StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Death Penalty as a Barbaric Form of Punishment - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The author of the paper "Death Penalty as a Barbaric Form of Punishment" argues that the bill of rights supports the right of individuals to live and associate freely. On the other hand, the same legal provision is also used to condemn capital offenders to a death sentence…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98% of users find it useful
Death Penalty as a Barbaric Form of Punishment
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Death Penalty as a Barbaric Form of Punishment"

Death Penalty Death penalty has been a controversial issue in the international community. Many nations have been disturbed and argued about the best way it can be handled. This has made generation of questions on how best the capital offenders can be punished in order to have justice for both the offenders and victims of the circumstances. The bill of rights supports the right of individuals to live and associate freely. On the other hand, the same legal provision is also used to condemn capital offenders to death sentence. The religious community questions the legality of the death sentences and at the same time urges citizens to follow the law. It is still ironical when they defend the law breakers. Many countries stress that the justice system must be observed for the victims. Several views have been given on this issue. They are legal, religious, political and socialist perspectives. There are arguments about the pros and cons of execution. Publicized studies have also confirmed that many innocent people have been wrongly executed. On the other hand, the issue of terrorism is a threat to state, especially when the perpetrators are not brought to book. What should be the best action to take? This has brought divergent views. Generally, opinion is divided on the step to take on this issue. Some people insinuate that it will be very expensive on the tax payer’s side if execution is allowed. It costs about between two to five times more to execute a criminal than to maintain a criminal in the prison for the rest of the life (Paternoster and Bacon 91). Those against argue that the financial amount required is pegged on the long court procedures, legal wrangling and many endless appeals. A criminal can be on death row for up to 20 years (Baumgartner, Boydstun and De Boef 47). This is very expensive for the state due to the said legal procedures. Supporters of the death penalty state that it is better to use state resources to penalize the murderers in order to save lives of innocent people. They categorically state that this action creates crime deterrent. Crime would always be on the increase if there is no any stern action taken against these people (Vaughn 98). According to research carried out in Pennsylvania alone, there are ineffective defense attorneys who fail to conduct satisfactory investigations to support their clients. This has lead to conviction of innocent suspects, especially those involved in complicated cases (Hood and Hoyle 105). Many cases are confirmed that some lawyers made mistakes and the judges have made rulings based on their findings. It is also argued that death penalty is barbaric form of punishment. Paternoster and Bacon state that all forms of death penalty are unfair (55). In exemplifying this, the argument states, whether it is through lethal injection, hanging, using the firing squad or electric chair, this state sanctioned murder is not fair before a crowd of people (Paternoster and Bacon 56). For instances, California physicians refused the demand by the government to use lethal injection as a means of execution hence execution was stopped. They claimed that there are many constructive ways in addressing violent crimes and those two wrongs do not make a right (Baumgartner, Boydstun and De Boef 78). However, the proponents of death penalty action feel that this is the only way to deter criminals from any further illegal actions. They argue that justice must be served in favour of the victims. Most fundamental legal provision is that punishment should always fit the crime. In addition, justice delayed is justice denied (Morris 70). Those against death penalty sentences say that it is bad because the state should not use killing to show that murder and manslaughter are bad. There should be another appropriate method. Prison alone is effective because life there is quite deterring, as stated by those who are against the death penalty. They quote, ‘’ Living in the prison is punishment enough” (Baumgartner, Boydstun and De Boef 123). It is also feared that the killers themselves can revenge against the state depending on the punishment effected, basing their arguments on ‘’they killed one of us” slogan may surface (Paternoster and Bacon 89). In addition, the movement claims that it can destroy the positive image of the country. Amnesty International for instance had printed T-shirt with dots in the year 2010. Red stars showed US states still practicing death penalty whereas white stars showed those states not recommending death penalty (Vaughn 35). In contrast, proponents argue out strongly on their stand. They simply note that the justice system shows sympathy to the criminals than to victims. They emphasized on re-establishing the criminal justice system back on track to ensure that justice prevails to the victims, and not to the accused. Besides, they have denied the claims by those opposing the innocent victims. On strengthening their position, they indicate that it is possible to conduct proper scientific research based on DNA testing to establish real murderers (Morris 203). Other forensic researches give confidence of about 99 %, thus it is very instrumental in the process of identification (Morris 196). These views are very critical, depending on the cases to be determined. CNN’s perspective report on interviewing the most perceived supporters of death sentences, the families who lost their loved ones, stated that those families believed that executing the murderer would not do anything to them (Paternoster and Bacon 98). Some give reason based on the family faith while others just do not understand the gains they can have in executing the guilty. Barbara Anderson from Mississippi wrote a letter to district attorney giving reasons that out of faith, the family had reconsidered their stand on the murder case and was against capital punishment (Roger 49). Other people state that when the prisoners are locked up in the cells, this may give them another opportunity escapes the prison cell. The remedy is simply to execute once and for all. This explains their argument for the death penalty. Many states have started abolishing the death penalty conviction. It is only the countries like US, South Korea and Japan which are still practicing the capital offence punishment. But, even these countries are slowly coming to reality and in many democracies; the capital offence punishment is almost ending. In conclusion, we have observed divergent views on the issue, but I noticed some important observations stated on the subject. That it makes no different in cases where the murderers are executed. This leads to even killing the innocent victims. Therefore, the best action to take in dealing with the capital offenders should not be death penalty. This will give room for reformation of these law breakers. In addition, human beings make laws and it is in such a way that they can be redesigned to enhance democracy in the whole world. Works Cited Baumgartner, Frank, R. , Boydstun, Amber, E. and De Boef, Suzzane, L. Decline of the Death Penalty & Discovery of Innocence. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2008. Print. Opposing view points. Hood, Roger, G. and Hoyle, Carolyn. “Death Penalty.” Worldwide Perspective. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2008. Print. Neutral view point. Morris, Bakken, G. Invitation to an Execution: History of Death Penalty in US. Mexico: University of New Mexico Press, 2010. Print. Supporting viewpoints. Paternoster, Raymond and Bacon, Robert. Death Penalty. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2008. Print opposing views. Vaughn, Courtney. Living With Death Penalty. Bloomington, Ind: Xlibris Corporation, 2006. Print. Supporting views. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Death Penalty Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words - 1”, n.d.)
Retrieved de https://studentshare.org/law/1392117-death-penalty
(Death Penalty Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words - 1)
https://studentshare.org/law/1392117-death-penalty.
“Death Penalty Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words - 1”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1392117-death-penalty.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Death Penalty as a Barbaric Form of Punishment

