StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

The Life and Death Arguments on Assisted Suicide - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper "The Life and Death Arguments on Assisted Suicide" explores the arguments in favor of assisted suicide that is based upon humanitarian consideration towards patients. One cannot completely prove that the arguments in favor of and against the same are completely right and valid…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.4% of users find it useful
The Life and Death Arguments on Assisted Suicide
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The Life and Death Arguments on Assisted Suicide"

Assisted suicide: pros and cons The controversy on assisted suicide is still unresolved because some people consider human life as a divine gift from the god and some others do not consider the same different from other living things. The arguments on assisted suicide are based upon life and death. The arguments in favor of assisted suicide are based upon humanitarian consideration towards patients who are suffering from deadly diseases. As assisted suicide is a controversial issue related to life, one cannot completely prove that the arguments in favor of and against the same are completely right and valid. If one gives ample importance to miracles in life, one cannot support assisted suicide. On the other side, those who give importance to the problems faced by the patients support assisted suicide. Thesis statement: Assisted suicide is a controversial issue and the arguments in favor of and against the same is valid in certain situations in life but cannot be generalized to a broader context (special references to the arguments in favor of and against assisted suicide). Ethics and assisted suicide The question of ethics is the core of the controversy on assisted suicide. Thomas stated that “Questions whether a physician should be able to help a terminally- ill patient to commit suicide by prescribing him lethal medications and if such an act is morally justifiable have long split the population” (3). As a doctor’s duty is to help the patients to be free from illness, assisted suicide cannot be considered as legal. At the same time, patient autonomy in critical conditions cannot be considered as legal, but is a practical measure. From a different angle of view, doctors should not act like dictators, but should show respect towards the individual opinion of patients. One can see that medical ethics is the core of the controversy because medical treatment aims to cure diseases, not to harm human beings. Most of the world nations are not yet ready to provide legal sanction to assisted suicide. This proves that ethical consideration is most important in medical field. But those who are in favor of assisted suicide consider the same as an important help to patients. On the other side, those who are against assisted suicide argue that the real help must be in curing diseases, not in helping to commit suicide. Most of the patients who do not like to be a burden to the society are ready to accept assisted suicide as a final solution. But ethical and legal sides of assisted suicide never consider the same as a help. For instance, palliative care can help the patients to be free from the problems related to diseases. The doctor-patient relationship is an important factor of early recovery from diseases. So, those who are in favor and against assisted suicide need to consider this fact as important. Then, the ethical problem related to assisted suicide can be solved. Arguments in favor of assisted suicide Those who are in favor of assisted suicide are of the opinion that it helps the patients to be free from unending pain. For example, if doctors confirm that a patient cannot come back to normal life; assisted suicide can help that patient to end suffering. Besides, right to live is a fundamental right. So, assisted suicide must be considered as the freedom of a patient. Battin made clear that “The arguments in favor of assisted suicide appeal to the conjunction of two fundamental moral principles: self-determination and mercy” (96). Those who are in favor of assisted suicide consider that the same helps the patients to have a death with dignity. For instance, physical illness leads to emotional trauma and this ultimately leads to pessimism. Within this context, assisted suicide can help a patient to be free from physical illness and emotional trauma. In addition, assisted suicide can reduce the scope of economic problems related to expensive treatment. If medical treatment cannot save an individual from deadly diseases, the best possible way is to help the patient to end his or her life, not providing unneeded and costly treatment. One can see that medical profession is considered as noble and doctors and nurses must use their valuable time to save the patients. When the relatives of a patient with incurable disease insist to provide care, the doctor’s time is utilized for vain. When a patient realizes that his or her illness cannot be cured, others must respect his or her individual