StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Platonic and Knowledge-Definition Claims - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The Greek philosopher Plato writes extensively of the dialectic methods used by Socrates. The foundation upon which the Socratic philosophy rests is made up of two principles. First, the Platonic claim where for any concept (C) (like a table), there is some intrinsic feature or combination of features (F's) that all tables have, and which all non-tables lack…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.4% of users find it useful
Platonic and Knowledge-Definition Claims
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Platonic and Knowledge-Definition Claims"

Download file to see previous pages

I do not agree with the knowledge-definition claim because I think it is possible to recognize a concept (like a book) and have no clue about the elements of a Socratic definition of that concept. I am very comfortable with the Platonic claim because it relies upon observation and classification. It defines a concept in terms of its characteristics, and eliminates those things which do not exhibit the same elements. In my example of the table, it is very easy to observe the primary elements of tables.

A table will have a flat surface upon which something can be placed. It will have some sort of a support structure, whether legs or a post, which elevates the flat surface. It is therefore easy to apply the Platonic claim in seeking to define a table; if an object has a flat surface and a support system, it is a table. Armed with the knowledge of these intrinsic features, even though there are only two in my simplified example, I can confidently identify tables and distinguish them from non-tables.

If an object, say a broom, is presented to me, I can immediately define it in terms of its "table-ness" by looking to the object's characteristics and applying the Platonic claim. A broom does not have a flat surface supported by a stable structure. It may have a flat surface, e.g., the sides of the bristles or the top of the platform that holds the bristles. It certainly has a structure; the handle and bristle binding. But it is not a table because there is not a flat surface where something can be placed while being supported by the structure.

Articulated in Platonic terms, there is the concept of a table (T) that has two features; a flat surface able to accommodate the placement of other things (F1) and a support structure that elevates the surface to a useful height (F2). Therefore, T=F1+F2. For any object under analysis, that particular object cannot be a T if it lacks F1 and F2. T may have diversity within its features, like a surface that is round or rectangular, as long as the primary element of F1 is met. T can have different examples of a support structure, like three or more legs, a central post with feet, etc.

, as long as the essential characteristics of F2 are met. The object may even have other features, like drawers or decorative elements, which fall outside of the primary definition given here; but as long as the elements of an object exhibit both F1 and F2, it is a table. The broom, lacking these features is then readily identified as something other than a table. I do not agree with the knowledge-definition claim. This claim asserts that if a person knows what a thing is, they know a Socratic definition of that thing.

While I understand the method, and believe that it might have useful applicability in limited scenarios, I think it is possible to recognize an object without knowing what that object truly is. To illustrate the distinction I am making, I will use another simple object; a book. It is certainly possible to recognize a book without understanding what it is. An individual may know that an object with a cover and pages of text is a book. They do not even have to be literate to recognize the object as a book, as they

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Platonic and Knowledge-Definition Claims Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 words”, n.d.)
Platonic and Knowledge-Definition Claims Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1515100-platonic-and-knowledge-definition-claims
(Platonic and Knowledge-Definition Claims Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words)
Platonic and Knowledge-Definition Claims Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1515100-platonic-and-knowledge-definition-claims.
“Platonic and Knowledge-Definition Claims Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1515100-platonic-and-knowledge-definition-claims.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Platonic and Knowledge-Definition Claims

Discuss the ideas of love in Geoffrey Chaucer and Shakespeare

The Miller claims he is married, but is not bothered by his wife sleeping with other men since it is none of his business (Vaziri, 8).... In Shakespeare's sonnets, love does not have a single definition and ranges from platonic love to romantic love.... The Ideas of Love in Geoffrey Chaucer and Shakespeare Since time immemorial, human beings have devised ways to communicate their thoughts, feelings and emotions....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Christs Discipleship by Paul

Key Words: Revelation, Aristotelian Teleology, platonic Dualism, Stoicism, Interpretation, Argument, Christ, Religion What is an argument from the letter and intent of the law and how does Paul use this type of argument to resolve the situation in the Roman church?... Discuss how platonic Dualism, Aristotelian Teleology, and the Stoic theory of the acquisition of knowledge as virtue contribute to the argument of Hebrews.... platonic dualism owing to its perspective regarding the body and soul in acquisition of knowledge differs from Hebrews' argument....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Origens Allegorical Interpretation

Origen was not the initial one to face this anxiety, and he was proficient to find out from preceding Jewish and Christian whereabouts with Hellenism, mainly platonic philosophy, in his individual effort to confirm the Bible and its ideas in the framework of the Greek intellectual surroundings....
13 Pages (3250 words) Essay

Man vs Environment in Juan Rulfos Short Stories

This paper encompasses a discussion of hyperreality.... Hyperreality is a philosophy first made popular by Jean Baudrillard, Daniel Boorstin.... It is important not to confuse Hyperreality with the tenets of surrealism.... Hyperreality is a concept in concept in semiotics and postmodern philosophy that requires a little knowledge about the subject to truly understand....
5 Pages (1250 words) Book Report/Review

20th Century Philosophy Paper

The period saw the following philosophical revolutions in… The birth of analytical philosophy can be traced back to beak of 20th century when Frege refuted Kant's claims that mathematics is grounded neither in experience, not in logic but spatio-temporal structure.... Analytical PhilosophyThe birth of analytical philosophy can be traced back to beak of 20th century when Frege refuted Kant's claims that mathematics is grounded neither in experience, not in logic but spatio-temporal structure....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Postulation of Forms

Thus, finding the basis for our knowledge claims mainly for what our intellect and senses preserve often becomes a problem.... In the paper “Postulation of Forms,” the author shall touch on how many objects and properties Plato's postulation of forms may apply to and from this understanding attempt an argument against the many platonic forms existence....
9 Pages (2250 words) Assignment

State and defend the deductive argument that God is required for the existence of objective moral laws

A theoretical/ deductive argument on the existence of God is one that claims that God exists because this is the best explanation for life, objective moral laws and nature.... A case in point is platonic realism in which it is explained that abstract objects exist outside of time and space; these objects stay constant and have no cause.... Therefore, platonic realism illustrates that since morality laws are brute facts (have no explanation), then there is no need for a lawmaker....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Platos Theory of Forms

In the paper “Plato's Theory of Forms” the author focuses on Plato's 'innovative' practice for capturing and imparting knowledge.... He wrote a series of dialogues that were held between citizens of Athens who belonged to his environment which were used in order to express ideas of general acceptance....
12 Pages (3000 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us