StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

How Governments Could Use the Excise System to Implement Fast Food Consumption Reduce Policy - Assignment Example

Summary
"How Governments Could Use the Excise System to Implement Fast Food Consumption Reduce Policy" paper argues that obesity generates huge social costs, governments need not pay a blind eye to the problem in the hope that consumers will realize the need to remain healthy…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.9% of users find it useful

Extract of sample "How Governments Could Use the Excise System to Implement Fast Food Consumption Reduce Policy"

How Governments could use the Excise System to Implement a Policy that Reduced People’s Fast Food Consumption Name: Course: Tutor’s name: Date: Background to Obesity Statistics published by the World Health Organisation in 20111 reveal that approximately 500 million people worldwide were obese in 2008. In the medical field, a person is considered obese if their Body Mass Index (BMI) exceeds 25. The WHO report goes further and states that the risk factors for health conditions such as cardiovascular disease, diabetes, musculoskeletal disorders and some cancers, are higher in obese people when compared to people whose BMI is less than 25. Apart from the medical problems, national economies also suffer the consequences of having a significant percentage of the population considered obese. Kuchler and Ballenger2 for example estimate that the US incurred a total of $117 billion in 2000 alone; costs that were used either directly or indirectly in addressing obesity-related conditions. But where does the issue of fast foods come in? Well, according to different researchers3,4 two lifestyle factors receive all blame for the increased rate of obesity throughout the world. The first lifestyle factor is the fast food culture that has permeated all countries irrespective of their geographical position; the second factor is the fact that people do not exercise as much as they should, and therefore do not burn calories in a manner that would retain their BMI at healthy levels. Although many governments consider the consumer as a sovereign individual who is capable of making choices that upholds optimal wellbeing, the prevalence of fast food outlets coupled with the obesity statics sends a clear message that maybe some sought of policy intervention is needed in order to stem the ‘obesity epidemic’. After all, with obesity generating huge social costs and becoming a threat to social welfare, governments need not pay a blind eye to the problem in the hope that consumers will realise the need to remain healthy and hence quit their overindulgence in fast food habits. Excise Tax Excise tax on fast foods is not an entirely new concept. The World Health Organisation for example recommends that all its member states should consider using ‘fat taxes’ as a measure of increasing prices on unhealthy foods and any ingredients that may lead to high calorie consumption5. In its most basic definition, excise tax is the levy made on the ‘manufacture, sale or consumption of certain (particular) non-essential goods or services’6. Governments use excise taxes as means of: raising revenue; internalising social externalities that lead to increased social costs; and enforcing paternalistic policies. Smeets proposes two approaches that governments can use to enforce excise tax. They are: 1) through a BMI-Tax levied on people whose BMI is beyond a specific limit; and 2) through imposing excise tax on foods that contribute to obesity7. A BMI-tax would make obese people to compensate governments for resources spent in treating diseases whose onset is triggered by their obesity. By so doing, the burden of costs associated with the healthcare extended to obese people would not be paid by other members of the society. Such a tax, according to Smeets8, would reduce the opportunistic behaviour by some people, who over-indulge in unhealthy eating habits knowing that the medical costs of any lifestyle disease that would afflict them because of their eating habits would be offset by the government. While it is true such a policy would encourage people to adopt more healthy eating habits, there is no denying that implementing such a policy would present several challenges to governments. For starters, weighting and determining an entire population’s BMI is a challenging undertaking by itself. Additionally, determining the best way to enforce such a policy would no doubt introduce some treachery from some people who can work to lower their weights through extreme measures such as dieting just some days or weeks before the weighting period. Such people would then go back to their eating habits once the weighting period is over. Marti et al. 9 further observes that medical science is yet to conclusively determine whether obesity is purely a consequence of lifestyles, or a genetic disorder. Such uncertainty would most likely create a scenario where the BMI-tax would raise questions regarding its ethics and fairness. Smeets10 also notes that in some countries like the US, a BMI-tax would have regressive effects low-income households since it has been observed that obesity is more prevalent among the poor people than it is amongst the wealthy. The fat-food tax seems to be the most appropriate way of discouraging the use of fast foods. Specifically, governments can devise policies that target imposing taxes on fast foods based in their fat or sugar content; calorie count; or food type. This proposition is based on the understanding when consumed in large quantities, fatty foods, those with high sugar content, and high-calorie foods are more likely to lead to obesity when compared other regular and healthy foods. Instead of getting into the complexities of counting calories and determining the sugar or fat contents, governments can opt to classify foods into categories based on their calorie count, sugar