StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

The Amend a Music Industry Agreement - Case Study Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper "The Amend a Music Industry Agreement" describes that if a key A&R member at the label as left or the Managing Director, this could prejudice the priority accorded by the label to breaking the Artist. There should be a provision enabling the Artist to terminate the agreement in this situation…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.2% of users find it useful
The Amend a Music Industry Agreement
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The Amend a Music Industry Agreement"

Further to reviewing the draft recording agreement (the Agreement), I set out requested amendments on behalf of the Artist below on a clause by clause basis for ease of reference. Clause 1(a) - Please amend to include sideman clause. Record labels usually require artists to sign to the label exclusively (Harrison), which prevents the artist recording for another label without permission or terminate if unhappy with the label (Passman). Record labels invest large sums of money into making an act successful and argue that such control through an exclusivity clause is necessary to protect their investment and ensure profit or alternatively, minimisation of losses in the event that the act flops (Passman). However, the changing nature of the contemporary music business marketplace has made it in the commercial interests of an Artist to collaborate and record with other bands and artists (Passman). In some cases, this can even help break a new artist (Carrey & Verow). Accordingly, the inclusion of a sideman clause will enable the Artist to do studio work and collaborations with other bands and artists (Carrey & Verow). Without this, the Artist is narrowly restricted in being prohibited from performing for any other label or band under this contract. Clause 1(b) Please amend re-recording restriction to cover records actually released under contract with the label This clause prevents the Artist from re-recording music on another label post termination or expiry of the contract. Whilst the five year period is an industry standard (Harrison), the clause should be amended to only cover records actually released by the label as my view is that this is sufficient to protect the label’s interests. Furthermore, please refer to my other comments in relation to clause 3 with regard to the inclusion of a general long-stop provision to ensure protection regarding the maximum duration of the Term of this Agreement. Clause 2 (c) - Please amend the ninety day cure period to read ten (10) days. Record companies have a time limit within which to exercise their option to extend the term of an agreement. The time period in this case is that the option must be exercised before the expiry of the prior contract period. The notice requirement is implemented to remind the label of the option period by placing the onus on the Artist to remind them under what is labelled a “cure period” (Passman). However, a period of ninety (90) days seems too long for a cure period, particularly in light of the recording commitment of the Artist. Moreover, the ninety day period leaves the Artist in an uncertain position as to their rights under contract and prevents negotiation with other potentially interested labels (Harrison). Clause 3) Recording Commitments – Please see general amendment suggestions below. During each option period, the record label should guarantee a fixed number of master recordings equivalent to an album and include an express provision setting this out as a maximum guarantee (Harrison). Accordingly, please remove clause 3c) requiring the delivery of “such further masters as are required”. Any further masters required should be specified and the fixed amount should be stated as the maximum delivery requirement (Carey & Verow). This is necessary in order to create certainty from the Artist’s perspective as to what they are committing to under the contract and prevents the risk of being subject to an open ended recording commitment that can tie them up for many years (Passman). Moreover, in order to exercise the options as stated in clause 2, the Agreement should be amended to provide that the label shall have “released” those masters or a percentage of those masters during the specified territory during each contract option period. It is insufficient for the artist to just record and submit the masters; the label needs to release these (Harrison), which is further reflected in my suggestions regarding clause 7 below. Clause 3d) Please delete “commercially”. The commercially acceptable principle is in respect of the record label’s desired for radio hits (Passman) and if determined not to be commercially acceptable, it will have a knock on effect on how long the Artist is tied to the contract (Carey & Verow). If a record label is only willing to accept commercial recordings in place of merely technically satisfactory ones, this will potentially result in the Artist having to continuously rework or record material before the label is happy of commercial chart potential (Passman). Moreover, this could result in overrunning of the contractual option periods, in which the album under the commitment clause is due before the album commits to a release date (Harrison). The inclusion of “commercially acceptable” leaves it to the record label discretion to determine the album’s success, which impacts the release commitment obligation and delays the exercise of the next option (Carey & Verow). As such, it is therefore further advisable to include a long-stop provision in the Agreement to limit the overall duration of the contract to not more than six or seven years (Passman). Clause 4a) - Please amend to include a copyright reversion clause at a specified future date or on termination, whichever is the earlier date. Most exclusive recording contracts require an artist to assign copyright in the sound recordings to the record company (Bainbridge). Moreover, an assignment will generally be for the life of the copyright, which in the case of sound recordings is 50 years from the release date (Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988). There are two central issues of concern for the Artist with this clause as currently drafted. Firstly, this clause requires an assignment in respect of unreleased recordings, copyright ownership of which remains with the label for the entire duration of the Artist’s career (Bainbridge). Secondly, once the label has recouped all costs incurred on breaking the Artist, the label still owns the masters, which is clearly not desirable from the Artist’s perspective (Bainbridge). As