StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Has the Release of Wikileaks Documents Cost Lives - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper "Has the Release of Wikileaks Documents Cost Lives?" will be seeking out answers to the following questions: Why Censorship is not the Best Option When it comes to Whistleblowers like Wikileaks? Why Citizens should not have access to all Information?…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.2% of users find it useful
Has the Release of Wikileaks Documents Cost Lives
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Has the Release of Wikileaks Documents Cost Lives"

Prof. T English 112 02/21 Why Censorship is not the Best Option When it comes to Whistleblowers like Wikileaks and why Citizens should not have access to all Information In 2010, Wikileaks made headlines after publishing several sensitive documents about Iraq, Afghanistan, the United States and many countries around the world (BBC News). Wikileaks also promised to divulge important information about certain big companies in the United States and abroad. The documents leaked to the press by Wikileaks caused a lot of concerns among nations that many world leaders wanted to have the founder of Wikileaks, Julian Assange, arrested (Entous and Perez). While world leaders cried foul, many people around the world commended Wikileaks for informing the public regarding what governments and big corporations are doing. Many people believe that the public has the right to know what their leaders are doing and that Wikileaks must be allowed to continue providing the public with critical information without being censored (Lang). While some people see Wikileaks as a hero, others feel that the company has breached the bounds of decency and ethics for divulging damaging information without taking into considerations the consequences of its actions. Yet, despite the possible ethical breach on the part of Wikileaks, this does not mean that censorship of the press is the best solution to avert possible harm and prevent potentially embarrassing situations on the part of the government. There is no doubt that the right to information is very important but the question now is whether or not it is morally and politically correct for an organization like Wikileaks to spy on governments and big companies and divulge sensitive information to the public. In other words, to what extent should the public be kept informed about government transactions and when should the government be allowed to withhold information from its constituents. We have to understand that the public does not need to be a privy to all activities of the government and there are things that are better left unsaid to protect the people. Information is very powerful and it can make or unmake a company, a government, an organization or an individual. Since information is very powerful, there is a need to temper the sharing of information and use it only to promote the highest good (Thierer and Anderson). The right to be informed is very important so there is a need for people to be kept informed on the issues that affect them. In the case of Wikileaks, providing the general public with the right information is crucial so there is a need to scrutinize the kind of information that it gives to the general public. Note that certain types of information can cause a lot of damage and put the lives of people in danger. Potentially embarrassing leaks can lead to international tension and may lead to the breakdown of diplomatic ties of some nations. Allegations that the United States is selling nuclear arms to terrorists for instance are a very serious and it can create dangerous backlash. Publishing this kind of information without putting the information in the right context is very dangerous it can undermine the stability of certain nations. The idea that companies like Wikileaks can hack into the database of certain government offices and private companies is disturbing because any information that these companies generate can be used against the offices where the information came from. A clear example of this is what happened in Iraq when Wikileaks published sensitive Iraq war documents (BBC News). Note that Iraq had an inconclusive election in March of 2010 and the publication of the war documents added to the uneasiness in the area. According to Prime Minister Nouri Maliki, the war documents published by Wikileaks undermined the efforts of the Iraqis to form a strong government (BBC News). Although some political observers noted that the information published by Wikileaks did not seem to impress the majority of the people in Iraq (BBC News), there is really no way of saying how this information had influenced the way the world look at Iraq. Note that the war documents were published online and people from all over the world and see them so the sphere of influence created is so wide that it is difficult to clearly measure the impact of that these documents had on the general public. Since lives may be at stake if certain information is made public, should companies like Wikileaks be subjected to censorship? The idea that whistleblowers like Wikileaks should be silenced is rather disturbing and when we start to go after whistleblowers, we may stifle the truth and cause injustice to prosper. Censorship stifles the flow of information and it can curtail the freedom of the press so there is a need to hit a balance between what should be or should not be published (Thierer and Anderson). There are certain types of information that should be made known to the public even if they are shocking to the senses of humankind. For instance, war crimes that go unpunished should be made known to the public in order to pressure world leaders to act on these injustices. By publishing documents that pinpoint war criminals, world leaders may be persuaded to go after these criminals. Note that in certain parts of the world, powerful people, organizations and even governments commit criminal acts against innocent people without being brought to justice. In the same manner, publishing unethical practices of certain companies can save lives so there is a need to companies like Wikileaks that are brave enough to tell the ugly truth as it is. If organizations like Wikileaks are prohibited from blowing the whistle on these individuals and organizations, several lives can be in great danger. Information can be a double-edge sword and it can go either way. If we withhold critical information, people can die and if we irresponsibly divulge sensitive information people can also die. Given this situation, it is very important for companies like Wikileaks to have the right moral values and motivations. Merely publishing critical information just for the sake of giving information to the public should be avoided to minimize damage to property and the loss of lives. As it is, journalists and publishers both online and offline must observe proper conduct and must put the best interest of the public first before anything else. The right to be informed is not an absolute right, thus, journalists and publishers should use sound judgment to decide whether or not publishing sensitive information will bring the highest good to the public. There is a need to journalists and publishing companies to act responsibly and consider the consequences of their actions. Works Cited BBC News. “Wikileaks Iraq war documents: the key issues.” BBC News. 25 October 2010. 28 February 2011 http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-us-canada-11617892 Connolly, Katie. “Has release of Wikileaks documents cost lives?” BBC News, Washington. 1 December 2010. 27 February 2011 http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-us-canada-11882092 Entous, Adam and Evan Perez. “Prosecutors Eye WikiLeaks Charges”. The Wall Street Journal. 21 August 2010. 27 February 2011 http://online.wsj.com/article/NA_WSJ_PUB:SB10001424052748704488404575441673460880204.html Lang, Olivia. “Welcome to a new age of whistle-blowing.” BBC News. 27 July 2010. 27 February 2011 http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-us-canada-10774473 Thierer, Adam and Brian Anderson. A Manifesto for Media Freedom. New York: Encounter Books, 2008 Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Why Censorship is not the Best Option When it comes to Whistleblowers Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1409135-wiki-leaks-has-spurred-an-incredible-debate-do
(Why Censorship Is Not the Best Option When It Comes to Whistleblowers Essay)
https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1409135-wiki-leaks-has-spurred-an-incredible-debate-do.
“Why Censorship Is Not the Best Option When It Comes to Whistleblowers Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1409135-wiki-leaks-has-spurred-an-incredible-debate-do.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Has the Release of Wikileaks Documents Cost Lives

