StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Create a dialogue between two people. Describe and critique two perspectives on morality - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Dialogue on moral perspectives Introduction Ethics defines sets of rules in a society that helps in distinguishing between moral wrongs and moral rights. Different ethical perspectives exist and may have varying judgments on an issue or behavior and this paper explains and criticizes deontological and utilitarian perspective of ethics through a dialogue between two individuals, Steve and David…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.1% of users find it useful
Create a dialogue between two people. Describe and critique two perspectives on morality
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Create a dialogue between two people. Describe and critique two perspectives on morality"

Download file to see previous pages

I believe in utilitarian ethics and I would like to discuss it with you and maybe learn about your moral basis.” Steve was delighted by the topic and replied, “I have also noted our differences and attributed it to diversity. Discussing our moral values would be important to our interpersonal relationship and will improve our perspective on our environments. I believe in deontology ethics. Could you please tell me about your ethical perspective?” David: “Utilitarian ethical perspective is based on the concept maximum good to a majority of members of the society (Brooks and Dunn 183).

It informs judgment on a act, whether of commission or of omission, based on effects on members of the society and therefore means that morality of an act is determined after members of the society have interacted with the act and its effects, both positive and negative have been observed. The act is then said to be unethical if realized bad effects on members of the society are more significant than benefits from the act. It is however considered moral if greater benefits can be derived from it and this identifies two perspectives to determining ethics in an act, the extent of effects on people and the number of people that the act affect.

Utilitarianism also relates to decisions whose implementation has effects on people. Rule utilitarianism explains this by offering rules that can lead to maximum good in a society. A decision to restrict a person’s right to smoke in a public place is for example moral under utilitarian ethics because while it may infringe the smoker’s need and may be cause distress, it will be beneficial to many other people I the immediate environment through ensuring clean air and protecting the people’s lives (Kanniyakonil 65- 66).

” David: “I should have been keen to note that your judgments are based on consequentialism. My ethical perspective, deontology, is however a rule based perspective to moral judgment. The perspective associates morality with duty that is expected of people in a society and is based on social rules. It is different from your ethical perspective because it disregards consequences of an act or a decision. An act that is consistent with established rules is for example considered ethical despite its negative consequence to members of the society and an act that contradicts existing rules and obligations is considered immoral irrespective of the net benefit that in which it results.

considering your example of smoking in a public place and suppose that a the society allows people to smoke in public places, then the act of smoking is considered moral regardless of the air pollution and its associated effects on people’s health (Basford and Slevin 214, Showler 21)” David: “Reliance on rules for judging decisions and actions has the benefits in fair judgment and this is contrary to the scope of your utilitarian approach that also appear to be subjective. One of my concerns with utilitarian approach to ethics is the lack of a suitable measure for benefits and harm of an act.

There is no standard measure and this compromises reliability and fairness because some people may be more sensitive than others are while some may exaggerate consequences. It is also difficult to identify population segments that have been affected by an act or a decis

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Create a dialogue between two people. Describe and critique two Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved de https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1492689-create-a-dialogue-between-two-people-describe-and
(Create a Dialogue Between Two People. Describe and Critique Two Essay)
https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1492689-create-a-dialogue-between-two-people-describe-and.
“Create a Dialogue Between Two People. Describe and Critique Two Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1492689-create-a-dialogue-between-two-people-describe-and.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Create a dialogue between two people. Describe and critique two perspectives on morality

This is a take home exam, there are 4 different questions that have to be researched and answered

On this basis, Adorno created a view point that morality is being stuck within its powerless objective, in a world that values only recognizable facts, and morality becomes a mere prejudice of individual subjectivity.... It is hard to discern what morality signifies to Adorno and why it has become powerless.... But my understanding of morality is the codes of conduct put forward by a society or by a religion.... This question is taken in the context of sociological perspectives that encourages us to examine aspects of social environment...
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Dreams and Realities in Broken Glass, The Mupandawana Dancing Champion, and One Day I Will Write About This Place

In using this theory and approach, the reader/critique to evaluate and understand the theme of the selections in relation to society and the author.... “Ours is one of the biggest growth points in the country, but the only real growth is in the number of people waiting to buy coffins.... In Mimetic Theory, literary works are seen as a reflection of the society; it is inspired by true events, people, and places (Gebauer and Wulf 28).... This theory suggests that aside from its entertainment purpose, literature also aims to depict an event or people in society....
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay

Habermas Political Philosophy

In other words it attempts to explain the universal nature as well as the obligatory nature of morality through inducing the universal obligation of communicative rationality.... Habermas implies that the validity of the norms of morality is not justifiable in the mind of an individual and on his/her impression of the world....
20 Pages (5000 words) Essay

Ethical Foreign Policy

In addition due to a more accessible world people and governments (representative of the people) feel themselves to be more attached with the affairs of others as they directly or indirectly affect them politically, economically or sheer as per the national morality/psyche.... Modern communication media make the suffering of people in different places immediately apparent to a global audience, provoking the public into believing that something must to be done....
14 Pages (3500 words) Essay

Critique in rehabilitation model of nursing

Nursing is defined as the job of a specially trained and fit individual to help a person or a group of people to deal According to Orem's theory, in order to maintain optimal health and wellness, each person not only has need for self-care, but also has ability and responsibility to care for themselves and dependants....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

Political Philosophy of Habermas

Though it is justice centered morality theory, the Kohlberg theory is found highly compatible with the contents of deontology and eudemonia.... nbsp; The levels and stages of the Kohlberg's theory refer to the relativity and the quality of moral reasoning which normally people adopt which incidentally does not translate directly into blaming or praising of the critical actions of an individual.... Hence, it may not be always applicable to situations where the arguments of people are based on other values and moral aspects in their actions....
26 Pages (6500 words) Term Paper

Reconstruction of the Character of Scheherazade

This essay analyzes that The Arabian Nights and the Tales of Scheherazade have been reinterpreted by several authors, artists, musicians, and filmmakers.... The Arabian Nights' protagonist Scheherazade distracts the attention of her new husband, the Sultan, and manages to buy her life night.... hellip; This paper discusses why the Western interpretation is so narrow with regard to the concepts of orientalism, othering, inequality, alienation, and culture with regard to the character of Scheherazade....
19 Pages (4750 words) Essay

The Attitudes of Men and Women

hellip; However, there are still those who suggest that those were better days when society had a more positive influence but considering the works of these two writers as well as their thinly veiled disgust for the social order, it is perhaps better to say that the era did very little for the positive development of society.... In fact, beyond these two authors, there are several other related examples of writers using their craft to show the awkward and extremely uncomfortable relations that existed between society and sexuality during the Victorian era....
12 Pages (3000 words) Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us