Similarities and Differences - Essay Example

Similarities and Differences Both the of the stories try to bring the sense of life in their regions. Wilkins tries to reduce her work by laying the key talents that are possessed by the women that are possessed by the women in the region of England. The authors move beyond their regions, and try to offer focus concerning the psychology about women’s challenges as the century begun. They both use of dialect is seen to be similar to that used by twains as they tried to illustrate the efforts and commitments he had knowledge about in a clear precision. The authors of the stories trade the sentiments and the melodrama in their writings, but they also express their knowledge and thoughts to the realism that was started by Harriet. They achieve this through coming up with memorable pictures of towns that are smaller in size and the people who reside in this town. To be precise, the authors sought out and come up with statements, which at times seem to be of protest, others that depicts celebrations for the sake of the female individuals who are obscured in their lives. Wilkins scrutinizes the subjugations that troubled the individuals who resided in the villages, especially the women. This is seen in these stories of “A New England Nun” and in the “Humble Romance” (Johnson 2008). Similarities between Both Stories Both stories focus on women as the center of the plot. The women are mostly considered to have come from the rural settings. As opposed to men, in the tales of Wilkins, she uses the freeman women who represent the little remains of strength and aspiration to the society. An example is that of the “New England Nun” where Louisa is depicted as a protagonist while in the story of “The Mother of Revolt,” Sarah depicted as the protagonist character. The authors explain about the women characters that have succeeded and the struggle they encountered as they struggled to achieve their goals. Through the stories, we get a picture of the women who seem to be in conflict with their society. In the story of “A New England Nun,” Ellis is not in good terms with her partner whom they are about to get married while in the story of “The Revolt Mother,” wrangles with her spouse. Both the female characters in the stories emerge victorious as they struggle to overcome the beliefs and the power of their traditions (Johnson 2008). This woman chooses some decisions that act as a major change in their lives and the changes are resultant of the decisions that enables these women to create and establish their new identities. The authors base their questions on the integrity of the women, the women’s courage, and the privation. This is explained in “The Revolt of Mother” when the author states that the house where Sarah had lived for more than forty years was emptied by five o’clock and the room turned itself to becoming a new barn. While of the story of the hired man, the author explains that she has a good sense and she will not break her heart nor even make a fool of herself. Her father explains that she is very sure that she will not get married. The women characters in both stories make their decision after a long period as it is depicted by Ellis, who made her decision after more than fifteen years of her suffering while Penn made her decision after forty years. Sarah states that it is forty years now yet she had not built a house while in Ellis story, she was to get married in a months’ time after she was engaged in a courtship that had taken place for more than fifteen years (Johnson 2008). The authors depict that the men in this region commonly interferes with the efforts put in place by the women to develop their lives. Ellis life and the struggle to achieve her success is greatly interfered by Joe after he returns from Australia while Sarah’s life is influenced by Adoniram and he does only affect Sarah’s life, but also the whole life of her family after he constructs a new barn rather than constructing a new house that will be better. Both the authors place more emphasis on the women’s experiences that they encountered on a daily basis as part of their life. The women’s used in the stories passes their days in a manner that is not eventful. Differences between both stories: Both Ellis and Sarah, who act as a protagonist in the stories, have a separate and different mode of lives. Ellis is a single woman who is not dependent on others for economic obligations while Sarah channels the standards of a woman belonging to the nineteenth century. She is married to Adoniram and she depends on him to provide the basic needs and for economic needs. In the story of the hired man, the author indicates that Ellis was engaged to her fiancée for more than fifteen years and after Joe returns from Australia, Ellis refuses to marry him (Johnson 2008). On the other hand, faces her husband for having promised her that he will construct a good house that they will both occupy and after forty years of Sarah being married to him, he built a barn and not a house as he had promised. Penn exhibits her character of the rebellion that enables her to achieve her desired changes while Ellis tries to test her dislikes and fears that she will encounter as she ventures into the unknown. The female characters also have different attitudes. Ellis indicates how calm she is while Sara has a character that is rebellious (Johnson 2008). Women Ellis attention mainly focused to perfection. She wanted everything in her home to be always tidy and in its right place to stay. She does her domestic chores as if they were rituals and this gives her satisfaction that similar to that of an artist. His fiancée was returning from Australia to marry her, but she never wanted to change her lifestyle. Through this, her dislike to change is clearly shown. Once his fiancée is back, she is forced to assume her independence state and to follow the marriage tradition (Johnson 2008). She has never been comfortable in the lifestyle and so she decides to divorce his husband and get back to her in depend lifestyle. She does this not because he hated his husband or his husband was unfaithful, but for the sake of her comfort. The peace she feels always is related to her nature of being lonely. Despite the fact that she feels lonely, she never gets sad or wants to change her situation. She is always happy, at peace and calm with her lonely nature. This is also the kind of lifestyle she has always wanted. Her nature of being alone is depicted to be out of her own choice (Johnson 2008). Sarah on the revolt of mother also depicts her strong urge of independence and rebellion unlike the Ellis nature of calmness. Against the opinion of the last, one Sarah moves to the house of his husband a new barn while she tries to run away from poverty. She also shows signs of rejecting her societal roles where she is required to be submissive to other people. She does this by saying that she got her own thoughts and feet and so she will do according to what she thinks is best. Rather than what is ordered by her. She never allows her indecent spirit to be stifled though she accepts to do the domestic chores (Johnson 2008). Sarah is a challenge to her husband; she stresses much of her dignity and tries to secure a better life of her daughter in the future. She is always the one making family decision rather than the husband. Despite her nature, she is a caring and forgiving wife. They got many differences with the husband, but they always work them out peacefully. Men Men are the decision makers in their homes, whereas the women represent the domestic’s works. Their differences are depicted clearly in the book of the revolt of mother. There was a situation where Sarah was concerned with what several men were doing in her yard, but is husband dismissed her by telling her to return to her domestic chores. This means that she was supposed to mind only what concerned her. Sarah husband depicts the male dominance over their wives. This is the act that men are not supposed to explain to their wives about their plans. Wives are expected to attend to all their domestic chores and not to question their husbands (Johnson 2008). Ellis fiancee also represents the role of men. This is from his appearance after fifteen years and breaks the routine of leis lifestyle. This shows the dominance, power of men. Louise was always faithful to the husband for all those years since she knew she was engaged to him. The husband wanted to keep having a relationship with his secret lover, but he felt committed to Ellis, who had waited for him for the fourteen years. Although what he really wanted to do was to keep having a relationship with Lily Dyer, his lover (Johnson 2008). Work Cited Johnson, James W. The Autobiography of an Ex-Colored Man. Radford, VA: Wilder Publications, 2008. Print. Read More

