StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Human Embryonic Stem Cell Research should be Legalised - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
This paper "Human Embryonic Stem Cell Research should be Legalised" focuses on describing the reasons why embryonic stem cell research should not only be legalized but also funded by the federal government. Thus, the writer discusses the arguments for the stem cell research…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.5% of users find it useful
Human Embryonic Stem Cell Research should be Legalised
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Human Embryonic Stem Cell Research should be Legalised"

Human Embryonic Stem Cell Research should be Legalised Introduction Though bioethical views are important in influencing global opinions, the moral arguments disapproving the legalization and funding of scientific research are unsubstantiated and deceiving. After the isolation of embryonic stem cell in 1998, stem cell research scientists presumed they had found a solution to several underlying medical problems that had been a mystery for long. Little did they know that people using misleading points of view would oppose the unearthing leading to restrictive measures and withholding of government funds for this project. Stem cells are progenitor cells found in the human body that are capable of developing into any type of cells, tissue, or organ. Stem cell research on the other hand is a research that has been going on for quite some time in which scientist obtains stem cells from the adult tissues such as bone marrow or from embryos. The stem cells are then utilized in growing new tissues or organs within the laboratory that are used for transplant purposes. Most people support harvesting of stem cell from adults. However, majority of people are opposed to embryonic stem cell research in which researchers make use of embryos to obtain the stem cells. This paper focuses on why embryonic stem cell research should not only be legalized but also funded by the federal government. Embryonic stem research is one of the greatest breakthroughs in stem cell research. This is because it enhanced advancement of the stem cell research and promises a cure to several degenerative diseases currently considered incurable. The research entails obtaining stem cell from human embryos and using them in the laboratory to produce tissues and organs. Prior to this breakthrough, research scientists were using adult stem cell, which were multipotent, meaning they could only develop into limited types of cell. Conversely, embryonic stem cells are capable of differentiating into almost all cell types and are said to be pluripotent. Embryonic stem cells are considered more superior than the adult stem cell and are thus preferred for research purposes. The issue on whether to legalize stem cell research have been ongoing for quite some time particularly over the last decade. Currently, adult stem cells are used to obtain tissue for treatment purposes. However, the inability of adult stem cells to develop into some tissues limits their use in treatment of generative and genetically inherited diseases. The pluripotent trait of embryonic stem cells enables scientists to use them to generate any type of tissue or organ. The study of embryonic stem cell is also a source of information on correction and treatment of hereditary diseases prior to birth. Opponents of embryonic stem cell research argue that harvesting of embryonic stem cell entails killing. However, other sources of stem cell such as aborted embryos are available. Since abortion is legal in United States, the aborted embryos are discarded while they could be used in productive embryonic stem cell research. In addition, most embryos used for embryonic stem cell research are cultured in the laboratory. In vitro fertilisation only requires an egg and sperm donors. In rare cases, the research may require use of blastocysts removed from a woman’s womb. However, such cases are negligible and not adequate to discontinue a promising research such as in case of embryonic stem cell. If the government funded the research, scientist would expand in vitro fertilisation technologies to obtain embryos for the research. The moral argument that the research involves killing embryos is thus not a reason enough to bar legalization of embryonic stem cell research (Forman, MacDonald 30-36). Another objection to embryonic stem cell research, which is posed by pro lifers, is the claim that using in vitro fertilization to obtain embryos for the research is morally wrong. They argue that it is immoral to create life and then destroy it. Even if embryos could be considered as morally human, which they are not, embryonic stem cell would still be a worthy cause since a single embryo can be used to save several lives since it is endowed with numerous cells (Monroe, Miller and Tobis 115-122). Another unambiguous issue is the belief that blastocysts are human thus using them for research entails killing. On the contrary, blastocysts are not morally human since they lack rationality, empathy, and sentience. That is why abortion is legal since the mother is empowered to make the decision on whether to retain the embryo until birth. In case of embryonic stem cell research, mothers should be allowed to decide whether they could donate embryos for the research purposes in the few cases that may require use of embryos from a woman’s womb. Most couple end up procuring abortion in cases when the women gets pregnant and they feel that do not need another child. It is thus crucial that the government legalises embryonic stem cell research so that such couple can help by donating the unwanted embryos (Peters, Lebacqz, and Bennett 22-25). Embryonic