StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

The Bursting of Bubble in the US Mortgage Market - Case Study Example

Cite this document
Summary
The objective of this paper is to study the structure and mechanism of the mortgage market and in the light of these characteristics, analyze the factors that led to its ultimate demise. Identification of the problematic areas within this subject will facilitate the process of…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.4% of users find it useful
The Bursting of Bubble in the US Mortgage Market
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The Bursting of Bubble in the US Mortgage Market"

THE BURSTING OF BUBBLE IN THE US MORTGAGE MARKET The objective of this paper is to study the structure and mechanism of the mortgage market and in the light of these characteristics, analyze the factors that led to its ultimate demise. Identification of the problematic areas within this subject will facilitate the process of finding adequate solutions to those problems through policy changes and other measures that will restore the economy back to its original progressive stance. Introduction In the year of 2007, the world witnessed an economic crisis of a magnitude unimaginable in today’s sophisticated times withal its detailed planning, theories and innovations. Some compared it to the Great Depression of 1930s. It began with the crashing of the US Mortgage Market that is one of the most active sectors in the US economy. Gradually, it spread to the financial of many other countries and in 2008 one of the biggest investment banks in UK, the Lehman Brothers, crashed. Though the crisis affected the financial sector resulting in problems pertaining to banking, it soon got transmitted to the real sector through a fall in employment and output. The ultimate effect was an economic slowdown. (Muller, 2010, p.1) In this research, we will analyze the factors that led to the crash of the US Mortgage Market and contributed to a large-scale financial crisis. The US Mortgage Market To identify the factors responsible for the bursting of the bubble in the US Housing sector, its structure and mechanism has to be studied in detail. General structure The US mortgage market has been one of the oldest sectors in the US economy. The structure of this market is complex and in order to understand its mechanism it is important to study the interactions between the primary and secondary markets. Twenty five years ago, the mortgage market was dominated by the primary sector local banks and local Savings and Loan (S&L) which was run according to a set of rules and regulations. The mortgages were held till the time the loans matured and were refinanced in one way or the other. But, from 1980s onwards the banks and S&L discovered that more profits can be made by the securitization and sale of these loans to investors, retaining only the servicing functions the fees for which will be paid to it. As a result, of securitization, the banks, now, did not have to wait till the maturity of loans since they have already been bundled and sold off to investors in return for its monetary value. Consequently, lending of credit increased earnings per share increased and the dividend to shareholders and corporate increased as well. Loans were bundled as per the requirement of the investors and sold to the one offering the best rate of interest. Soon, the primary sector banks and S&L were completely driven out from taking part directly in the mortgage market. It was, now, ruled by the secondary sector organizations, investment and mortgage banks. These banks formed a circular system with no lender of last resort like the FED or government bank and S&L. (Kim, 2010, p.139) Mechanism of the Bursting of Bubble in the Housing sector The secondary sector banks engaged in mutual securitization and purchase of one another’s loans. Also, due to lack of regulatory measures in the market, information about borrowers was either not verified or it was foreclosed, in the greed of making more profits and expanding. This resulted in an increase in the number of Non-Performing Assets (NPAs). The effect of each NPA on the mortgage market was magnified due the large number of layers created and it corroded the credit base. Finally, as the negative effect from these NPAs outweighed the overall wealth of these organizations, the entire mortgage market collapsed. Thus, the banks in the financial sector suffered severe losses and people withdrew their money from these banks. In 2007, two hedge funds, the High Grade Structured Credit Strategies Fund and the High Grade Structured Credit Strategies Enhanced Leverage Fund had reported losses due to their exposure to the mortgage market. Investors lost confidence in the shares of these hedge funds and withdrew money. As a result, these two organizations collapsed and even capital injections could not rescue them out of the crisis. (Global Economic Crisis Research Centre, 2010, p.26) The decay of the financial sector resulted in credit-rationing and thus, less investment in the economy. This led to a fall in employment generation and output (real sector variables) and finally, a slowdown of the economy. Reasons for the Bursting of Bubble in the Mortgage Market There were a number of factors that contributed to the collapse of the mortgage market in USA. Among these are three important factors that had a direct bearing on the incident. These are the \speculation, carelessness in the process of lending, and increasing interest rates on mortgages. Rate of interest on mortgages had always been low in the US. Davis, Lehnert and Martin conducted an experiment on the valuation of houses in US based on data from 1960 to post-1995. They conducted this experiment by calculating the rent-price ratio of houses. During the period 1960 to 1995, this ratio remained consistent but it showed a sharp decline from 1995 onwards. For this ratio to reach its consistent high level, the price level of houses was required to fall by approximately, 3%. Therefore, they concluded that value of houses would fall by 3% in the period after 1995. This clearly showed that the US mortgage market was over-valued. However, the proponents of this theory did not take a tough stand while there were others who drew up contradictory conclusions. The reason was that economics still does not have a complete understanding of the reasons and time of price deviations in the long term. (Watcher & Smith, 2011, p.52) The US government policy on mortgage and other loans is that higher interest rates are charged on riskier assets and lower interest rates on assets that are less risky. Due to this policy, late payment and defaults on loans of all kinds, including mortgages decreased during the period