StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Bicultural Program for Deaf People - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
This paper "Bicultural Program for Deaf People" discusses a teaching technique that understands the value and significance of hearing and deaf cultures as the bilingual or bicultural approach (BiBi). One of the positives of this approach is that it incorporates both these aspects into education…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.6% of users find it useful
Bicultural Program for Deaf People
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Bicultural Program for Deaf People"

Bilingual/Bicultural Program A teaching technique that understands the value and significance of hearing and deaf cultures is the bilingual or bicultural approach (BiBi). One of the positives of this approach is that it incorporates both these aspects into education. These types of programs are very similar to ESL programs. Those children who are deaf and skillful in American Sign Language (ASL) are usually better readers of English than deaf children who do not know ASL. This seems quite strange because ASL is quite different structurally from the English language (Goldin-Meadow & Mayberry, 2001). ASL can be used as a method of critical thinking and problem solving. It also allows deaf children to form relationships with “normal”r people and open themselves up to knowledge (Cummins, 2010). ASL is used by BiBis ASL not just as a tool for English and the pursuit of knowledge, but also as a vital method for responding to ideas and issues that matter. The principle for enhancing ASL language skills is no different than developing English language skills for children whose mother tongueirst language is English (Cummins, 2010). McAnally, Rose, and Quigley (2007) believe that if ASL can be taught thoroughly, then English language abilities can be reached without experience to English through speech, or alternatively, through a manually code English sign system. Goldin-Meadow and Mayberry (2001) touch on how important it is to pick up a mother tongue language in the first few years of life. As such, knowledge of ASL does not hinder learning to read written English. On the contrary, ASL could actually assist deaf children in learning how to read English. Goldin-Meadow and Mayberry (2001) highlight just how important it is to learn a language in the early years if deaf children are to going to be able to read English. The first step to help deaf children become readers of English is to make sure than they develop appropriate language skills (it can be any language at all). Deaf children who are learning ASL or any type of sign language from their deaf parents do not need any extra help at this stage because they will pick up language in the same way that normal hearing children learn spoken language. However, deaf children with hearing parents do need interventions in several areas. The early detection of loss of hearing, early entry to education, and continuous contact with fluent speakers of English can help to ensure that profoundly deaf children can learn a language because they have access to it. Mayberry et al. (2002) carried out research that highlights the costs of not developing a strong mother language early in life. For example, Mayberry and Lock (2003) reported that the age of a first language experience can determine the future ability to understand grammatical information. Deaf individuals who were not exposed to their first language until they were six or older displayed low accuracy in English grammatical judgment and understanding compared to deaf and hearing individuals who had learned English as a second language in school after appropriate exposure to a (signed or oral) first language in the home during the first few years of life. Cochlear Implant One of the major debates within the field of deaf education currently concentrates on the effects of cochlear implants on spoken language and academic learning practically in literacy skills. The cochlear implant device was approved by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) in the 1980s (FDA, 2009) and not only was controversial, but added new thoughts to the continuing debate between spoken and sign language methods (Gale, 2010). Although the numbers of deaf children with these surgically implanted devices grew worldwide (Hyde and Power, 2006), key issues about the device still remain, particularly within the deaf community (Gale, 2010). The device itself and the appropriate modes of communication is in question, especially with members who have a strong preference for American Sign Language (ASL). It is a fact that cochlear implants are not a threat to deaf culture. The major issue revolves around recognizing deafness as a cultural identity. The important subjects that educators in the field of DHH are concerned about are the benefits of cochlear implants as well as how it affects spoken language and academic learning. It is no secret that many students who are DHH also have poor reading skills (Emerson, 2010). According to Luckner and Handley (2008), the average student who suffers from hearing loss graduates from high school with fourth-grade reading skills. Even worse, some of these students finish school with a second grade reading level or lower. Unfortunately, many students with DHH have poor literacy skills. This infringes upon their ability to function effectively in school. Therefore, poor literacy skills play a negative role in acquiring academic skills. Spencer and Tomblin (2009) mentioned that over 30 percent of deaf children graduate from American high schools as if they were illiterate. On the reading skills of deaf children, Wauters, van Bon, and Tellings (2006) responded that the typical reading comprehension scores of deaf children and adolescents were terribly bad. There are many factors that have been identified as playing a role in a deaf child’s difficulties with literacy. One problem is that most deaf children have poor knowledge of spoken language that is represented in written text (Archbold et al., 2008). The rising availability of cochlear implants has given hope for higher levels of literacy for profoundly deaf children (Archbold, Harris, O’Donoghue, Nikolopoulos, White, and Richmond, 2008). Knowing spoken language skills has a say in improved literacy skills for DHH students in the classroom. Students with cochlear implants showed increased literacy ability. Vermeulen, Bon, Schreuder, Knoors, and Snik carried out a 2007 study on reading comprehension; the study contained two groups of 16 children in each group. These two groups were made up of prelingually deaf children with CIs and another group with normal hearing. These findings indicated that children with CIs obtained higher reading comprehension levels than deaf children without CIs, when compared to those with normal hearing. Emerson (2010) touched out a study performed by Moog (2002) that examined 17 children, aged between five and 11, with cochlear implants. All of these students used spoken language as their number one mode of communication; they had also attended a private school that focused on teaching listening and spoken language skills. Moog assessed reading levels. This reading assessment compared the results of deaf students to those who were of hearing ability. Of the 17 students who were assessed between 1997 and 2000, over 70 percent had reading scores within the normal range for their age. Also, Archbold, Harris, O’Donoghue, Nikolopoulos, White, and Richmond (2008) assessed 105 deaf students of ages 11 to 14 years; all of these students were implanted before the age of seven. The reading abilities of these students were assessed in the areas of vocabulary, sequencing, and sentence comprehension. This research showed that children implanted before three and a half years old had a reading age normal for their age. CIs played an important role in improving the academic performance of DHH students. The major debate is still between the pathological and deaf community views. The pathological view sees deafness as an auditory deficiency, a handicap, and a medical problem to be remedied so that a deaf person becomes as normal as possible. The deaf community recognizes deafness as a cultural identity. This community includes non-hearing parents of deaf children and deaf educators and organizations such as the National Association of the Deaf (NAD.) From their point of view, deafness is not a disability that can be fixed but rather is a cultural identity that should be accepted and supported in our society. They fear that cochlear implants are an isolating means. This will eradicate the use of ASL, hold back communication development, and ultimately threaten the rich and supportive deaf cultural traditions (Wolpe, 2005). There is a cultural gap between the pathological and deaf community views. The failure of these two camps to compromise on the issue of CIs is a result of a distinct socio-cultural divide. Hearing and non-hearing parents possess two entirely incompatible views of deafness. This prevents them from understanding each other (Wolpe, 2005). In summary, cochlear implants are seen as an affront to deaf cultural identification and are not welcome. Despite this, CIs are not a threat to deaf culture. The actual debate lies in recognizing deafness as a cultural identity. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Bicultural Program for Deaf People Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 words, n.d.)
Bicultural Program for Deaf People Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 words. https://studentshare.org/education/1775045-literacy-development
(Bicultural Program for Deaf People Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words)
Bicultural Program for Deaf People Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words. https://studentshare.org/education/1775045-literacy-development.
“Bicultural Program for Deaf People Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words”. https://studentshare.org/education/1775045-literacy-development.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Bicultural Program for Deaf People

