StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Accounting and Regulation; Will there ever be full comparability - Literature review Example

Cite this document
Summary
This paper reviews three different scholarly writings in regards to whether there will ever be full comparability in accounting and regulations across different sectors and countries. It is important to note that comparability has been applied in this context to infer to the…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.4% of users find it useful
Accounting and Regulation; Will there ever be full comparability
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Accounting and Regulation; Will there ever be full comparability"

The paper "Accounting and Regulation; Will There Ever Be Full Comparability" is an outstanding example of a literature review on finance and accounting. This paper reviews three different scholarly writings in regards to whether there will ever be full comparability in accounting and regulations across different sectors and countries. It is important to note that comparability has been applied in this context to infer to the extent, state, or quality of different accounting procedures and regulations being comparable.

Therefore, this section will discuss aspects of accounting and regulations that will enable full comparability and even those aspects that will discourage full comparability.  Aspects of accounting and regulations that promote full comparability With reference to the writings by Benston et al. (2006), they stated that certain forms of accounting regulations provide a basis for full comparability of accounting records from different sectors and countries. For example, Penman (2007) stated that accounting records could be fully comparable on the basis that the accounting records should be able to ascertain and report on the performance of the business in terms of either loss or profit.

The second aspect about accounting and regulations, which encourage comparability, is the fact that accounting records provide information for planning and control of resources of business entity. Thirdly, since accounting records are used for decision-making and forecasting purposes, it means that different forecasts, as well as decisions, can be compared based on the supporting financial records that were used. Fourthly, Penman (2007) stated that specific accounting records such as balance sheets, cash flows, and profit and loss account, all serve different specific purposes, which means that users from different sectors and countries can compare these different records based on their distinctive purposes.

For instance, to obtain the net worth of a particular business that operates in a different sector and country, one needs to look at the business’s balance sheet records. Aspects of accounting and regulations that discourage full comparability According to Zeff (2007), different companies apply different accounting strategies and they might apply different regulations depending on the industry best practices. For example, Penman (2007) stated that the accounting records of two competing companies such as The Coca-Cola Company and the Pepsi Company bear differences that make it hard to do comparisons.

These differences arise from simple facts such as the difference in terms of the markets that the two competing companies cover or difference in a product range that the two companies produce. This means it will be hard to compare the market performance for these two different companies since they could classify the markets differ from each other and comparison of product performance could also be hard since there are certain products that Pepsi offers while Coca-Cola company does not offer and vice versa.

Benston et al. (2006) wrote that even from a local or national level, it is usually hard to compare accounting and regulations because each company adopts its own unique accounting period (year ending and start dates) and regulations that make certain accounting items to be interpreted in a unique manner, which is different from other companies. For example, a company may decide to record its assets in terms of their market value while others may opt to use their depreciated values, therefore, comparing these two financial records will create inconsistent results that are not accurate.

By looking at this issue from a broader perspective, Zeff (2007) stated that the Generally Accepted Accounting Principles (GAAP) aims at establishing uniform accounting procedures and regulations framework that is applicable within a certain specified jurisdiction. Zeff (2007) further added that GAAP stipulates the rules, standards, and conventions that accountants should follow whilst recording or drawing up financial statements. The existence of GAAP further makes it hard to ever fully compare accounting and regulations because GAAPs are designed for application only in specified jurisdictions or countries, and therefore, the accounting and regulation of a certain jurisdiction bear certain differences with those in other jurisdictions.

Because of the fact that GAAP stipulates the rules, standards, and conventions that accountants should follow whilst record or drawing up financial statements, this also means that it influences the syllabus for accounting courses. Since accountants learn about different accounting procedures and regulations, it means that financial statements will not be recorded in a uniform manner all across the world. For example, the United Kingdom has a distinct accounting syllabus that has certain differences with the accounting syllabus of other countries such as the United States of America.