freedom. When one considers the problems faced by the patient’s family, assisted suicide reduces emotional trauma. Laws and regulations in the medical field can reduce the scope of the abuse of assisted suicide and can protect individual freedom. Not allowing a patient to take decisions on one’s life is cruelty because medical treatment has its own limitations. If an individual decides to undergo assisted suicide, some vital organs can be used to save some other patients. So, those who are in favor of assisted suicide argue that the same is the best possible way to help a patient to be free from physical and emotional trauma. Arguments against assisted suicide The people who are against assisted suicide are of the opinion that the same is the violation of the Hippocratic Oath taken by the doctors. To be specific, doctors do not have the right to help a patient to commit suicide, but they must save that patient. Assisted suicide is totally against medical ethics. Another argument against assisted suicide is that it does not consider the value of human life. Those who are in favor of assisted suicide do not provide ample importance to human life. So, assisted suicide should be considered as a crime. Those who are in favor of assisted suicide are unable to give life to anyone. So, assisted suicide is totally immoral and illegal. From a different angle of view, assisted suicide can lead to large scale abuse of the same. Forman made clear that “Many opponents of euthanasia fear that legalizing assisted suicide might eventually lead to similar abuse in the United States” (14). Then, the doctors may not consider their professional ethics as an important factor of their career development. Furthermore, assisted suicide may be misused to fulfill selfish motives. Most of the world religions are totally against assisted suicide because human beings do not have the right to kill others. Assisted suicide cannot be considered as a help to the patients because it is a criminal act. Another argument against assisted suicide is that it gives less importance to recovery. Those who are in favor of assisted suicide do not believe in the power of human mind in restoring health. One cannot devalue the scope of human mind in healing illness. When assisted suicide is considered as the best possible way to help a patient who is suffering from a deadly disease, the doctors and others provide less value to medical treatment. One cannot prove that all the patients who are suffering from deadly diseases cannot return to their normal lives. If one is ready to wait (say, with optimistic attitude towards life) and continue medical treatment, there exists scope for early recovery. In short, those who are against assisted suicide are of the opinion that the same cannot be considered as a help, because it is an inhuman practice. Summing, assisted suicide is a controversial issue and the arguments on the same prove that both the sides are partially correct. Those who are in favor of assisted suicide argue that the same is the best possible way to reduce pain (say, physical and mental) suffered by a patient. On the other side, those who are against assisted suicide argue that human beings (say, doctors) do not have the right to provide assisted suicide because it is an inhuman practice and crime. In short, both the arguments are theoretically correct but its practical value is still controversial to an extent. Works Cited Battin, M. Pabst. Ending life: ethics and the way we die. New York: Oxford University Press, 2005. Print. Forman, Lillian. Assisted Suicide. Minnesota: ABDO, 2008. Print. Thomas, Jasmine. Physician-assisted Suicide in the United States. Norderstedt: GRIN Verlag, 2010. Print. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(The Life and Death Arguments on Assisted Suicide Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 words, n.d.)
The Life and Death Arguments on Assisted Suicide Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 words. https://studentshare.org/psychology/1761239-consider-ethics-write-an-essay-on-the-pros-and-cons-of-assisted-suicide-make-sure-your-essay-is-balanced-between-pros-and-cons-do-not-favor-one-side-over-the-other-in-the-essay-keep-neutral
(The Life and Death Arguments on Assisted Suicide Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words)
The Life and Death Arguments on Assisted Suicide Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words. https://studentshare.org/psychology/1761239-consider-ethics-write-an-essay-on-the-pros-and-cons-of-assisted-suicide-make-sure-your-essay-is-balanced-between-pros-and-cons-do-not-favor-one-side-over-the-other-in-the-essay-keep-neutral.
“The Life and Death Arguments on Assisted Suicide Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words”. https://studentshare.org/psychology/1761239-consider-ethics-write-an-essay-on-the-pros-and-cons-of-assisted-suicide-make-sure-your-essay-is-balanced-between-pros-and-cons-do-not-favor-one-side-over-the-other-in-the-essay-keep-neutral.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Life and Death Arguments on Assisted Suicide

