StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Marx vs Smith's Views on Analyzing Current Political Issues - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
As the paper "Marx vs Smith's Views on Analyzing Current Political Issues" tells, Karl Marx and Adam engaged in debates and discussions with the aim of restoring tranquility in daily operations in society. But, their discussions differ depending on the different schools of thought they represent…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.6% of users find it useful
Marx vs Smiths Views on Analyzing Current Political Issues
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Marx vs Smith's Views on Analyzing Current Political Issues"

Karl Marx and Adam Smith are together since they all believe in classical economic thought. Moreover, Karl Marx is a renowned Communist while Adam Smith is associated with Classical ideologies. Therefore, adequate analysis of articles will sufficiently bring out the difference between the two theorists regarding current trends in society. Moreover, the essay will assess the debate between the different classes of thought Marx and Smith represent.

To reflect the claims above, the article in wall street journal titled, Politics Counts: the Red/Blue Retail Divide approaches issues affecting the rapid expansion of the United States economy. The United States is a two-party state, which comprises Democrats and Republicans. This article replicates that the consumption of goods and services from the party supporters differs greatly. Consumer subcultures have diversified so much that it threatens communal coexistence in the country. Democrats and Republicans have adopted different ways of shopping which if not curbed early will threaten mutual understanding. From this article, Marx's and Smith's ideologies clash. America is a democratic state so every civilian has a right to engage in activities wanted as long as it does not ruin stability in the country. Adam Smith emphasizes the free market whereas Marx articulates an economy where a ruling class should not exploit the proletariats. From this, allowing the party supporters to shop differently will aggravate political animosity in the country. Smith argues that free trade leads to increased economic prosperity while on the other hand, Marx argues that allowing free trade and competition will lead to the exploitation of workers by employers rendering them powerless. Conversely, labor should be part of the final product and employers need to conquer to step up the free competition, accompanied by a social and political constitution adopted in it, and the economic and political sway of the bourgeois class (Theriault 37).

Wall Street also carried out an article putting Some Facts in the Tax-the-Rich Debate. This article emphasizes tax fairness between the rich and the poor. For economic stability, the rich should be taxed a higher amount than the poor civilians. However, this sparked a debate among political elites among them president Obama who seconded the idea. This article has created a clash between classical and liberal theorists. Smith propagates on the political economy where he says both political and economic systems should be integrated together to achieve political stability. He bestows all powers to political elites and entrusts them with the privilege to make policies governing economic activities. Marx’s ideologies are against the political economy because it concentrates property and power on a few individuals, which leads to classes for instance propertied and propertyless. Taxing the rich more than the poor will reduce the gap between the propertied and the propertyless in society therefore, economic development will improve enabling all people to access goods and services. There are classes in the world whereby the oppressed struggle to free themselves from the oppressors that make society “a manifold gradation of social rank” (Marx 14).

The Wall street journal carried an article, States Get Say in Health Law. President Obama’s administration changed health policies, which will screen insurers’ considerations when charging insurance covers. Employer groups praised the policy but observed that it never covered the rights of small consumers who end up paying higher money than expected. Moreover, the policy will deter healthy people from paying the high premiums charged. Liberalists adjudicate for individual priority over the state; therefore, the people should have consent on policies implemented by the government. Marx argues that workers should have the freedom of doing what they want, for instance, choose the type of cover they want without state interference. According to this article, the law permits smokers to be charged 50% higher than non-smokers, which contravenes Smith’s virtues of life, for instance, self-command, prudence, benevolence, and justice. “The undeveloped state of the class struggle, as well as their own surroundings, causes Socialists of this kind to consider themselves far superior to all class antagonisms” (Marx 32).