Her father explains that she is very sure that she will not get married. The women characters in both stories make their decision after a long period as it is depicted by Ellis, who made her decision after more than fifteen years of her suffering while Penn made her decision after forty years. Sarah states that it is forty years now yet she had not built a house while in Ellis story, she was to get married in a months’ time after she was engaged in a courtship that had taken place for more than fifteen years (Johnson 2008).

The authors depict that the men in this region commonly interferes with the efforts put in place by the women to develop their lives. Ellis life and the struggle to achieve her success is greatly interfered by Joe after he returns from Australia while Sarah’s life is influenced by Adoniram and he does only affect Sarah’s life, but also the whole life of her family after he constructs a new barn rather than constructing a new house that will be better. Both the authors place more emphasis on the women’s experiences that they encountered on a daily basis as part of their life.

The women’s used in the stories passes their days in a manner that is not eventful. Differences between both stories: Both Ellis and Sarah, who act as a protagonist in the stories, have a separate and different mode of lives. Ellis is a single woman who is not dependent on others for economic obligations while Sarah channels the standards of a woman belonging to the nineteenth century. She is married to Adoniram and she depends on him to provide the basic needs and for economic needs. In the story of the hired man, the author indicates that Ellis was engaged to her fiancée for more than fifteen years and after Joe returns from Australia, Ellis refuses to marry him (Johnson 2008).

On the other hand, faces her husband for having promised her that he will construct a good house that they will both occupy and after forty years of Sarah being married to him, he built a barn and not a house as he had promised. Penn exhibits her character of the rebellion that enables her to achieve her desired changes while Ellis tries to test her dislikes and fears that she will encounter as she ventures into the unknown. The female characters also have different attitudes. Ellis indicates how calm she is while Sara has a character that is rebellious (Johnson 2008).

Women Ellis attention mainly focused to perfection. She wanted everything in her home to be always tidy and in its right place to stay. She does her domestic chores as if they were rituals and this gives her satisfaction that similar to that of an artist. His fiancée was returning from Australia to marry her, but she never wanted to change her lifestyle. Through this, her dislike to change is clearly shown. Once his fiancée is back, she is forced to assume her independence state and to follow the marriage tradition (Johnson 2008).

She has never been comfortable in the lifestyle and so she decides to divorce his husband and get back to her in depend lifestyle. She does this not because he hated his husband or his husband was unfaithful, but for the sake of her comfort. The peace she feels always is related to her nature of being lonely. Despite the fact that she feels lonely, she never gets sad or wants to change her situation. She is always happy, at peace and calm with her lonely nature. This is also the kind of lifestyle she has always wanted.

Her nature of being alone is depicted to be out of her own choice (Johnson 2008). Sarah on the revolt of mother also depicts her strong urge of independence and rebellion unlike the Ellis nature of calmness. Against the opinion of the last, one Sarah moves to the house of his husband a new barn while she tries to run away from poverty. She also shows signs of rejecting her societal roles where she is required to be submissive to other people. She does this by saying that she got her own thoughts and feet and so she will do according to what she thinks is best.

Read More