StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

State-Controlled Media: Different, Biased Versions on the Ukraine Crisis - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
This paper declares that as the Ukraine crisis unravels, people from different sides of the world rely on different news and information sources to understand what is happening. The media, though used in the singular sense, is then actually far from being a monolithic entity. …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98% of users find it useful
State-Controlled Media: Different, Biased Versions on the Ukraine Crisis
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "State-Controlled Media: Different, Biased Versions on the Ukraine Crisis"

As the Ukraine crisis unravels, people from different sides of the world rely on different news and information sources to understand what is happening. Some of them use state-sponsored media, or social media, or Western media, or all of the above, while others may be witnesses to these events themselves. The media, though used in the singular sense, is then actually far from being a monolithic entity. In the case of the Ukraine crisis, the media can be differentiated across every nation and region. Western media is composed of the United States and the European Union (EU), Ukraine and Russia have their own media monopolies, and every nation have their own social media users who support or criticize their governments and other governments. It is important to analyze the role of the media in depicting and shaping the Ukraine crisis because whoever controls the media affects what the media intends to affect- the ideology and behaviors of the civil society of each state and perceptions of the international public. Each state controls government-sponsored media for their own political and economic interests by promoting their official stories through framing the news and information which their supporters reinforce through social media reporting and all of them present issues and the news without further commenting on the incompleteness of these media reports and analyses and without promoting critical thinking for all audiences, thereby creating a misinformed public sphere. Western media is guilty of framing the Ukraine issue through familiar official stories that easily pit pro-Ukrainian versus pro-Russian with greater vilification against the latter because of the importance of maintaining a pro-Western ally in Ukraine. Many reports from the West describe Russia as the enemy that instigates unrest in Ukraine for its own political needs of re-claiming Eastern Europe away from the EU and the U.S. BBC’s “Ukraine in Maps” provides a simplistic view of the Ukraine issue. Because of what is happening in Ukraine, the West reports that Russia is taking advantage of the unrest to annex Crimea. The BBC reports: “The EU and U.S. condemned the ‘annexation’ of Crimea and imposed sanctions on Russian and Ukrainian officials” (“Ukraine in Maps”). The report frames the issue in ways that immediately place Russia as the enemy of Crimea, Ukraine, and the West, without fully providing details of what happened in Crimea and how it is connected to Ukraine. Vladimir Golstein of The Nation criticizes how Western media covers the Ukraine crisis. He undercuts the manipulation of facts by the media through the example of Western coverage on the burning of pro-Russians in Odessa: “the Western press dutifully refers to ‘the clashes between pro Ukrainian and pro-Russians,’ without any explanation as to why several dozen unarmed citizen of Ukraine were burned alive in an Odessa building” (Golstein). The Western media framing of the crisis serves to only over-simplify the issue by immediately showing compassion for the Ukrainian state and supporters and denigration for the Russian state. The impact is fanning the flames of old official narratives about evil, communist, authoritarian Russia and the benevolent, freedom-giving, democratic West. Aside from the West, the Ukrainian and Russian states and supporters also influence the media so that it will report a frame that benefits each of them in the eyes of the civil society because they want a public sphere that supports their political and economic interests. The BBC provides some information of what some of these basic economic interests are. The West has an economic interest in Ukraine that will be cemented through the loan they will provide to the latter: “With funds from other donors [from the International Monetary Fund (IMF)], including the EU, the total package will be worth £32.1bn” (“Ukraine in Maps”). Other economic interests are also political because it concerns energy needs. Ukraine imports majority of its gas and oil from Russia, while around one-third of Europe's gas also comes from Russia, where around half goes through Ukraine (“Ukraine in Maps”). Ukraine media benefits then from being more pro-West than pro-Russia because of the loan it needs to aid its struggling economy. Russia has a political interest in maintaining its leadership in the region. Golstein remarks on how Ukrainian and Russian media each approach their ideological perspectives. With interconnected or conflicting interests, it is not surprising that their media frame the Ukraine crisis for their own interests. Social media reinforces or contradicts state-sponsored media, but not always to improve the quality and quantity of information, but to replicate each group’s ideologies. Social media platforms are now used to mimic real-life socialization patterns and effects. In The Culture of Connectivity , Jose van Dijck asserts that social media is now complementing, if not at times, supplanting, “informal and ephemeral manifestations of social life” (6). While the upside of social media is that it can offer new sources of accurate news, the downside is that it can also be used as political propaganda for people who prefer to preserve their ideologies with regards