StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

World Trade Organization - Case Study Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper "World Trade Organization" is a perfect example of a politics case study. This paper will evaluate the reasons why the governing organization is deemed to have undermined democracy within communities, families and the environment as asserted by the Global Exchange. The World Trade Organization (WTO) was enacted to replace the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade (GATT) in 1995…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.8% of users find it useful

Extract of sample "World Trade Organization"

Running Head: WORLD TRADE ORGANIZATION World Trade Organization Insert Name Institution Course Date World Trade Organization Thesis statement: This paper will evaluate the reasons why the governing organization is deemed to have undermined democracy within communities, families and environment as asserted by the Global Exchange. Introduction The World Trade Organization (WTO) was enacted to replace the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade (GATT) in 1995. GATT was a post-second world war institution created in 1947 to enhance international governance. The international institutions were created to respond to the economic and social crises as those occurred in the 1930s thus preventing the international climate from deteriorating to the point of war (Hoekman and Mayroidis, 2007). In the 1930s, countries imposed subjective and biased trade barriers in an endeavor to hold the effects of financial depression out of their countries by keeping domestic trades active and thus preserve domestic service (Dowlah, 2004). However, protectionism led to the effects of economic depression to stretch all over the world. The global trade body is little known to many people across the globe despite the fact that it has enhanced its scope to focus on reduction of tariffs on the manufactured goods. This means that the institution no longer follows the original rules which governed its predecessor institution the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade (Hoekman and Mayroidis, 2007). Currently the organization is determined to reduce non tariff barriers whether they are deemed to be good by the host nation or not but the institution might consider them as hindrances to international trade. The inception of global trade body increased concern by critics since the institution was to be lead by unelected bureaucrats who would seize power from citizens and their governments. The critics were drawn from business men, academic people and government supporters (Dowlah, 2004). It is important to note that some of the rules of the organization reach into just every spot of daily life including water allocation, professional principles, transport rule, cultural assortment, food creation, environmental security, and the price of pharmaceuticals (Dowlah, 2004). The global trade body is a ‘member-driven’ organization. This implies that all its decisions are made by all its members; there is no executive body like that of the World Bank. Decisions at World Trade Organization are reached through consensus despite the fact that the agreement advocates for decision making by the majority vote this has never happened. The organization acts as the primary international body that deals with trade barriers and unfair competition through multilateral negotiations. The institution provides an avenue for countries both developed and developing to air their grievances regarding the trade policies of their trading partners. The underlying goal of the World global trade body is to liberalize world trade and establish secure basis which will enhance economic growth and development (Global Exchange, 2009). The global trade body, in aiming to realize its goals toward trade liberalization, the institution has round of negotiations. There have been eight rounds since its inception and the eighth rounds took place in Uruguay Round. This round was one of the most important to the United States agriculture. This is so because despite the growth in the agriculture sector, it was not part of the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade. At the eighth round, reform was eminent. All the governments felt that economic growth was on the verge of collapsing due to the increasing budget expenditures and trade frictions. Since the inception of World Trade Organization (WTO), corporate attorneys usually form part of global trade body panels and have consistently ruled against laid down rules. Rulings such as the United States law protecting sea turtles was a barrier to “free trade”, it is a clear indication that our democratically nominated public representatives are stripped of their powers to protect the environment and public health (Hoekman and Mayroidis, 2007). The world governing trade rules can be enforced through a sanction which is not the case for United Nations treaties or even the International Labor Organization conventions. This way of enforcing rules gives World Trade Organization more power than any other organization operating on the international stage since its authority eclipses national governments. The corporate agenda was getting into the nerves of people and needed to stop. In 1999, people challenged the corporate agenda at Seattle and demanded a more democratic, socially just and environmentally sustainable global economy. According