StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Misapplication of the Myth of Hercules to the Injustices of Imperialism - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
"Misapplication of the Myth of Hercules to the Injustices of Imperialism" paper fleshes out the thesis that, ‘based on first-hand accounts of John Smith and Frethorne, the analogy between the heroic labors of Hercules and the enterprise of imperialism is misleading at best and malicious at worst. …
Download free paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.3% of users find it useful
Misapplication of the Myth of Hercules to the Injustices of Imperialism
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Misapplication of the Myth of Hercules to the Injustices of Imperialism"

?The misapplication of the myth of Hercules to the injustices of imperialism – based on illustrations by John Smith and Richard Frethorne The imperialists’ adoption of the myth of Hercules and the many headed Hydra to their cause is problematic and flawed. Firstly, there is nothing Herculean about the imperialist agenda of expansion and economic exploitation. Secondly, far from being the devilish and much maligned mythic creature that is the Hydra, those represented by it are mostly victims of imperial conquest. In other words, the various groups of colored people, revolutionaries and the progressive-minded who comprise the Hydra are actually the ones who are Herculean in their courage and intent. Hence, it is easy to see the problem of usurping an ancient mythological dichotomy of ‘Good v Evil’ and applying it incorrectly to promote an imperial agenda. This essay will flesh out the thesis that, ‘based on first-hand accounts of John Smith and Richard Frethorne, the analogy between the heroic labors of Hercules and the enterprise of imperialism is misleading at best and malicious at worst’. Let us begin the task of de-mystifying this myth by turning to a few key firsthand accounts of life under the Crown’s orders. The firsthand experiences of Captain John Smith are testimony to the misery and acute poverty of the assigned Hydras. Far from being venomous and hazardous as the many-headed beast, the subjects of the colonies were exploited to the utmost. Even their bare survival was a matter of chance at times. As Captain Smith notes in the beginning of his journal entry “Being thus left to our fortunes, it fortuned that within ten days scarce ten amongst us could either goe, or well stand, such extraeme weaknes and sickness oppressed us… our allowance was somewhat bettered, by a daily proportion of Bisket, which the sailors would pilfer to sell, give, or exchange with us, for money, Saxe-fras, furres or love.” (Smith, p.110) It is impossible to believe that such famished subjects as the servants of the imperial crown would later be brandied under the term Hydra when they revolted in the name of fairness and justice. To illustrate, let us consider the dire shortage of vital resources faced by Captain Smith and his team of expeditioners as they went about to fulfill the Crown’s command. The acute short of food for the sailors on imperial mission is well captured in the following lines: “…that indeed he allowed equally to be distributed, and that was halfe a pint of wheat, and as much barley boyled with water for a man a day, and this having fryed some 26 weekes in the ships hold, contained as many wormes as grains; so that we might truly call it rather so much bran then corne, our drinke was water, or lodgings Castles in the ayre: with this lodging and dyet, our extreame toile in bearing and planting Pallisadoes, so strained and bruised us, and our continuall labour in the extremitie of the heat had so weakened us…those that escaped, lived upon Sturgeon, and Sea-crabs, fiftie in this time we buried…” (Smith, p.110) Hence, it is becoming clear that the imperialists have employed the rhetoric of the Herculean myth to express their difficulties in containing a form of economic globalization instituted by imperialism. Rather than reacting to a genuine threat of offence, colonial elites have instead been assigning the taint of the Hydra to whichever group that contested their authority. (Linebaugh & Rediker, 2000) As first-hand testimonies of colonial officers and historians prove, the claim for Herculean virtues and the imposition of bestial vices to the two groups is arbitrary, propagandist and largely a matter of convenience for the rulers. It is no surprise then, that, only those with vested interests in promoting imperialist rule were the most vocal in the dissemination of the myth. But when we take into account the voices of the weak and subordinate, a totally different picture emerges. The Experiences of an Indentured Servant is a moving and saddening piece of emotional outpouring. Written by indentured laborer Richard Frethorne to his parents, the letter captures the conditions and feelings of those ruled in the Virginia of early 17th century. “And I have nothing to comfort me, nor is there nothing to be