StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

An Aspect of Early 20th century in Gerard Manley Hopkins, The Wreck of the Deutschland - Essay Example

Summary
"An Aspect of Early 20th century in Gerard Manley Hopkins, The Wreck of the Deutschland" paper examines the poem written to attest to the differences between the individual and religion. Hopkins uses many symbols in the poem to look at life in a philosophical way…
Download free paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.2% of users find it useful
An Aspect of Early 20th century in Gerard Manley Hopkins, The Wreck of the Deutschland
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "An Aspect of Early 20th century in Gerard Manley Hopkins, The Wreck of the Deutschland"

An Aspect of Early 20th century in Gerard Manley Hopkins, "The Wreck of the Deutschland" Gerard Manley Hopkins was a Catholic priest who wrote "The Wreck of the Deutschland" poem because it was an actual incident in history. He was so moved by it that he sat down and wrote the poem. The Deutschland was a ship that in 1875 crashed and sunk off the coast of Bremen. Five Catholic nuns were on board and died on the ship. The nuns were heroic in saving some of the people on board so Manley wrote the poem to honor them (Kelley 2008). The poem is written to attest to the differences between the individual and religion. He uses many symbols in the poem to look at life in a philosophical way. He uses many devices to show that God is mightier than the individual themselves because when all else fails God is there to save the masses (Tilley 2003). In the beginning aspects of the poem Manley talks about a specific incidence of his own that happened to him without reference to God. This sets the stage for the juxtaposition between God and man. As the "part the first" is read it is clear that Manley has reached out to God to let him know that no matter what he is given as a man, he acknowledges God as the one who gives him trials or joy. He wholeheartedly puts himself in the hands of God and stands waiting to allow God to give him anything that he wishes to hand to him. He speaks of the trials and tribulations as just more aspects of how he must go through life and accept that God has given him the strength and the courage to go through anything. He gives the indication that he will continue to let God move him forward whether he is given positive or negative situations because he knows that God will prevail. Although Keating calls this a dilemma for the reader, it seems to set the stage for the next aspects. It seemed somewhat appropriate that Manley would start the poem with his own religious experience and illumination because the wreck of the ship touched him so much. It would seem that he is setting the stage to look at the wreck through the eyes of someone who has already accepted that God is bigger than man could ever see or understand. As he moves into the story of the wreck in "Part the Second" he is beginning to tell the tale of the wreck itself. He says that God has already decided the fate of the ship ("The goal was a shoal, of a fourth the doom to be drowned") [Bartleby.com stanza 94] and he now is watching to see what will happen. Manley puts a lot of emotion into the poem because it brings out the idea that his own soul is in anguish after having read about this wreck and he sees how God has determined the fate of these people. It seems that he is attempting to figure out the "why" of this event through the eyes of religion. Keating suggests that Manley is bewildered by what happened and that this bewilderment was " It was the bafflement of mans mind confronted by a certainly paradoxical universe and a seemingly paradoxical God" (Keating 23). In the poem, like with other poems of the time, Manley is examining his own moral and spiritual experience against that larger one of the universe. He always points out that God is the larger aspect of the situation and that the individual cannot understand the vastness of the world around them without the understanding that God is in control. According to Keating, there are four paradoxes that the reader is asked to look at through Manleys lens: 1. the severity and the compassion of God; 2. the terror and the beneficence of the universe; 3. the insignificance and the worth of man; and 4. the weakness and the vitality of the Church. (Keating 23) The first paradox is shown throughout the poem in the way that he describes what happened. Stanzas 92 through 95 show that the intent of the situation was to send the 200 souls to their death which is the severity of God. At the end of the event, God shows his compassion by taking the women swiftly in their plight for death. They have done what they could as brave