StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

The American Splendor Film by Pucini and Berman as Being Adapted from Harvey Pekars Comic Book - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper "The American Splendor Film by Pucini and Berman as Being Adapted from Harvey Pekars Comic Book" highlights that for film the audio component is available and used to convey meaning and messages, whereas in the comic book form there is only the visual element and no sound…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.7% of users find it useful
The American Splendor Film by Pucini and Berman as Being Adapted from Harvey Pekars Comic Book
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The American Splendor Film by Pucini and Berman as Being Adapted from Harvey Pekars Comic Book"

? The 'American Splendor' Film By Pucini and Berman as Being Successfully Adapted from Harvey Pekar's Comic Book Table of Contents On 'American Splendor' by Pucini and Berman as a Successful Adaptation of Harvey Pekar's Comic 'Pekar' 3 References 7 On 'American Splendor' by Pucini and Berman as a Successful Adaptation of Harvey Pekar's Comic 'Pekar' This paper is an analysis of the argument of Hight that the Berman and Pucini film 'American Splendor' is successfully adapted from the comic book by Harvey Pekar. The criteria for evaluation include the consideration of the problems inherent in adaptations of the kind done with the movie as described by Harvey and Lefevre. The analysis also benefits from the use of ideas drawn from the articles by Lefevre, Harvey, as they are brought to bear on the arguments presented in Hight's article. In essence, the question is whether the or not the film makers were successful in overcoming the hurdles identified by Lefevre and Harvey with regard to the successful staging of such movie adaptations (Hight, 2007, pp. 180-198; Lefevre, 2007, pp. 1-12; Harvey, 1996, pp. 173-191). To the question of whether the movie is a successful adaptation of Pekar, the answer is yes. The rest of the paper supports the argument and weighs in on the counterarguments and objections of Lefevre and Harvey. Harvey points out for instance, relating to photography versus hand-drawn images, that the difference is fundamental between the two. The latter are manual creations, while the latter are machine creations, being photographs. Now Harvey says that in essence machines have limitations in terms of not being able to render what hands can image wise. Machines are constrained to render nature, and not the creations of hands (Harvey, 1996, p. 175). Lefevre on the other hand says the same thing, and adds that the photography in film implies movement, whereas in drawn images the default is that of static frames. This presents fundamental problems in rendering drawn images as photographed moving images (Lefevre, 2007). Hight essentially deflects those objections via a discussion on genres and treatment. classifies 'American Splendor' as a drama-documentary, and the work itself has its focus both the art of Harvey Pekar, as reflected in the comic which has an eponymous title, or has the same name as the author, as well as the comic itself. Drama-documentary implies realism and the use of the personal subjective perspective of the key character and of Pekar himself to render the comic series on film. In essence, with the use of the genre, the film is able to effectively render the static hand-drawn image unto film overcoming the objections of Lefevre and Harvey. The answer to the objections raised by Lefevre and Harvey, in other words, is the choice of the drama documentary and all that the genre implies in terms of filming technique and overall approach to film making, and Pekar's own vision of his art work as the rendering of images the same way that photographers take pictures realistically (Hight, 2007; Lefevre, 2007; Harvey, 1996). With regard to page layout for the comic and the image on one screen, Lefevre says that this is a problem because in comic books the reader dictates the pace and the images are at closer proximity to them. In film, the watcher has to move along in the pace dictated by the movie. The watcher is unable to leaf through pages like in comic books, linger on a page. The experience is not the same (Lefevre, 2007). Harvey says the same thing, that one page on a comic does not equate to several sequences in a film, or that there are difficulties in rendering unto the movie image, moving, a single comic page that can capture a series of movements or a meaningful snapshot of events (Harvey, 1996, p. 176). To this objection Hight basically says that the unique rendering of the film essentially means that the film is able to bridge the gap between the page layout of the film and the