to the Global exchange, the next ministerial took place in Qatar, a state in the Middle East where free-speech privileges are imaginary. In this meeting, empty pledges which geared toward an implicit acknowledgement that the current system was unfair in respect to the poor countries. Cancun, Mexico, was the next meeting point where the rich countries hunted the growth of the WTO. The new issues which were tabled received a major blow after the new coalition of the developing countries argued that the inequitable universal agricultural system had to be cleaned up first. The talks did not succeed since the coalition of the poor countries stood their ground (Dowlah, 2004, Global Exchange, 2009). However, this stand was not long lasting since the most powerful countries paved jointly a nominal compromise to get the discussions back on track by giving false guarantees that agriculture would be fairly improved. Member countries of the trade organization have the right to confront other countries’ local or federal laws as barriers to international trade under the rules of World Trade Organization (Hoekman and Mayroidis, 2007). Any government, according to the laws of global trade body, overturns any of its laws that contravene the laws of organization or risk facing trade sanctions. It clear that this kind of transfer in control to a global-level administration challenges a foundation of democracy- the manner in which citizens create laws that shield the public interests. Despite the fact that the organization gives priority to developing countries in accessing modern markets, the trade liberalization demoralizes Southern nations’ long-term progress forecasts (Hoekman and Mayroidis, 2007). Under World Trade Organization, small firms experience a lot of difficulties in competing with multinational firms since they lack equivalent access to advanced technology, economies of scale, or capital. This issue of inequality among firms is evident in the agriculture sector because World Trade Organization rules governing trade and domestic policy development weaken national approaches to ensure food protection. According Global Exchange, (2009), the service sector has also been affected by the new governing rules which strip safety for local firms. For instance, most locally owned banks are under threat since the global trade body rules force countries to allow foreign banks to open branches in small towns where communities have already associated themselves with the local banks. Martin Khor, an economist from Malaysia, argues that the rules of governing trade organization could make the access of health care low and expensive since they allow private companies to purchase hospitals. Most of the private companies are primarily from the North (Dowlah, 2004). The developing countries are not yet out of their wounds especially if the proposed Multilateral Investment Agreement is nodded. This agreement would strip the developing countries power to safeguard local industries and traditions from being cleaned up by overseas firms. The Uruguay Round did not address the censorship of employee rights which is the most rife trade subsidy of all. During the meeting, members failed to establish the procedure for learning the addition of internationally acknowledged employee rights in the World Trade Organization (Global Exchange, 2009). The failure was as a result of the opposition mainly drawn from Southern governments on the grounds that the worker-rights standards would be used as trade barriers against the exports of low-income countries. According to Dowlah, (2004), there are two concepts which root for the link between labor and environmental standards to the World Trade Organization. The first concept is the infringement of core worker rights and environmental standards which is used by firms and governments to gain inequitable benefit in trade. The second concept is the core labor rights and environmental standards to be protected in the global trade body must be the rights and standards globally recognized by International Labor Organization and international environmental treaties (Global Exchange, 2009). Under the laws of organization, no nation has a right to discriminate against any product on the grounds of the production process, even if the production procedure is by environmentally destructive technologies or is by child labor (Hoekman and Mayroidis, 2007). For instance, one of the United States law banns the imports of tuna from countries that advocate for long rounded nets intended to grasp tuna, but which also ensnared and slay many dolphins. The controversy is that, in the rules of World Trade Organization, a can of tuna should not be determined by the number of dolphins killed in the catching and production process. The organization rules have contentious aspects especially when they advocate for the use of ‘least trade-restrictive’ test. Under global trade body laws, a measure is considered “essential” only if there are no less trade-restrictive resources accessible to realize the measure’s rightful health-related goals (Dowlah, 2004, Hoekman and Mayroidis, 2007). This test limits a organization member’s capability to expand its own strategy to ecological safety. This principle was used by European Union in challenging the United States Corporate Average Fuel Economy standards, alleging that the fuel maintenance objectives of the values could have been just as easily obtained through gasoline taxes. The