StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Envalue the Auditor Independence Provisions - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The purpose of this essay is to discuss the theoretical framework associated with auditor’s independence, code of conduct and ethics, which is based on the FEE Paper Comparison International Ethics Standards Board for Accountants (IESBA) Code of Ethics…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.3% of users find it useful
Envalue the Auditor Independence Provisions
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Envalue the Auditor Independence Provisions"

?Envalue the Auditor Independence Provisions Introduction The purpose of this study is to discuss the theoretical framework associated with auditor’sindependence, code of conduct and ethics, which is based on the FEE Paper Comparison International Ethics Standards Board for Accountants (IESBA) Code of Ethics that says “An individual’s objectivity must be beyond question when conducting and reporting on a statutory Audit.” This is applicable when auditors themselves act as statutory auditor, or when they are auditing on behalf of an auditing firm. In order to endow the public with a feeling of confidence, the auditor should maintain the objectivity (Rittenburg, Johnstone, and Gramling, 2011). This is only possible when the individual who is conducting the audit is independent of the organisation and the people within the organisation. The audit firms generally try to maintain a quality control system in order to safeguard the independence of the auditors. For achieving this objective, EC Recommendation (ECR), Statutory Audit Directive (SAD), which is also collectively regarded as European Union (EU) provision, and IESBA Code offer guidance and requirements for audit firms and statutory auditors, so that they can follow those standards (Federation of European Accountants, 2013). This study would summarise the concepts that are used in the legal regulatory framework, and would identify the conceptual framework of auditor’s independence. Apart from this the regulations for auditor independence would also be discussed, with respect to European Union, as this will assist in analysing how the auditors can keep their personal interest aside and focus towards an unbiased and flawless audit report. The Conceptual Framework of Auditor Independence Auditor independence signifies independence of the external and the internal auditors from the stakeholders or those who have financial interest in the company that is being audited. Independence involves integrity and an intent approach towards audit. This concept is based on the requirement of auditors to carry out their work liberally, in a goal-oriented manner. The internal auditors should have independence from those parties, whose interest would be hurt by the consequence of the audit. The internal issues that usually arise in such context are insufficient internal control, unsatisfactory risk management system, and lack of governance. The audit committee and the Charter of Audit usually offers independence of code of ethics and management of the company which assist in guiding the clients, third parties or suppliers on theories and concepts of independence (Federation of European Accountants, 2013). The independence of external auditors signifies freedom from those parties that have increase in the consequence published in the financial statement of the entity. The external auditors should be supported by the Audit committee of the company, and reference should be drawn from the public accounting codes and standards. The external and internal concerns are complicated when the nominally self-regulating divisions of the company offer consulting and auditing services. In order to solve this complication, Sarbanes – Oxley Act of 2002 is a legal solution. In case of statutory audit the most significant principle is regarded as objectivity. Before considering any non-assurance or assurance engagement, audit or entering into any relationship with the client, the auditor should consider all the threats to their independence that might hinder principle of objectivity (ICISA, 2004). Regulations in the European Union There are various regulations within EU in relation to auditor independence. The major enforcement in case of auditor independence is directed through the Companies Act of 1985, and Companies Act of 1989. The Companies Act of 1985 states that it the accountability of the shareholders to appoint auditors rather than the directors at the annual general meeting. This theory has been stated so that the directors cannot influence the auditors by threatening them or through bribery. Generally it has been seen that that the existing auditors are re-appointed for another annual general meeting, but the shareholders have full liberty of choosing another auditor or audit firm if they wish to do so. There are exceptional cases when the directors are allowed to appoint the auditors, such as to fill the casual vacancies. However, such appointments automatically expired by the next annual general meeting. According to The Companies Act of 1985, the shareholders can even eliminate the re-appointed auditor if they want to wish to elect some other auditor (Dauber, Qureshi, and Levine, 2009). The Companies Act of 1989 part II protects the independence of the auditors in various other ways. It directs that the auditors has to be from recognised supervisory body, otherwise they should not be allowed to undertake the work. Within EU ACCA, ACAEW, ICAI, and ICAS have been given such a status. In gauging the independence of the statutory auditor, both the audit firm and the auditor has to follow the EC recommendations that have been stated on the statutory auditors’ independence and IESBA code that are essentially referred (Federation of European Accountants, 2013). In this approach the threats need to be identified that hinders the independence of the auditors. Threats that the EC Recommendations have highlighted for the auditors are self-interest, advocacy, intimidation, trust, self-review. These are the challenges which hinder independence and checks individuals to keep aside their own objective for a transparent auditing (Smith, 2012). Profession Ethics and Code of Conduct Codes of ethics are the principles or expectations that govern the behaviour of the organisation and the individual for conducting audit. It explains the minimum obligations for conduct and the behavioural expectations than just specific