StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

A Concise Note on the Concepts of Ideal Societies - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
This work "A Concise Note on the Concepts of Ideal Societies" describes a comparative analysis of the concepts of an ideal society as professed by Confucius and Mozi. The author outlines that Confucius’s ideal society is based on dutiful and responsible behavior on the part of each and every member of society…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.6% of users find it useful
A Concise Note on the Concepts of Ideal Societies
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "A Concise Note on the Concepts of Ideal Societies"

of the of the Assignment A Concise on the Concepts of Ideal Societies Introduction This paper is a comparative analysis of the concepts of ideal society as professed by Confucius and Mozi. Historically, Mozi and his philosophy known as Mohism have been interpreted as a Chinese school of thought that criticized Confucian philosophy on a number of occasions. On the other hand, many scholars like Ivanhoe and Bryan, etc. hold that Confucianism is the savior of Chinese culture. In this paper, the following question will be answered through a step by step analysis: Question 4:– Describe the ideal societies of Confucius and Mozi. What is it about them that make them ideal? Which is better, and why? Confucian ideal society The concept of ideal society from Confucian point of view is rather straight forward and simple. It is straight forward in the sense that it develops upon the older concepts of ideal society as used to exist in ancient China even before the advent of Confucian philosophy. Confucius developed his thesis upon the concepts like those of heaven and hell, gods and goddesses, nobility, divinity, etc. Also, Confucius did not take the risk of altering the pre-existing social strata; Confucius preferred to say that he was not giving anything new; he was just conveying what already existed in the sphere Chinese culture and legacy. But, Slingerland (35) notes, “Confucius felt anyone from any social class could potentially become a gentleman and that social status did not necessarily correspond to actual moral worth.” Of course, this is a humanistic approach where Confucius’s ideal society would be a place that would harbor the innate qualities of a human being irrespective of economical, political, ethnical, or even ethical stereotypes. Confucius stated that in an ideal society, trustworthiness (誠信) is most necessary to foster mutual support and strengthen social relationships (Slingerland, 15). A Confucian ideal society is not a Utopian concept and it is very much practicable because it neither relies on too much austerity nor necessitates lavish customs. According to Confucius, an appropriately generous person must give his needy peers the very right amount to fulfill their shortcomings – neither more nor less (Bonevac and Phillips, 40). Therefore, Confucius’s ideal society is based on dutiful and responsible behavior on the part of each and every member of the society, who will usher five major qualities of humanity: kindness, hard work, genuineness, generosity, and seriousness. All these virtues would culminate at Rén (仁). Western translators have interpreted Rén as the collective virtue of humanness or goodness (Bonevac and Phillips, 37-41). Ideal society of Mozi Mozi’s ideal society is based on some sort of societal awareness. To understand Mozi’s ideal society, one must keep in mind that Mozi was not born in a typical noble family. He was a skilled craftsman who was an expert in fortifications. Hence, the contemporary Chinese kingdoms (who used to remain engaged in almost regular warfare among them) needed technical experts like Mozi. So, Mozi managed to penetrate in the aristocratic world of the local rulers and warlords. But, Mozi interpreted contemporary Chinese society from the point of view of a common Chinese man. The result was that Mozi visualized the ideal society as a peaceful place where common people would be valued most. Mohist ideal society is based on a stable state that would be empowered by material prosperity and social order. Scholars like Ivanhoe and van Norden (60) define the aforementioned features of Mozi’s ideal society as a kind of state consequentialism. In the Mohist ideal society, an individual must be provided with enough food, clothing, and shelter. Instead of aiming at spiritual and moral well being, Mozi’s ideal society stresses on materialistic well being, rule of law, and avoidance of unnecessary warfare. Modern thinkers have praised Mohist philosophy as a heterodox but sensible school of thought. Even the leftist policy makers in today’s People’s Republic of China have identified Mohism as an early anti-war thesis. Mozi’s ideal society is poised to better use of science and technology and optimal resource allocation for public welfare instead of unnecessary warfare. (Yates, 549-554) What makes the society ideal? From Confucian point of view, pursuit of spiritual and ethical excellence will make the society an ideal one, where cultural purity and sincere ritualism would play a paramount role. The ideal society continues with the relatively older concepts of noble behavior and gallantry. To die in warfare is glorious death, and service to the society and nation is a supreme virtue. Confucian ideal society depends on humanistic behavior, and can be regarded as one of the earliest examples of a humane organization. From Mohist point of view, avoidance of warfare and assurance of a stable state that can provide its people adequately would eventually culminate at an ideal society. In Mohist ideal society, there is no place for something that is not serving the more useful purposes of social organization. According to Mozi, these useful purposes are law and order, collective prosperity, peace, and a thriving population (in Mozi’s time, scarcity of population was a problem in most of the Chinese kingdoms and counties). Hence, a society with the pursuit of material happiness and peace can be regarded as Mozi’s ideal society. Whose approach is better: Confucius or Mozi? Throughout most of the Chinese history, Confucian ritualism achieved extensive success because it addressed the necessities of inheritance rules, cultural legacy, and values of the aristocratic factions. Therefore, even in modern China before the founding of the republic, Confucianism remained a plastering element across the diverse social and ethnic groups. Yet, Mozi’s approach toward social theory and his interpretation of the ideal society appears to be better. Although Mozi was critical toward everything that he considered unnecessary for collective and social good, the points he made are relevant even today. Mozi advocated that whatever customs and rituals did not contribute to general public good must be abandoned. In doing so, he even advocated abolition of music and dance. Moreover, he considered an increasing population to be a parameter the ideal society must achieve. In one go, these assumptions may appear to be jocular. But considering Mozi’s contemporary social environment, excessive ritualism along with dance and music might have frustrated the thinker. Also, scarcity of population was a real problem in ancient China. So from a more rationalistic perspective, Mohism can be regarded as a philosophy that was aimed at achieving greater public welfare instead of abstract and spiritual accomplishments. In doing so, Mozi’s ideal society has enough room to determine the duties of the aristocracy and the king toward common people. Despite Mozi was stifled by his contemporary thinkers, rulers, noblemen, and intelligentsia, excessive ritualism and aristocratic customs led to unhappiness and sorrow. In the wake of 20th century, China was weak and suffering from in fighting. In such a state of affair, both nationalist and communist reformers helped to revive Mohism that could attack the concept of fate or Ming (命) and challenge the Chinese plight instead of defining and justifying it as the wrath of gods. Conclusion Mainly because of Mozi’s critical attitude, a scholar would find Confucius and Mozi at the opposite poles of Chinese philosophy and classical thought. But both of them wanted their disciples to pursue a social system that would help to achieve greater human good. Both of these great philosophers wanted people to be happy. But due to Mozi’s materialistic approach, his philosophy appears to be more adaptable with the needs of the modern world. Mozi’s ideal society has enough room to accommodate the human activities as related to industrialization and destroy orthodoxy. Works Cited Bonevac, Daniel, and Stephen Phillips. Introduction to World Philosophy. New York: Oxford University Press, 2009. Print. Ivanhoe, Philip J., and Bryan W. van Norden. Readings in Classical Chinese Philosophy. Indianapolis: Hackett, 2005. Print. Slingerland, Edward. Confucius Analects: With Selections from Traditional Commentaries. Indianapolis: Hackett, 2003. Print. Yates, Robin D.S. "The Mohists on warfare: Technology, technique, and justification." Journal of the American Academy of Religion 47.3 (1980): 549-603. Print. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(A Concise Note on the Concepts of Ideal Societies Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 words - 2, n.d.)
A Concise Note on the Concepts of Ideal Societies Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 words - 2. https://studentshare.org/religion-and-theology/1793661-not-sure
(A Concise Note on the Concepts of Ideal Societies Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words - 2)
A Concise Note on the Concepts of Ideal Societies Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words - 2. https://studentshare.org/religion-and-theology/1793661-not-sure.
“A Concise Note on the Concepts of Ideal Societies Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words - 2”. https://studentshare.org/religion-and-theology/1793661-not-sure.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF A Concise Note on the Concepts of Ideal Societies