standards were ruled incompletely in contravention of World Trade Organization. According to Dowlah, (2004), the organization has failed terribly in tackling environmental worries; in fact, most governments have used this weakness as a platform to challenge more strict environmental policies from Northern countries. Several environmental groups have spearheaded the abolishing of committee and substituting them with more reliable environmental evaluation process. Some groups from countries in North and South and their governments have criticized the World Trade Organization policies and have the idea of creating a new institution which would better serve the needs of the greater part of people in the globe (Hoekman and Mayroidis, 2007). A good number of critics concur that there is a want for a universal trading organ that has the ability to inflict the trade regulations that are settled upon among countries (Global Exchange, 2009). The reason for this argument is that a just trade order would be governed by a body that is open and transparent, more democratic whose foundation is on new set of rules and is rooted in new set of principles. This is because the principles that govern World Trade Organization can only be possible if all nations had equal development pace. The world today is full on inequality and countries must be allowed to protect home industries and laws (Hoekman and Mayroidis, 2007).It will be advisable to have a global trading body that gives countries the power to control home industries since this will lead to maintaining and improving social and economic standards across the globe (Dowlah, 2004).Governments have the authority to evaluate domestic industries in a manner to encourage local production but this is a dream under laws and rules of World Trade Organization. Communities should be given the opportunity to protect their seeds and homeopathic medicines from the ‘intellectual property’ incursions of huge seed and pharmaceutical corporations (Global Exchange, 2009). This idea should imply that there is any global body that should be in a position to undermine any nation’s health, safety, environmental or other laws as being too stringent. Every nation should be in a position to determine how high standards should be within its territory. However, no single nation that be given the opportunity to gain uneven advantage in the global trade through the denial of emerging international worker rights (Dowlah, 2004). A new global trading body should be given the mandate to enforce this. Conclusion In conclusion, the World Trade Organization has undermined communities, local firms and families forcing them to live in a dictatorial world. Assuming ten multinational companies venture the markets of the developing countries and they will have their own manpower, the local community will be greatly affected in competing for vacancies in the said companies (Hoekman and Mayroidis, 2007). The local firms will find it difficulty to muscle the strength they have in competing with the internationally recognized corporations. People who purely depend on the products from the local firms my not easily adapt to the foreign products which are usually expensive. The governing body undermines democracy more since it allows private companies to buy hospitals and this can be a disadvantage to the society especially if the services of the hospitals are expensive (Hoekman and Mayroidis, 2007). On the environment, the World Trade Organization is the most insensitive organ that has ever been created on the earth. The body argues that, if some burns charcoal of one thousand tones, it is still charcoal whether there was deforestation or not. From the argument that people catching tuna and killing dolphins, it is clear that the World Trade Organization is reluctant to environmental conservation. References Dowlah, C. (2004). Backwaters of Global Prosperity: How Forces of Globalization and GATT/WTO Trade Regimes Contribute to the Marginalization of the World's Poorest Nations, Praeger . Global Exchange (2009), Retrieved from on March 4, 2011 Lanoszka, A. (2009). The World Trade Organization: changing dynamics in the global political economy, Lynne Rienner Publishers Mayroidis, P., Hoekman, B. (2007). The World Trade Organization: law, economics, and politics, Routledge Nunes, L. (2008). Collateral Damages, Lulu.com, pp. 100-134 Smith, J. (2008). Social Movements for Global Democracy, JHU Press, pp. 213-245 Read More
Tags
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(World Trade Organization Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 2000 words, n.d.)
World Trade Organization Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 2000 words. https://studentshare.org/politics/2038036-1-the-world-trade-organization-is-the-most-powerful-legislative-and-judicial-body-in-the-world-by
(World Trade Organization Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 2000 Words)
World Trade Organization Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 2000 Words. https://studentshare.org/politics/2038036-1-the-world-trade-organization-is-the-most-powerful-legislative-and-judicial-body-in-the-world-by.
“World Trade Organization Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 2000 Words”. https://studentshare.org/politics/2038036-1-the-world-trade-organization-is-the-most-powerful-legislative-and-judicial-body-in-the-world-by.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF World Trade Organization