of 2004-06. This led the banks to believe that these assets were not as risky as calculated. As a result, the procedures of verification of information about borrowers were relaxed. Sub-prime mortgages increased as did a number of other loans like the NINJA (No Income, No Job and Asset) loans. There was no down payment or a negligible amount of down payment on these loans and the only way to earn profits on them was by bundling them up together and selling them to investors. This led to an increase in the layers or leverages of the credit base and increased its vulnerability. This means that the effect of each NPA would be magnified and felt directly and indirectly on all the banks or mortgage organizations connected to it. The ultimate result was an explosion of NPAs on the credit base of the US Mortgage market. (Baumol and Blinder, 2010, p.781-782) A sudden, unexpected increase in the interest rate led to the inability of a number of homeowners to pay mortgage. Mortgage defaults were increasing at a rate of 10% during the period 2008-09. As a result, sales and valuation of houses decreased. There was a fall in the sale of houses by 78% and prices of houses fell by 30% from 2005 to 2008. This was followed by a decrease in the value of securities. By 2010, 12 million loans, i.e. one-fourth of the total housing debts, were reported to have exceeded the value of appraisal. Thus, the US mortgage market was doomed. (UN: Economic Commission for Europe, 2010, p.16) This proved to be the final nail in the coffin of the US mortgage market. Interpretation of Facts and Figures From the analysis of all the facts and figures given above, it is evident that the collapse of the mortgage market in US, that caused the global financial crisis, occurred primarily due to a negative wealth effect. The main reason for this is a massive mistake in speculating the value of real estate. Since the value of houses was on an upswing, people expected it to rise even further. The probability that the value of houses may fall was hardly considered, even though some economists found statistical proof to support this claim. The theory that the value of real estate is likely to fall rapidly after 1995 was subjected to strong opposition. As the proposers of this theory were themselves not too sure about it, the theory was easily discarded. With this assurance from the authorities on the subject, real estate continued to be increasingly over-valued. Coupled with this was the carelessness in the lending standards. Even the most risky assets were securitized at the high value of houses prevailing at that time. And, the increase in rate of interest of mortgage loans proved to be the final move. Due to increased mortgage payments, there was a rise in the number of NPAs. Thus, houses became a less lucrative option for investment. Sales and valuation of houses decreased and the situation became such that even if the houses were sold, the loaned amount could not be recovered. The negative wealth effect came into play. As the commercial banks associated with the mortgage market attempted to bail out these mortgage institutions by capital injections, they also went bankrupt, too. This was, again, due to the waning confidence of the customers who were withdrawing their money. The ultimate result was the collapse of each and every financial institution connected to the mortgage market and in addition, it also affected the real sector. Policy Recommendations There are a few policy recommendations that can lift the US economy and others out of this financial crisis. The adverse shock suffered due to the complete shattering of the financial backbone of the economy had had fatal effects on growth of the real sector by a rapid decrease in employment and output rates. With time the impact of this fiasco as well as the interactions between the financial and the real sectors is intensifying. In order to steer the economy out of impending problems, effective monetary and fiscal policy has to be implemented. (OECD, 2008, p.11) It must be realized that injecting capital into the financial system is not the solution to the problem. Capital injections must be given to the real sector by investing in public undertakings that will provide more employment and increase the output of the economy, thus, tackling the problem of a low rate of growth. The FHA and GSE are government mortgage loans that became less popular after the advent of the sub-prime mortgage market. However, these are extremely well monitored and thus, have relatively lower levels of NPAs. In order to tackle the problem of information asymmetry in the mortgage market, the provision for standardized FHA loans should be made that can be compared to subprime loans. Furthermore, it should be made mandatory for the lenders to disclose details about high risk ventures. (Lucas, 2010, p.128) Conclusion It may be concluded that even though the magnitude and extent of effects of the collapse of the US mortgage market on the real sector and the economy of other countries is vast, its detrimental effects can be reversed by the use of adequate policies and massive public investment for output and employment generation. References Baumol, W.J. and A.S. Blinder (2010), Economics: Principles and Policy. USA: South-Western Cengage Learning. Global Economic Crisis Research Centre (2010). Global Economic Crisis: Impact on Finance. USA: South-Western Cengage Learning. Kim, S. (2010). International Banking in the New Era: Post Crisis Challenges and Opportunities. UK: Emerald Group Publishing Ltd. Lucas, D (2010). Measuring and Managing Federal Financial Risk. London: University of Chicago Press Ltd. Muller, A. (2010). Financial Crisis: Impacts and Reactions. Germany: GRIN Verlag. OECD (2008). OECD Economic Surveys. US: OECD Publications. UN: Economic Commission for Europe (2010). Forest Products Annual Market Review 2009- 10. USA: United Nations Publications. Watcher, S.M. & S.M. Smith (2011), The American Mortgage System: Crisis and Reform. USA: University of Pennsylvania Press. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(What caused the bubble and bust in housing Term Paper, n.d.)
What caused the bubble and bust in housing Term Paper. https://studentshare.org/macro-microeconomics/1756022-what-caused-the-bubble-and-bust-in-housing
(What Caused the Bubble and Bust in Housing Term Paper)
What Caused the Bubble and Bust in Housing Term Paper. https://studentshare.org/macro-microeconomics/1756022-what-caused-the-bubble-and-bust-in-housing.
“What Caused the Bubble and Bust in Housing Term Paper”. https://studentshare.org/macro-microeconomics/1756022-what-caused-the-bubble-and-bust-in-housing.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Bursting of Bubble in the US Mortgage Market