to organizations or governments that they support. David Stern reports from the National Geographic that pro-Russians and pro-Ukrainian media, mostly social media, are framing news to support their own views. On the one hand, “Pro-Russians glossed over or denied that members of their contingent apparently shot at the pro-Ukrainians from behind police lines (as one video seems to suggest),” and, on the other hand, “the pro-Ukrainians have omitted important information as well. Their crowd was packed with far-right nationalists. They too were well armed and ready for a fight” (Stern). These reports indicate that social media is also being skewed for the purpose of manipulating the public sphere and generating a lop-sided public debate on the crisis. Connectivity is now being used to spread slanted news, where opinions and interpretations of images and information are mixed with what social media users believe as “facts” or “reality.” Social media and state-sponsored media work together in supporting their own ideology of beliefs about Ukraine and Russia. The media misrepresents the news by creating monolithic perspectives and disregarding transparency and not calling for critical, balanced thinking among the audiences. The media uses the public sphere to inform public opinion and actions. Manuel Castells argues that the public sphere is not only a space for public interaction, but a “cultural/informational repository of the ideas and projects that feed public debate” (79). The media do not promote critical thinking and openness in the public debate because every media has its own political motivations. In Social History of the Media, Asa Briggs and Peter Burke depict the history of the information age. As communication technologies evolved, media role in society changed too. Media no longer just broadcasts information in an objective manner, but slant, or skew, them to serve particular interests. In addition, Briggs and Burke stress that the civil society is now informatized because of how people can easily access information through the media. However, Briggs and Burke underscore that media has a developed a larger role in controlling information because of their control on its content and intentions. As a result, they argue that the media’s control of information has implications for power in the knowledge world: “[c]ontrol of information…would be the essence of wealth and power in the future” (Briggs and Burke 232). The Ukraine crisis is defined according to who controls the media. Catherine E. Shoichet of CNN reports from the West, but she, at least, accepts that the news says what its state wants. For every question, she answers it from the sides of Ukraine, Russia, and the U.S. In doing so, she presents people different sides of the issue, though in summarized forms. Still, majority of the media overwhelming lacks the absence of accountability of how incomplete and potentially biased their news sources are. As a result, people who support either side can cherry pick whatever supports their opinions instead of inviting debate in the civil society of each nation and across the globe. Hence, the media, in its plural sense, frames the Ukraine issue along lines of official stories that each state wants to express in the public sphere, each of which lacking in objectivity and completeness, because of the prevailing ideologies that shape the interests of framed news. The role of media in the Ukraine crisis is not to report the news as it is, but to report the news to support particular ideologies. Whether it is the ideology of the West, Ukraine, or Russia, the media has become a means for political and economic preservation and promotion for each state. Civil society is left to analyze which parts of the news are true or accurate. The public sphere is now the motley of politically-and-economically-motivated news. Social media and connectivity, apparently, is not a refuge, but may even be a means for greater misinformation and propaganda. Hence, the Ukraine crisis proves that the media is far from being objective, but a means for national and international propaganda for particular economic and political interests. Works Cited Briggs, Asa, and Peter Burke. Social History of the Media: From Gutenberg to the Internet. 3rd ed. Malden, MA: Polity, 2009. Print. Castells, Manuel. “The New Public Sphere: Global Civil Society, Communication Networks, and Global Governance.” The Annals of the American Academy (2008): 78-86. Web. 24 May 2014. van Dijck, José. The Culture of Connectivity: A Critical History of Social Media. Oxford: Oxford U P, 2013. Print. Golstein, Vladimir. “Western Media Coverage of the Ukraine Crisis Is as Distorted as Soviet Propaganda.” The Nation, 22 May 2014. Web. 24 May 2014. Shoichet, Catherine E. “Ukraine Crisis: What's Happening? Depends On Whom You Ask.” CNN, 4 Mar. 2014. Web. 24 May 2014. Stern, David. “The Twitter War: Social Media's Role in Ukraine Unrest.” National Geographic, 10 May 2014. Web. 24 May 2014. “Ukraine in Maps: How the Crisis Spread.” BBC News, 9 May 2014. Web. 24 May 2014. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“State-Controlled Media: Different, Biased Versions on the Ukraine Essay - 1”, n.d.)
State-Controlled Media: Different, Biased Versions on the Ukraine Essay - 1. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/journalism-communication/1647095-use-concepts-to-writer-a-paper
(State-Controlled Media: Different, Biased Versions on the Ukraine Essay - 1)
State-Controlled Media: Different, Biased Versions on the Ukraine Essay - 1. https://studentshare.org/journalism-communication/1647095-use-concepts-to-writer-a-paper.
“State-Controlled Media: Different, Biased Versions on the Ukraine Essay - 1”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/journalism-communication/1647095-use-concepts-to-writer-a-paper.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF State-Controlled Media: Different, Biased Versions on the Ukraine Crisis