THE_MEDIA_DB

If freedom is to be restricted, who has the power to do so?... Clinton underscored high opportunity cost for countries which filter or shut down the Internet (On real Internet Freedom).... The judicial position on the Pentagon Papers on Vietnam, refusing to grant prior restraint on publication of classified documents, serves as a clear guide for internet freedom (On real Internet Freedom).... Internet facilitates publication of such documents as evidence by wiki Leaks....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Wikileaks Endangered Lives Saved by Military Censorship

As Navy Admiral Mike Mullen explains, the release of classified information makes the jobs of military personnel “a lot more difficult and in fact, could jeopardize their lives ” (Garamone).... This release of censored material shows why censorship is actually a positive thing when it comes to military documents, as it has caused problems with military security.... This, too, is the case with military censorship in the Afghanistan war, and is something else shown by the release by Wikileaks of confidential documents....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

What Is Wikileaks Website

he founding and registration of wikileaks.... The founder of wikileaks was Julian Assange who was an Australian internet activist.... It was not until 2007 when Julian Assange was referred to as the “founder” of wikileaks.... It started publishing leaked documents in 2007 which were significant and became leading front page news items.... wikileaks is a website that publishes submissions of private, secret and....
17 Pages (4250 words) Essay

The Impact of the Wikileaks on the International Terrorism

While the actions of wikileaks might seem to be within the law, and thus protected by the privileges of the First Amendment of the USA constitution, there seem to lack some sense of security responsibility in their actions (Abrams & Benkler, 2013 n.... Further, the activities of wikileaks do not only affect the USA interest in fighting international terrorism, but also its effectiveness in international diplomacy, which is an essential concept for effective international cooperation in war against terrorism (Galrahn, 2010 n....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Ethical Analysis of Snowdengate

fter the release of the Snowden stories, even the most powerful British spy agencies The MI5 and the GCHQ had to face public hearings against their surveillance techniques.... government and citizens have towards the intelligence organization; they are vulnerable, meaning that the country is very vulnerable to any kind of attack based on the release of confidential information to the wrong people.... The government should only do so when there is a sufficient sustainable cause that has the potential to cause harm....
1 Pages (250 words) Research Paper

The Importance of Information Security

Information technology is not entirely a technological issue; it has more to do with the administration of an organization.... The mesh of links among people, organizations, and governments has made cyberspace a highly complex yet costly entity (Whitman, 2003).... This research paper "The Importance of Information Security" discusses the problem of privacy in our everyday life....
14 Pages (3500 words) Research Paper

Short Answer about Politics

The coursework "Short Answer about Politics" provides information about the sequence of formation, crisis, and the climax of neoliberalism, financialization, climate change, digitalization, and social movement.... This paper outlines the process and qonsequences.... ... ... ... The sequence of formation, crisis, and climax of neoliberalism is interpreted as an era in the history of the rise and fall of such international and social configurations like hierarchies among classes....
8 Pages (2000 words) Coursework

Wikileaks and the Freedom of the Press

The risks of wikileaks have made people acquire the power of the press in a serious manner, and numerous hidden realities have emerged to the surface.... Julian Assange is the founder of wikileaks.... WikiLeaks has dominated the news due to their release of secret documents.... Wikileaks has modified how news is presented since its daring leaking and the development of an appropriate safety framework that a person can submit their documents....
7 Pages (1750 words) Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us