StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

The Similarities and Differences Between Public and Private Nuisance - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
This essay "The Similarities and Differences Between Public and Private Nuisance" focuses on nuisance as a tort that means an unlawful interference with a person's use or enjoyment of land, or some right over, or in connection with it. Nuisance is of two kinds…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.9% of users find it useful
The Similarities and Differences Between Public and Private Nuisance
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The Similarities and Differences Between Public and Private Nuisance"

Critically examine the similarities and differences betweeen public and private Nuisance. Support your answer with relevant statute and case law.. please use UK laws, cases, and statutes Nuisance as a tort means an unlawful interference with a persons use or enjoyment of land, or some right over, or in connection with it.(Winfield on Tort, 7th ed.p.193) Acts interfering with the comfort, health or safety are the examples of it. The interference may be any way, e.g., noise, vibrations, heat, smoke, smell, fumes, water, gas, electricity, excavation or disease producing germs. Nuisance is of two kinds : (i) Public or Common Nuisance. (ii) Private Nuisance, or Tort of Nuisance. Difference and Similarity between the two : Public nuisance is a crime whereas private nuisance is a civil wrong. Public nuisance is interference with the right of public in general and is punishable as an offense.: Obstructing a public way by digging a trench, or constructing structures on it are examples of public nuisance. Although such obstruction may cause inconvenience to many persons but none can be allowed to bring a civil action for that, otherwise there may be hundreds of actions for a. single act of public nuisance. To avoid multiplicity of suits the law makes public nuisance only an offence punishable under criminal law. In certain cases, when any person suffers some special or particular damage, different from what is inflicted upon public as a whole, a civil right of action is available to the person injured. What is otherwise a public nuisance, also becomes a private nuisance so far as the person suffering special damage as concerned. The expression special damage in this context means damage caused to a party in contradistinction to the public at largest For example, digging trench on a public highway may cause inconvenience to public at large. No member of the public, who is thus obstructed or has to take a diversion along with others, can sue under civil law. But if any one of them suffers more damage than suffered by the public at large, e.g., is severely injured by falling into the trench, he can sue in tort. In order to sustain a civil action in respect of a public nuisance proof of special and particular damage is essential. The proof of special damage entitles the plaintiff to bring a civil action for what may be otherwise a public nuisance. Thus, if the standing of horses and wagons for an unreasonably long time outside : mans house Creates darkness and bad smell for the occupants of the house and also obstructs the access of customers into it, the damage is ‘particular, direct and substantial’ and entitles the occupier to maintain an action.(Benjamin v. Storr,(1874) L.R.9C.P.400) In ‘Rose v. Milles’(1815; 4M.&S.101): the defendant wrongfully moored his barge across a public navigable crack. This blocked the way for plaintiffs barges and the plaintiff had to incur considerable expenditure in unloading the cargo and transporting the same by land. It was held that there was special damage caused to the plaintiffs support his claim. In ‘Campbell v. Paddington Corporation’(1911; 1K.B.869) the plaintiff was the owner of a building in London. The funeral procession of King Edward VII was to pass from a highway just in front of the plaintiffs building. An uninterrupted view of the procession could be had from the windows of the plaintiffs building. The plaintiff accepted certain payments from certain persons and invited them to occupy seats in the first and second floor of her building. Before the date of the said procession the defendant corporation constructed a stand on the highway in front of the plaintiffs building to enable She members of the Corporation and its guests to have a view of the procession. This structure now obstructed the view from the plaintiffs building. Because Of the obstruction the plaintiff was deprived of the profitable contract of letting seats in her building. She filed a suit against the Corporation contending that the structure on the highway, which was a public nuisance, had caused special loss to her. It was held that she was entitled to claim compensation. If the plaintiff cannot prove that he has suffered any special damage, i.e., more damage than suffered by the other members of the public, he cannot claim compensation for the same. The essentials of Private Nuisance : 1. Unreasonable Interference Interference may cause damage to the Plaintiff’s property or may cause personal discomfort to the plaintiff in the enjoyment of the property. But every interference is not a nuisance and to constitute nuisance the interference should be reasonable. Thesiger L.J. stated in ‘Sturges v. Bridgman’(1979) “what would be a nuisance in Belgrade square would not necessarily be so in Bremondsey.” Also in ‘Sadleigh Denfield v. O’Callaghan(1940) A.C.880 Lord Wright stated for the purpose of nuisance it has to be seen as to “what is reasonable according to the ordinary usages of mankind living in society, or more correctly in particular society.” If the Plaintiff is extra sensitive when the act that is otherwise reasonable does not become unreasonable and actionable when the damage, even though substantial, is caused solely due to the sensitivity of the plaintiff. It was stated in ‘Heath v. Mayor of Brighton’(1908) 98 L.T. 718 that the court refused to grant injunction in favour of the incumbent and trustees of a Brighton Church to restrain “ a buzzing noise” from the defendant’s power station. It was stated that the noise did not cause annoyance to any other person but the incumbent, nor was the noise such as could distract the attention of ordinary persons attending the church. It has also been ruled by the courts that if an act, otherwise lawful act of the defendant has been done with an evil motive to annoy the plaintiff will not be considered as nuisance. (‘Allen v. Flood’(1898)A.C.1) Interference with the use or enjoyment of land that constitutes a injury to the property itself or injury to comfort or health of occupants of the property will constitute nuisance. This position was adopted in (‘St. Helen’s Smelting Co. v. Tipping’ 1865; 11 H.L. Cas.642) A person also has a natural right to have his land supported by his neighbour’s and therefore removal of support, lateral or from beneath is a nuisance.(Humperies v. Brodgen ; 1850 ; 12 Q.B. 739). In respect of buildings the right of support may be acquired by grant or prescription.(‘Partridge v. Scott’ 1838; 2 M& W.220). Right to Light is also not a natural right and may be acquired by grant or prescription. When such a right has been acquired, a substantial interference with it is an actionable nuisance.(‘Colls v. Home and Colonial Stores Ltd.’ 1904; A.C.179). Substantial interference with the comfort and convenience in using the premises is actionable as a nuisance. A mere trifling or fanciful inconvenience is not enough. The rule is De minimis non curat lex, that means that the law does not take account of very trifling matters. DAMAGES Unlike trespass, which is actionable per se, actual damage is required to be proved in an action for nuisance.(‘Nicholls v. Ely Beet Sugar Factory’ 1936). In the case of Public Nuisance, the plaintiff has to prove a special damage caused to him while, in Private Nuisance, although damage is one of the essentials but the law often presumes it. Bibliography Bangia,R.K.; Law of Torts, ALA Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Critically examine the similarities and differences between public and Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1552623-critically-examine-the-similarities-and-differences-between-public-and-private-nuisance-support-answer-with-relevant-statute-and-case-law
(Critically Examine the Similarities and Differences Between Public and Essay)
https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1552623-critically-examine-the-similarities-and-differences-between-public-and-private-nuisance-support-answer-with-relevant-statute-and-case-law.
“Critically Examine the Similarities and Differences Between Public and Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1552623-critically-examine-the-similarities-and-differences-between-public-and-private-nuisance-support-answer-with-relevant-statute-and-case-law.
  • Cited: 4 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Similarities and Differences Between Public and Private Nuisance

