StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Philosophy - Categorical Imperative - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The second form of the Categorical Imperative says, ‘Act in such a way that you treat humanity (he uses the term “rational nature”), whether in your own person or in the person of another, always at the same time as an end and never simply as a means’.
But when…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.5% of users find it useful
Philosophy - Categorical Imperative
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Philosophy - Categorical Imperative"

Instructions: APPLIED ARGUMENT: Think about this: The second form of the Categorical Imperative says, ‘Act in such a way that you treat humanity (he uses the term “rational nature”), whether in your own person or in the person of another, always at the same time as an end and never simply as a means’. But when precisely are we using someone as a ‘mere’ means and when are we using someone ‘legitimately’ as a means to our ends? In life, we use people ‘legitimately’ as means to our ends all the time.

We use the farmer as a means to getting food. Part of the relationship of friendship entails using a friend to get companionship, and likewise, teaching entails using a teacher for learning. So what is a ‘mere’ means? Is there a line, and when might we cross that line between a ‘legitimate’ means and ‘mere’ means? Let’s consider the workplace. It is quite clear that slavery is using someone as a mere means. Holding someone captive and working to another’s ends is certainly using him or her as a mere means.

Slavery is one extreme. One might say that at the other extreme is the self-employed person who determines his or her own ends and purposes, who decides when and how much to work and at what projects. In between these two extremes are a vast number of different types of work situations. Kant says we use people as ‘mere’ means when we determine their ends and purposes for them. Would involving the worker more in the decision-making process of work transform using them as a ‘mere’ means to using them as a ‘legitimate’ means?

Have you ever worked or are you working now for minimum wage? At the time of this writing, minimum wage in America is about $5.35 per hour, in other words, $856 per month, and $9844 per year (with small variations in some states). Is the kind of life the wage could provide for the worker a relevant matter in determining a case of ‘mere’ means? Does raising someone’s salary or giving them a Christmas bonus transform using them as a ‘mere’ means into using them as a ‘legitimate’ means?

If yes, is there a salary level at which this transformation takes place? Think about the working conditions for many people earning a wage. It seems that some of the most repugnant jobs are actually the ones paid the least—standing over a hot, greasy French fry station, hard manual labor, cleaning up others’ waste, etc. Is the degree that a job is repugnant a meaningful determinant for ‘mere’ means? If poorly paid repugnant work is one of ‘mere’ means, and if we raise the wage for repugnant work, does that transform it from ‘mere’ means to ‘legitimate’ means?

Maybe wage-labor, because of its very nature, is always using someone as a ‘mere’ means. In other words, does the fact that workers are in positions where they aren’t totally involved in every single decision that determines their own ends, but rather are working to another’s ends for a wage, reduce them to being a ‘mere’ means to those others? Write about this: To what extent and under what conditions is wage-labor using someone as a ‘mere’ means?According to Marx’s socialist economic theory even the capitalists system is based on the exploitation of labor, despite the claims that under such a system the labor is free to work for an agreed wage with an employer he or she chooses.

The only difference between slavery and capitalism being the laborer is not tied to an individual capitalist like in slavery but to the capitalist class as a whole. In the present day world, though people have the liberty to choose which employer he wishes to work with, the amount of wage that he should get is still left to the discretion of the employer. This attitude of the employee to allow him to be used is mainly attributed to illiteracy and poverty. Thus in a world where illiteracy and poverty is still widely prevalent, it would not be surprising if a wage laborer is used as a mere means.

It is under conditions such as these that people are unable to voice out their opinions and tend to obey their employers. Employing children is another way by which an employer uses wage-labor as mere means. Here the poverty of the family is being exploited. Impoverished children just tend to do their jobs and get whatever pay has been fixed for their labor. The stakes are high for the employer in this case as he can get the work done more efficiently in return for a smaller pay. People employed in smaller organizations who either due to poverty or illiteracy, cannot afford to loose their jobs by standing up against their employers asking for pay hikes continue to work as mere means.

Thus improving the literacy rate among citizens is highly important for every developing nation. Immigrant labor who are exposed to an alien foreign land and foreign language, end up doing jobs with meager wages. Immigrant worker percentages are on the rise in several developed countries, as people from the under developed nations continue to throng such places for better employment and wages. But they hardly realize the fact that they will only work towards meeting their employer’s end than their own, as that is the prize they will have to pay to be employed in a foreign land.