The Ways in Which the Liberalism Ideology Has Changed from Its Classical Origins

However, even before these concepts of liberalism were laid out, the principles which have fundamentally differentiated liberalism from other ideals have already been present in civil society.... Name (student number) Liberalism Introduction Most societies are governed by varying ideals.... These philosophers had different views of the social contract as they supported the liberal ideal that government is essential in protecting social harmony....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

Gay Marriage: Not a Very Good Idea by William J.Bennett

The author also warns the people that the institution of marriage is already reeling because of the revolutionary concepts in sex activities.... The researcher of this essay aims to analyze The article “Gay Marriage: Not a Very Good Idea”.... The present research has identified that the author used both analytical and instinctive methods judiciously in this article to catch the attention of the readers....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Is Postmodernity a Useful Concept

Common Themes in Definitions of Postmodernity Drolet (2004) informs that postmodernity and postmodernism do not have concise definitions because the terms are used to convey various concepts depending on the field of discipline using the terms.... Is Postmodernity a Useful Concept?...
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

The Right to Euthanasia for the Terminally Ill

It is vital to note that such an act is painless way of terminating one's life in case the referred individual is suffering from a chronic and a progressive disease.... It is vital to note that one's won personal reasons would be valid because they would request for euthanasia....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

The Rule of Law in the Studies of Tamanaha and Belton

The rule of law is taken very frequently as a widely spread piece of rhetoric, but it can't be disregarded in no way, as it is indeed an extremely significant prerequisite for the establishment and permanence of a free, democratic society.... A lot of politicians speak over and over again about the rule of law, and in this way the rule of law constitutes a relevant accessory of their empty political discourse....
15 Pages (3750 words) Essay

Role Of The Public Sphere

While this may raise the question of "cultural imperialism", one has to realise that in the interpretation and evaluation of its various methods of display and communication, the public sphere has become a strong purveyor of the idea of opening up societies to each other besides a relevant model upon which various studies like those of consumer patterns, may be based. ...
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

GI2045 How does the concept of international society' differ from that of 'international systems'

n essence the essay tries to differentiate the the issue of international societies and international systems based on different theoretical perspectives of… International relations as a discipline is a branch of politics or political science to be specific.... n addition it is necessary to note that the field of international relations does cover other specialized entities like non-governmental organizations, inter-governmental organizations, intra-governmental organizations as well as supra-governmental agencies....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Personality Assessment Instrument or Inventory Critique

Personality assessment instruments are practically designed by psychological experts to be able to come up with the most important personality evaluations that individuals need to be able to find their weaknesses and strengths that are necessary for one's personal development.... hellip; These assessment instruments are basically used by business HR departments as well as school counsellors to assess the individual capabilities of each person making up the said institutions1....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us