such, it would clearly be preferable to include a reversion of title clause specified to occur at a future date (one option would be for after recovery of costs) or alternatively on termination of the agreement (especially if a key person involved in the Artist’s signing to the label leaves, which is discussed further below). Clause 4b) The clause currently is drafted widely in applying to “exploitation of the Masters”, which is equivocal in potentially applying to many circumstances. As such, the name and likeness clause should be amended to grant a right to use the name and likeness only in direct connection with the sales of the records and not the business of the label (Bainbridge). Clause 4c) The label should not have unrestricted rights to licence the name and likeness for any other purpose such as endorsements for example (Bainbridge). Moreover, no money should be paid to the record company for rights to use the name and likeness and the licensing requirements in clause 4c) need to be amended accordingly. Additionally, the Agreement itself refers throughout to exploitation in any “Media” which remains undefined. Moreover, the Agreement itself should specifically include an express purpose clause stating the definition of exploitation to include without limitation the following: 1) Physical sales through CD, vinyls and cassette; 2) Public performances of works; 3) Sale of digital products such as downloads and ring tones (which should be included in the definition of Media); and 4) Audio-visual devices including DVDs (Bainbridge). This is important to the Artist in relation to the label’s release commitment (Passman) and royalty payments under the Agreement. Clause 5) Royalties/Advances The definition of “Net Receipts” must be specific in referring to income received from exploitation of the following (without limitation): 1) Physical sales through CD, vinyls and cassette; 2) Public performances of works; 3) Sale of digital products such as downloads and ring tones (which should be included in the definition of Media); and 4) Audio-visual devices including DVDs (Bainbridge). This clause should further be amended to state that the advance in subsequent contract option periods is payable on the basis of percentage of previous royalties, as well as higher advances for the albums in later years (Harrison). Moreover, the recoupability of advances against royalties and “all bona fide costs” needs to be taken out as the clause as currently drafted enables the label to recoup advances against subsequent royalties and sums. As such, this means that if sums are unrecouped in one option period and the Artist is entitled to another advance as under this Agreement, any amounts unrecouped will be offset against subsequent advances (Passman), which is clearly undesirable. Furthermore, this clause is phrased in the language of cross-collateralisation, whereby the unrecouped sums in one option period can be used to recoup unrecouped advances under the recording agreement in subsequent option periods (Harrison). Clause 7(a) and (b) Clause 7 should be amended and redrafted to secure a positive release commitment from the label in the UK (Carey & Verow). Moreover, the definition of “Territory” covering the “Universe” should be amended and if worldwide, the release commitment should include a positive release commitment in the territories covered by the Agreement (Carey & Verow). This is clearly desirable in light of the recording commitment obligations of the Artist under the Agreement. Moreover, failure to comply with the release commitment should enable the Artist to terminate the Agreement and/or buy back their recordings with reversion of copyright on termination for failure to comply with the release commitment (Bainbridge). This would then enable the Artist to license their recordings to another label or self-release (Bainbridge). Moreover, the release commitment clause should incorporate a clause with a minimum marketing spend to support the release, which is not recoupable (Passman). Clause 8 b) This should be amended as considerable costs are incurred on marketing and promotion and it is undesirable for these sums to be recouped from the Artist (Harrison). Moreover, whilst significant costs may be incurred, “with a likely earnings ration of 3:1 in the label’s favour, they’re going to break even a lot quicker than any artist can recoup” (Salmon). Clause 11 Whilst prior consent is required in respect of artwork, it would preferable for the Artist to have consent in respect of synchronisation and an express clause requiring the record label to observe and not infringe the moral rights of the Artist in the recordings (Bainbridge, Copyright Designs and Patents Act 1988). Clause 13 This clause should be amended and drafted as a mutual warranty between the label and the Artist. Moreover, loss should be limited to direct loss and preferably subject to cap on the indemnity figure (Bainbridge). Clause 14 There should be an express provision in this clause to clarify and protect the Artist’s position in ensuring that the label cannot recoup advances paid to leaving members for solo releases against the remaining members’ royalties. Moreover, there should be incorporated into the Agreement an express key-man clause (Passman). If a key A&R member at the label as left or the Managing Director, this could prejudice the priority accorded by the label to breaking the Artist. Accordingly, there should be a provision enabling the Artist to terminate the agreement in this situation (Passman). Bibliography Bainbridge. Intellectual Property. Pearson Longman. 2007. Carey, P. and Verow, R. Media and Entertainment Law. 2nd Edition Jordans. 2002. Harrison, A. Music: The Business: The Essential Guide to the Law and the Deals. 3rd Edition Virgin Books. 2005. Passman, D. All You Need to Know About the Music Business. 5th Edition Free Press. 2003 Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Music and Media Law: analyse and amend a Music Industry Agreement Case Study, n.d.)
Music and Media Law: analyse and amend a Music Industry Agreement Case Study. https://studentshare.org/media/1546171-music-and-media-law-analyse-and-amend-a-music-industry-agreement
(Music and Media Law: Analyse and Amend a Music Industry Agreement Case Study)
Music and Media Law: Analyse and Amend a Music Industry Agreement Case Study. https://studentshare.org/media/1546171-music-and-media-law-analyse-and-amend-a-music-industry-agreement.
“Music and Media Law: Analyse and Amend a Music Industry Agreement Case Study”. https://studentshare.org/media/1546171-music-and-media-law-analyse-and-amend-a-music-industry-agreement.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Amend a Music Industry Agreement