Marx and smith's ideologies differ because Marx believes in Communism while Smith advocates for capitalism. For the economy to develop, political, social, and economic components need to merge. According to Smith, free trade creates fairness in competition and restores morality. Marx advocated for the protection of labor and the protection of their rights. The economy should be open for individual development and prosperity. These ideologies have created coherence in society as individuals try to merge them to provide social order in society.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“[Political Economy] Derive Classical theorist Marx vs. Smith view to Essay”, n.d.)
[Political Economy] Derive Classical theorist Marx vs. Smith view to Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/history/1461894--political-economy-derive-classical-theorist-marx
([Political Economy] Derive Classical Theorist Marx Vs. Smith View to Essay)
[Political Economy] Derive Classical Theorist Marx Vs. Smith View to Essay. https://studentshare.org/history/1461894--political-economy-derive-classical-theorist-marx.
“[Political Economy] Derive Classical Theorist Marx Vs. Smith View to Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/history/1461894--political-economy-derive-classical-theorist-marx.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Marx vs Smith's Views on Analyzing Current Political Issues

Distribution Pattern Analysis of Public Parks and accessibility in Madinah Using GIS Technique

Green spaces and parks are of great importance both for ecological balance and for the health of individuals (Frumkin, 2001).... They play a fundamental role in providing opportunities for rest and relaxation and enjoying the beauty of nature for the urban population.... ... ... ... The results show the distribution of distance to the nearest green space, calculated using a network analysis of the distance between neighbourhood centroids and green space access points....
15 Pages (3750 words) Essay

UK Chocolate Market: Turning Green

The 'ugly' part of this consumerism is the degradation on a planetary scale causing issues like e global warming, water pollution, deforestation, and loss of biodiversity the relevant evil here is the excessive materialism that detracts from the true meaning of life and stresses individualism desire and narcissistic tendencies.... Similarly, it can also apply product placement and competitors vs complements in order to gain a comparative advantage over its competitors....
14 Pages (3500 words) Essay

Critically discuss the extent to which capitalism has affected human relationships

usehold production, and the state, just as preceding socioeconomic systems relied on subsystems such as the market, the state, and the church; what is involved is more than an empirical observation that different structures and systems have coexisted through history; what is Under these views capitalism has not a ‘stable' and ‘standard' format but tends to alternate in order to be adapted to the current political, social and financial conditions of a specific society.... From a general point of view capitalism should be considered as a major ‘economic' and ‘political' movement that influences several factors of social and private life....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

Production and Market behaviour

The early classical political economy paradigms existing from the 18th century to mid 19th century associated with Adam Smith's Wealth of Nations treatise in 1776, the precursor of modern economic theory, David Ricardo and Karl Marx have all revolutionized economic theories.... netheless, contemporary economic theory as advocated by sociologists is derived from Max Webers institutionalism paradigms, Émile Durkheims social environment and individuality, as well as Karl marx pitch regarding control of resources (Dobbin and Baum, 2000)....
15 Pages (3750 words) Essay

Econ308 Final paper

here are a number of differences and similarities in the issues that classical and neoclassical economics address.... In classical economics economists ask a number of central questions; these issues include the nature of economic growth, and how is wealth distributed between the forms of wages, rent and profit.... In investigator these concerns classical economists approach the issues from a social science perspective.... They emphasized how goods are accumulated and how surplus accumulation is implemented; as a result classical economists from Adam Smith to Karl marx were primary concerned with the...
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

Solutions to Rent-Seeking

??Institutions frame behaviors and exchanges in markets, business networks, communities, and organizations throughout the world… The fast-growing field of ‘new institutional economics' (NIE) analyzes the economics of institutions and organizations using methodologies from a wide range of disciplines (including political science, anthropology, sociology, management, law, and economics).... From this basis, the essay will examine current events as transpired with the recent “Wall St....
14 Pages (3500 words) Research Paper

What Analytical Insights do Marxist Political Economy Provide

The essay 'What Analytical Insights do Marxist political Economy Provide?... examines the Marxist political economy, its place in the modern world, gives a detailed overview of the analytical value of the Marxist economy and compares the Marxist model of the political economy with the classical model of the economy developed by Adam Smith.... In the academic circle, it is argued to have lost its analytical value particularly in a 'discipline' that owes its development to Marxists' thoughts, political economy....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Ethnic Conflict and Multiculturalism

The notion of common ethnicity has played a significant role throughout the history of human civilization, whereas patriotism, as is presently understood, is a relatively new phenomenon – only with the emergence of modern democratic institutions and the establishment of nation-states did patriotism gain currency in political discourse.... If one were to classify all such examples given by the author, it becomes evident that the concept of ethnonationalism has more often than not been abused by astute political leaders to gain power....
12 Pages (3000 words) Annotated Bibliography
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us