Should the Fed Intervene in Asset Bubbles

Prior to that, specifically in the period between years 2000 to 2006, residential housing prices in the us almost doubled.... Although not very prevalent in the us and in other Western economies, such practice is contributory to asset bubbles because it results in the misallocation of scarce financial resources better invested elsewhere.... Some experts blame complex financial instruments known as derivatives as the prick that finally caused the bursting of the housing bubble; in particular, they liked to cite collateralised debt obligations (CDOs) as the culprit....
46 Pages (11500 words) Thesis

What Caused the Bubble and Bust in the US Mortgage Market

39) Mechanism of the bursting of bubble in the Housing sector The secondary sector banks engaged in mutual securitization and purchase of one another's loans.... What Caused the Bubble and Bust in the us mortgage market?... Even though the magnitude and extent of effects of the collapse of the us mortgage market on the real sector and the economy of other countries is vast, its detrimental effects can be reversed by the use of adequate policies....
6 Pages (1500 words) Term Paper

Investment Bubble versus Long-Term Investment

bubble in Precious Metal In another class of asset namely Gold, the situation is again not much different.... Investment Bubble Introduction Investment bubble is now a well known phenomenon that has taken place in various classes of assets such as real estate, stock market or bullion market throughout the world.... Increased price gives confidence to the investors and they flock to the market with increased vigor and enthusiasm....
9 Pages (2250 words) Personal Statement

Housing Market in the US

As an economic bubble, the United States housing bubble grew up alongside the stock bubble in the mid-90s.... In this case, a decline in demand due to high interest rates and a tightening of credit standards leads to bursting of the bubble.... Housing market in U.... Name Institution Housing market in U.... In mean time, speculators find their way in the market believing of making profits through short-term buying and selling....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

The 2007 Real Estate Market Crash

This research paper looks at the recent drop in real estate market prices that is taking place in the U.... The drop in real estate market prices is not an isolated event.... economy was doing well, the truth was much darker than what most people believed: the economy's weakest link, the housing market, was in even worse shape than many realized.... n February 7, 2007, the Senate Banking Committee indicated that nearly 20 percent of sub-prime mortgage loans obtained from 2005-2006 would be foreclosed, threatening over 2....
11 Pages (2750 words) Research Paper

Credit Crunch in the United States

he crisis began with the bursting of the housing bubble which then by chain reaction affected every other industry due to this strong interdependence among countries and economies.... Apart from that, the surge in the mortgage market was a result of generous monetary policy stance adapted by FED in order to ease the recession caused by the dot com bubble.... Also know as the "credit crunch", this financial contagion has now almost affected every market which is economically integrated and interdependent with the rest of the world. ...
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

The US Real Estate Bubble

The paper "The US Real Estate Bubble" argues housing bubble in the us has been caused by a number of factors.... During this time, the annual increase in home prices in the us was at 124% and above.... Most of these frustrated homeowners started selling off their homes but at much lower prices than they had secured the homes, and the real estate market was flooded with supply.... Aggressive marketing by the real estate developers and the mortgage providers led to a huge portion of the public going for mortgages to buy houses....
1 Pages (250 words) Research Paper

Mortgage Crisis in the United States

The current mortgage crisis began with the bursting of the bubble house in 2001 and reached its optimal point in 2005.... uring its semiannual worldwide financial report released on 8th April 2008, the paramount statue of international finance analysis (that is IMR) stated that the collapsing house prices and rising queries in the residential mortgage market or arena losses of approximately five hundred and sixty five billion US dollars.... When there are such rapid increases there is a subsequent decline in home prices and mortgage debt that is greater than the actual value of...
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us