Report on CEDPA Training

n building an organization or program to aid women it is vital that the group has the ability to sustain itself over time.... Monitoring and constant evaluation of the project will give us the yardstick we need to measure the program's value.... The Global Women in Management (GWM) course that was presented by the Centre for Development and Population Activities (CEDPA) in the summer of 2006 was as inspirational as it was instructive....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Media Impact on People's Thoughts

hellip; The media also has a powerful impact in shaping how people think and has been used as a tool to frame and alter public opinion, especially in the context of the war in Iraq.... In the weeks just after the United States invaded Iraq, public support from the American people for the war was high.... For example, one local television news program aired a fifteen-minute segment each evening when it focused on the body of one dead soldier in a brief eulogy....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

IT Consulting Firm

The report shall propose the introduction of an online consultancy firm to deal with some of the problems facing companies today in relation to becoming culturally sensitive.... The corporate world is currently embracing information technology at a fast pace.... … Many companies use online consultancy firms to recruit their staff members....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

How diversity impacts educational efforts and programs within the area of academia

As the society has become increasingly multicultural over the decades, it has imparted a need for the professionals to be able to understand the individualistic needs, norms and values of people belonging to different cultures so that they can be entertained.... Diversity has a significant impact on the educational efforts and programs particularly in the area of nursing given a nurse has to interact with people coming from different backgrounds on a daily basis....
1 Pages (250 words) Research Paper

Sakru japan

Encouraging employees to work closely with people of different cultures in order to learn about such cultures would as well solve this problem.... The Japanese are generally hard working people, which mean that poor performance can only be attributed to lack of motivation.... This reason calls for a cultural training program aimed to solve cultural problems in the company.... Through the cultural program, intercultural problems in the company would be solved through cross-cultural training....
1 Pages (250 words) Assignment

Restructure Writing

art B: Significance of BilingualismDiversity imposes different communication needs and common examples are in communication between people who speak different oral languages and communication a deaf person and one who is not deaf.... Among the deaf, use of both sign language and mouthing are able to adjust to communication needs around them for effective communication (Parasnis, 1996, P.... Bilingualism also facilitates cognitive competence among the deaf and this can be inferred to other competence areas, even among other population segments (Nussbaum, Scott & Simms, 2012, P....
1 Pages (250 words) Assignment

World Relief jurnal

World Relief is helping over 4 million people a year and its staff of volunteers is nearly 100,000 (World Relief Website).... In the area of medicine World Relief includes five programs that provide medical equipment and supplies throughout the world for the people with low-income at little cost or in free way.... World Medical Relief gives medical support and equipment to local clinics other non-profit health organizations) In 2008 feeding centers of World Relief organization provided people with nourishing food....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Major Comparisons in Key Culture Areas between Australia and Pakistan

Pakistan is a society that is mixed with people hailing from conservative as well as liberal backgrounds.... This is because Australia pays a great amount of respect to the field of education and what it does towards its own people is meticulous.... This is a facilitating step as it empowers the people to understand what backgrounds they are coming from and how they can exchange ideas and relations with one another (Laubscher 1994)....
5 Pages (1250 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us