Abolishing Death Penalty

This research paper "Abolishing Death Penalty" discusses the death penalty as a wrong alternative that the justice system exposes capital offenders who are charged with severe crimes.... Some people also cite the death penalty as a cause of psychological burden to the executors, prone to errors, and a mark of death and not life.... As a form of punishment, in some justice systems,' the death penalty punishes a collective number of capital offenders who are guilty....
10 Pages (2500 words) Research Paper

Anti-Death Penalty

Anti Death-penalty Anti Death-Penalty A debate has existed in the United States of America for quite some time that whether death-penalty proves itself to be a justified and valid form of punishment for the wrong-doings of the people or not.... The proponents of the death-penalty justify it by biblical quotations to use death penalty as the ultimate punishment for murders and equivalent crimes.... The opponents believe that death-penalty should be abolished because it is a barbaric act of murder which involves the death of an individual in a...
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Is the Death penalty effective

A debate has existed in the United States of America for quite some time that whether death-penalty proves itself to be a justified and valid form of punishment for the wrong-doings of the people or not.... The proponents of the death-penalty justify it by biblical quotations to use death penalty as the ultimate punishment for murders and equivalent crimes.... The opponents believe that death-penalty should be abolished because it is a barbaric act of murder which involves the death of an individual in a similar...
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Case against death penalty

Some people also cite death penalty as a cause of psychological burden to the executers, prone to errors, and a mark of death and not life.... As a form of punishment, some justice systems death penalty punishes a collective number of capital offenders who are guilty.... The practice of the death penalty is a cruel form of ending the life of capital offenders, because justice systems take their life with no thought about it.... eath penalty is a barbaric act of punishing capital offenders as compared to other options like life imprisonment (Banner 169)....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Punishment for a Crime Committed

Some nations had sentences in the form of beating to death, burial when alive, g at sea and crucifixion (Melusky & Pesto 8).... death penalty, also known as capital punishment is a legal process that involves the killing of a person as punishment for a crime committed, also known as capital crimes.... Most legal firms claim that a death penalty is justice only if one has committed a capital crime such as killing another person.... Capital punishment has been in existence for a long period....
4 Pages (1000 words) Term Paper

Cruel and Unusual Punishment

These people consider the death penalty to be a form of cruel and unusual punishment.... They believe it is an appropriate form of censure.... People argue that it is a part of a barbaric ancient world and as such it no longer has any place in our contemporary world.... But upon critical consideration, the idea that the death penalty is cruel and unusual punishment does not stand up to scrutiny.... The truth is we need to look at the death penalty in the contemporary world and examine its effectiveness....
8 Pages (2000 words) Case Study

Death Penalty in Africa and the USA

They revolve around making a necessary recourse of this form of punishment.... Also, alternative means of punishment other than the death penalty need to be prioritized over the later.... Conversely, more intensive debates about the abolition of this form of this punishment keep arising.... The paper "death penalty in Africa and the USA" focuses on the critical analysis and comparison of the death penalty between the African states and the United States and concludes in supporting the abolition of the practice in resonance with the international trend....
7 Pages (1750 words) Term Paper

The Use of the Punitive Controls

Some commit crimes to avenge or seek justice and are usually punished on the retributive principle in demand for an equal proportion of punishment.... Punishments for crimes are in the form of imprisonment, deportation, execution, community service, and compensation, among others.... Based on penology context a punishment is a penalty imposed on criminals by the state authority in response to a violation of the law.... Legal punishment is imposed by state constituted institutions, entails unpleasantness to the victims, for parties in breach of law....
7 Pages (1750 words) Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us