Cultural Differences between the US and Saudi Arabia

Nevertheless, while too many people think that there is nothing common about the cultures between United States and Saudi Arabia, there are similarities and differences between them.... Therefore, this expose elucidates these similarities and differences while focusing on the important aspects of attachment to gas, the way people lived in these two societies, the role of women, and the role of the youths in the two societies.... However, from a general viewpoint, the differences in culture seem to be more than the similarities....
10 Pages (2500 words) Research Paper

Public Sector Accounting Issues

Overall the four sections in the project analyze if the differences between the two sectors' accounting practices are prominent or if there is any reduction in their differing frameworks.... Public Sector Accounting Table of Contents Table of Contents 2 Introduction 3 Accounting Needs & Objectives 4 Accounting Laws, Regulations & Guidelines 5 Public Sector Performance Assessment 7 Role of Auditor in Public/private Organizations 8 Conclusion 9 References 11 Bibliography 12 Introduction This project includes a critical analysis of public sector accounting in UK as to how the public sector organizations demonstrate accountability....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Law. Discussion of views

Principles of law and morality therefore interact with some similarities and differences.... private nuisance such as throwing objects into a person's piece of land causes damage to the specific landowner or specific peoples who have right over ownership or usage of the infringed piece of land.... One of the differences between law and morality is in their sources.... Difference between criminal and civil law There are also a number of differences between criminal law and civil law....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Public and Private Nuisances

The paper 'Public and Private Nuisances' addresses both public and private nuisance by expounding on their definitions.... private nuisance occurs when the comfort and convenience of a person who rightfully owns the land they possess occur for a continuous period of time.... It also explains the conditions that should be met before a nuisance claim is presented to a law court.... The law describes nuisance as public or private depending on the case it attracts....
8 Pages (2000 words) Research Paper

Government vs. Private Sector

Financial Finance and Accounting: The Difference between public and private Sector Finance and Accounting There isa significant difference between public sector and private sector management of finance and accounting.... The context of public and private sector finance and accounting management also differs in such a way that the private sector has more autonomy to make any financial and accounting decisions in order to achieve what ought to be achieved (Finkler, 2010)....
1 Pages (250 words) Coursework

Public Sector Accounting

Overall the four sections in the project analyze if the differences between the two sectors' accounting practices are prominent or if there is any reduction in their differing frameworks.... ccounting Needs & ObjectivesThe public sector encompasses all the organizations that are not owned or operated by private organizations.... In the first section of the project the needs and objectives of the public sector accounting has been discussed along with a comparison with the objectives of non-public sector organizations....
8 Pages (2000 words) Case Study

Guidance for the Early Years Foundation Stage of Swedish and English Curricula

This paper "Guidance for the Early Years Foundation Stage of Swedish and English Curricula" considers the similarities and differences of both the English and Swedish approaches with regard to policy, curriculum, and practice with the aim of outlining the specific details of these curricula.... he government support through the municipalities: In Swedish society special funds set aside to assist children and their families to comfortably fit while in the English setting education is funded mainly through the public and private education and care centers....
28 Pages (7000 words) Literature review

Similarities and Differences between the Australian Labor Party and the American Democrats

This essay "similarities and differences between the Australian Labor Party and the American Democrats" presents the Australian labor party (ALP) that came into existence as a federal party in Australia a few years before the first Australian parliament sitting in 1901.... imilaritiesFederal SystemBoth parties exist in a federal system where there exists a power division between the national government and the state governments....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us