and fat content, and then impose excise tax based on the likelihood of such foods to induce obesity. For example, based on the calories count and fat content in hamburgers and French fries, a specific government can decide to impose a 45 percent excise tax on all such products of specific weights. The 45 percent excise tax would mean that all products in the defined category register an increased price, and this could possibly discourage less people to purchase the product, or the price increase could reduce the frequency that such people consume the fast foods. Providing an Alternative In order to avoid a situation where a government imposes excise tax on fast foods without providing consumers with healthier alternative food choices, policy makers should consider using the revenues collected from such a tax to offset the cost of other healthier food choices. For example, Smeets11 proposes zero-rating low-fat foods in vending machines located in schools since such a move would encourage more students to choose the healthier option based on the price difference between the low-fat foods and high-fat foods. Policymakers could also consider reducing taxes imposed on fruits, vegetables and other inputs used in preparing healthy meals, and providing alternative revenue by imposing high excise tax on fast foods. As evident from tobacco taxation, the revenue generated from excise imposed on fast foods can also be used for civic education in order to inform the populace about healthy lifestyles12. Governments can also opt to commission fast food restaurants as agents and marketers of healthier foods by providing them with enticing incentives. Such a move is especially significant because ‘[the] unprecedented exposure to energy-dense, heavily advertised, inexpensive, and highly accessible foods’ has been blames for the fast increase of obesity in most societies13 Imposing excise tax on fast foods would directly affect the selling price of such food items thus making less affordable. As Chaloupka et al.14 notes, a 10 percent price increase in fast foods or beverages would most likely lead to an average of 9.5 percent reduced consumption of the same. A higher tax would hence bring out even more responsible eating behaviour. Studies conducted in the US for example revealed that a price increase in sugar sweetened beverages led to an increased consumption of alternative beverages such as low-fat milk, juices, tea and coffee15. Governments that are intent on reducing obesity rates in their respective countries should specifically rely on empirical research findings, which indicate children, teenagers, and people within the low-income brackets are most responsive to any increases in fast foods16. However, for excise tax to have the desired effect on the consumption of fast foods, it is rather notable that the cost of healthier food alternatives would need to be lowered. This is especially important to policy makers because some people (e.g. those within poor households) consume fast foods because they are affordable. Conclusion It is quite clear that obesity is becoming a pandemic that threatens social welfare in most developed countries. Hence, the need for government intervention through excise tax policies should be considered as a means of increasing the cost of such foods and hence reducing their consumption. For such a policy to be effective, policymakers would need to devise an acceptable rationale for taxing the fast foods by balancing the needs and wants of individual consumers against the greater good of the larger society. Additionally, policymakers would need to adopt a systematic approach that would lead to the classification of fast foods into objective categories. For example, fast foods or drinks that have empty calories can receive the highest excise tax, while those that have higher nutritional content should receive relatively lower taxes. Finally, an excise tax policy on fast food is a curative approach to addressing the obesity menace. However, if governments intend to prevent the problem from occurring, other measures such as engaging fast food restaurants to market or advance healthier food choices to their clients as noted elsewhere in this essay should be considered. Governments should also consider conducting civic education in order to inform the masses about the taxes, their rationale, and the need to adopt healthier eating habits. Bibliography Amelia Marti et al., ‘Genes, Lifestyles and Obesity’ (2004) 28 Int J Obes Metab Disord, S29. David Cutler, Edward Glaeser and Jesse Shapiro, ‘Why Have Americans Become More Obese? (2003) 17Journal of Economic Perspectives 93. Frank Chaloupka, Lisa Powell and Jamie Chriqui, ‘Sugar Sweetened Beverage Taxes and Public Health’ Robert Wood Johnson Foundation Research Brief, refer < http://www.rwjf.org/files/research/20090715beveragetaxresearchbrief.pdf>,1. Fred Kuchler and Nicole Ballenger, ‘Societal Costs of Obesity: How Can We Assess When Federal Interventions Will Pay?’ (2002) 25 Food Review 33. Karin Stenberg et al., ‘Responding to the Challenge of Resource Mobilization-Mechanisms for Raising Additional Domestic Resources for Health’ (2010) 13 World Health Report, 19. Linus Powell, Jamie Chriqui, and Frank Chaloupka, ‘Association between State-Level Soda Taxes And Adolescent Body Mass Index’ (2009) 9 Journal of Adolescent Health, 229-257. Michael Grossman, ‘The NBER’s Health Economics Program, (2004) NBER Reporter. Paul Smeets, ‘Following Tobacco and Alcoholics, It Is Time for Tax Fat’ refer < http://arno.unimaas.nl/show.cgi?fid=11425>, 29. Steven Yen et al., ‘Demand for Non-Alcoholic Beverages: The Case of Low-Income Households’ (2004) 20 Agribusiness 309-321. Thomas Wadden, Kelly Brownell, & Gary Foster, ‘Obesity: Responding to the Global Epidemic’ (2002) 70 Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 510-525. World Health Organisation, ‘Obesity and Overweight’ (2011) Fact Sheet no. 311, refer . Read More