women and now as the last woman cries out, God shows his compassion. The second paradox is shown as the storm continues and the people on the ship are faced with the isolation and "nowness" that happens inside a terrible event like a storm. They are doing what they can to maintain but somewhere they understand that the universe is much bigger than "man" and therefore must be dealt with on its terms: Hope had grown grey hairs, hope had mourning on, Trenched with tears, carved with cares. Hope was twelve hours gone And a frightful a nightfall folded rueful a day Nor rescues, only rocket and lightship shown. (Bartleby.com Stanzas 113-118). Paradox 3, the insignificance and the worth of man is a point that Manley shows throughout the poem because he feels the enormity of the universe and the smallness of man. His images of the way the storm worked with people and worked to kill them shone through stanzas like: One stirred from the rigging to save The wild woman-kind below, With a ropes end round the man, handy and brave- He was pitched to his death at a blow (Bartleby.com Stanzas 121-125). These stanzas give a very strong image of not only what happened but the fact that even in helping someone else the universe can decide to eliminate the individual. In this respect God is saying that although the individual has done a good dead, he (man) still has to be sacrificed. The weakness and vitality of the church is apparent because although the nuns were devote and attempted to save anyone, they too are sacrificed in the end. They were brave and god fearing but in the end, God took them away as part of the total sacrifice. In this manner, the church was not strong enough to keep these people from death although the individuals were praying and asking for help. Soumyajit suggests that man is always being dealt blows by the universe and it is often difficult not to strike back at him as a human response. The author speaks about the difficulty that man has with the universe and how often they are basically at the whim of misfortune. Soumyajit suggests that Manley is actually showing how man without God and man with God react differently. As an example, the crew and the people on the ship reacted differently than the nuns. Those who had faith showed less fear than those who did not. In Soumyajits words: "He portrays both the kinship of God and man as well as the deep human alienation from a hostile Almighty" (112). It is an interesting note that during the Victorian Era many people felt that God was someone to be feared and that if you did not fear him he might become hostile. Much of the old testament of the bible says the same which is possibly why this was taken so seriously as a theme in the poem. The poem is Hopkinss most extended account of mans relationship with God. By his sinning nature man has violently disturbed the cosmic harmony in the universe (Soumyyajit 112). The poem also seems to be the way that Hopkins makes sense of what happened and eases his own conscience about the horrible death of the people on this ship. He is looking at it from the lens of how terrible man is and how he cannot help but be wretched in the eyes of God. Miller suggests: It is Christ that has driven the nuns westward from their sanctuary. He has unchancelled them. He is the master of martyrs, the ruler who commands and judges them, but he can be their leader only because he is himself the master of martyrs… (25). In a sense there is irony in this situation because the nuns needed a sanctuary outside of Germany since they were exiled from it. Although this is an interesting way for them to find sanctuary it is a common occurrence when man works with or against nature. As in the real event, Manley redeems everyone at the end of the poem including the reader. The last stanza of the poem, "Pride rose, prince, hero of us, high-priest, Our hearts charitys hearths fir, our thoughts chivalrys throngs Lord" (Bartleby.com Stanza 270-280) seems to be the total redemption of everyone and a final praise to the Lord who is the almighty savior. Works Cited Hopkins, George Manley. "The Wreck of the Deutschland". Poem. 29 April 2009 . Keating, John E. The Wreck of the Deutschland: An Essay and Commentary. Ohio: Kent State University Press. 1963. Kelley, Brian. "The Wreck of the Deutschland". 2008. Catholicism.org. 30 April 2009. Miller, Joseph Hillis. Victorian Subjects. US: Duke University Press, 1991. 30 April 2009 < http://books.google.com/books?id=VgMB9- tMSMoC&printsec=copyright&dq=the+wreck+of+deutschland&client=firefox-a. Soumyajit, Samanta. Lovescape Crucified. India: Sarup & Sons. 2005. 29 April 2009. . Tilly, Ruth. "Gods Terrible Beauty in The Wreck of the Deutschland ". 2003. The Victorian Web. 26 April 2009 Read More

