StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Major Issues in Contract Law - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The essay "Major Issues in Contract Law" focuses on the critical analysis of the major issues in contract law. In common law, a contract is an agreement for the transfer of lawful objects involving two or more voluntary parties bound by their individual intent to create legal duties between them…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.1% of users find it useful
Major Issues in Contract Law
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Major Issues in Contract Law"

Contract Law: Case Study Number Department Rose v Saba In common law, a contract is an agreement for thetransfer of lawful object involving two or more voluntary parties bound by their individual intent to create legal duties between them. A valid contract must have an "offer" by the offeror and "acceptance" by the offeree (Mann, & Roberts, 2012). The parties must have the legal ability to make "consideration" in respect of the offer and establish mutuality of responsibility. Although, Rose may not provide proof of these elements of a contract in writing because she communicated her intent to create a contract via telephone call, common law considers unwritten contracts as valid and enforceable. Nonetheless, the relationship between Rose and Saba concerning a graphic design desktop computer worth 1,500 did not constitute a valid contract. Despite the seller’s “offer” of the item for sale, MacIntyre (2013) would argue that Rose’s response did not meet the “acceptance” test. Her counter-offer of 1,000 for the same item was not readily accepted by the seller, thus stripping the agreement of any validity. This case is almost similar to Hyde v Wrench (1840) 49 ER 132 in which the respondent offered a piece of land valued at £1,000 for sale (Elliott, & Quinn, 2014). The plaintiff gave a counter offer of £950 which the seller refused. The plaintiff then communicated his acceptance of the initial offer of £1,000, but the seller refused to sell the property to him, prompting the litigation for performance. The court is likely to follow the precedent set in Hyde where a counter-offer invalidated the contract and stripped the claimant of the rights to specific performance. (Word Count 270) Rose v TW The status of contract between Rose and TW depends on whether each party acted reasonably to see its creation. Whereas the two weeks that Rose took to communicate her acceptance of the TW offer was reasonable, it may have been the cause of the subsequent delay, leading TW to revoke the contract. The main legal issue in this case is whether TW made a valid revocation of the offer. The validity of a revocation of an offer principally lies in its communication to the offeree. Rose has grounds against the validity of TW’s letter of revocation. Rose’s claims are backed by the ruling in Byrne & Co v Leon Van Tien Hoven & Co [1880] 5 CPD 344 where the court imposed a ban on revocation of an offer by the postal rule, but allowed acceptance under similar circumstances. As Justice Lindley held in the case, TW would only be deemed as having validly revoked the offer through a direct communication to Rose, which it did not do. As Cooke (2007) said, the verdict in Byrne overruled Shuey v U.S. (1875) 92 US 73, where it was held that a revocation should be communicated through the same means as the offer, because unlike acceptance, cancelling a contract is an adverse action with negative impacts. (Word Count 217) Rose v The Police The contract between Rose and Police for security services at the function is valid and enforceable. As Keenan and Smith (2007) said, the contact met all of the conditions required such as: a) an offer by Rose seeking protection at the function; b) acceptance by the police agency to send in some officers; c) consideration in the service fee amounting to 95; and the intent of either party to create a legal relationship where Rose would pay the money for the security service. Rose’s refusal to pay for the services is therefore actionable under the law. A court is likely to order specific performance in addition to compensation for any reasonable losses incurred by the agency following Rose’s breach of the contract. Rose’s situation resembles the situation in which the defendant in Sunrock Aircraft Corp v Sandinavian Airlines Systems [2007] EWCA Civ 882 was in. In the latter case, the court may have ordered the payment of nominal damages to the claimant for a breach of the contract if he had not sold the aircraft at a cost which technically covered the repair expenditures (Elliott, & Quinn, 2013). In the case, the claimant had lent the defendant two aircraft under an agreement requiring him to repair the planes before taking them back, but he did not. By contrast, the court is most likely to order Rose to pay the 95 as per their agreement. (Word count 238) Rose v the Band Rose entered into a contract with the Band concerning the use of her songs by the latter party at a fee. Other members of the band say that according to the contract, Rose would be entitled to her song-writing royalties only. In light of this, Marson (2013) noted that a court of law is likely to uphold the letter and spirit of the contract, and thus deny Rose of any additional payments, particularly if Rose’s claims are not substantial. However, if Rose has proper documentation of the earnings and has made appropriate steps to inform the rest of the band members about the amount of money she expects from them, then her claims are likely to be granted, provided there is proof of the consideration. Williams v Roffey Bros & Nicholls (Contractors) Ltd [1990] 2 WLR 1153 is a landmark case, in which the court held that changing an agreement after formalizing a contract can be legal, provided there is consideration in the form of "factual benefits" to the defendant (Riches, & Allen, 2011). In the case, the claimant was a carpentry company awarded a sub-contract to complete wooden fittings on 27 flats. In the course of the work, the claimant realized that it had under-quoted the cost of the services. It ran into financial difficulty and notified the contractor who then contracted another party and refused to pay Williams’ his dues (Jones, 2013). Unlike in Rose’s case, the court found consideration in Williams in the defendant’s expectation of a timely completion of the job in order to avoid penalty obligations upon the defendant (Word Count 264) References Cooke, J. 2007. Law of Tort. London: Longman. Elliott, C., & Quinn, F., 2013. Contract Law. Upper Saddle River: Pearson Education, Limited. Elliott, C., & Quinn, F., 2014. English Legal System. Upper Saddle River: Pearson Education, Limited. Jones, L., 2013. Introduction to Business Law. Oxford: Oxford University Press. Keenan, D.J., & Smith, K., 2007. Smith & Keenans English Law: Text and Cases. London: Longman. MacIntyre, E., 2013. Business Law. Upper Saddle River, NJ: Pearson Education, Limited. Mann, R. & Roberts, B., 2012. Essentials of Business Law and the Legal Environment. New York: Cengage Learning. Marson, J., 2013. Business Law. Oxford: Oxford University Press. Riches, S., & Allen, V., 2011. Keenan and Riches Business Law. Upper Saddle River: Pearson Longman. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Answer question Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words - 3”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1670665-answer-question
(Answer Question Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words - 3)
https://studentshare.org/law/1670665-answer-question.
“Answer Question Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words - 3”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1670665-answer-question.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Major Issues in Contract Law

