StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

The Harm Principle by John Stuart Mill - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The author of the following paper "The Harm Principle by John Stuart Mill" operates mainly based on a question which can be stated as follows: If a government can hinder or harm a person to prevent harm to others, why not for that person's own good?…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.2% of users find it useful
The Harm Principle by John Stuart Mill
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The Harm Principle by John Stuart Mill"

Mills' principle seems to aim at safeguarding the rights of a minority group against the majority regime. However, the harm principle bars individuals from continually harming themselves and their property, since doing so may have severe implications on other societal members. The harm principle states that freedom of speech is essential because every individual possesses liberty of thought (Eisenach 117). However, he did agree that although freedom of speech is justified, it should not cause any harm to others. Mills argues that tyranny is a democratic form of government for uncivilized countries, on the best people on the condition that they look into the interests of their subjects.

He introduced the various tyrannies that included the majority and the societal tyrannies (Mill 156). The harm principle proves to be democratic, since it equates individuals, with the reigning regime ensuring the law is upheld. Mill’s principle on liberty also safeguards people from being downcast and keeps them content, thereby promoting a self-sacrificing society (Mill 156). The harm principle thus seems to promote fairness among members of society. It precludes selfish behaviors and makes an individual aware of the consequences if they were to hurt others.

Mill’s principle on liberty appears to promote individual liberalization and a free society. However, critics argue that the principle may have some loopholes (Linklater 104). Mills' principle fails to elaborate the meaning of ham and only tries to quantify physical harm that can be effortlessly measured, thereby failing to address other forms of harm, including physical harm. The theory highlights the significance of safeguarding individuals from harm emanating from their fellow societal members’ acts.

However, it fails to explicate on issues of self-harm, as well as individual harm from external aspects. Besides, the affected parties may be willing to be harmed for the own pleasure (Linklater 105). The principle only safeguards individuals from harm from others, thereby failing to address the fate of animals, plants, and other natural resources that are of significant interest for the survival of humanity. 

Society may perceive various individual acts as amorous, as well as detrimental to its ultimate development. This renders the principle incompetent and it highlights its inability to govern a country alone. As such, the reigning regime ought to intervene and implement other laws that safeguard individual and societal rights, thereby promoting development.

Philosophers conducted in-depth research, in their quest to refute Mill’s principle on liberty (Eisenach 117). Such include Durkheim, who stated that the self-freedom may not always be for the benefit of involved parties. He indicated that self-gratification did not always lead to contentment. Thorough research compelled Durkheim to assert that societies that upheld Mill’s principle faced the predicament of several individuals committing suicide.

Instances where the harm principle may appear incomplete include drug abuse, abortion, and gay marriages (Linklater 105). Various activists may apply the harm principle in promoting such incidences. These activities may pose adverse impacts on individuals. The role of the government is to protect individual rights, thereby promoting societal growth. Such incidences obligate the government to implement measures that discourage such acts. These activities may seem to be harmless to parties that are not actively involved in them. However, severe indirect implications occur to other societal members as time elapses.

Some individuals may also fail to take certain forms of medication, including vaccinations from diverse communicable and pandemic ailments, on basis of their religious beliefs (Mill 156). Basing their argument on Mill’s principle, the individuals may appear to be doing what is legally acceptable. However, these individuals pose a great threat to themselves and other societal members. Such a case may compel the government into forcing them to take the medications and vaccinations, for individual, as well as public benefit (Linklater 105).

Individual freedom is essential among members of a society since it enhances their ultimate development. However, some individuals may misuse these rights, and thereby harm other societal inhabitants and themselves. In the Harm Principle, Mill promotes these rights and argues that a person may exercise the right to do anything, on condition that it may only harm themselves. However, critics highlight several incidences where Mill’s principle appears to be incompetent and thereby emphasizes the need for government involvement for the benefit of such individuals, and the larger society.  

