StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Critical Analysis of the article provided - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The article "Dr. Drug Rep" by Daniel Carlat, published on Nov 25, 2007 in the New York Times, brings to the fore the ethical issues raised by the marketing strategy, employed by pharmaceutical concerns, of employing doctors to promote their own drugs in order to lend more credibility to the marketing of their drug…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.1% of users find it useful
Critical Analysis of the article provided
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Critical Analysis of the article provided"

Download file to see previous pages

These two approaches are the most applicable to the situation prevailing in the healthcare industry, as revealed by the author. The first ethical issue that is obvious in the article is the practice by pharmaceutical firms to entice doctors, with lavish fees and expense, into promoting their own drug as against the other drugs present for the same medical condition. This is achieved through the screen of "medical education." However, this education provided by paid doctors is entirely one sided and favors one company's drug, in comparison with other drugs used for the same medical condition.

This practice may lead to the promotion and use of harmful drugs, as has happened several times in the past. The companies get the credibility of the doctors, who they pay for promotion, to promote even under-researched drugs which are known to cause harm to the users. Another ethical concern is that concerning the doctors, who agree to become drug representatives by forgetting the moral responsibility that comes with the medical profession, and suppressing their critical faculties in exchange for monetary compensation.

The author was himself one of the doctors who became a drug representative for a particular drug - at first with a clear conscience and in the belief that he is helping to educate other doctors in the benefits of the drug in question, then with a guilty conscience, in withholding some negative information that he came across about the drug he promoted. The author says that the monetary and other benefits provided by the pharmaceutical firms are so large that it clouds the critical faculties of the doctors involved and makes them commit immoral behavior.

Another concern brought forth is the unethical marketing strategy used by the pharmaceutical firms in order to make the most profits, even from under-researched or harmful drugs, before the harmful effects of the drugs become full public knowledge leading to a ban on such drugs. The profit motive leads them to commit further unethical acts by recruiting doctors to promote unscrupulous drugs by attracting them with large amounts of money and other benefits. They involve other institutions in this unethical behavior, such as the pharmacies, the American Medical Association, medical research firms and others.

There are two basic approaches applicable in this situation. These approaches are used in analyzing the above concerns as below.Utilitarian ApproachThe Utilitarian theory of ethics is also a consequential or teleological theory. It believes in the "happiness principle" of ethics. "Utility" or "Greatest Happiness Principle" is the foundation of morality according to this theory. Actions are right in proportion to the happiness they promote and wrong in proportion to the pain they produce. So, any action that "promotes the greatest good to the greatest number" is morally and ethically correct according to this theory.

There are two types of utilitarianism: Act utilitarianism and Rule utilitarianism. Act utilitarianism postulates that any action that promotes pleasure and an action that leads to the greatest pleasure or good to the greatest number of people, even if produces pain in a few, is basically morally correct. In this sense, the action of the author and other doctors, and the firms which are employing this particular marketing strategy for untested drugs are actually promoting the greatest good

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Critical Analysis of the article provided Essay”, n.d.)
Critical Analysis of the article provided Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1511526-critical-analysis-of-the-article-provided
(Critical Analysis of the Article Provided Essay)
Critical Analysis of the Article Provided Essay. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1511526-critical-analysis-of-the-article-provided.
“Critical Analysis of the Article Provided Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1511526-critical-analysis-of-the-article-provided.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Critical Analysis of the article provided

Emotions in Romantic Relationships

It, in fact, introduces the article to the reader, provides some idea about the work carried out and inferences reached.... The authors of this article have developed a catchy title which captures the main idea f the article.... The abstract written for this article is very comprehensive and provide a good idea about the article in a brief.... They have discussed various attachment strategies at almost all levels and provided the existing evidence which analyzed these strategies from all aspects....
4 Pages (1000 words) Article

Critical Analysis of Two Ways a Woman Can Get Hurt by Jean Kilbourne

 the article Two Ways a Woman Can Get Hurt written by Jean Kilbourne dwells on the negative impact of advertising and advertisements in the electronic and print media can have on society.... She talks about how advertisements use women's bodies as objects to increase sales of a product....
6 Pages (1500 words) Article

Evidenced Based Medicine and the EMR

The university breaks EBM down into six step, ASSESS the patient, ASK the right questions, ACQUIRE the evidence from appropriate areas, APPRAISE (evaluate) the evidence, APPLY (confer with the patient) and probably the most difficult of all, do a critical analysis of one's performance.... Yet the article states that HIT could be more successful if the VA had kept better clinical statistics concerning those research criteria such as smoking, cancer and patient obesity....
2 Pages (500 words) Article

Crossing a Line in the Sky

he author of the article has depicted the facts relating to the declaration of China about ADIZ in an unbiased manner.... he article has only one subheading revealing the conclusion of the article.... In this regard, it can be comprehended that the paragraphs of the article are coordinated and organized throughout.... the article 'Crossing a line in the sky' published on 30th November' 2013 in the 'The Economist Newspaper Limited' in the year 2013 intends to present different facts in relation to Air Defence Identification Zone (ADIZ) that has been declared by China....
10 Pages (2500 words) Article

Critical Analysis: Caribbean Exchange, Invest in Property and Get Citizenship by Kris Hudson

This paper shall critically analyze the article and evaluate it while focusing on any areas of weakness.... As a result, he is not entirely able to be objective in writing his view on the article.... This article by Kris Hudson tells of the new way of investing the Caribbean to gain a passport.... The main purpose of this article, as described above, is to analyze and present the average view of the issue of Caribbean nations on investing using citizenship....
1 Pages (250 words) Article

How to Bike Like a Local in Copenhagen

hroughout the length of the article, there are different pictures that are directly intact with the headings of the articles.... nbsp;… Through the article the author tries to give the ideas through about the society of Denmark, the people of Denmark and their practices in terms of commuting.... For the purpose of understanding, the article is put under the section of “Beyond the Guidebook: Where locals go” This section is prominently filled with local writers from their specified region and countries who give deep insight about their culture and the way things happen in their countries....
6 Pages (1500 words) Article

March in March: Two Sides to the Story We Didn't Run by J. Maley

the article observed by the author of the paper "March in March: Two Sides to the Story We Didn't Run by J.... hellip; Additionally, the article gives many reasons as to why Herald should not be blamed for not covering March in March protest.... On the other hand, Foucault's theory has been applied in the article in analyzing the alleged bias of Herald....
6 Pages (1500 words) Article

Role of Social Media Platforms in Healthcare Interventions in Work's Denecke

nbsp;It is also reliable Fails to provide accurate information since it focuses on matters related to privacy and confidence when accessing online healthcare Comparison Table: Figure 1As can be seen in Figure 1 above, the major strengths of the article rests with the fact that it is relevant to the topic under study since it provides pertinent information in relation how mobile-based technologies can be used to improve psychosis evaluation and treatment; it is accurate in terms of data provided; reliable and up-to-date....
5 Pages (1250 words) Article
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us