single image of the screen. To this he presents the case for the way the film makes use of a hybrid set of techniques and approaches so that the distance between the page and the single screen is bridged. The choice of the realistic modes of shooting the film, for instance, is made to make sure that the page layout in Pekar is rendered in good faith to the moving image. The aesthetic sensibility stands out as the overriding concern. The proof is that Pekar himself approves of the film as being a faithful reproduction of the artistic intent and impact of the comic as it is read. One can say meanwhile that the objections above are substantially counter-argued in Hight in the sense that Hight essentially paints a picture of the movie making aesthetic for the film as something that captures unto the moving image the primary intents and the core sensibilities rendered by Pekar unto the printed page, via his drawn images. In essence Hight argues that Pucini and Berman render unto film, with the advice and blessing of Pekar, what Pekar the comic book would have looked like if the author were working with film, and infusing that work with the same sensibilities and overall artistic aesthetic (Hight, 2007, pp. 180-198). With regard to the arguments relating to sound in cinema versus silence in the comic book page, Lefevre notes that in modern cinema sound is an intrinsic aspect, but in comics sound is absent, and in this sense the two are very different mediums that cannot coexist. Lefevre notes that while comic pages can evoke sound, it is not the same when rendered unto film sounds. It is such that the comic book reader becomes disoriented when the voice that he imagines is not the same as the voice in the film (Lefevre, 2007). Harvey concurs by saying that for film the audio component is available and used to convey meaning and messages, whereas in the comic book form there is only the visual element and no sound (Harvey, 1996). Hight again resorts to making an equivalence between the voice of Pekar annotating certain parts of the movie with a kind of authentic rendering of the “silence” that makes up the thought processes behind the comic book images in Pekar. The idea behind the arguments in Hight is that the film making techniques employed in the movie equates to the creation of a correspondence between the original silent elements of the comic book page with the voices and sounds that were incorporated into the movie. That the voice over was from Pekar himself is argued to fit in nicely with the documentary nature of the movie itself, reinforcing an overall aesthetic that is consistent with the intent and vision of Pekar. In conclusion, while Lefevre and Harvey makes valid technical points with regard to fundamental differences between the comic book page and film, Hight makes a good case for viewing the movie as being faithful to the artistic vision of Pekar, overcoming the hurdles and making it a successful adaptation, everything considered (Hight, 2007, pp. 180-198; Lefevre, 2007, pp. 1-12; Harvey, 1996, pp. 173-191). References Harvey, R. (1996). Only in the Comics: Why Cartooning is Not the Same as Filmmaking. The Art of the Comic Book: An Aesthetic History. University Press of Mississippi. Google Books. Retrieved from http://books.google.com Hight, C. in Gordon, I. and Jancovich, M. (ed) (2007). American Splendor: Translating Comic Autobiography Into Drama-Documentary. Film and Comic Books. University Press of Mississippi. Google Books. http://books.google.com Lefevre, P. in Gordon, I. and Jancovich, M. (ed) (2007). Incompatible Visual Ontologies? The Problematic Adaptation of Drawn Images. Film and Comic Books. University Press of Mississippi. Google Books. http://books.google.com Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“The 'American Splendor' Film By Pucini and Berman as Being Essay”, n.d.)
The 'American Splendor' Film By Pucini and Berman as Being Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/english/1487375-the-american-splendor-film-by-pucini-and-berman-as-being-successfully-adapted-from-harvey-pekars-comic-book
(The 'American Splendor' Film By Pucini and Berman As Being Essay)
The 'American Splendor' Film By Pucini and Berman As Being Essay. https://studentshare.org/english/1487375-the-american-splendor-film-by-pucini-and-berman-as-being-successfully-adapted-from-harvey-pekars-comic-book.
“The 'American Splendor' Film By Pucini and Berman As Being Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/english/1487375-the-american-splendor-film-by-pucini-and-berman-as-being-successfully-adapted-from-harvey-pekars-comic-book.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The American Splendor Film by Pucini and Berman as Being Adapted from Harvey Pekars Comic Book