The Suicide tourist

Moreover, the assisted suicide procedure has elicited controversial issues concerning the respect for personal rights and desires versus the threat for abuse.... At the heart of this controversy is Dignitas and its patients seeking assisted suicide services.... Evidently, Switzerland is the only country that permits foreigners to come and seek the services of assisted suicide.... The Suicide Tourist is a compelling and moving documentary that narrates the last days and eventual assisted suicide of Craig Ewert....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Did Timothy Behave Appropriately Towards Diana

But The doomed person has a right to decide about her life and body.... No doubt, there were indirect guiding hands that assisted her through every step towards the unhappy end.... The unreasonable striking of the disease, intolerable agony it causes, the hopelessness of an impending death sentence and the ultimate cruelty of an unbearably painful end – cancer had remained the worst killer of modern times, which unfailingly makes the human beings realise the mortality of life....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Ethical Issue in Health Administration: Euthanasia

tatistics on assisted suicide PracticeThe Wisconsin Right to Life (2011) details the states where assisted suicide is considered legal.... The article likewise identified the groups opposing the legalization of euthanasia and assisted suicide as coming from both medical and disability rights groups.... he Johns Hopkins University and Bruce Leff (2007) discussed ethics at end of life scenarios, particularly euthanasia where three diverse interventions were explained: active, passive and assisted....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Assisted Suicide for People with Failing Health

nbsp;A second reason for revisiting the law on assisted suicide, and working out a better way to regulate the whole area of end-of-life-care more thoroughly, is that prohibition in the face of clear demand breeds underground activity which is riskier than a regulated system would be.... This assignment “assisted suicide for People with Failing Health” will begin with the statement that thanks to the many benefits of modern science and technology, many people who suffer from serious health conditions can be offered treatment which prolongs life....
4 Pages (1000 words) Assignment

What Are the Arguments in Favor and Against of Mercy Killing

"Reasons Why People in Switzerland Seek assisted suicide: the View of Patients and Physicians.... The aim of this study was find out reason due to which a physician has no choice but to carry out an assisted suicide and the circumstances that led that person or patient to opt for euthanasia also known as elected suicide.... Other reasons include a mutual decision taken both by the patients and their physicians in whom the patients had the right to control their death, they thought they have lost the right to live, some patients think that they cannot live further or perform their daily chores and are now relying on others and that is affecting their dignity as well as living a life of no reason, they chose to end their lives (Fischer 336)....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Should the Terminally Ill Be Able to Have Physicians Help Them Die

In the light of this current reality, the problem of physician-assisted death is of current significance.... Since it allows the patients get to die in a rather lesser pain way or lowers prolong suffering as much as possible, the majority of the public in the US believe that Euthanasia should be legal and morally acceptable and in a democratic society a person should be allowed to choose his or her time of death.... We can't deny the fact that today, patients' decision to request for a cessation of various treatment, reflecting their personal preference for death as opposed to a continuation of ailments suffering or discomfort....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

You Dont Know Jack the Life and Death of Jack Kevorkian

hellip; This essay analyzes the movie “You Don't Know Jack: the life and Deaths of Jack Kevorkian”, a 2010 released HBO movie.... However, these thoughts are well illustrated in the movie “You Don't Know Jack: the life and Deaths of Jack Kevorkian”, a 2010 released HBO movie.... According to the report, assisted suicide is the terminology used for actions by which an individual helps another individual in bringing out his own death on his will (Emanuel, p793)....
7 Pages (1750 words) Research Paper

What Are the Arguments against and in favor of Mercy Killing

The paper contains a summary of articles about mercy killing such as "Legalisation of Euthanasia or Physician-assisted suicide: Survey of Doctors' Attitudes" by Seale and "Reasons Why People in Switzerland Seek assisted suicide: the View of Patients and Physicians" by Fischer, Huber, and Furter.... nbsp; … The entire study is quite relevant to my research project and provides an ample amount of information regarding the research question of why people are in favor of assisted suicide....
6 Pages (1500 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us