StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Nursing and Principles of Protecting Patient Safety - Case Study Example

Cite this document
Summary
This essay discusses the legal aspects of nursing including proper administration of narcotics to patients which is an aspect of patient safety relating to procedures as well as to the accuracy of the doses given to patients. Timeliness of administration is also an issue…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.3% of users find it useful
Nursing and Principles of Protecting Patient Safety
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Nursing and Principles of Protecting Patient Safety"

 Table of Contents I. Principles of Protecting Patient Safety Involved in Case 3 II. On whether the nurses were negligent for delaying medication documentation 3 III. On whether the delay was below the standard of care 3 IV. Ethical Principles for Consideration When Hospital Looks at Situation Root Causes 4 V. Charges if the Case Were to Go to Trial, Kind of Court to Hear the Case 4 II. Defendants, Plaintiffs 4 II. On How the Court is to Rule on the Case 5 III. On Whether to Involve the Nursing State Board or Not, and Why 5 IV. On Whether the Policy and Procedures Manual of the Hospital Should be Altered/Changed or Not, and Why. Involved Parties In Case Changes Are to be Made 6 V. Answers to End of Case Questions 6 References 8 I. Principles of Protecting Patient Safety Involved in Case The proper administration of narcotics to patients is an aspect of patient safety relating to procedures as well as to the accuracy of the doses given to patients. Timeliness of administration is also an issue, where for instance the procedural changes can affect the timeliness and availability of the medications when they are needed. Errors are to be expected in complex setting such as acute care, but they have to be addressed systematically to improve patient safety and outcomes (Brindley, 2010). II. On whether the nurses were negligent for delaying medication documentation There were practical reasons that the nurses cited to break with procedures and delay the documentation for the medication. First the nurses would electronically sign off on IV bags, for instance, so that they would be available when they were needed, even though they had to be junked sometimes when the situation for their need ceased to be operative, or the doctors changed their minds. There was no procedure in place also to make sure that nurses remembered what they signed for electronically, as they did this at the end of the shift or during their breaks. The redundant electronic and manual entries were procedural elements that led to lapses due to human errors that are understandable given the situation. No, the nurses are not negligent. The procedure is flawed (Brindley, 2010; WHO, 2002; AMA, 2013; Jones, n.d.) III. On whether the delay was below the standard of care It is not below the standard of care to delay the documentation for the documentation, given that this has to take a lower priority in a list of priorities that include spending time with more critical patient-related tasks, such as administering the medications, doing the rounds, and assisting the doctors with patient-related needs. This is an error in procedure that the nurses were made to go into, and which led to understandable lapses (Brindley, 2010; WHO, 2002; AMA, 2013; Jones, n.d.). IV. Ethical Principles for Consideration When Hospital Looks at Situation Root Causes The primary consideration is intent. Do the nurses have an intent to cheat procedures in order to gain personally, and to compromise patient safety and outcomes? Is the intent criminal, or are the mistakes and lapses understandable consequences of nurses making mistakes due to flaws in procedures themselves? Are the nurses working in earnest, rather than intentionally cheating in order to gain access to narcotics for their own use? (Brindley, 2010; WHO, 2002; AMA, 2013; Jones, n.d.) V. Charges if the Case Were to Go to Trial, Kind of Court to Hear the Case The charges the hospital may level against the nurse would be intentional breach of procedure in order to procure narcotics and cheat the hospital, and criminal intent to compromise patient safety by compromising supplies of vital narcotics, among many other potential cases. A labor court, or a criminal court, can hear this case (Brindley, 2010; WHO, 2002; AMA, 2013; Jones, n.d.) II. Defendants, Plaintiffs If the case were to go to trial, there would be the given that the arbitrator had ruled in favor of the nurse who was suspended. That nurse in question had filed a grievance. The hospital had appealed the decision of the arbitrator, and would sue. The plaintiffs in a case, if this were to go to trial, would be the hospital administrators, on behalf of the hospital. The