StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Livingstone, Sauer and French Regional Geography - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The reporter states that while Carl Sauer and David Livingstone each contributed to geography, they represent very different modes of thought. Livingstone traveled at the end of the nineteenth century, an age of intense exploration…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.3% of users find it useful

Extract of sample "Livingstone, Sauer and French Regional Geography"

Livingstone, Sauer and French regional geography While Carl Sauer and David Livingstone each contributed to geography, they represent very different modes of thought. Livingstone traveled at the end of the nineteenth century, an age of intense exploration. Sauer was head of the geography department at Berkeley in 1923, when geography was recognized as an established discipline (Bruman 1996). Thus, given the different expectations of their time periods, the initial purposes and methodologies of the two men differed. Livingstone, initially a missionary, explored Africa during the new imperial age of exploration opening new paths for European ideals. Coming into close contact with Africa’s slave trade, he intended to replace the slave trade with Christianity and commerce as carriers of the “civilisation” he felt Africa needed, but he was not successful as a missionary and made numerous geographical errors (Sykes 1996). His miscalculations nearly sacrificed his Zambezi expedition and he thought he had found the source of the Nile only to realize later that it was the upper Congo (Sykes 1996). Sauer is considered one of the founding fathers of American geography marking the initial separation of physical geography from human or cultural geography. His predominate concern was the relationship between people and their environment and he stressed the importance of anthropology. Coming from a scientific background, his purpose was scientific observation of other traditions and religions. In his presidential address delivered to the Association of American Geographers in 1940, Sauer explains his academic three-point underpinning to the study of geography including the studies of the history of geography, physical geography, and anthropology (Sauer 1997). The main difference between Livingstone and Sauer can be found in anthropology, which stresses the importance of avoiding ethnocentricity. Livingstone, an example of the contrary, considered the Africans “wild” and described them as “humans of a lower form” (Crawfurd 2005). Sauer was a follower of human geography feeling “human geography... is a science that has nothing to do with individuals but only with human institutions, or cultures” (Sauer 1997) and remained interested in how the environment is managed. “The design of science that Montesquieu, Herder, and Buckle forecast, failed because we know that natural law does not apply to social groups … We have come to know that environment is a term of cultural appraisal which is itself a ‘value’ in culture history” (Sauer 1997). Social Darwinism supported Livingstone’s perspective, which today would be considered racist. It is to this idea that Sauer refers when he explains natural law does not apply to social groups. Thus, Sauer was concerned about the relationship between people and their surroundings, while Livingstone was concerned with leaving a mark. Livingstone was greatly influenced by the importance that Christianity and commercialism held for European society in a time when Social Darwinism was generally accepted. Sauer was the product of the natural sciences and anthropology allowed him to become well versed in participant observation and cultural relativity (Entrikin 1984). Despite all of these differences, both men contributed greatly to geography. Sauer led the impressive field of cultural geography, connecting the areas of physical and human geography with historical geography by using the all-important historical methodology. He advocated ‘humane’ use of environment and argued that ecological geography should be given higher importance pointing to rural cultures as examples. He said cultural ecology, physical and human geography all work by adapting themselves to their environments and needs. Under his influence, this field developed as the main branch of geography. “Sauer was explicitly concerned to counter an environmental determinism which had dominated the American geography of the previous generation, within which human agency was given scant autonomy in the shaping of the visible landscape,” http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cultural_landscape He coined the phrase ‘human cultural action’ referring to the idea that culture is the main force in shaping visible features of physical environment by provoking action, responses and adaptation by humans. He also indicates cultural traits imposed by Europeans during colonization on pre-existing cultures shaped these cultures in a different way. “Culture is the agent, the natural area is the medium, the cultural landscape is the result. Under the influence of a given culture, itself changing through time, the landscape undergoes development, passing through phases, and probably reaching ultimately the end of its cycle of development. With the introduction of a different – that is an alien – culture, a rejuvenation of the cultural landscape sets in, or a new landscape is superimposed on remnants of an older one,” Sauer (1925), The Morphology of Landscape.” University of California Publications. French regional geography was a model of what Sauer propagated. The French school of geography was highly influential. It ‘…became known for its descriptive regional monographs presented in a lucid and flowing manner, human and historical geography were its forte.’ There is no denial that French regional geography reflected the historical and military developments of the country. Talking about hundred years’ war between France and Britain, Sauer says (Northern Mists) that France lost most of her ports and her north and southwest regions were ravaged. Unending political rivalry with Britain, Napoleon’s wars and the French revolution influenced French landscape, its geography and culture. Fresh rivalry in newly found lands had begun with England, Spain and Portugal. Use of tobacco spread rapidly in France and immigration, especially to America, was continuing with gusto. Due to the above historical background and climatic changes, vegetation was not considerable in France. European agriculture did not originate in Europe and did not advance much over the centuries. “Fields were plowed and planted principally in order to raise grain, which supplied the starch and a good deal of the protein in the diet of the people,” Sauer (1981, p. 31). Many plant foods came from colonies as the French were good with animal husbandry. “Dairying is the foundation of north European husbandry, not only the cattle, but largely as well as sheep and goats. Fresh and sour milk, curds, butter and cheese provided, together with grain a cheap and sufficiently balanced basic diet,” (ibid, p. 36). Woodlands and community lands were vigorously maintained, meadowlands were protected. Fields remained important grazing lands, and fallowing was in practice. There existed a good balance between climate, man, livestock and vegetation. “The difference between the deserts and their margins in the Old and the New Worlds may be explained by the different histories of occupation by man. The Old World lands were lived in much longer by more people and by people who turned flocks and herds out to graze and browse. The people of the New World had neither herd animals nor plow.” P.102, Sauer (1969). French regional geography changed according to the political and trading fields of the country. It showed the imperialistic ambitions of French society, its desires to win far away colonies and its competition with other European powers. These paradigms included new inventions and discoveries of new continents. Darwin’s determinism was also an immense contribution to cultural geography. Environmental determinism, also known as Climatic Determinism is the view that physical environment, rather than the social culture, determines culture. With a slight difference, Darwin and Sauer are speaking the same language. It also argues that these peculiarities determined the nature of the people themselves. Even though determinism was later rejected, environmental determinism found a new life under Sauer’s influence. Sauer used ‘landscape as theatre’ and his ideas and theories were largely appreciated. He said ‘culture area is a region of world shared by people with similar cultural traits. Single cultural trait like maize agriculture, forcing the communities together, can group other communities because of common cultural complex, culture area analysis has been used widely in both anthropology and cultural geography ‘because it facilitates comparisons between regions, assists in the historical reconstruction of cultural development, and lends itself to questions about the impact of the natural environment on the form of human culture’ http://www.csiss.org/classics/content/15 Sauer undoubtedly “…reinvigorated the culture area concept within the field of geography by synthesizing the ideas of the European Kulturkreise school with the anthropological approaches to culture area …Sauer argued that the diffusion of ideas from a few “cultural hearths,” or cultural centeres, had been the driving force in human history,” http://www.csiss.org/classics/content/15 It interested him to find out the meaning and distribution of arts and artefacts of man and how they materialised at particular places and moulded the physical experiments. “I like that expression, the meeting of natural and cultural history, partly because I prefer natural history with its sense of real, non-duplicated time and place to ecology, and culture history for the same reason to sociology or social science,” (p.2, Sauer, 1969). In the meantime, quest of cultural geography continues with particular emphasis on ecology and environment. “We remain a part of the organic world, and as we intervene more and more decisively to change the balance and nature of life, we have also more need to know, by retrospective study, the responsibilities and hazards of our present and our prospects as lords of creation,” Sauer (1954, p.104). Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Livingstone, Sauer and French Regional Geography Essay”, n.d.)
Livingstone, Sauer and French Regional Geography Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/geography/1535754-i-request-the-researcher-i-had-for-order-number-109158-to-do-this-order-also
(Livingstone, Sauer and French Regional Geography Essay)
Livingstone, Sauer and French Regional Geography Essay. https://studentshare.org/geography/1535754-i-request-the-researcher-i-had-for-order-number-109158-to-do-this-order-also.
“Livingstone, Sauer and French Regional Geography Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/geography/1535754-i-request-the-researcher-i-had-for-order-number-109158-to-do-this-order-also.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Livingstone, Sauer and French Regional Geography