stem cell researchers hope that they will be in a position to get a cure for diseases such as Parkinson’s, diabetes, leukaemia, other cancer, and many other diseases caused by defective genes or cells. These diseases have been a nuisance as there was no cure for these conditions. Getting a solution to these diseases will be a milestone in the field of medicine since these diseases results in high motility and morbidity throughout the world. (Monroe, Miller and Tobis, 62-63). To emphasize on the seriousness of the illnessess that scientists are attempting to cure, I will give a brief analysis of the motality and mobidity resulting from these conditions. Diabetes is one of the conditions whose cure might be found through embryonic stem cell research. Diabetes kills about 500,000 people per year within United States. Alzheimer’s is another condition that kills the brain cell of infected persons resulting in loss of memory thus the patients are unable to live a normal life. Parkinson is an additional condition resulting in high mobidity in united States. Other life threatening conditions that reseachers in stem cell research hope to resolve include treatment of severe burns and scars, as well as spinal cord injuries. The treatment to above conditions can not be identified using adult stem cell since they are less versatile compared to embryonic stem cell (Peters, Lebacqz, and Bennett 18-22; Forman, MacDonald 22). Another opposition against stem cell reseach is the supposition that the research might not be successsful thus might lead to waste of taxpayers money. This argument is void since there is no way we can realize the benefit of any deed by doing nothing. Legalizing stem cell reseach will actually encourage several organizations and institutions to come on board and help fund the research thus reduce the burden on the taxpayers and still reap the benefits of the research. Even without government funding, the reseach has already revealed how beneficial it could be since some advancement in treatment of leukemia have already been made. Stem cell researchers have by now identified some of the causes of leukemia and how they can be taken care of. Attempts to find the cure for multiple sclerosis by studying embryonic stem cell are underway. The list of solution that could be attained through stem cell reseach are several and many more could be established if the reseach was legalized and funded adequately (Forman, MacDonald 22). The opponents of embryonic stem cell are puzzled by the number of untreatable diseases that cause numerous deaths. It is thus hypocritical to obstruct embryonic stem cell research, which promises to offer a solution to these diseases. If the opponents were in actual fact concerned with preserving life, they would be moved by the many suffering patients with diseases such as cancer and consent that embryonic stem cell legalisation is meaningful (Peters, Lebacqz, and Bennett 116-119). Another argument put forward by opposers of embryonic stem cell research is the claim that the practise is unethical since the embryo does not give its consent. This is ambigous since the same people are supportive of medical procedures such as pediatric organ transplant ,which is also done without the consent of the infant. In pediatric organ transplant, the parent consent is enough. This should be the same case in embryonic stem cell research, if the mother consents to the use of the embryo, then the researchers should be given a legal go ahead to use the embryo’s for research. It is clear that opponents of embryonic stem cell are not actually fascinated with preserving life, since they have opposed other alternatives of obtaining embryos. Such substitutes include therapeutic cloning, which is still a controversial issue. Therapeutic cloning entails use of genetic materials to make copies of individuals. Attempts to clone human being to obtain embryos have been criticized by those who call themselve human life promoters. If promoting human life entails letting our fellow brother and sister suffer and die of ailments that can be cured through research, then the word promote has fully lost its meaning (Forman, MacDonald 70.) In conclusion, while the ethical and moral issues condemning stem research could be right in some way, they are not sufficient to prevent embryonic stem cell research. It is worth considering the many answers that success in stem cell research will bring about. Some scientists might exploit the research for personal benefits but is worth to keep in mind the fact that even the visibility of the silver lining is enhanced by dark clouds. Works Cited Forman, MacDonald. Stem Cell Research. Minnesota: ABDO, 2007. Print. Monroe, Kristen, Ronald Miller and Jerome Tobis. Fundamentals of the Stem Cell Debate: The Scientific, Religious, Ethical, and Political Issues. California: University of California Press 2008. Print. Peters, Lebacqz, and Bennett Gaymon. Sacred cells?: why Christians should support stem cell Research. Maryland: Rowman & Littlefield, 2008. Print. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Human Embryonic Stem Cell Research should be Legalised Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/health-sciences-medicine/1453462-human-embryonic-stem-cell-research-should-be-legalised
(Human Embryonic Stem Cell Research Should Be Legalised Essay)
https://studentshare.org/health-sciences-medicine/1453462-human-embryonic-stem-cell-research-should-be-legalised.
“Human Embryonic Stem Cell Research Should Be Legalised Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/health-sciences-medicine/1453462-human-embryonic-stem-cell-research-should-be-legalised.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Human Embryonic Stem Cell Research should be Legalised