Major Issues on the Law of Contract

The essay "major issues on the Law of Contract" focuses on the critical analysis of the major issues on the law of contract.... A contract is a legally binding agreement between two parties, which is enforceable by law.... For a contract to exist it should be between two parties the parties must have the duties to perform and it should be enforceable by law.... This is because the contract was not enforceable by law....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Contract Law, Laws Relating to Legality

The paper "contract law, Laws Relating to Legality" highlights that the law of contract is a very wide and important topic.... Laws relating to legality This section of the law is said to be one of the most confusing areas of contract law.... The rights and obligations that are created by contact are enforceable in the courts of law.... An illegal contract cannot be enforced by a court of law according to English laws.... Forming an illegal contract has its consequences under English law....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Major Issues on the Law of Contract

The study "major issues on the Law of Contract" focuses on the critical analysis of the major issues on the law of contract.... This issue concerns the invitation to treat under the law of contract.... He would not succeed in any court of law for him to be sold the gold watch at £25.... The prospective buyer, by offering that price is himself the offeror and his offer, if accepted, creates a binding contract....
7 Pages (1750 words) Case Study

Unfair Terms in the Contracts and Exclusion of Liabilities

There are circumstances under which the courts have barred the use of a particular term of the contract simply because the term could be treated as an 'unfair' one.... The author states that an unfair term in a contract implies that the contract contains a clause capable of causing imbalances in the rights and obligations concerning one of the parties to the contract significantly detrimental to the party.... But it is certain that the Unfair contract Terms Act 1977 considers the invalidation of the limitations and exclusions of the liabilities arising out of the operation of the standard written terms of business in case they are found to be unfair or unreasonable....
62 Pages (15500 words) Essay

Employment Law: Implied Contracts

The author of the paper titled "Employment law: Implied Contracts" critically discusses the statement that a survey of the leading cases dealing with implied contractual terms would suggest that the judge's decisions almost always favor the employee.... Johnson v Unisys Limited, 2001 is also a leading labor law in the United Kingdom and represents a case where damages were made for unfair dismissal of the employer and the nature of the employment contract.... Statutory terms are terms imposed and regulated by law such as the period of minimum statutory notice Expressed terms are terms that are specifically stated in the employment contract, either written down or in oral agreements, and have been agreed mutually by both the employer and the employee....
13 Pages (3250 words) Case Study

Limitation of Liability in Civil Wrongs Cases

One of the similarities between a condition and a warrant is that they are both terms of a contract.... They set out the obligations contract parties are supposed to undertake in order for the contract to be executed.... Secondly, both warranties and conditions have a significant effect on the way a contract will be performed.... While a breach of a warrant entitles the innocent party to damages, a breach of a condition is sufficient ground for the innocent party to seek termination of the contract....
6 Pages (1500 words) Assignment

Breach of Contract as a Major Issue in the Law of Contract

Various issues associated with the terms of a contract and the failure of the parties to comply with those terms hold up the contract law.... The paper "Breach of Contract as a Major Issue in the law of Contract" discusses that the question of whether Josh and Julie's legal rights and obligations allowed them to claim against breach of contract is answered.... Breach of contract is a major issue in the law of contract.... The essay's argument will be based on an applicable case law related to the provided case, which gives evidence for the argument....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Law of Contract

The paper "law of Contract" is an impressive example of a law case study.... The paper "law of Contract" is an impressive example of a law case study.... The paper "law of Contract" is an impressive example of a law case study.... Compuhelp through its sales representative Sophie after a conversation with Office supply states that Compuhelp can provide the services requested by Office supply and promises to send a contract for Office supply to review....
6 Pages (1500 words) Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us