StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Death Penalty and The Ethical Doctrine of Utilitarianism - Admission/Application Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper "Death Penalty and The Ethical Doctrine of Utilitarianism" highlights that the significance of the death penalty has been a disturbing moral question with respect to its validity in deterring future criminal activities. People have different opinions as to whether or not the death penalty is justifiable …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.6% of users find it useful

Extract of sample "Death Penalty and The Ethical Doctrine of Utilitarianism"

Death PenaltyDeath penalty is a form of capital punishment where convicted criminals are executed after being found guilty of a crime. This act is normally perceived as a deterrent for potential criminals. Death penalty is one of the controversial issues, in most criminal punishment debates. Its proponents perceive it as the best method for punishing criminals while its opponents argue that it denies criminals their human rights. This debate has triggered many societies to question the validity of the death penalty in solving criminal acts.

This paper illustrates the significance of differentiating between justifying a moral issue and justifying certain actions that fall under it. The ethical doctrine of utilitarianism is applied to assess the arguments about the justification of the death penalty or capital offence. Utilitarian defense of the death penalty focuses on deterrent of self, deterrent of others and general social benefits. The significance of the death penalty has been a disturbing moral question with respect to its validity in deterring future criminal activities.

The disturbing question is that people have different opinions as to whether or not the death penalty is justifiable (Pollock 332). In this case, there are two justifications of capital punishment. The retributive perspective asserts that capital punishment is justified on the basis that violation of law deserves punishment. It is morally right that criminals deserve punishment worth their wrong doings. Therefore, a society where criminals receive punishment worth their guilt is better than a society where criminals do not account for their wrongdoings (Pollock 332).

According to the ethical doctrines of utilitarianism, bygones are bygones, and only the future consequences of a moral issue are the considerable factors to present decisions. Therefore, capital punishment is only justifiable with references to its future consequences of keeping it as one of the ethical doctrines of maintaining social order (Pollock 337). Therefore, the past consequences of the death penalty are not worth considering in determining its future consequences. Capital punishment is justifiable only when it can be approved to address the future interest of a society.

One of the reasons of carrying out death penalty is to scare other criminals from indulging in the same crime. Utilitarian can assert that inflicting pain is justified since it brings about much happiness and less pain, in the future (Pollock 334). Therefore, capital punishment is a justified means of deterring crime if the real offenders are executed, and the same offenses are not committed, in the future. However, its significance becomes invalid in a case where a series of criminal activities takes place, but not even one of the offenders is caught.

This can sometimes lead to the framing and killing of an innocent man. In this situation, the ideal instance of utilitarian or capital punishment becomes insignificant since the culprits themselves are left to commit same crimes, in the future (Pollock 337). According to these arguments, capital punishment or utilitarian becomes unjustifiable in relation to deterring other criminals from committing the same offense and creating peace in the society. This is because capital punishment can sometimes cost a life of an innocent man while the real culprit is left to commit further crime.

Additionally, further crimes will still create insecurity, in the society. In this case, utilitarianism becomes unjustifiable. However, death penalty becomes justifiable in the deterrence of offenders. Hanging real criminals means that they will not exist to commit further crimes. In this case, utilitarianism becomes justifiable since future crimes by these offenders are prevented. Works CitedPollock J. M. Ethical Dilemmas and Decisions in Criminal Justice. New York: Cengage Learning, 2011. Print

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Death Penalty and The Ethical Doctrine of Utilitarianism Admission/Application Essay”, n.d.)
Death Penalty and The Ethical Doctrine of Utilitarianism Admission/Application Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/psychology/1786561-contemporary-moral-issue-in-any-society-and-apply-the-ethical-doctrine-of-utilitarianism-to-defendagreeaccept-this-issue
(Death Penalty and The Ethical Doctrine of Utilitarianism Admission/Application Essay)
Death Penalty and The Ethical Doctrine of Utilitarianism Admission/Application Essay. https://studentshare.org/psychology/1786561-contemporary-moral-issue-in-any-society-and-apply-the-ethical-doctrine-of-utilitarianism-to-defendagreeaccept-this-issue.
“Death Penalty and The Ethical Doctrine of Utilitarianism Admission/Application Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/psychology/1786561-contemporary-moral-issue-in-any-society-and-apply-the-ethical-doctrine-of-utilitarianism-to-defendagreeaccept-this-issue.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Death Penalty and The Ethical Doctrine of Utilitarianism

The Ethics of Peta and The Death Penalty

The two groups working for the ethics of the death penalty and animals' right to live are both paradoxical and in favor of each other.... ETA stands for People for the ethical Treatment of Animals.... Capital punishment, more often known as the death penalty or execution (beheading, hanging or submitting to the electric chair) is the taking away of human life due to a capital crime committed following a judicial proceeding.... Capital crimes include premeditated murders and more recently the death penalty is awarded for kidnapping in some countries as well. … While the death penalty is eminent the world over, there are many groups of people who consider it an unethical practice....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Utilitarianism and the Ethical Policy

Lyons, David, "Forms and Limits of utilitarianism".... the ethical policy which stated that moral value of an action is exclusively resolute by its donation to overall efficacy.... Utilitarianism the ethical policy which stated that moral value of an action is exclusively resolute by its donation to overall efficacy.... of the of the Philosophy Before going directly towards the topic first have look on utilitarianism.... The finest way to argue in conflict to abortion is with Mill's utilitarianism....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

The Ethical View of Utilitarianism

The writer of this essay analyzes the ethical view of utilitarianism.... This action would follow the foundation of utilitarianism.... Utilitarianism is the ethical view that every action is either right/wrong on the basis of the impact that it will create, more specifically if it will produce the greatest good for the greatest number of people.... the ethical View of UtilitarianismUtilitarianism becomes a very practical option in many situations....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Utilitarianism

Secondly is one's consciousness feeling guilty and resentment on the cause of action Utilitarianism Question The core principle of utilitarianism s that “actions are right in proportion as theytend to promote overall human happiness”.... Utilitarianism is the ethical act of maximum utilization of morals.... Utilitarianism is the ethical act of maximum utilization of morals.... utilitarianism extends to political ethics which introduces the problem of tyranny of majority....
1 Pages (250 words) Assignment

Utilitarianism

Such members are governed by ethics, with the doctrine of utilitarianism forming a significant proportion of their obligations.... It is rather absurd to think that generating the greatest utilitarianism al Affiliation) utilitarianism utilitarianism, as described by its proponents John Stuart Mill and JeremyBentham, focuses on actions that derive maximum benefit to all.... utilitarianism lies in the complete spirit of the ethics of utility....
1 Pages (250 words) Coursework

Why Bernard Williams Argues That Utilitarianism Is Wrong

The paper "Why Bernard Williams Argues That utilitarianism Is Wrong" states that utilitarianism would approve to meeting the demands or implementing actions such as attacks that would risk the hostages' lives in the process, because of the strong attached negative responsibility of the commander.... utilitarianism hence entails consequentialism, which lays emphasis on the outcome of the available choices; as a result, an action is right if it delivers the best result of all given alternatives....
8 Pages (2000 words) Coursework
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us