The History of Stem Cell Research Legislation

Moreover, in 1990, the US Congress voted against the moratorium on government funding of embryonic stem cell research but President George Bush vetoed their decision.... Moreover, in 2004, Congress sought Bush's review on his policy on embryonic stem cell research funding that he refused to revert (Popular Issues Home, 2012).... Indeed, on August 9, 2001, Bush announced his decision to allow Federal funding on existing human embryonic stem cell lines prior to August 9, 2001 and equally enhanced the ban on federal spending on deriving new embryonic stem cells from fertilized embryos....
5 Pages (1250 words) Research Paper

Embryonic Stem Cell Research and Challenges

embryonic stem cell research Name: Course: Instructor: June 16, 2012 Abstract Stem cell research is an issue that came to light in late 1998 following the isolation of the first human embryonic stem cells (Advancing Science, serving Society, 2011, Para.... This paper seeks to discuss the effects of the various factors on the research such as the influences of political interests; media being one of them, religious beliefs and financial challenges on embryonic stem cell research....
9 Pages (2250 words) Research Paper

Embryonic Stem Cells

embryonic stem cell research has become a topic of controversy because removing the stem cells leads to destruction of the embryo (Wert & Mummery, 2003).... Catholic Church Opposing embryonic stem cell research The Catholic Church is strongly opposed to the idea of embryonic stem cell research.... hellip; human embryonic stem cells (hES) can generate pancreas, liver, cardiac, neural cells in tissue culture or through other technique and can be of immense help for therapeutic purposes; however, the moot question is whether it is ethical to use hES for research purposes....
8 Pages (2000 words) Research Paper

Molecular Identity of Co-transporter KCC in Differentiated and Undifferentiated Mouse Neuronal Cell Line CAD

That has been left to the dissertation that shall elucidate in the results of the research experiments.... This paper analyzes the molecular identity of co-transporter KCC in differentiated and undifferentiated mouse neuronal cell line CAD.... The CAD cell line is specifically neuronal, a characteristic that is very suitable for KCC2 study as the cotransporter too is neuronal specific.... hellip; Specific association between the culture cell line and the cotransporter has not been made in this paper....
35 Pages (8750 words) Research Paper

Stem Cell Research

stem cell research helps in a broad way to understand basic mechanisms of human differentiation and development as well as develops new hope for advanced treatments of diseases like spinal cord injury, diabetes, myocardial infection etc.... Human stem cell research has raised many… The derivation of pluripotent stem cell from embryos and oocytes is apprehensive with disputes regarding the inception of human reproduction and human personhood.... Human stem cell research has a great effect on the advancement of medical technology against deadly diseases....
8 Pages (2000 words) Research Paper

Legal Implications Religious Stand Associated with Abortion

This research paper would discuss the history of abortion along with the legal, moral and religious implications.... What has also not been considered is the genetic disorder that can arise in human fetuses.... And also would discuss the case of three young girls who had become pregnant not by choice but ultimately had to make a decision whether to carry the child or undergo an abortion....
14 Pages (3500 words) Research Paper

Importance of Embryonic and Adult Stem Cell Researches

From the paper "Importance of Embryonic and Adult Stem Cell Researches " it is clear that while embryonic stem cell research has been restricted greatly, adult stem cell research is more easily undertaken; however, the potential is greater in the former sphere than in the latter.... hellip; Reports indicate that Sweden is most supportive of all stem cell research including therapeutic cloning.... History of stem cell research can be traced the back the to late 1800s at which time scientists were experimenting with mammalian egg fertilization processes, but achieved success only in 1959 with the successful production of rabbits through in-vitro fertilization....
36 Pages (9000 words) Research Paper

Background and Legal Issues Related to Stem Cell

However, considering the potential of the discovery in 1998, the NIH appealed to the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) about the funding for human embryonic stem cell (hESC) research.... Thomson and its potential use in treating various diseases marked the beginning of the widely debated issue about stem cell research.... However, despite the immense utility of stem cells, it is also been ciated with several moral and ethical issues which has resulted in several country specific legislations and legal regulations both in the United States and several other countries which are involved in stem cell research (Dhar & John Hsi-en Ho, 2009)....
8 Pages (2000 words) Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us