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF How Governments Could Use the Excise System to Implement Fast Food Consumption Reduce Policy

Sin Taxation: Legal, Economic, and Moral Justifications

Part three analyzes the rationale and public policy in support of sin taxes and raises counterarguments.... here is a sound tax policy in implementing sin taxes and placing them on indulgences.... Thus, through sin taxes, the government can boost its revenue and reduce the negative impact of these vices in the community.... Indeed, "Taxation aims to reduce private consumption and private investment so that the government can provide social goods ....
35 Pages (8750 words) Essay

Food Policy Milk and Dairy Products

The paper "Food policy – Milk and Dairy Products" investigates that although milk production occurs in extremely large quantities every year, lack of proper infrastructure and technology hinders hygienic transportation and distribution of milk and dairy products to the consumers.... The purpose of this paper is to define the parameters of food policy in the global scenario with a special emphasis on milk and dairy products.... efinition of food policyFood policy can be defined as a set or sets of plans of actions to accomplish certain purposes related to food products....
13 Pages (3250 words) Coursework

Can food education reduce the obesity levels in schools

Although the UK's childhood obesity levels are not unique, they have reached unprecedented levels and remain a major concern for policy-makers and health officials.... Although the UK's childhood obesity levels are not unique, they have reached unprecedented levels and remain a major concern for policy-makers and health officials.... In 2004, obesity was identified by the UK government as a major policy concern and targets were established for reducing childhood obesity by the year 2010....
43 Pages (10750 words) Dissertation

Should Americans Be Discouraged or Even Prevented from Consuming Fast Food

n addition to the health conditions associated with fast food consumption, obesity or overweight may also result in serious psychiatric sequelae.... The paper "Should Americans Be Discouraged or Even Prevented from Consuming fast food" states that fast food in American society has become a lifestyle and discouraging a learned behavior where the citizens prefer consuming fast food products is not easy.... Since the fast-food industry continues to exhibit rampant growth domestically and internationally, there is a need for a critical review on health implications of fast food and implement policies that can discourage the population from the habit of overreliance on these convenient foods and embrace nutritious and healthy meals (Cutler, Glaeser & Shapiro 93)....
7 Pages (1750 words) Admission/Application Essay

Manage an information or knowledge management system

The major drawbacks include failure of the system to deliver the expected outcome and the inability to use by some users.... i) Planning of policy guidelines is to control or give direction to the system performance to follow the required way but the system performance is not to be monitored via the planning of the policy.... ii) The policy guidelines do not draw attention to the areas of underperformance but it is the system performance that can be said to be underperforming or not....
20 Pages (5000 words) Research Paper

Combating Obesity in the US

The upcoming trends of having fast food to maintain the status of lifestyle have increased the number of obese and would augment its impact.... This statement is viable in the present scenario as adolescents are more affected by obesity due to the consumption of unhealthy fast foods.... The US environment has been categorized as 'obesogenic' as it inspires high energy consumption and low energy spending.... Obesity can be dealt with by providing a series of educational seminars and workshops to get knowledge regarding the nutritional value of the food being consumed (Hellmic, 2013)....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

Government Policies that May Reduce Consumption and Production of Demerit Goods

Tax policy will be helpful in making the firms reduce harm to an optimum level.... This essay "Government Policies that May reduce Consumption and Production of Demerit Goods" discusses high consumption and production of demerit goods in the free market that leads to market failure through high external costs.... Awareness programs and persuasion can also be used to reduce overconsumption and overproduction.... consumption of alcohol by teenagers also makes their parents incur huge medical expenses when the teenagers get sick....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

Effectiveness of Food Taxes

Obesity condition is not only a result of unhealthy food consumption.... It evaluates food taxes' effectiveness, resulting implications, and complexity of the policy.... This paper argues that the solution to preventing diseases caused by obesity and overweight does not lie within the taxation policies, but requires a set of combined measures to assist the population in healthy consumption.... From the paper "Effectiveness of food Taxes" it is clear that With the help of the government, education systems and workplaces should implement strategies to promote physical activities like sports in schools and within the community, and affordable gym plaza closer to the busy workplace....
11 Pages (2750 words) Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us