Comic Books in America and Japan

Both America and Japan have witnessed the increased trend of comic book use in children, and the regions depict a variation in behaviourists the entity presents impacts to their development.... The comic book prevalence in the two countries has been evident in the inclusion of superheroes' fictionally writings.... The term has always been the comic book in America and the inclusion of manga in Japan.... The argument is placed that the creation of the american comic books and superheroes influenced the creation of the manga characters....
12 Pages (3000 words) Case Study

Comic Books in America and Japan

comic book popularity has recently been boosted by advances in technology, as children can now access comic plots through the internet on their computers and/or mobile phones.... In both America and Japan, the increased trend of comic book use in children is obvious, although the regions depict a variation in child behaviour in response to comic books.... apanese production of manga has been larger as compared to the american comic industry, occupying for precenting of personification production in Japan (Schodt, 1996, p....
10 Pages (2500 words) Case Study

Superman: The American Icon

Superman: the american Icon INTRODUCTION It was in the year 1933, at Cleveland in Ohio, two high school students were about to create a phenomenal change in the socio-cultural paradigm of America, quite unknown to their own selves even.... The trajectory of this blue costumed, red capped and stylized red and yellow inscribed ‘S' shield on his chest to an iconic figure of the american culture was not paved in a single year.... It took decades and several socio-cultural and socio-economic activities followed this transportation of the comic superhero into an emblem and cultural icon of America....
8 Pages (2000 words) Research Paper

Comic Book Critical Analysis

But we should note that they use the same materials and methods as we see in the printed books and are common sold in comic book stores.... A definition used by librarians refers to them as book-length narratives told using a combination of words and sequential art, often presented in comic book style.... The constant in both definitions is "comic book.... He is one of the american comic artists to assimilate magna influences in to his work....
5 Pages (1250 words) Assignment

Comic Books and Ideology

Comics and ideology is a book that offers several useful essays that talk more about the american superheroes and mostly focuses on Wonder Woman, Superman, and many more gay characters in the comics (Mathew, 2001).... I personally agree with the book, as it has the power of influencing a large number of citizens in the United States to promote moral uprightness.... The paper "comic Books and Ideology" addresses social issues such as the immoral behaviors that took place in the US....
5 Pages (1250 words) Book Report/Review

Why comics based movies are more polular than comics themselves

Additionally, the Batman franchise is an intense sample of TV and film reusing comic book background.... First comic book in America was printed in 1842, and, though this type of art has become really popular in no time-The Brownies: Their Book, printed in 1887 became world-renown, its style was impressively different from the one we are used to nowadays ("Comic Books").... There is a great number of movies that gained their popularity seemingly from the scratch - 300 Spartans, Sin City, V is for Vendetta - in a row with films that where based on franchise that already has been famous - Spider Man, Batman, X-Men; also Blade, The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen, Conan, Shadow, The Crow - some people would hardly realize, that all these films were based on a source-book ("Cover Browser")....
15 Pages (3750 words) Research Paper

Comic Book as History

The author of this coursework "comic book as History" describes key features of comic books.... In the long span of comic book art, little attention was given to the use of sequential art in narrating significant historical events, true to life stories, journalism, and travelogues among others.... They also question the ethical grounds of employing such unusual mediums and questions the authority of the comic book creators on the depiction of historical events in comic art (Witek 1989)....
10 Pages (2500 words) Coursework

History of Comic in the 20th Century

However, the theme of Racism as well as past Vs Present echoes quite strongly in this book.... Art Spiegelman's book has two major faces: 'And Here My Troubles began' and 'A Survivors Tale; My Father Bleeds History'.... The paper "History of comic in the 20th Century" aimed to understand what comic is, identify the use of comic in the novel Maus by Art Spiegelman, and relate it to our current use of comic and understand the milestone to which comic has come nowadays....
6 Pages (1500 words) Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us