StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Lois Tyson and her Book Critical Theory - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
This essay "Lois Tyson and her Book Critical Theory" deals with the overview of the book concerning the reader-response theory as the way an audience or reader reacts to literary works that unlike other theories do not focus much on the form, content, or the owner of the work. …
Download free paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.7% of users find it useful
Lois Tyson and her Book Critical Theory
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Lois Tyson and her Book Critical Theory"

Applying an Implied Reader Response Lois Tyson in her book Critical Theory defines the reader-response theory asthe way an audience or reader reacts to a literary works that unlike other theories does not focus much on the form, content, or the owner of the work. The theorem seeks to defend the notion that a text can be understood in two ways; its outward meaning, that is the meaning created by the words, constructing it, or what the words put together are meant to say. In its understanding, the reader-response theory suggests that while two people might be subjected to the same text in reading, they understand it differently. Some of the key determining factors in an audience’s understanding include the perspective that a reader applies in interpreting it such as experimental, familial, or cultural, and the second one is adhering to the text’s guiding through an “implied reader” perspective. In reading Ernest Hemingway’s Hills Like White Elephants short storyfrom an implied reader’s response,we understand and interpret the development of characters and events through the girl who acts as the guide, as the following evaluation will elaborate. The girl is the main guide constructing the reader’s interpretation. Her responses dominate their conversation with the American man where she seems to graduate from a calm and talkative person to irritated by the end of the story. Most of the story is about her as the man talks little compared to her. She, unlike the man talks about the drinks, the hills, abortion, and their relationship. The man on the other hand only seems interested in convincing the girl to abort the child as he is seen ignoring the other unrelated topics that she introduces. The standoff between them in which case the girl seemingly gets annoyed by the man’s ignorance and mean nature, inspires the title of the story. When the girl once hinted to the man that the distant hills looked like white elephants, the man shot the topic down and that is where the argument emerged from. The short story is based on a young couple’s life, which from their conversations is at crossroads, seemingly caused by what we understand is an accidental pregnancy. From their exchanges, one can tell that they are a young couple, as the pregnancy seems to have come when they were not settled or ready to raise a child. It is furthered by the man’s pleas of convincing the girl to terminate the pregnancy through abortion, promising that nothing about them will be affected by the act. There is a hint that before the pregnancy, the couple was having a smooth life of enjoying their togetherness but the pregnancy threatens to ruin it. This is evident as the man puts it, “We’ll be fine afterwards. Just like we were before… that is the only thing that bothers us. It’s the only thing that’s made us unhappy” (Hemingway 2). The girl’s utterances and perspectives are supported by the construction of the story by Hemmingway. Her argument is that aborting the child is not necessary, to which the man seems to offer no ear, and this creates the notion in the reader that the man is not concerned about what the girl has to say. The title in itself supports the girl’s views; the hills are hills and not elephants. In the same way, the story might portray that the man is not as loving or trustworthy as the girl thinks he is. At the end of the story where she insists that the man should stop talking, it is likely that she has come to realise this, and she knows the real hills are not “white elephants”. The author did not directly expose the traits of the characters, but gradually introduced them with the development of the story. The only information that one has is that an American man and a lady are together outside a building seated under a shade at a point we can tell is midway between Barcelona and Madrid, a route served by railroad. The man is polite and calm. The lady is talkative. In support of this; from the moment their conversation is introduced, the girl is the one who suggests that they have drinks and the man gives in. After their drinks are served, she introduces the elephants’ topic; the man is uninterested. Immediately after, the lady notices the curtain with prints and on learning that it’s a beer, requests to taste it, a request to which the man agrees without a hassle. Further, in the story, the girl’s moods seem to worsen and she no longer wants to talk or listen to the American man. The above evaluation creates a dilemma in the understanding of the story. Whereas the story seems to support the girl’s perspectives, we get the notion that the man is not as bad as we earlier thought. We see him bowing to her requests and even acting a gentleman when they are about to leave their resting place. In short, we cannot tell who between the two is wrong or right, or who is oppreesed and who is doing the oppressing. This dilemma supports that in reading, we encounter indeterminacy since we cannot tell one’s feelings from just reading. Their actions or facial expressions might be defined but those are insuffiecient to tell the reader of the characters’ feelings. Concisely, we cannot get everything about a particular story’s characters from just reading it. In summing up, it is sufficient to conclude that the Lois Tyson’s explanation of the reader-response approach termed as the “implied reader” is indeed effective and true. In this analysis, the understanding of the events did not rely on what the author had directly stated, but was developed from the behaviors and exchanges of the featured characters. As the reader, I did not have to think beyond any of my own specific experiences to understand it, so I did not apply the approach of using my experimental, familial, or cultural factors. The story, although short, is tactfully written such that even though the author does not directly provide information about the characters, the reader can understand them from just reading it. Works cited Ernest, Hemingway. Hills like Elephants. 1927.Web. 9 April, 2014. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Lois Tyson and her Book Critical Theory Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words”, n.d.)
Lois Tyson and her Book Critical Theory Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/literature/1638640-writer-design
(Lois Tyson and Her Book Critical Theory Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words)
Lois Tyson and Her Book Critical Theory Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words. https://studentshare.org/literature/1638640-writer-design.
“Lois Tyson and Her Book Critical Theory Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/literature/1638640-writer-design.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Lois Tyson and her Book Critical Theory

A Procedural Analysis of Gideons Trumpet

1 Professor Name Date A Procedural Analysis of Gideon's Trumpet It's ironic that a book about the landmark case of Gideon vs.... Wainright (1963) should be titled Gideon's Trumpet, since it is this case that would re-sound the klaxon of human rights throughout the land.... hellip; Prior to the case of Gideon vs....
5 Pages (1250 words) Book Report/Review

Their Dogs Came with Them

‘Their Dogs Came with Them': book Review In the work, the author Helena Maria Viramontes tries to present the problems faced by the Chicano community due to the construction of freeways in East Los Angeles.... It begins with a child watching an old woman packing up her belongings as her home is about to be taken over by bulldozers.... The first one is that Zumaya child is injured by urbanization that caused the disappearance of her community and identity....
4 Pages (1000 words) Book Report/Review

Critical Thinking

As an editor, using personal affairs to make conclusive remarks leads to poor critical thinking.... The editor therefore did not use facts to justify the actions of Deed to keep her conditions to herself but attacked… The major argument was if Deed's condition was as a result of unhealthy eating.... Instead the author concludes that diabetes have The editor attacks Deed using her conditions.... The editor therefore did not use facts to justify the actions of Deed to keep her conditions to herself but attacked her directly by claiming that she attempted to remain silent about her condition despite being a public figure therefore describing here as hypocrite....
1 Pages (250 words) Book Report/Review

Journal 6

This book talks about the importance of preparing the mind before indulging in any sports activity.... I found find this book interesting because it… I must prepare my mind before joining any race.... Hurry slowly: this chapter talks about being fast in everything Mind gym Mind gym is a book written by Gary Mack with David Casstevens.... This book talks about the importance of preparing the mind before indulging in any sports activity....
1 Pages (250 words) Book Report/Review

Reaching Students and Their Needs for Learning in a Manner by a Short History of Nearly Everything

nbsp;… In the book, A Short History of Nearly Everything by Bill Bryson, there is the ability to reach readers with scientific facts related to the cosmos.... The presentation that is used in this book and the way in which the information is communicated creates a distinction with science and the basic concepts of astrology and the cosmos....
7 Pages (1750 words) Book Report/Review
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us