activities. Auditing, especially internal audit is objective assurance, independent and consulting activity, which is planned to add value and develop the operations of the organisation. It assists the organisation to achieve its objectives by utilising disciplined, systematic approach to analyse and improve the efficiency of risk control, management and governance processes. The code of ethics in case of auditing should essentially have two components, namely the principles that are applicable for practicing auditing, and the rules of conduct that will describe the behavioural norms for the auditors. These rules act as an aid to the auditors for interpreting the practical implications and provide an ethical guide to the auditors (Gramling, Johnstone, & Rittenberg, 2012). The code of ethics should be based on the principle of integrity, confidentiality, objectivity, and competency. Integrity assists in establishing trust and assists in developing a basis for reliance on judgement. Confidentiality on the other hand is significant because the foremost duty of an auditor is not to disclose the information with appropriate authority (Russell, 2007). Objectivity means exhibiting high level of objectivity for evaluating, gathering and communicating relevant information regarding the processes or activities that are being examined. The auditors make balanced assessment of relevant circumstances. They should not get influenced for protecting their own interest or any other’s interest in case of developing judgements. Finally competency is required in terms of skill, knowledge and experience; otherwise the auditor will not understand fraud, theft or miscalculation (if any), in financial statements. The rules of conduct states that auditors should perform diligently, and honesty and they have to understand and observe law for making all the disclosures in a professional manner. They shall not be a part of any illegal activity and will contribute towards ethical and legitimate objectives of the company (Millichamp, 2002). Future Developments There are various ideas and assumptions present regarding the future development of auditing in context of independence. Many have advocated the fact that in order to stay strictly independent, auditors should not be authorized to offer audit clients with any sort of advisory services. This idea has been also directed in the EC recommendations’ eighth directive. This was designed so, in order to remove the conflicts that usually arises from interests of the companies to increase their revenue. In US the audit control procedure states that the audit reports should be reviewed by another company once in three years, which is also called peer assessment (Mathews, 2006). However, this system is not accepted by auditors in EU. However, in big companies, the peer reviews of audits are done, by the other offices of the same company present in another country. It has been also argued that the external auditors in the company should not be fixed, and this should be made mandatory. However, the empirical evidences are mixed regarding the issue. Many researchers have also stated that their reporting standard is usually lower when the tenure of the auditor is less. Most of the clients propose that the tenure should be a maximum period of five years (Gupta, 2004). Conclusion Audit firms and auditor must maintain their independence for the reports of the auditors to be free from any external, personal and organisational impairment. This report discussed all those factors which were enough to discuss how auditors can keep aside their personal objectives and interests in order to support the quotes that have been mentioned at the beginning of this study. Auditors are like examiners who check the annual performance of the companies in order to assist them in forecasting and decisions making. However, if code of ethics and laws are not followed then companies would function on wrong guidelines, and there are many examples that can be drawn from the recent financial crisis to describe how faulty judgement can lead to bankruptcy. References Dauber, N. A., Qureshi, A. A., and Levine, M. H., 2009. The complete guide to auditing standards, and other professional standards for accountants 2009. New York: John Wiley & Sons. Federation of European Accountants, 2013. FEE Paper on auditor independence provisions. [online] Available at http://www.fee.be/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=1300&Itemid=212&lang=en> [Accessed 13 June 2013]. Gramling, A. A., Johnstone, K. M., & Rittenberg, L. E., 2012. Auditing. 8th ed. Connecticut: Cengage Learning. Gupta, K., 2004. Contemporary auditing. 6th ed. New Delhi: Tata McGraw Hill Education. ICISA, 2004. International standard on auditing 560 subsequent events. [online] Available at: < http://www.icisa.cag.gov.in/Background%20Material/SUBSEQUENT%20EVENTS%20(560).pdf> [Accessed 13 June 2013]. Mathews, D., 2006. A history of auditing: The changing audit process in Britain from the nineteenth century to the present day. London: Taylor & Francis. Millichamp, A. H., 2002. Auditing. Connecticut: Cengage Learning. Rittenburg, L. E., Johnstone, K., and Gramling, A., 2011. Auditing: A business risk approach. Connecticut: Cengage Learning. Russell, J. P., 2007. The Internal Auditing Pocket Guide: Preparing, Performing, Reporting, and Follow-Up. 2nd ed. Milwaukee: ASQ Quality Press. Smith, 2012. CPA 2012 AUD: How to pass the CPA exams after studying for two weeks without anxiety. USA: T. Smith. Bibliography Weil, R., Schipper, K., and Francis, J., 2009. Financial accounting: An introduction to concepts, methods, and uses. Connecticut: Cengage Learning. Wolk, H. I., and Tearney, M. G., 1997. Accounting theory: A conceptual and institutional approach. 4th ed. Ohio: International Thompson Publishing. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Envalue the Auditor Independence Provisions Essay”, n.d.)
Envalue the Auditor Independence Provisions Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/finance-accounting/1480530-envalue-the-auditor-independence-provisions
(Envalue the Auditor Independence Provisions Essay)
Envalue the Auditor Independence Provisions Essay. https://studentshare.org/finance-accounting/1480530-envalue-the-auditor-independence-provisions.
“Envalue the Auditor Independence Provisions Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/finance-accounting/1480530-envalue-the-auditor-independence-provisions.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Envalue the Auditor Independence Provisions