Democracy in Ukraine

The difference between exit polls and the official count in the ukraine, by contrast, was more than 14%, and considerable evidence suggests that the Kiev government tampered with the results.... The judiciary in the ukraine is notoriously inefficient and subject to corruption.... The essay concerns the question of "Democracy in ukraine".... The insinuation that a democratic ukraine would somehow be beholden to American interest, however, is ludicrous....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Political Decisions in Ukraine

Months of political stalemate followed, with the Anti-crisis Coalition continuing to hold Rada sessions, even after opposition parties Our Ukraine and BYuT resigned their seats and deprived the parliament of a constitutional quorum.... Natasha Lisova in Kiev, (2007), Judges attempt to end Ukraines political crisis, , Retrieved on February 10, 2009 from http://www.... k/news/world/europe/judges-attempt-to-end-ukraines-political-crisis-445160.... Ever after the separation from the former Soviet Union though ukraine tries to follow the democratic methodologies, much of the recent happenings in ukraine questions their awareness about democracy....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Crisis in Ukraine

ukraine crisis: Six Reasons Why U.... The two rivals from the Cold War are once against confronted with the scenario of supporting the allies and aiming to enforce its dominance and… The recent development in the form of overthrow of the president incumbent followed by the enthronement of the like minded President of ukraine who's first trip was to Washington D.... The question whether United States of America and the other ukraine at present is the center of attention for the global powers....
2 Pages (500 words) Assignment

Ukraine-Russian oil Dispute

This essay tells about an economic crisis in the preceding years between Russia and Ukraine that have grown into a political stalemate, with the involvement of other Western nations.... The US and other western nations' attempts to mitigate over the crisis have been futile, with Russia refusing to supply oil to Ukraine.... The main conflict is that both nations fail to take responsibility over the crisis while pointing fingers at each other.... Ukraine-Russian oil Dispute Ukraine-Russian oil Dispute Russia and Ukraine have had an economic crisis in the preceding years that have grown into a political stalemate, with the involvement of other Western nations....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

Ukraine and wage

A good example is when the authors give statistics on the ukraine's economy especially after the Revolution.... A good example is when the authors give statistics on the ukraine's economy especially after the Revolution.... It is true that the ukraine economy is collapsing and that investors need to come in and save the situation.... Kiev and Sloviansk state that the GDP is expected to fall by a 10% margin, they also talk of the inflation rates that have… With these facts in question, one can easily accept the thought presented by the authors. From the article, I strongly feel that the authors would have at least included a positive side of today's ukraine and wage Kiev and Sloviansk....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

The Theory of the Spiral of Silence

The theory attempts to expound on the tendency of individuals to remain silent regarding an issue that has the support of the majority in the society (Noelle-Neumann, 1993).... The theory further… First, the isolation phobia is a contributing factor in the theory of spiral of silence.... In this case, the persons fear that the members of a particular group due to In addition, the people experiencing the circumstance of the theory often fear to lose their position in the society because of their divergent views (Donsbach, Salmon and Tsfati, 2013)....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

Colonialism in Ukraine

This essay stresses that it is rather difficult to specify the exact date when ukraine was finally colonized and forced into joining the Russian empire, this is primarily because the 1654 agreement between the Russian Emperor Aleksey Mikhailovich and the Ukrainian Hetman BohdanKhmelnytskyis.... In this council The Ukrainan Hetman BohdanKhmelnytsky signed a treaty with Muscovy which had the effect of causing ukraine to lose its independence and engage in a colonial unification with Russia....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Ukrainian Involvement in WWI

The First World War played a critical role in the fight for ukraine's independence.... ukraine emerged as a fully… During the war ukraine fought for two fronts: the allied and central powers.... The war was caused by conflicts which arose from geographical The paper "The Status of ukraine on the Eve and During the First World War" is an excellent example of a term paper on history.... Before the First World War broke out ukraine didn't exist as a nation....
3 Pages (750 words) Term Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us