StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Nobody downloaded yet

Breach of Duty of Care between a Doctor and Patients - Assignment Example

Summary
The paper "Breach of Duty of Care between a Doctor and Patients" discusses that not every negligent act would amount to a breach of a legal duty of care. This breach must be strictly proved and the burden lies on the patient to prove it on balance of probabilities…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.3% of users find it useful

Extract of sample "Breach of Duty of Care between a Doctor and Patients"

Download file to see previous pages

At the time of contracting, the parties had inserted in the contract a time factor clause within which the contract was to be executed and a penalty for breach imposed. As it were, the plaintiff, while fearing the effect of this clause, the plaintiff successfully engaged the defendant in an oral contract for additional funding amounting to £10,300 at a cost of £575 per each finished flat. After seven weeks of perfect completion of eight flats with substantial work in 17 flats, the defendant had only paid £1500 upon which the plaintiff ceased working. He brought this action claiming payment for £10,300. The issue was whether the oral contract was enforceable for lack of consideration.

1(a) what is the ratio decidendi of the case?

(ii)Ratio decidendi

The reasoning is that where there is a promise to pay some amount of money and that money is recoverable and enforceable; the defendant may be estopped in equity from denying the existence of that consideration and is referred to as past consideration. It was observed that in normal contractual agreements, a contract may be entered into by a written agreement, conduct or orally as observed by Chitty on Contracts. In the current case, this was a legally binding oral contract.

Furthermore, the Court stated that for a contract to exist there must be an offer, acceptance, consideration and intention to create legal relations. In this case, all Judges observed that the oral contract was valid and that there was consideration evidenced by the defendant’s promise to pay an additional £10,300 which was relied upon by the plaintiff. This made the contract legally binding and enforceable. The only thing which would have vitiated that contract is if it was procured by mistake, fraud, duress, undue influence, or illegality. None of these factors were seen as available.

Besides, Court further observed that since the plaintiff had done such substantial work on seventeen flats with eight flats complete. So, he was entitled to that payment minus the amount worth the defect in the carpentry work done. Therefore, the appellant (defendant) was precluded from denying the promise made to pay the additional amount under the equitable doctrine of promissory estoppel, which acts as a shield but not a sword.

...Download file to see next pages Read More

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Breach of Duty of Care between a Doctor and Patients

Law and medicine: Informed consent, battery and mistaken identity

Their objective is “to ensure that the community receives the highest standards of care, and to prevent doctors from abusing the trust and power granted to them by the community”.... The practice of medicine is governed by medical law, particularly civil and breach of contract laws which include Torts.... This paper investigates the legal background of medical malpractice in relation to obtaining informed consent from patients for planned surgical procedures or medical treatment and the legal aspects of medical practice, particularly in relation to consent, battery and mistaken identity....
22 Pages (5500 words) Essay

Analyzing the Case of Hookey vs Paterno

Hookey breached his duty of care by failing to adequately inform the patient of postsurgical risks.... The judges emphasized the duty of care and its legal impact.... Referring to Rogers v Whitaker (1992) HCA 58 the High Court stressed the legal duty to adequately inform patients of dire surgical consequences related to prescribed treatment.... Procedures involved in treatment must be clearly explained to patients to enable them to give informed consent on the treatment they receive....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Medical Law Problem

The author of the essay emphasizes that to prove tort of negligence the defendant must have a duty of care.... Notably, in clinical negligence, causation constitutes the link between the breach of duty and damage.... In this case, it was decided by the House of Lords that the principle of the standard of care was not violated, as long as a responsible body of similar professionals corroborated the medical practice that resulted in damage.... Additionally, the harm caused to the claimant should have been the result of a breach of this duty....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

The Law on Confidentiality between a GP and His Patient

It can be concluded that although the doctor has a duty to maintain the confidentiality between themselves and their patients there are occasions when the courts can order a breach of that confidentiality.... Doctors can also have a statutory duty in some instances to disclose the medical condition of their patients....
6 Pages (1500 words) Case Study

Medical Law on The Example of The Case of Charles

This paper outlines a duty of care, negligence of the doctor, crimes, position of the doctor and Court approach.... In the case of Anns v Merton LBC3, this principle was further refined to state that a duty of care would be owed when there is a sufficient relationship of proximity between the alleged wrongdoer and the person who suffered the damage.... In the case of Caparo v Dickman4it was held that in order for a duty of care to exist, the situation should be such that the Court considers it fair and just and reasonable for the law to impose such a duty....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Doctor-Patient Confidentiality

The case study "Doctor-Patient Confidentiality" states that doctor and patient confidentiality is one of the most elemental requisites of a trusting and effective doctor-patient relationship.... There may be instances however, when a doctor or a medical professional may be tempted to breach this agreement.... This may be seen in the case of a doctor testing a patient's blood and later uncovering that the patient has AIDS.... A patient can be forthright with his doctor when he knows that he can trust his doctor with the intimate details of his life....
12 Pages (3000 words) Case Study

Confidentiality - the UK Medical Law

egal IssuesConfidentiality is central to a trusting relationship between doctors and patients.... Shah and Richard (doctor and Patient) on disclosure of patient information.... Shar and Richard is that of a doctor's duty of confidentiality to the patient's medical information.... Failure of following those principles warrants a breach of confidence in the patients.... The case between Coco v A N Clark (Engineers) Ltd [1969] RPC 41, ChD provides evidence of conditions that define a breach of confidence....
18 Pages (4500 words) Assignment

The Use of Morphine in Health Care

The professionals are it the doctors or the nurses are required to follow strictly the rules and regulations stipulated in prescribing the drugs to the patients.... The professionals are it the doctors or the nurses are required to follow strictly the rules and regulations stipulated in prescribing the drugs to the patients.... This is to ensure the safety of the patients to avoid accidents of overdose or under-dose situations that can lead to health complications or even death....
9 Pages (2250 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us