StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

The Story of an Hour Critique - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The essay "The Story of an Hour Critique" focuses on the critical analysis of the author's interpretation of The story of an Hour by Kate Chopin that portrays ironies that could be true in a relationship. It is the story of a woman with heart disease whose husband was presumed dead in a car accident…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.6% of users find it useful
The Story of an Hour Critique
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The Story of an Hour Critique"

Full The Story of an Hour The story of an Hour by Kate Chopin portrays ironies that could be true in a relationship. It is the story of a woman with a heart disease whose husband was presumed dead on a car accident where he was thought to have been involved in, and great care was taken to break the news to her as gently as could possibly be. Her sister Josephine, who told her about the death of Brently Mallard, the husband, was worried that Mrs. Mallard woman would be depressed and greatly grieved over the news which might consequently affect her health, but quite the opposite happened. The woman instead lavished the future she was expecting to have without her husband, a future that was all hers, alone. Death or loss of a loved one usually brings grief and it is a normal reaction people always expect from the bereaved family so that Josephine was worried her sister might get even sicker with an already existing heart disease, when she hears about the death of her husband. She did cry hard, as an initial reaction to knowing that her husband died, that she just lost an important person in her life. I could quite relate to this, having lost my grandmother a few years earlier. She was a big figure in our home, always having the time to spend with us and having strong influences to the family, being a determined person. I grew fond of my grandmother because she always helped me with my works at home and in school, played with me most of the time and when I was in my adolescent stage, she always gave me advices that served me much wisdom in my growing up. Losing her affected me so much. I did not have the appetite to eat and the house just made me miss her even more whenever I remember her voice and laughter, when I see the things that she used to work with or the places she frequently spent her leisure time. There was a feeling of emptiness in me especially during the first few months and sometimes it is just overwhelming I shed tears remembering her. So the weeping of the wife in a “sudden, wild abandonment” as described in the story is understandable, because the emotions over death are simply gripping, one would not mind how s/he looks or what others might say about him/her. Crying is a universal language used to express grief that most would understand even without words. “And yet she loved him- sometimes”, is a line from the story that shows Mrs. Mallard’s reflection of her husband. Her initial reaction mentioned earlier was because of that love that she had for her husband. However, no matter how much a person loves another, there comes a time in one’s life that the love grows cold or dies. This could be so because of how a person treats another and an action could also go the opposite direction. In the example of my grandmother, I think I grew up to like her so much because she was a kind person. I could say she pampered me with all the things I asked from her and probably gave me more attention than my mother did. Simple things like buying clothes for me, taking me to the park and cooking my food were always a joy for my grandmother to do and she never seemed to get tired of what she was doing. She usually took me out to restaurants and there shared me a lot about her childhood experiences, asked me about how I was fairing in school, inquiring about my friends and giving me advices on some problems. There were times that she got angry with me and scold me really hard but those were covered with all the love that she has shown me so the scolding rather had a positive effect on me. Looking at the character of the husband and wife in the story, the reason why Mrs. Mallard was very happy of the future she foresaw despite the fact that she loved her husband, was the treatment she got from Mr. Mallard. On the opposite direction, the reason for such a reaction towards the death of a loved one was due to an unfair treatment, probably a love that was not reciprocated, was ignored or abused. The story described the hands of Brently Mallard as kind and tender which means the husband did not abuse the woman physically but the abuse was probably psychological. The reason why Mrs. Mallard looked forward to a future lived by herself is because of the feeling that she was caged by her own husband, having no freedom to do things the way she wanted them to be or go places that she wished to visit. This could be shown in the words she uttered when she was alone in her room, “Free, free, free!” The words were repeated thrice which emphasizes the importance of the main character’s desire, the want for freedom. Written in the late nineteenth century when women were not as liberal as the modern women, Mrs. Mallard probably had the problem of feeling alone and not loved by being left in the house most of the time. Women were perceived then to be housekeepers in the sense that they should do no other jobs but attend to household chores, raise children and take care of their husbands. However, in the case of the couple in the story, they had no children and Mrs. Mallard was probably the kind of person who loved to go places so that staying home alone probably seemed to her like being imprisoned. The words she kept whispering, “Free! Body and soul free!” gives the reader a glimpse to this thought of Mrs. Mallard. For who would want freedom but one who has been imprisoned? Her husband may have been a good provider and a good person but the suggestions of the society locked them both in a relationship where bitterness was planted instead of a love that could have been nurtured. No matter how a person might want to be good, the environment probably might always have an effect in a person’s life like that of the Mallard couple and in contradiction, even the vilest person when immersed in a place where there is so much love, would have a change of heart and become a better person. I believe that the person I am today was greatly affected by the people who surrounded me. Although I am not counting on my environment alone of who I will become, I believe my beliefs and character have been built on the ideas, teachings and experiences I have been through. Being raised in a loving family, I learned to be understanding of others, forgiving and being humble in circumstances that call for such attitudes. Life being full of ironies is probably one of the messages the author wanted to bring to the reader’s attention in the story as it was shown twice in the last one hour of the life of Mrs. Mallard. First, her sister was worried sick of her that she might be very weak and might not be able to stand the grief the death of her husband might bring. However, the woman proved to be strong enough to withstand the bout of death and instead of feeling deeply saddened with it, she rather felt glad. In fair judgment of the character, it is not that she hated her husband to the point of wanting him dead but she cherished her freedom more than she loved being married to loneliness, being left alone most of the time. Similar circumstances abound in this world, not on the same issue of death but on matters that a person usually expects. Sometimes, one is surprised at just how another person reacts unexpectedly. Sometimes, you help a person and you expect that individual to be indebted to you, making him/her humble and thankful you extended a hand however, there are people in this case who treat you like you owe him/her more. Sometimes the people you expect to be happy over small favors are the ones who complain about it and those you expect to be ungrateful are the ones who show more gratitude than what you expect from the other. The people we suppose to be weak sometimes prove to be the survivors and vice versa. In the case of Mrs. Mallard, she was expected not to be able to survive the news because of her weak heart but then from the author’s note of her characteristics, she was described to have lines on her face that showed repression and certain strength and proved her audiences’ expectations wrong. The story ends in irony with the declaration of the doctors that Mrs. Mallard “died of heart disease- of the joy that kills”, of the joy of seeing her husband alive. Have they known what transpired in the mind of the woman, that her happiness exceeded her grief over her husband’s death, they would not have made such pronouncement about her death. Her physical death was probably a symbolism of the end of the hope for the freedom she desired because as they discovered that Mr. Mallard was not after all involved in the accident, the wife’s dreams of freedom ended. The death of the woman is an irony in itself because she was able to withstand the blows of the news that was feared would make her sick or even kill her but she died because of shock that her bright future was suddenly dimmed with the appearance of her husband. Doctors say she died of joy but she died of grief over the end of her dreams that made her happy for a moment after knowing that she will be free for the years to come. The story exposes that the day before, Mrs. Mallard thought with a shudder that life would be long and when she considered what life she will enjoy now that her husband died, she prayed that her life would be long. She died shortly after that. Life indeed is full of surprises and sometimes they just come like a joke, an irony that would probably exist while there is life. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(The Story of an Hour Critique Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 words, n.d.)
The Story of an Hour Critique Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 words. https://studentshare.org/creative-writing/1757985-write-an-essay-about-the-story-of-an-hour
(The Story of an Hour Critique Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words)
The Story of an Hour Critique Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words. https://studentshare.org/creative-writing/1757985-write-an-essay-about-the-story-of-an-hour.
“The Story of an Hour Critique Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words”. https://studentshare.org/creative-writing/1757985-write-an-essay-about-the-story-of-an-hour.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Story of an Hour Critique