By the time, the immigrant learns the rules of the game in that land, he would have already allowed himself to be used as a mere means by his employer. Forced prostitution constitutes another form of wage labor where ignorant people get used and exploited for the benefit of others. Once they get into the trade there is hardly a way out. In all the above cases, employers take the sole responsibility in determining the rules and wage for the labor. The employee has literally no say. All that is required from him is to do the work and get the fixed pay.

Hence there is a need to understand how exactly the capitalist world works and thereby prevent the situation where people would be reduced to work as mere means.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Philosophy - Categorical Imperative Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words”, n.d.)
Philosophy - Categorical Imperative Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1544530-philosophy-categorical-imperative
(Philosophy - Categorical Imperative Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words)
Philosophy - Categorical Imperative Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1544530-philosophy-categorical-imperative.
“Philosophy - Categorical Imperative Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1544530-philosophy-categorical-imperative.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Philosophy - Categorical Imperative

Kant's Metaphysics of Morals, the Importance of Duty

He formulated his deontological ethics in a categorical imperative of doing good for the sake of good regardless of its consequence.... In the example stated, categorical imperative dictates to “wake up” early because it is good to wake up early even without considering one's need not to be late for work.... Consistent to this, Kant's categorical imperative states that every person has the duty to use and exercise his goodness/humanity as a means to an end....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

The Philosophers and Their Theories

The following assignment entitled 'The Philosophers and Their Theories' presents ethics which involves defining the behavior of a human being in order to be labeled as good conduct or behavior.... 'Good life' happens to be the central aspect while talking about ethics.... hellip; It's also pointed out that Thomas Hobbes who is credited for explaining the concept of the state of nature....
3 Pages (750 words) Assignment

Kant's Categorical Imperative

According to Kant, humans can act according to the categorical imperative by taking three forms of action.... The function of categorical imperatives is to act as a test for the principles of our actions and check whether they are moral or not.... The principle behind these categorical imperatives is the principle of fair play (Kant, p....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Practical Anthropology and Moral Philosophy Distinction

Kant asserts that all moral theories prior to this fail to explain the categorical nature of moral obligation and to articulate a supreme moral principle that could capture the categorical nature of morality because those previous moral theories had neither recognized moral agents as autonomous nor recognized that the supreme moral principle must be self-legislated.... The result of self-legislation in the previous theories on moral philosophy could only lead to hypothetical imperatives whereas Kant's theory, solely based on the autonomy of legislation, could lead to categorical imperatives....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Singer- and Kants categorical imperative

Bioethics is the study of these controversial issues that arise as a result of advancement of medicine and biology.... It is also involved in the… A good example of ordinary ethical issues is the decision to pull the switch on a patient who is being kept alive by hospital machines since they are brain dead hence the chances of their recovery One of the major contributors in bioethics is Peter Singer who has put across various theories in this field....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Is It Ever Ok to Lie, Steals or Break One's Promises

According to Kant, the categorical imperative is the principle that determines the morality of an action.... A categorical imperative refers to an unconditional command.... The categorical imperative that one cannot lie, steal, or break a promise means that one cannot do any of these things if they serve personal interests.... In order evaluate the permissibility of lying, stealing, or breaking a promise as proposed by Immanuel Kant it is imperative to under Kantian Ethics....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

The Roles of Moral Habituation in Aristotle's Account of the Development of a Virtuous Person

hellip; Practicing categorial imperative ethics which is to do good all the time will not only address the social ills that the lack of ethics created.... "The Roles of Moral Habituation in Aristotle's Account of the Development of a Virtuous Person" paper characterizes Aristotle's doctrine of the mean, explains how it relates to views concerning the complexity of moral life, and gives an example of its working of the mean that was not discussed....
6 Pages (1500 words) Assignment

Categorical Imperative-Application to Journalism

The paper "categorical imperative-Application to Journalism" says that categorical imperative pertains to an unreserved and absolute requirement that must be obeyed and adhered to in all situations and circumstances and is understandable as the end in itself.... hellip; The categorical imperative is a philosophical concept that was coined by Immanuel Kant and pertains to social ethics and morality.... Based on the principles of the categorical imperative, it is important that journalists act independently by remembering that their sole loyalty is to their readers, not the politicians, the advertisers, or the government....
6 Pages (1500 words) Term Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us