defendant would be the nurse who was initially suspended. The case would then be built on these case facts, with the decision of the arbitrator and the ensuing appeal filed by the hospital, together with the evidence presented in the trial tied to the appeal, as being the givens of the case (Brindley, 2010; WHO, 2002; AMA, 2013; Jones, n.d.) II. On How the Court is to Rule on the Case If this case were to go to trial, given the evidence presented in the case facts, the court would rule in favor of the defendant, and the hospital charges would be junked. This is because it is clear from the evidence that there was no intention to cheat the hospital. The error lay in the procedures, that made the nurses prone to commit errors in the manual documentation (Brindley, 2010; WHO, 2002; AMA, 2013; Jones, n.d.). III. On Whether to Involve the Nursing State Board or Not, and Why Certainly a case can be made for involving the state nursing board in this case, because the nurse’s rights may be compromised, and if the trial goes in favor of the hospital, then the rights of other nurses may also be compromised. This is because the problem is with procedure. The same procedure of having to do manual documentation for medications can lead to other nurses making the same lapses, and can lead to the hospital charging them for similar crimes (Brindley, 2010; WHO, 2002; AMA, 2013; Jones, n.d.) IV. On Whether the Policy and Procedures Manual of the Hospital Should be Altered/Changed or Not, and Why. Involved Parties In Case Changes Are to be Made The procedures relating to the manual documentation of medications should be changed. The manual and electronic systems have to be integrated, and should have facilities for returning items that were not used due to various reasons, such as change of circumstances and change of mind on the part of the doctor. The hospital admin and the nurses should be involved when making changes, because the nurses for one have intimate knowledge of the process and its current flaws (Brindley, 2010; WHO, 2002; AMA, 2013; Jones, n.d.). V. Answers to End of Case Questions 1. The facility did not seem to have ample evidence to enforce the suspension of the nurse from her work. This is due to the fact that they took the procedure as fool-proof and error-proof, and there were the testimonies of the nurses that showed the flaws in the procedures (Brindley, 2010; WHO, 2002; AMA, 2013; Jones, n.d.) 2. The testimonies of the other nurses clearly show that the procedures are full of holes, and that the manual documentation procedure, when considered in the context of the work flow of the nurses, is prone to error. These testimonies are material, and have deciding impact on the case (Brindley, 2010; WHO, 2002; AMA, 2013; Jones, n.d.) 3. Additional questions: Do other nurses show the same discrepancies in their manual documentations, or is this an isolated case? Did they pursue similar cases if there were discrepancies with other nurses, or are they solely prosecuting the nurse in this case? (Brindley, 2010; WHO, 2002; AMA, 2013; Jones, n.d.) 4. I would rule in favor of the nurse, and junk the case filed by the hospital, for the reasons already cited in the above discussion (Brindley, 2010; WHO, 2002; AMA, 2013; Jones, n.d.) References AMA (2013). New AMA Report Offers Principles for Patient Safety After Hospital Stays. AMA. Retrieved from http://www.ama-assn.org/ama/pub/news/news/2013-02-06-principles-patient-safety-after-hospital-stays.page Brindley, P. (2010). Patient safety and acute care medicine: lessons for the future, insights from the past. Critical Care. Retrieved from http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2887110/ Jones, K. (n.d.). An Introduction to Patient Safety Principles for Rural Healthcare Providers and Governing Boards. University of Nebraska Medical Center. Retrieved from http://www.unmc.edu/rural/patient-safety/presentations/Intro%20to%20Patient%20Safety%20Principles%20for%20Boards%20revised%20final.pdf WHO (2002). Quality of care: patient safety. WHO. Retrieved from http://www.who.int/patientsafety/worldalliance/ea5513.pdf Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Nursing and Principles of Protecting Patient Safety Case Study”, n.d.)
Nursing and Principles of Protecting Patient Safety Case Study. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1793986-legal-aspects-of-nursing
(Nursing and Principles of Protecting Patient Safety Case Study)
Nursing and Principles of Protecting Patient Safety Case Study. https://studentshare.org/law/1793986-legal-aspects-of-nursing.
“Nursing and Principles of Protecting Patient Safety Case Study”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1793986-legal-aspects-of-nursing.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Nursing and Principles of Protecting Patient Safety