Rotation of Auditors Improving Quality of Audits

The impact of the rotation of auditors upon the quality of audit ensuring auditor independence and how the factors affecting the auditors' independence are tackled with rotation of audit is discussed.... The quality of audit is measured upon various techniques where the relation of the auditor is one of the major factors that result in the rotation of the auditors.... In the corporate governance the best practice principals denotes the quality of audit to be enhanced when the rotation of the auditor is made after every three years....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Does Audit Regulation Ensure Auditor Independence

arey and Doherty (1966) arose with three different views of auditor independence: First, in the logic of not being subsidiary, it means candour, veracity, objectivity and dependability.... he auditing line of work has come under regular analysis regarding the auditor's perceived objectivity: In 1970, Forbes brought out editorial inquiring auditor independence by hoisting the following: As auditors are chosen and remunerated by management, are they really independent (Forbes, 1970)....
41 Pages (10250 words) Dissertation

Auditors Independence

45). auditor independence is a term which truly umbrellas many different matters, and which thus must be understood fully and thoroughly in order to be understood properly altogether.... Basically, in order to understand the meaning of auditor independence you must first understand the fact that basically the professional independence of auditors has truly been held responsible for that of the many corporate collapses and financial debacles that have taken place worldwide, and that this explains the essentiality of understanding the importance of the independence factor in the auditing sector....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Audit and Assurance

It outlines the main purposes of an audit, types of assurance engagements, discusses the independence of the auditor and assurance services for an external audit, ethical threats developed by the International Federation of Accountants (IFAC).... When giving out a reasonable assurance, the auditor gives out a positive report (means the statement given out would be a positive one as opposed to a normative statement given out in limited assurance).... the auditor should be honest while giving out his conclusion on the financial statements....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Auditor independence

The adverse effects of auditors providing services to clients that pay them directly question the impairment of auditor independence.... An association between fees received by the audit firms directly from the clients will possibly impair auditor independence with particular interest to the going concern reporting decision that continues to have considerable interest to the regulators and others.... 190) investigates the relationship between abnormal market returns for the Andersen clients and the fee-based measures of auditor independence....
4 Pages (1000 words) Research Paper

Auditing Practices, Professionalism, Ethics, And Standards

The paper "Auditing Practices, Professionalism, Ethics, And Standards" critically discusses the contemporary auditing practice and its flaws with particular focus to the professional ethics regarding auditor independence and a critique of the relevant standards.... auditor independence refers to the internal auditor's independence and freedom from freedom from any form of control by parties that may have financial interests in the business under auditing (Baker, 2005, p....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

The Role of External Auditors in Companies

The paper "The Role of External Auditors in Companies" discusses that the fact that the information may be made credible by the auditor's report should not be considered a guarantee for the protection of investors, because there are external risks that may not be addressed....  … Although the work of the auditor is to express an opinion on the financial statements and whether they present a true and fair view, such an opinion must be: an informed opinion in relation to facts from his or her examination, with access to important records; legally compellable; and in relation to given reporting standards....
17 Pages (4250 words) Assignment

Corporate Governance and Ethics

An independent and external auditor is concerned with the assessment of the fairness of the financial statements of the firm.... Investors expect the independent and external auditor to make a verification of the internal control procedures, which are put in place by the company, verify the accounting methods and procedures used by the company's accountants in the preparation of financial statements and provide an opinion on the operations of the company.... In addition, investors might use independent and external auditor's report to make an assessment of how the senior managers of the firm perform and the extent to which their actions impacts on the profitability, competitiveness and reputation of the firm....
8 Pages (2000 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us