The Story of An Hour and In the Lake of the Woods

The paper shall look into the story of an hour, a short story by the American author Kate Chopin and In the Lake of the Woods by another American author, Tim O'Brien.... In In the Lake of the Woods, the author Tim O'Brien relates to the reader the story of a man named John Wade.... the story revolves around the mystery of the murder of John's wife and how he himself is suspected to have a hand in the murder of his wife....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Protest Art: Art as well as Protest

Tim O'Brien's recreation of the horrors of the Vietnam War and the My Lai massacre that led to the killing of many Vietnamese civilians, In the Lake of the Woods is the story of how the ghosts of John Wade's past return, to haunt him.... nbsp;… The poem also seeks to critique the traditional roles that women are supposed to play in society.... The novel uses this story not as the major part of it but as a setting to explore the effects of the Vietnam War upon the American soldiers who were guilty of perpetrating violence upon the Vietnamese people....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Ian McEwan's Dead as They Come

Modern theory of masculinity is addressed throughout the story as the narrator struggles between his emotions and his need to suppress them.... For instance, throughout the story whenever the narrator is feeling insecure or worried he repeatedly refers to himself as "a man.... In his short story, Dead as They Come Ian McEwan evokes a gloomy, almost depressing, fragment of a world where the narrator fights to balance himself on the edge, and finally falls to reveal himself as the broken, self centered man that he is....
6 Pages (1500 words) Book Report/Review

Do you Agree that Religion is an Illusion

As such, at the beginning of the book, he raised a critique on civilization by claiming that civilization does not intend to affect the just distribution of wealth extracted from nature but that it intends to perpetuate the current distribution of wealth and the status of human interrelationship (Freud, 1989:4-5)....
4 Pages (1000 words) Assignment

Does the Internet make us smarter

If this distraction was not present, it would have taken him an hour and not four of them to complete his work on an average basis.... The 21st century is known as the technological era; the era that consists of digital media and technology, a world in which it is impossible for people to survive without disseminating text, sounds, images etc....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Comparison Critique

A perfect example of some of the 48 hour Mystery's program broadcasted was the special “9/11: 10 Years Later” episode.... The two-hour program recapped most of the 2002 documentary done by two French filmmaking brothers Jules and Gedeon Naudet.... Under its current single-topic format topic, the program does not use a single host however, it is narrated by a specific narrator assigned to each story that is broadcasted depending on which reporter was assigned which story....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

In Between Masculinity and Society - Ian McEwan's Dead as They Come

nbsp; As the story line progresses the reader slowly comes to the conclusion that it is the narrator's own selfish desires and insecurity are what ultimately destroys the image of masculinity he has worked so hard to achieve.... he modern theory of masculinity is addressed throughout the story as the narrator struggles between his emotions and his need to suppress them.... This paper 'In Between Masculinity and Society - Ian McEwan's Dead as They Come" focuses on the fact that in his short story, Dead as They Come Ian McEwan evokes a gloomy, almost depressing, fragment of a world where the narrator fights to balance himself on the edge....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

The Story of An Hour and In the Lake of the Woods

The author of this book report "the story of an hour and In the Lake of the Woods" compares and contrasts two books, their plots,  peculiarities of characters, main idea and the role of protest.... The paper shall look into the story of an hour, a short story by the American author Kate Chopin and In the Lake of the Woods by another American author, Tim O'Brien.... n In, the Lake of the Woods, the author Tim O'Brien relates to the reader the story of a man named John Wade....
6 Pages (1500 words) Book Report/Review
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us