World Trade Organization Benefits

The World Trade Organization as its name implies is an international organization that specializes in dealings pertaining to trade and other mutual exchange.... World Trade Organization Benefits.... The World Trade Organization as its name implies is an international organization that specializes in dealings pertaining to trade and other mutual exchange.... History can be dug to find out that many disputes over trade resulted in large scale wars, however on the contrary to that perception; World Trade Organization provides a platform for resolving all disputed issues pertaining to the trade and exchange....
7 Pages (1750 words) Assignment

World Trade Organization Information

But this expanded and grew yearly and in January 1995, in the Uruguay Round of Multilateral Trade Negotiations (1986-94) expanded on the GATT and created the World Trade Organization or WTO.... The World Trade Organization was created with a goal and ultimate objective set in mind.... The World Trade Organization is designed to create the rules involved with trade.... Efforts to form an international trade organization foundered, with many countries raising the same objections later leveled against the WTO: fear of lost sovereignty....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

The World Trade Organization

The author of the present case study "The World Trade Organization" highlights that trade is very essential to every nation.... This agreement has made it possible for the implementation of the World Trade Organization to have a significant influence to access overseas markets for a number of industries.... In a business environment, the political environment has a great influence in shaping the general nature of the external environment as well as being responsible for passing legislation that affects specific types of organization (Palmer & Hartley 2002)....
8 Pages (2000 words) Case Study

World Trade Organization Today

It is intended to provide the explanation of the origin, the role and functions of the World Trade Organization and fundamental principles of trading.... This paper provides an understanding of the WTO (World Trade Organization) system and its implications to government policies and international business.... The study "World Trade Organization Today" describes the work of the institution responsible for the multilateral trading system.... The World Trade Organization (WTO) is the one and only international organization dealing with multilaterally agreed rules on trade among its member countries....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

The World Trade Organization

The author focuses on the World Trade Organization the main purpose of which is to supervise and liberalize the trade regimes which are present within the world.... The two different viewpoints are very staggering and offer a different perspective if seen with regards to the World Trade Organization.... It is true that the World Trade Organization is indeed acting as a global organization and that globalization has happened for all the right as well as wrong reasons under the aegis of this organization....
1 Pages (250 words) Assignment

The World Trade Organization

Although the G20 endorsed the goal of concluding the talks in The World Trade Organization WTO has played a key role in enhancing international trade.... This paper will give an account to this fact and give the rationale for WTO as an efficient and effective system to mange global trade.... here were a number of complains from the developing countries concerning their obligation under the last trade round and their difficulties with WTO in regard to its bargaining structure....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

WTO (world trade organization)

One of the such organizations is the World Trade Organization (WTO).... here was a rigorous process World Trade Organization Various organizations occur in the world.... One of the such organizations is the World Trade Organization (WTO).... The significant function is to negotiate for the reduction of barriers to trade and agree on principles of operation of the international trade (World Trade Organization (WTO) 1).... First, the body helps member countries to sort out trade problems they face with each other (World Trade Organization (WTO) b 1)....
2 Pages (500 words) Research Paper

Law of World Trade Organization

In this regard, such agreement can be recognised as the Agreement on the Application of Sanitary and Phytosanitary Measures (the 'SPS The paper "Law of the World Trade Organization" is a perfect example of an annotated bibliography on law.... ossche Peter Van den and Zdouc Werner, The Law and Policy of the World Trade Organization: Text, Cases, and Materials.... World Trade Organization, 'Guide to Reading the GATS Schedules of Specific Commitments and the List of Article II (MFN) Exemptions' [2005] In accordance with the report published by World Trade Organization, the provided question, which revealed that WTO does not address health and human rights-related issues, can be supported based on the establishment of The General Agreement on Trade in Services (GATS)....
3 Pages (750 words) Annotated Bibliography
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us