Comparison Between Livingstone and Sauer

 This essay "Comparison Between Livingstone and Sauer" discusses professional careers of Carl sauer and David Livingstone have both contributed to contemporary geography, they are products of very different time periods characterized by very different modes of thought.... nbsp; Sauer, however, began to head the geography department at Berkeley in 1923, when geography was beginning to take form as an established discipline (Bruman 1996).... In the late nineteenth century, geography was more of a reading genre than it was part of institutionalized academia....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Opening the West to New Horizons

Then there is the other end of the spectrum, where David livingstone comes in.... Not every geographer agreed with one another, and many had differing ideologies and ways of accomplishing things.... Often, geographers would disagree totally or having completely opposing views as to what to do about certain cultures....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

The Ideas of Carl Sauer in His Specific Ideological View

Carl Sauer is generally known in geographic circles as one of the founding fathers of geography thanks to his focus on the human or cultural geography as it differed from physical geography.... In bringing forth these ideas, Sauer differed greatly from his predecessors, such as David Livingstone, who explored geography on a purely physical plain.... Modern geographers such as Harry Kitchen, on the other hand, have taken to segregating their studies into various fields such as economics and physical geography, but yet have continued to draw out the linkages between these fields....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Carl Sauer and Berkeley School of Geography

french regional geography is an example of how the various political, cultural, military, historical and economic upheavals of the country are etched on the landscape.... Carl Sauer led the field of cultural geography from the Berkeley School of geography, advocating ‘humane' use of environment as seen in rural cultures.... He said cultural, physical and human geographies adapt to their environments and made cultural landscape geography the science's main branch....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

France's geographic location, climate, neighbors, culture during French Revolution

Location and geography.... The government of France became highly centralized during the French Revolution; there are different levels for instance there are different regional levels, different national levels.... french Revolution is very historic in world's history, several corrupt practices were being followed in several churches in France, everything changed for the better and this revolution also spread to the neighboring countries.... The main focus of this paper will be on the… Several crucial changes took place economically during the french Revolution; poor people like the laborers were hit very hard....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

David Livingstone by Horne C. Sylvester

In the paper “David livingstone by Horne C.... hellip; The author states that David livingstone, the main character, begins his life as a young man who is eager to discover the glory of slavery in Africa.... David livingstone, published by C....  livingstone was born on March 19th, 1813at the village of Blantyre in Lank shire.... By the time he was 10 years old, livingstone found himself a job at the cotton-spinning factory, where he worked for almost ten years....
3 Pages (750 words) Book Report/Review

Livingstons Americans, Thou Shalt Shop

IIn the article, “Americans, Thou Shalt Shop and Spend for the Planet,” the author contradicts some economists, journalists, and politicians who criticize American shopping for being wasteful and meaningless because it is harmful to the planet and the economy and it harms the human soul....
2 Pages (500 words) Book Report/Review

French Wine Regions

The paper describes some of the most famous wine regions in France and explains why France has been considered as the most important wine producing country in the world for many centuries…  The author gives information about there are ten major regions of wine growing in France and a number of smaller areas scattered across the entire territory of the country....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us