gotten here but sickness and death, except that one had money to lay out in some things for profit. But I have nothing at all no, not a shirt to my back but two rags, nor clothes but one poor suit, nor but one pair of shoes, but one pair of stockings, but one cap, but two bands…So that I have not a penny, nor a penny worth, to help me too either spice or sugar or strong waters, without the which one cannot live here.” (Frethorne, 1623, p.2) In the case of Richard Frethorne and his lot, the conditions were precarious right from the beginning of their long voyage by sea. Even on land, some of them barely managed to survive while others were not even that lucky. Jamestown, which was one of the stationing towns for indentured laborers, was witness to many stories of agony and misery among the imported wage workers. Most of the work centered on import and export activities from the port. Work often began at the break of dawn and went on till midnight, hardly giving laborers enough time for rest and recuperation. Whether it rained or shined, the workers were mercilessly held to account for their contract, which was acutely inhuman by any measure. (Frethorne, 1623, p.3) The hostile conditions for indentured laborers and other subjects of the empire were highlighted by researchers Peter Linebaugh and Marcus Rediker. They lay out some valid reasons exposing the flimsy claims of the myth in the first chapter of their book. They note that it is all too convenient to get carried away by the effervescence of the myth, without paying critical attention to the reality. For example, the kind of turbulence awaiting sailors ashore is resonantly captured thus: “On July 25, 1609, the sailors of the Sea-Venture scanned the horizon and spotted danger. Separated from their convoy of eight other vessels sailing from Plymuoth westward to Virginia, England’s first New World colony, they spied a tempest- or what the Carib Indians called a hurricane – scudding swiftly toward them…” (Linebaugh & Rediker, 2000, p.8) Hence, in conclusion, as evidence from various first-hand accounts of sailors, officers and indentured laborers suggest, the myth of Hercules is very misleading to say the least. To the contrary, the oppressed subjects of the empire are more closely aligned to Hercules in terms of their courage and endurance. The colonial masters, on the other hand, with their multifarious methods of control and repression, are easily associated to the Hydra. The ruling elite that masterminded the systematic plunder of the trans-Atlantic economy found it convenient to revive and embrace the immortal mythic hero Hercules to their own narrow goals. Though not backed by facts, the myth served a symbolic purpose in projecting the power, order and prosperity brought about by the image of Hercules. (Linebaugh & Rediker, 2000) Hence, the officially circulated version of the Hercules-Hydra analogy is not merely false, but the opposite of the truth. It is important that students of history and political science understand the exaggerations and counter-positions created by the myth, for the truth is very far from it. It is only by heeding to the subaltern viewpoint will the discerning student of history come to comprehend it accurately. It is thus fair to say that the deconstruction of the Hydra myth is a useful exercise for students and policy-makers alike. Works Cited: Frethorne, Richard, The Experiences of an Indentured Servant, First Hand Accounts of Virginia, 1575-1705, retrieved from the virtual Jamestown Project on 13th September, 2012. Smith, John, What Happened Till the First Supply, Chapter 2, From the General Historie of Virginia, New England and the Summer Isles, Colonial Settlements, p.110-120 Linebaugh, Peter & Rediker, Marcus. The Wreak of the Sea-Adventure, The Many-Headed Hydra: Sailors, Slaves, Commoners, and the Hidden History of the Revolutionary Atlantic, Published by Beacon Press in 2000. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“The misapplication of the myth of Hercules to the injustices of Essay”, n.d.)
The misapplication of the myth of Hercules to the injustices of Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/literature/1457100-the-misapplication-of-the-myth-of-hercules-to-the-injustices-of-imperialism-based-on-illustrations-by-john-smith-and-richard-frethorne
(The Misapplication of the Myth of Hercules to the Injustices of Essay)
The Misapplication of the Myth of Hercules to the Injustices of Essay. https://studentshare.org/literature/1457100-the-misapplication-of-the-myth-of-hercules-to-the-injustices-of-imperialism-based-on-illustrations-by-john-smith-and-richard-frethorne.
“The Misapplication of the Myth of Hercules to the Injustices of Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/literature/1457100-the-misapplication-of-the-myth-of-hercules-to-the-injustices-of-imperialism-based-on-illustrations-by-john-smith-and-richard-frethorne.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Misapplication of the Myth of Hercules to the Injustices of Imperialism

