StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Egoism Perspective and Respect for Persons Perspective - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
According to the author of the paper 'Egoism Perspective and Respect for Persons Perspective', it is very evident that the use of cadavers is fully justifiable according to the tenets of Egoism. Egoism points out that being an egoist one does have the duty to improve those things that promote one’s own wellbeing…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.9% of users find it useful
Egoism Perspective and Respect for Persons Perspective
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Egoism Perspective and Respect for Persons Perspective"

In addition, as Pritchard points out in the case, parents were given the evidence that despite a 75 percent rise in the number of cars, there was a 50 percent decline in the fatality rate. Thus, their egoism gave way to forgetting reservations.

A further look into the principles of egoism proves that the most suitable approach is to give permission to the use of corpses for crash testing. As Hinman (116) points out, according to the moral stance of egoism, the most appropriate action is the one that produces the most well-being. In the present case too, it is evident that allowing the crash testing using children’s corpses will produce more personal and social good than sticking to the traditional moral reservation that “even the dead possess human dignity” (Pritchard, 226). Another postulation of Egoism is that one should adopt the action that least affects one's welfare. According to this point too, it is evident that the parents and the society can well understand the personal and social benefits of using corpses for crash testing. Thus, in total, as far as there is no better way in hand, egoism permits the use of human corpses for crash testing.

A look into the Respect for person outlook proves that this ideology to supports the use of cadavers for crash testing. The viewpoint is that all ethical theories and reservations are to be taken as mere understandings, procedures, and judgment criteria that rational people must affirm, and not be taken as concrete rules. It is pointed out that this is the stance that is practical and beneficial. Now, going back to the present case, it is evident that sticking to the notion that “even the dead possess human dignity” (Pritchard, 226) is not practical and beneficial in the present case, and hence permissible according to the viewpoint of Respect for Persons. However, a point of consideration here is that Respect for Persons calls for honoring others’ rights and responsibilities. In other words, one does not have the right to use others for one’s own ends (Rights Theories).

Considering this point of view, it is possible to argue that authorities do not have the right to force people to give permission to use corpses for crash testing forgetting their reservations. However, it can also be argued that people do not have the right to prevent the government from rightfully performing its responsibility of reducing road accidents. In addition, one should also remember the fact that according to the Respect for person perspective, ethics is to be acknowledged as judgment criteria, and hence, when things are done as a matter of course, ethics is not a consideration.

In total, it becomes evident that both Egoism and Respect for Persons' perspectives support the use of cadavers as far as it is evident that this is the most appropriate action for personal and social good.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Case: The Use of Cadavers for Crash Testing: Egoism perspective and Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/other/1425410-case-the-use-of-cadavers-for-crash-testing-egoism
(Case: The Use of Cadavers for Crash Testing: Egoism Perspective and Essay)
https://studentshare.org/other/1425410-case-the-use-of-cadavers-for-crash-testing-egoism.
“Case: The Use of Cadavers for Crash Testing: Egoism Perspective and Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/other/1425410-case-the-use-of-cadavers-for-crash-testing-egoism.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Egoism Perspective and Respect for Persons Perspective

The branches of philosophy

Knowledge regarding the essentials of philosophy and ethics is significant in one's life as one's personal philosophy, points of view and ethical perspectives exert great influence on one's decisions and deeds.... .... ... ... The learning experiences of the module also made me to evaluate such controversial issues as abortion, euthanasia, capital punishment, homosexuality and environmental ethics from various ethical perspectives such as deontological teleological, aretological, utilitarian, retributive, abolitionist and egoist approaches....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Morality & Cultural Ethical Relativism

The author states that from the Christian philosophical perspective, self interest aspect is viewed as self love or duty to self or saving one's soul or other aspects but this does not necessarily mean that people should refuse to share with others.... Making moral decisions about medical decisions is based of self-interest and many other contemporary medical aspects take into considerations ethical egoism practices.... Ethical egoism is desirable because nothing is inherently wrong as long as one does it in a right way to avoid lawsuits....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Corporate Contributions To Political Campaigns

It contrasts this method of resolution with the perspective of relativism.... This term paper "Corporate Contributions To Political Campaigns" addresses the ethical issues that corporate contributions lead to and how the classical theory of virtue ethics can be used to address this problem....
7 Pages (1750 words) Term Paper

Todays Daoist: An Ecological Perspective

For the purposes of this paper 'Today's Daoist: An Ecological perspective', the term Dao will be used interchangeably with Tao, which is a phonetic difference—although Dao and Tao mean the same thing.... Taoism has a record for being a religion that focuses on caring about one's environment and surroundings....
7 Pages (1750 words) Assignment

Ethical Egoism: Service

In the ethical egoism perspective, my service is morally wrong as it does not pursue my own self interests.... In my point of view, we are brought up and taught to respect our traditions and customs.... This paper outlines these benefits gained and costs incurred by performing service to others, elucidates the theory of ethical egoism, and also offers an analysis on whether my service is a morally good action. ... This paper outlines these benefits gained and costs incurred by performing service to others, elucidates the theory of ethical egoism, and also offers an analysis on whether my service is a morally good action....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Ethical Issues and Theories in Business Organisation

However, business ethics are guided by a certain set of ethical principles and theories where each theory contributes a completely new perspective towards ethical behavior in a business organization.... n this paper, I have selected abusive and unacceptable behavior in the organization as my subject with respect to which I will be discussing various ethical theories....
8 Pages (2000 words) Coursework

Development of Adult Education

The paper 'Development of Adult Education - an Ethical perspective' is a spectacular example of a literature review on education.... The paper 'Development of Adult Education - an Ethical perspective' is a spectacular example of a literature review on education.... he ethical perspective of adult educationThe ethical perspectives of adult education are varied, depending on the perspective of the arguments.... Some researches have argued that adult education consumes a lot of the countries' and families limited resources at the expense of the younger generation and that adult learners are egoists who in an attempt to gain late education, with relatively fewer years in service to the society, consume the limited resources which could have otherwise benefited more children resulting to another generation of uneducated persons....
12 Pages (3000 words) Literature review

Interpretation of the Selected Fables

Ethical egoism describes a perspective where one believes that it is moral to pursue a self interest.... Ethical egoism describes a perspective where one believes that it is moral to pursue a self interest.... hinking from the perspective of an ethical egoist, volunteer work should only be pursued if it helps the individual who is doing it and not for others.... Ethical egoism branches out with some believing that they should act in their won interest without caring about others, believing that others should act in the interest of an individual and believing that everyone should act in their own interest....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us