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Ifagovernmentcanhinderorharmapersontopreventharmtoothers,whynotforthat Essay”, n.d.)
Ifagovernmentcanhinderorharmapersontopreventharmtoothers,whynotforthat Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1495605-ifagovernmentcanhinderorharmapersontopreventharmtootherswhynotforthat-personsowngoodcriticizemill
(Ifagovernmentcanhinderorharmapersontopreventharmtoothers,whynotforthat Essay)
Ifagovernmentcanhinderorharmapersontopreventharmtoothers,whynotforthat Essay. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1495605-ifagovernmentcanhinderorharmapersontopreventharmtootherswhynotforthat-personsowngoodcriticizemill.
“Ifagovernmentcanhinderorharmapersontopreventharmtoothers,whynotforthat Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1495605-ifagovernmentcanhinderorharmapersontopreventharmtootherswhynotforthat-personsowngoodcriticizemill.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Harm Principle by John Stuart Mill

Does John Stuart Mill succeed in reconciling the concept of justice with utilitarianism

Although this view is in support of few philosophers like john stuart mill, there are several other opinions that charges to state that this principle is not attuned with what justice or fairness demands in distributing benefits to all sections of people in a society.... According to john Rawls justice “is the first virtue of social institutions, as truth is of systems of thought”.... As the concept of utilitarianism explains, the “Utility, or the Greatest Happiness principle” believes that actions should be considered as correct when they result in happiness, while they are stated as wrong when “reverse” of happiness occurs....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

John Stuart Mill's view of the Iraqi War

This essay reveals that one of the greatest utilitarian philosophers john stuart mill and his main positions from his philosophical work “On Liberty” have a discussion about the war in Iraq.... The mechanisms of behavioral templates creation and transformation of norms of morality are described by mill.... As far as we can see, mill's doctrine is profound and it is taken by proponents of American intervention to Iraq as the one supporting their humanitarian intervention and at the same time, opponents refer to mill's doctrine, as to the one, which criticizes American intervention to Iraq....
10 Pages (2500 words) Term Paper

Doing the Right Thing Lead To Worse Overall Circumstances

A generation later, utilitarianism found its most effective exponent in john stuart mill.... Raised by his father, the philosopher James mill, on strictly Benthamite principles, mill devoted his life to the defence and promotion of the general welfare.... With the help his long-time companion Harriet Taylor, mill became a powerful champion of lofty moral and social ideals.... mill's Utilitarianism (1861) is an extended explanation of utilitarian moral theory....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

John Stuart Mill's Principle of Liberty

The focus of the paper "john stuart mill's Principle of Liberty" is on public policy, the basic principle of freedom of information, the Difference Principle formulated by John Rawls, violation of equality, limitations on law enforcement, the second part of Mill's principle of liberty.... With such observations in mind, let us try to find out to what extent, if at all, john stuart mill's principle of liberty is a workable and attractive basis for public policy in light of real-life challenges....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Readings In Social Science

The paper "Readings In Social Science" describes what john stuart Mills was born in 1806 and was the eldest son of an already notable author who penned History of British India.... Through adapting these works toward the social commentary of the day, we find that in the same article of work by The Penguin Dictionary of Philosophy is that “mill's defense of the view that we ought to pursue happiness because we do pursue happiness, has been the object of savage attack by, among others, F....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

The Harm Principle of John Stuart Mill

Similarly, in an early essay in 1973 entitled Moral Enforcement and the harm principle--an essay which would sketch the contours of his later four-volume treatise on The Moral Limits of the Criminal Law--Professor Joel Feinberg rehearsed Mill's harm principle and he, too, pared the principle down to its original, simple formulation ... here is a related ambiguity in the interpretation of the harm principle.... Hence individual harmful conduct must be identified in order to use the harm principle....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

The study of John Stuart Mill

The study of john stuart mill's life and career must begin with some necessary references to his father: according to Courtney (1888), in his book Life and Writings of john stuart mill, "Without James Mill, the career of john stuart mill is inexplicable" although, besides their similarities, "there are many points of contrast between the two of them, both in character, circumstances and life.... Here he met Sir John Stuart of Fettercairn, who gave the name of his eldest son, john stuart mill....
19 Pages (4750 words) Essay

The Basic Principle of Utilitarianism

According to mill, the morality of an action should be determined by the consequences and this depends on the theory of intrinsic value.... This work called "The Basic principle of Utilitarianism" focuses on Kant's account on the moral right, the role of the existing virtue system.... The maxim is a rule or principle on which one should act in accordance with this universal moral law.... The second principle of Kant's formulation outlines that one should act in such a way that you treat humanity as an end in itself and not merely as a means to an end....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us