StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Libertarian Use of Punishment to Show Free Will - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Name Instructor Task Date Libertarian Use of Punishment to Show Free Will In this paper, I will examine the libertarian argument from punishment used as a justification for the claim that we have free will. This paper will follow two premises: The first premise will be to argue that libertarians deem that we may hold individuals morally accountable only if they exercise free will…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.9% of users find it useful
Libertarian Use of Punishment to Show Free Will
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Libertarian Use of Punishment to Show Free Will"

Download file to see previous pages

Libertarianism is the view that we have free will. Free will is an act based on a reason that an agent takes to choose an action from a range of alternatives (O’Connor, 2011). How choices transpire made at times of differing motives might agree with the increase of quantum indeterminism in individuals’ brains. Following my first premise, libertarians deem that we may hold individuals morally accountable only if they exercise free will, a person can freely choose to take an action, making them responsible, morally.

This makes that person free and ethically responsible because they have taken a choice that is undetermined. Regardless of the undetermined choices they put forward, few libertarians will assert to offer an episteme justification that persons did take that kind of choices.  Libertarians decide the degree of harshness that is assigned to a individual whose moral responsibility has been established to the acceptable standards of the society. However, they to agree that assigning those difficult characteristic of moral responsibility to individuals who does not believe in libertarian free will is to take action wrongly.

Hence justifying my premise that punishment bestowed by free willed libertarian can only be done to a believer of the same, in order to be deemed right. The second premise argues that that majority of libertarians deem that we should hold individuals morally responsible. Holding an individual morally responsible take account of a range of behaviours; that may be either positive or negative. Examples include: verbal accusation, praise and blame and retributive penalty. Libertarians differ among themselves over deciding how much of that assortment moral responsibility comprise.

However, due to the fact that even the smallest of undesirable behaviour harms people, libertarians use the obligation of moral responsibility as a justification to turns otherwise immoral behaviour into punishable action (Double). Some libertarians however have more to their thoughts on punishment. Mark Balaguer (1999) argues that there is enough grounds for believing alternative are undetermined as we do for supposing they are determined. He argues that nobody knows exactly how the human brain works.

But his argument fails to give reason to establish that brains make undermined choices gives room to believe we do make choices based our free will. Robert Kane (1996, 1999) takes an alternative view other libertarians stating that Kanian free choosers may only have partial control over their choices. His implies that they are only, to some degree, morally responsible for their deeds. Because Kane’s theory makes indeterministic choices rely upon a indeterminate quantum actions, he concede that Kanian free individuals lack control over what they choose.

Kane’s view would not be shared by traditional libertarians precisely because his argument of having less control over actions taken fails to support the responsibility that libertarians wish to assign. Doing this would make it difficult to give emphasize on the importance to libertarians of mitigating the practices of making a person responsible morally for his deeds.  The strongest argument raised against libertarian argument to use punishment to show free will is the proportionality rule.

The proportionality rule gives us how much penalty a claimant may exact to a wrong doer, and no more;

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Libertarian Use of Punishment to Show Free Will Essay”, n.d.)
Libertarian Use of Punishment to Show Free Will Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1443192-libertarian-use-of-punishment-to-show-free-will
(Libertarian Use of Punishment to Show Free Will Essay)
Libertarian Use of Punishment to Show Free Will Essay. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1443192-libertarian-use-of-punishment-to-show-free-will.
“Libertarian Use of Punishment to Show Free Will Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1443192-libertarian-use-of-punishment-to-show-free-will.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Libertarian Use of Punishment to Show Free Will

Morality of Punishment

It is thought by Hegel that free will is such a thing that can have visible existence though it is realized only in the moment or instance that it is manifested; such as in violent actions, force, or in the decision to devoid other's rights (Hegel, p 87, 2001).... free will is something considered destroyed by violent actions and a principle that is canceled by violence.... Are victims expected to show little emotion, anger, rage, or hatred towards their violator?...
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

The Moral Justification of Capitalism

When people compete for resources and profits, they use the laws governing competition and free-market; laws that they say belong to the jungle.... The author of this coursework "The Moral Justification of Capitalism" describes key aspects of capitalism.... This paper outlines a description of the prevailing attitudes toward capitalism and the challenge to learn why those viewpoints are all completely erroneous....
33 Pages (8250 words) Coursework

The Lower Nature of Prakriti

By enduring the hardships and pains, it forms the basis for one to liberate or free himself from evils of this world.... The assignment 'The Lower Nature of Prakriti' focuses on the terms 'Purusha' and 'Prakriti' which are two distinct elements of the manifest Brahman referred to as Iswara....
6 Pages (1500 words) Assignment

Libertarian and Non-Authoritarian Schooling Systems

This paper will compare libertarian and non-authoritarian forms of schooling, Summerhill School, and White Lion free School, citing their strengths and limitations and assess their goals and feasibility and determine whether such schools provide promise for future radical education.... free Schools have their roots in the modern school movement in Europe prior to the First World War.... It is evidently clear from the discussion that one of the most popular free schools in the UK is Summerhill, formed by A....
15 Pages (3750 words) Essay

Clash of Ideologies

This essay discusses that authoritarianism is a form of government in which citizens have to strictly obey the authority of a state.... The state maintains and enforces power using intimidation, oppression, and coercion.... Many aspects of citizen lives are subject to state authority.... hellip; This essay analyzes that libertarianism is a political philosophy which calls for minimum government intervention with possible individual liberty....
19 Pages (4750 words) Essay

The Idea of Liberty in Sam Slime Case

In a libertarian society, however, liberty must be pre-eminent.... The paper "The Idea of Liberty in Sam Slime Case" discusses that philosophical choices often are of this nature, since theory frequently leads us to the reduction which is unhappy or repugnant.... One can only hope that in the real world such dilemmas will be dissolved in good measure by civility....
8 Pages (2000 words) Coursework

Law, Economics, and the Right to Pollute the Environment

nbsp; Air pollution first became a problem during the industrial revolution when the use of coal increased.... ut as Professor Coase would be the first to point out, we don't live in a world where deals are free.... What principles should we use to get the best result?...
8 Pages (2000 words) Assignment

Theory of Justice

A person also receives punishment for their wrongdoing.... The theories of justice include utilitarian theories, libertarian theories, egalitarian theories as well as communitarian theories.... Under libertarian theories, justice gives protection to a person's rights to property and liberty....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us