998). Learning Theory in the Practice of Management Development: Evolution and Applications. Connecticut: Greenwood Publishing Group. Moon, J. (2013). A Handbook of Reflective and Experiential Learning: Theory and Practice. New York: Routledge. Powell, W. (2010). Management Experience Acquired: Necessary Skills for Successfully Managing Any Employee. Austin: BookPros, LLC. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Managers learn better from experience or theory Essay”, n.d.)
Managers learn better from experience or theory Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/management/1491305-managers-learn-better-from-experience-or-theory
(Managers Learn Better from Experience or Theory Essay)
Managers Learn Better from Experience or Theory Essay. https://studentshare.org/management/1491305-managers-learn-better-from-experience-or-theory.
“Managers Learn Better from Experience or Theory Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/management/1491305-managers-learn-better-from-experience-or-theory.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Managers Learn Better from Experience or Theory

The Role of the Manager in the Prevailing Globalised World

Apart from the internal factors, they also have to understand the external environment that is the economic condition, the government policies in the local as well as in other nations, changes taking place in customer's behavior and technology.... he growing competition in the business sector demands a high degree of efficiency from the managers; thus the company also motivates the mangers to update themselves by participating in different pieces of training sessions (seminars, conferences, and off-job training)....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

Management Experience and Theories

anagers learn better through experience and theory has nothing to offer.... The paper "Management Experience and Theories" highlights that it is very true that managers learn their skills and knowledge through experience and not theories because theories tend to be constant; they do not change with time and with the demands of society.... This statement is true to some extent and on the other hand, the theory has some importance.... On the other hand, an individual may learn the theory and harbours the knowledge without practicing what is learned can make the individual lose the knowledge and eventually the theory ends up not helping the manager in any way....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Managers Better Learn through Experience

The statement 'managers learn better through experience.... The theory has nothing to offer.... On the other hand, it has been observed that theory has a lot to offer in the management field, as there are some management theories that can be applied to solve problems facing managers in the modern world.... This means that theory cannot be fully left out in the field of management.... In order to study the reasons as to why learning through experience is the best form of learning for managers, this paper gives a discussion of the experiential learning theory and its practical application....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Managers Learn Better through Experience

The paper "managers learn better through Experience" describes that the process of learning for effective managers should involve theory and learn through experience.... This paper will explain why theory is not the best way for managers to learn and in addition explore the different perspectives of managers learning through experience.... This weakness of using theory in managers' training is the therefore in the pattern of the manager thinking or his way of doing things which may antagonise the theory that he is supposed to use....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Building Systems that Learn on a Large Scale

There are a variety of leadership styles a leader may hold; what separates a leader from the rest are the traits they possess to succeed and the various background assumptions held true by the.... There are a variety of leadership styles a leader may hold; what separates a leader from the rest are the traits they possess to succeed and the various background assumptions held true by the.... his report will discuss motivation and how managers can use it for a better, more profitable, efficient workplace....
6 Pages (1500 words) Research Paper

The Manager Shadowing Program

The report includes a basic understanding of management, summary of observations made during the shadowing process and an analysis of these observations on the basis of theory related to managerial functions.... Tremendous information on management and managerial roles is available from literature; however, without practical application one cannot realize the intricacies involved in manager's role.... The following report elaborates on my observations and learning from the shadowing activity....
14 Pages (3500 words) Essay

Globalization and need for Global Managers

Almost all organizations want to expand their offerings to these new markets and acquire revenues from these emerging countries where the middle class is developing rapidly.... The paper investigates and compares the classical theories of learning and development with a global perspective and provides recommendations related to practices that can be adopted by the organizations to develop global managers with an enhanced scope.... This expansion presents them with multiple challenges although for clarity the challenges related to management development of global managers are discussed in this report....
16 Pages (4000 words) Assignment

Integration of Facility and Security Managers

The roles of facility and security managers are designed to enhance customer experience while promoting operational efficiencies.... For instance, the concept allows companies to benefit from improved utilization of financial resources.... In recent years, real estate managers have realized that better facility management may involve the assimilation of several real estate services.... Consequently, more companies are seeking to better customer experiences through integration....
8 Pages (2000 words) Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us