Therefore, it will be hard to achieve full comparability between accounting and regulation in the UK and in the US.Summary, The review has noted that there is likely to be no full comparability between accounting procedures and regulation frameworks across different sectors and even countries because of differences that mainly span from the accounting policies between two different companies and differences in the Generally Accepted Accounting Principles applied by different countries.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Accounting and Regulation; Will there ever be full comparability Literature review, n.d.)
Accounting and Regulation; Will there ever be full comparability Literature review. https://studentshare.org/finance-accounting/1803123-review-accounting-and-regulation-will-there-ever-be-full-comparability
(Accounting and Regulation; Will There Ever Be Full Comparability Literature Review)
Accounting and Regulation; Will There Ever Be Full Comparability Literature Review. https://studentshare.org/finance-accounting/1803123-review-accounting-and-regulation-will-there-ever-be-full-comparability.
“Accounting and Regulation; Will There Ever Be Full Comparability Literature Review”. https://studentshare.org/finance-accounting/1803123-review-accounting-and-regulation-will-there-ever-be-full-comparability.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Accounting and Regulation; Will there ever be full comparability

The Requirements of the International Accounting Standard 38

Evaluation Over the last few years, the fact explains that, the relation between accounting and the extent of investment in activities giving rise to intangible assets has been an area of constant debates.... Essay, Finance and accounting Introduction The international accounting standard 38 (IAS 38) specifies the accounting rules for intangible assets that are not dealt with in other standards.... The general concern that people have shown regarding this particular activity and its link with accounting is the fact that some of the expenditures create economic assets and that the extent of mandated disclosure of these expenditures within the financial statement is limited....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

The International Accounting Standards Board and it role in harmonization of accountign standards

This is a committee of the IASB that assists the IASB in establishing and improving standards of financial accounting and reporting for the benefit of users, preparers and auditors of financial statements.... Consists of fourteen individuals (twelve full time members and two part-time members) and has the sole responsibility of setting accounting standards in the form of International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS).... accounting practices differ considerably from country to country and are based on 'generally accepted accounting practices' as in vogue in those countries....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Advanced Corporate Reporting

It was observed that the EU's financial regulation 2342/2002, article 87(4) claims that there I no need to attempt the recovery of any sum less than million euros and this has been ruthlessly exploited.... These accounting standards have shown a significant impact on the potential influence on the behaviour of economic agents.... accounting standards caused the financial institutions to behave in a certain way that enhances the financial stability in the long run....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

Controversy in the Finance Field

Some claim that the comparability of financial statements may be undermined, hence; their usefulness may be eroded.... … As the author of the essay puts it, one controversial topic that surrounds the finance field is the setting of accounting standards by the Federal accounting Standards Board.... Individuals who understand the nature of financial statements claim that alternative methods of accounting may diminish the integrity of financial statements....
3 Pages (750 words) Research Proposal

Advanced Financial Reporting and Regulation

There is a link between bank regulation and fair value accounting when trying to evaluate how fair value accounting can lead to a crisis.... Critics have claimed that fair-value accounting had a hand in the 2008 financial crisis.... They mainly claim that the fair value accounting makes firm to experience advantage in boom… This has resulted to huge debates concerning the advantages and disadvantages of fair value accounting (Laux and Leuz, 2009, pp....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Importance of Financial Statements

These statements are usually prepared at an interval of one year and the period is defined by the individual company or the accounting standards they follow.... It actually aims at depicting the financial health of the company.... It does not only provide a wide view into the financials of a company but it also identifies whether it can… It is important for the investors to understand the components of the financial statements and its uses so that they are not misguided by the company accounts....
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay

Financial Reporting for Harris Ltd

In the attempt to achieve the convergence in accounting practices, the IFRS has established the following principles: information relevance, information reliability (faithful presentation, neutrality, complete and free from material error and prudence), comparability (consistency and disclosure of accounting policies), understandability and materiality.... The company faces issues about compliance with different accounting policies.... hellip; The paper presents the three issues, in a report format, to the finance director describing the appropriate accounting treatment in the financial statement for the year ended 31 December 2014. In light of the varying accounting practices in different countries, the International Finance and Reporting Standards has established guiding principles to facilitate the convergence of the international accounting practices and to improve the quality of the information presented to different users....
7 Pages (1750 words) Coursework

IFRS 3 and IAS 17

From this paper, it is clear that IFRS 3 (after revision in January 2008) has become a standard that deals comprehensively with accounting and reporting matters relating to business combinations.... hellip; The researcher of this essay aims to analyze that IAS 17 has made specific regulations of accounting and reporting for finance as well as operating leases.... he process of accounting and reporting of the business combination is stated with absolute clarity under IFRS 3 particularly after its revision in January 2008....
9 Pages (2250 words) Coursework
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us