Consensual Relationship Agreements

CRA is short for a Consensual Relationship agreement.... Some organizations even ban husband and wife from working in the same firm, but obviously, one cannot predict or prevent personal relationships from forming as a consequence of spending 40 hours or more together or in close proximity with each other- hence the need for the CRA or Contractual Relationship agreement....
6 Pages (1500 words) Article

The Life and Business of a Music Manager

In the selection of a manager, it is vital to consider the following factors: the manager's managerial experience in the music industry; his network of music professional contacts and business connections that will help the artist's career; performance skills in all management functions and compliance with management contract; reputation as a manager; negotiation skills; level of success in the management of previous artists; genuine interest in the artist's talent and music; and values on honesty and integrity (Simpson 2006: p....
4 Pages (1000 words) Research Paper

Artist Management Business: The Musical Production of Bruno Mars

Offers recommendations, draw up contracts, and understand how to say what they want without coming off as impatient or greedy (Allen 13-21) SWOT analysis for music industry The beginning of just about every marketing strategy is history begins with what is understood s a SWOT Analysis.... The main objective of this essay is to describe the fundamentals of managing a music business.... Mars began producing music at a young age and participated in a series of behind-the-scenes jobs before establishing his name....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

Bilateral Trade Agreements between the EU and the Philippines

hellip; “A free trade agreement is a pact between two countries or areas in which they both agree to lift most or all tariffs, quotas, special fees and taxes, and other barriers to trade between the entities”.... goods" in the absence of a broader agreement like the Doha round (MacMahon)....
13 Pages (3250 words) Essay

Country Study: Israel

srael's High Tech IndustryOver the past decade, the hi-tech industry has driven the nation's economy and has played very important roles in is economic development.... The hi-Tech industry has brought Israel to the sustainable growth path that has seen a boost in investments, a cutback in unemployment, corporate merger, capital employment and hi-tech exports.... Israel's venture capital market plays a fundamental role in the development of the high-tech industry by providing and allocating necessary funding....
8 Pages (2000 words) Research Paper

The Textile Industry in Cambodia

Such an agreement which has elements of aggressive bilateralism and social chapters was signed between the United States and Cambodia in 1999 with regard to textile trade.... This agreement known as Cambodia Bilateral Textile agreement had specific clauses that the country can avail of textile quotas if the companies agree to certain labor laws and policies.... As per the agreement “The Royal Government of Cambodia shall support the implementation of a program to improve working conditions in the textile and apparel sector, including internationally recognized core labor standards, through the application of Cambodian labor law” (Labor Standards 1999, 4)....
9 Pages (2250 words) Case Study

Business Law: Contracts

The author examines the 3-year agreement signed in between the Susan Glass and the managers and concludes that all the facts presented in the case, it appears that the offeror, breached the contract by dishonestly concealing some material facts about her then current contracts with the managers … Susan's case presents a typical example of how contracts can are entered into between two parties.... It is an agreement between one party, Susan Glass, who offers to contract services to the other party, Spock/Noglass management to manage her acting and music industries by training and offering consultancy services  First, both the offeror and the offeree have the contractual capacity to contract as noted from their age and the nature of the contract in this case....
6 Pages (1500 words) Case Study

Artist Management for the Music Business

The author of this paper "Artist Management for the Music Business" examines the promotion campaign management within the music industry on the example of Bruno Mars, including the promotion to radio, social media as an immense piece of getting Bruno Mars music break into the mainstream.... eing a musician tremendous, it is virtually felony that people are permitted to play music for a living.... But like a felony, music does not normally pay....
9 Pages (2250 words) Report
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us