Epic Hero Hercules

The king challenged hercules to perform the task in just one day and he could give him an eighth of his cattle.... However, Eurystheus disqualified this labor of hercules as he received help from his nephew (Loewen, 1999: 324).... EPIC HERO hercules Name Date Introduction hercules who is known as Heracles in Greek is the most famous hero in Greek mythology renowned for the odd courage, masculinity and strength he had.... hercules was the son of a woman known as Alcmene who was seduced by Zeus who was not her husband....
5 Pages (1250 words) Research Paper

Sarcophagus Relief Depicting Labors of Hercules

One can see that the myth of hercules or Heracles was popular among the people in ancient Roman Empire.... Source The unknown artist made use of the Greco-Roman myth of hercules.... Sarcophagus Relief Depicting Labors of hercules Within the context of sculpture work, sarcophagus relief works can be considered as important because the same connects the past with the present.... The work named as Sarcophagus Relief Depicting Labors of hercules, is a Roman sculpture, by an unknown artist, which belongs to 3rd–4th century A....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Benefits of Imperialism to the Colonized States

This essay concerns the phenomenon of imperialism.... According to the text, the term "imperialism" identified states whose politics involved a colonial extension to civilize less advanced people and to take advantage of their available land and resources.... European imperialism determined shapes of modern borders economies and politics.... ??For many states that remained theoretically sovereign, imperialism meant economic, and not political, subordination”....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

What It Means for a State to Be an Imperial Power

Aside from these value-laden, extravagant representations of abuse and mistreatment, the issue of imperialism deserves a dispassionate look into what it means (both in the past and in the present) for a state to be an imperial power: Like many other terms in the popular lexicon, imperialism is one that finds its use in bolstering the emotional appeals of populist arguments.... That is, an accusation of imperialism is an accusation of civic viciousness: the will to destroy native cultures and to bind indigenous populations commercially to Western capitalism, itself an enslaving and demeaning force in the world, according to the worldviews of those of who use “imperialism” as an all-encompassing emotional plea....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Imperialism from a Theoretical Perspective

The term 'Imperialism' along with its historical connotation has been defined by different scholars in different ways, but the underlying commonality of the definitions refer to a form of domination of one political, socio-cultural and economic unit of geographical area over the others as one of the primary characteristics of imperialism.... true impartial tone about the core nature of imperialism is Lake's definition, as he says, 'Imperialism is a form of international hierarchy in which one political unit, or polity, effectively governs or controls another polity' (7232)....
6 Pages (1500 words) Report

The Labours of Herakles, Labor 7: The Cretan Bull

Heracles was the twin brother of Iphicles.... Heracles was the son of Zeus, a god, and Alcmene, a Greek mortal woman.... He is one of the most renowned divine heroes in Greek mythology owing to his.... ... ... Hera hated Heracles because he was the illegitimate son of Zeus and tried to have him killed when just a child by sending two snakes to him1....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Greek Mythology: Herakles

The film does contain a brief reference to the Twelve Labors of hercules but it has totally changed the culture of ancient Greece.... This movie review "Greek Mythology: Herakles" discusses the influence of the mythological tale of the Greek hero Herakles, which was made into a movie called hercules by the Walt Disney Feature Animation directed by Ron Clements and John Musker in 1997.... King Zeus was married to Hera but Herakles was his son through another woman called Alcmene, the wife of Amphitryon but in the film, hercules has been shown as the son of Zeus and Hera....
6 Pages (1500 words) Movie Review

American Imperialism

This events marked the end of the Spanish rule, forcing them to retract and concentrate on domestic affairs, but marked the start of imperialism in America.... This report "American imperialism" discusses the American imperialism that was motivated by political, territorial, and economic expansion desires, even though the events occurred at different times.... manifested imperialism in the 19th and 20th centuries in a couple of ways....
11 Pages (2750 words) Report
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us