Nurses Practice Acts, Federal Regulations and Nursing Homes

Consequent to compliance with the nursing standards and principles set by these legislations, patients' mental, physical, and psychological well being has improved considerably.... Introduction Since historical times, nursing and other medical professions have been interrelated to politics and governments through health departments and agencies.... As a result of these Acts' critical role in the protection of public health, welfare, and safety, their enactment and implementation should be supported to fruition....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Ethical Case Study: Jose

Theory of protective empowering for balancing patient safety and choices.... Even though nurses are obliged to respect the patient's decision with regards to their own preferred care and treatment, nurses should also keep in mind that they need to equally satisfy the principles of informed consent, non-maleficence, beneficence, and justice (Finkelman & Kenner, 2013, p.... Even though nurses are obliged to respect the patient's decision with regards to their own preferred care and treatment, nurses should also keep in mind that they need to equally satisfy the principles of informed consent, non-maleficence, beneficence, and justice (Finkelman & Kenner, 2013, p....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Legal Aspect of Nursing

There is violation of various principles that involve protecting patient safety that arise in this case.... One key principle is the proper administration of medications to patients; an error in medication endangers the safety of the patient (Austin, 2008).... An essay "Legal Aspect of nursing" outlines that the important fact that most professionals ought to understand is that; in both instances, those professionals who end up causing either often face serious consequences....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Legal Aspects Of Nursing

hellip; This essay presents that patient safety in medical field is the greatest and paramount thing that practicing professionals as well as the legal frameworks strive earnestly to realize in the day-to-day operations.... owever, failure to observe patient safety results to lengthy stay in the hospital by patients, permanent injuries as well as even death.... The purpose of the essay "Legal Aspects of Nursing" is to analyze the responsibility of all the stakeholders (all involved in the welfare of a patient) to ensure that effective safety principles, which include the fact that patients receive the right attention from qualified personnel, are observed....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

American Nurses Association

In the ethical code of American Nurses association, nine primary principles of ethics: are enshrined.... They include: Compassion and respect for the patient, commitment and protection of patient's health, protection of patient's safety and rights, being accountable and responsible, creating right environment, participation in advancement of profession, collaboration with other health professionals, and professional nursing by maintaining integrity and shaping social policy. … Other principles and ideas stated are respect to human dignity, sincere relationship with the patients irrespective of nature of sickness, honoring self-determination rights of the patients, co-operation with colleagues, primacy of patient's interests, avoiding conflicts of loyalty, collaboration with all aspects of patient's health and its requirements, care not to cross the professional boundaries, and protection from research in case of patient's denial, etc. Potential conflicts might arise from intra-professional integrity, collective responsibility, assertion of values, responsibilities to the public, implementing professional standards in clinical, administrative and educational practice, responsibility for care environment, influencing the environment with moral virtues and values, preserving integrity and ethical character, maintaining confidentiality, responsibility and accountability in judgment and action etc....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Principles of Health Care Ethics

This paper tells that nurses and other medical health practitioners have the responsibility of protecting and promoting the health of individuals and society.... Case Study: EthicsNurses and other medical health practitioners have the responsibility of protecting and promoting the health of individuals and society.... However, in this case there seems to be a conflict between beneficence and autonomy principles of ethics.... principles of Health Care Ethics....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

A Reflection on the Performance in a Professional Environment

hellip; As a university student taking a degree course in Assistant Practitioner Foundation in healthcare and also a community healthcare assistant with the district nursing team, I have a job with intensive roles.... The essay entails enormous consideration into UK laws attaching on the exposure of confidential information regarding the patients' health conditions and how it has affected my role as a health worker in the UK....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Miss Evers' Boys

The American Nurses Association explains that a nurse has a primary commitment to the patients and works to protect the rights, safety and health of the patient.... Government policies compel the nurse in the film to defy their ethical principles while the actions of the single nurse in the film shows that she understands the nursing ethics, and she strives to maintain them even in the grim instances.... The object of analysis for the purpose of this assignment is the film “Miss Evers' Boys” that captures the conflict that may often exist between nursing practice and government regulations....
2 Pages (500 words) Movie Review
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us