StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Primary and Secondary Rules of H.L.A. Hart - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
In the paper “Primary and Secondary Rules of H.L.A. Hart” the author looks at a great philosopher of the twentieth century. He was a barrister by profession but accepted the post of teaching fellowship at New College, Oxford. He was dedicated to the field of legal and political philosophy…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94% of users find it useful
Primary and Secondary Rules of H.L.A. Hart
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Primary and Secondary Rules of H.L.A. Hart"

Thirdly, they said that the laws are orders given by rulers that are followed by people forcefully. Hart was agreed on the first two points but he was not convinced with the third. He did not believe that a legal system is in total control of sovereign to command. According to him, it was because of the pressurizing of government that people do not obey laws. In the Concept of Law, Hart has argued that compliance of law is impossible when imposed forcefully on the public. Hart took a legal system as a union of primary and secondary rules and not as a compilation of individual laws.

He has defined primary rules as the rules which imply a force on a citizen on his deeds, that is, what he can and can not do. He said that secondary rules define specifics of the primary rules. A legal system, according to Hart is defined as those changes that are required in society to cure social problems. Hart said that primary rules work as a social force that puts a bound on the deeds of an individual. Even if there are no laws in a society there are certain rules that people follow to live as a part of society.

For example, nobody would walk naked on the streets, even if there is no such law against it. Being a social theorist, Hart never suggested that such rules are followed in order to avoid punishment; instead, they are followed because they set standards for individuals to survive in society. Hart also said that for the smooth functioning of law and order in a society, primary rules alone are not sufficient. It is because of several reasons; firstly people would have confusion about the law. There would no certainty that what the rules are, how they are applied, and what coarse of action should be followed if they are broken.

Second thing is that primary rules do not change accordingly to social, economic, and political changes. To overcome these difficulties Hart suggested a set of secondary rules. He defined secondary rules as the specification of primary rules. He said that secondary laws are required to establish an authoritative structure by which primary laws are defined and enacted.

Read More
Tags
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Primary and Secondary Rules of H.L.A. Hart Essay, n.d.)
Primary and Secondary Rules of H.L.A. Hart Essay. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1505513-political-philosophy
(Primary and Secondary Rules of H.L.A. Hart Essay)
Primary and Secondary Rules of H.L.A. Hart Essay. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1505513-political-philosophy.
“Primary and Secondary Rules of H.L.A. Hart Essay”. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1505513-political-philosophy.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Primary and Secondary Rules of H.L.A. Hart

Positivism and the Tradition of Austin

Introduction Professor HLA hart upended the legal world with his treatise about the nature of law.... hellip; This paper will attempt to explain the philosophy of hart, contrasted with the philosophies of Bentham and Austin, along with the critiques of hart, then attempt to reach a conclusion as to whether hart's philosophy is as flawed as Bentham and Austin's, or if hart's philosophy is grounded on a sounder basis than the philosophies of these two men....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

A Theory from H.L.A. Harts Book, the Concept of Law

hart's Book, the Concept of Law" tells us about anglo-American legal philosophy.... hart, and subsequently evaluating its contribution to contemporary law.... hart presents a valid argument over the challenges anticipated in the dispensation of the law, however, he does not offer an acceptable path towards the establishment of the proposed solutions to the problem.... hart argument is distributed in phases, where there exists the primary phase and the secondary phase of execution....
7 Pages (1750 words) Term Paper

Rules Are an Essential Component of Every Legal System

The Social Fact thesis require particular facts such as the presence of a sovereign or of primary and secondary rules as rules of recognition that provide legal validity.... (hart, p.... Is it possible to severe rules from any legal system The theories of legal philosophy are looked into in order to determine how they view rules and what roles do they conceive that rules play in the legal system.... Some induction is applied in this regard because the theories are not always explicit with regards to rules....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

Harts version of legal positivism and Dworkins attack of Harts particular version

hart.... Due to space constraints, this paper focuses only on hart's version of legal positivism and Dworkin's attack of hart's particular version.... These two theorists are chosen because of the prominence of the hart/Dworkin debate.... Part II of the paper summarises the ideas of hart.... Also associated with positivism is the discretion thesis, which describes the fact of judicial decision as such: when there are gaps left by legal rules (i....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

Comparing Dworkins and Harts Theories of Law

Hart's theory of law encompasses an “interplay of primary and secondary rules”1 whereby secondary rules bestow an element of power and primary rules entail obligations.... Put another way, primary rules govern conduct while secondary rules permits the regulation and… Ronald Dworkin's principles of law advance an interpretive theory that essentially encompasses a concept that law is a balancing of socio-economic priorities and individual rights.... In other words, law attempts to indorse current values and However, on a balance, hart's theory of law is more important to any discussion of law....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Judges as Lawmakers: Harts Rule of Recognition

rdquo;7 Thus, while primary rules spell out the obligations of the individual, secondary rules help courts to resolve disputes over the application and interpretation of those primary rules and may, therefore, be classified as rules of recognition.... This essay "Judges as Lawmakers: hart's Rule of Recognition" analyzes hart's rule of recognition which allows flexibility of judicial interpretation within the framework of social rules.... However, precedents set by the Supreme Court have undoubtedly formed the body of future law and therefore the objections to the judicial latitude allowed within hart's Rule of recognition are justified....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

The Relationship Between Law and Ideology by Hart and Dworkin

The legal system according to the philosophy of Hart consisted of primary and secondary rules.... The primary rules played an important part in governing and regulating society while the secondary rules were used to define legislation.... It focuses on the criticism of hart towards the legal philosophy of Dworkin.... hart wrote extensively about the source of legislation which according to him was prepared by human beings.... hart termed many laws as being extensions of social rules which obligate and constrain the people from breaching them....
14 Pages (3500 words) Research Paper

Harts Primary and Secondary Rules

The research "Hart's primary and secondary rules" begins with the statement that Herbert Lionel Adolphus Hart was a prominent philosopher who had written several books on law and jurisprudence.... Hart states that a good legal system should be governed by primary and secondary rules.... A developed system will have both primary and secondary rules while a primitive one will only have primary rules.... Secondary rules should include rules of recognition, rules of change and rules of adjudication in order to be effective....
16 Pages (4000 words) Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us