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF An Aspect of Early 20th century in Gerard Manley Hopkins, The Wreck of the Deutschland

Sprung rhythm in The Windhover by Gerard Manley Hopkins

Sprung Rhythm in “The Windhover” The “Windhover” is a beautiful sonnet by gerard manley hopkins depicting the swift and smooth actions of a bird caught in the light of the dawn.... Sprung Rhythm in “The Windhover” The “Windhover” is a beautiful sonnet by gerard manley hopkins depicting the swift and smooth actions of a bird caught in the light of the dawn.... “Poem of the week: The Windhover by gerard manley hopkins.... The sprung rhythm used by hopkins is a superbly effective technique in capturing the hovering imagery of the bird and comparing it to the glory of Christ while giving the sonnet a beautiful, charged and creative energy....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Early 20th Century Writers

The author states that women's writing in the early 20th century had a lot of things in common, but there were also some differences.... This can be discovered by comparing two works by women of this time period - Virginia Woolf's "Professions for Women" and Dorothy Parker's "The Waltz....
3 Pages (750 words) Book Report/Review

Gerard Manley Hopkins's Pied Beauty

As much as the items mentioned are very different, they complement each other to bring forth a unique aspect of the topic subject.... hopkins had for the longest time identified his talents in spoken and written poetry.... But this notwithstanding, God has given humans an active chance to bask and enjoy what he has created (hopkins, p 1).... hopkins notes that skies, Rose moles and fire coals are indeed a representation of the marvelous work that God did with his creation....
5 Pages (1250 words) Research Paper

The Windhover by Gerard Manley Hopkins

As a function of developing upon the meaning behind the meaning, this brief analysis will analyze one of gerard manley hopkins most famous points, 'The Windhover'.... As with so many forms of literature, the works of gerard manley hopkins cannot fully be understood by merely a cursory review of his poetry.... Through such an analysis, it is the hope of this author the reader/researcher will be able to draw a further and more complete level of inference with regards to both the intended meaning, means of address, and historical influences/factors that not only prompted but made gerard manley hopkins able to use the symbolism in the manner that he does....
5 Pages (1250 words) Literature review

A Product of Gerard Manley Hopkins Religious Awakening

The paper "A Product of gerard manley hopkins Religious Awakening" states that gerard manley hopkins' life of non-conformity with what most people call 'traditional' was strongly shown in his rejection of traditional poetry styles through the use of variable structuring.... (hopkins 9-10).... The Windhover can be also be interpreted as hopkins' attempt to break out of the usual metering styles commonly heard during his time, and the introduction of Old English terms while compounding different words come as the result of infusing modern ideas with classical approaches in wordplay (Easson 84)....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Early 20th century Shanghai Divergence

The paper "early 20th century Shanghai Divergence" is in response to Wasserstrom's article about thinking about Shanghai.... The central theme is an attempt to classify the city from the viewpoint of history, globalization, and to examine the divergence the city of the 20th century with that of the earlier periods....
6 Pages (1500 words) Literature review

Hopkins Poem Called Carrion Comfort

From the paper "hopkins Poem Called Carrion Comfort" it is clear that the first line of the sestet is descriptive.... by beginning with the word 'Not' and then repeating it in the second line, hopkins brings the information that is struggling and the repeated word strengthens this stand.... hopkins also repeats the word can, i.... hopkins faces depression and despair, by returning to his connection with God, he immediately realizes that there exists a reason behind his depression....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Gods Grandeur by Gerard Manley Hopkins

The paper "God's Grandeur by gerard manley hopkins" describes that In the first use of simile, the thought about 'flame' in signifying 'grandeur' is aided by the imagery of a foil that shakes and shines at the same time.... In the poem 'God's Grandeur' by gerard manley hopkins, the third-person speaker conveys his exceeding reverence for God.... Based on the poet's background, one may claim that hopkins himself is portrayed in the speaker's character since the English poet of the Victorian period was also a Catholic priest of the Jesuit order....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us