StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Land Law - Assignment Example

Summary
The paper "Land Law Assignment" presents that the scenario concerns issues regarding equitable and legal interests in registered land arising as a result of joint tenancies. The will left by Michael in 2005 expressly conveys the land to his four children ‘jointly’…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.8% of users find it useful
Land Law Assignment
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Land Law"

Land Law assignment The scenario concerns issues regarding equitable and legal interests in registered land arising as a result of joint tenancies. The will left by Michael in 2005 expressly conveys the land to his four children ‘jointly’, which renders it a joint tenancy where each of the tenants have equal share in the property. Thus, it is a legal joint tenancy, title to which is registered. Additionally, the scenario also raises issues concerning the law of severance. (i) Devolution of the legal estate The property was conveyed by will which stated that David, Aaron, Bartholomew and Christopher all must acquire title to it “jointly”. This creates a legal interest in the form of a joint tenancy by which all four recipients are entitled to equal and undivided shares of the property. The legal interest is necessarily that of joint tenancy here as a tenancy in common cannot subsist at law (s. 1(6) of the Law of Property Act 1925). The legal joint tenancy must, in the absence of any other intention in the trust instrument, should be followed by an equitable joint tenancy in the same, provided it fulfills the four unities required to form an equitable joint tenancy (Hammersmith and Fulham L.B.C v Monk (1992)), which is the case here. Hence, all three children that are of full capacity (Aaron, Bartholomeo and Christopher) hold the legal title in Oakhurst on a statutory trust governed by s. 35 of the Law of Property Act 1925, as well as the equitable title in the form of a joint tenancy subject to the provisions of the Trusts of Land and Appointment of Trustees Act 1996, meaning they hold the property as legal owners on a trust of land for themselves and David as equitable owners. David’s interest is necessarily equitable since he is a minor and until he becomes of age, he has an equitable share in the property according the provisions of TOLATA 1996, sched.1, para.1. Thus Bartholomeo, Christopher, and Aaron are the legal owners of Oakhurst holding it for the benefit of themselves and David as equitable owners. (ii) Size of David’s share Under a joint tenancy, David is entitled to an equal and undivided share in the property which should be accorded to him in the proceeds of sale. Moreover, as a joint tenant, David is also entitled to the Right of Survivorship which distributes the share of the deceased property equally amongst the surviving tenants. This, however, is only applicable if the joint tenancy has not been severed. The equitable interests in Oakhurst are capable of being severed from the joint tenancies so that a tenancy in common is created amongst the remaining joint tenants and the now-severed tenants in common. This allows the tenant to deal with his share of the property individually and also make sure that his share of the property passes to his heirs instead of the survivors of the tenancy. Thus, to analyze David’s share of the proceeds of sale, it is necessary to determine whether the joint tenancy was severed by the written note of Christopher, Bartholomew’s will, and Aaron’s mortgage. By virtue of s. 36(2), a person may be able to severe his share of the tenancy by giving notice in writing. We are told that Christopher writes to say that he no longer has any use for Oakhurst but expects a 25% share of the proceeds of sale were the property to be sold. Kinch v Bullard (1999) and Burgess v Rawnsley (1975) suggest this is sufficient to sever the joint tenancy, however, the facts of the case are closer to those seen in White v White (2000) where a contrary intention was shows to continue the joint tenancy whereas the written notice purported to sever it. The courts held that there was no severance in that case, and it is likely that they would follow the same route in Christopher’s case, given that his intentions to retain the joint tenancy are evident by his mention of retaining 1/4th of the proceeds of sale. Thus, on balance, the joint tenancy is still intact as far as Christopher’s concerned. In the case of Bartholomew, his share is subject to his wishes as mentioned in his will. An year has passed since his death and it is reasonable to believe that the notice of his intentions through the will was provided to the other joint tenants before Aaron later expressed his wish to sell the property in writing to Christopher and David. What falls to determine is whether he severed his joint tenancy interest to a tenancy in common so that the survivors of the tenancy are not entitled to his share, which would have been the case under a joint tenancy. On the facts, it does not seem so, and since the right of survivorship is superior to a will, his interest will be equally distributed amongst the remaining tenants David, Christopher and Aaron (Gould v Kemp (1834)). Aaron’s action of mortgaging his interest is more likely an “act operating on his own share”, which is enough to severe his equitable interest (Williams v Hensman (1861)). Bear in mind that Aaron is a trustee at law along with Christopher and thus cannot transfer the legal title alone without Christopher’s consent (First National Securities v Heggarty (1984)). He can only mortgage his equitable interest according to s.63 of the LPA 1925, which he does, thereby severing his equitable joint tenancy and becoming a tenant in common of 1/3rd of the property (since Bartholomew is now dead). Thus, if the property is to be now sold, David ought to be entitled to 1/3rd of the proceeds. (iii) If David disagrees as to the sale, how would the court order the sale? If David was to disagree, the other trustees with legal titles (Aaron and Christopher) can summon the court to intervene and order a sale under s.14 of TOLATA 1996. Under the old law, the Court favored a sale in case of a dispute as the trusts carried with them a duty to sale under s. 30 of the LPA 1925. However, with the advent of TOLATA 1996, the position has changed and the trusts are now of land instead of trusts for sale. As a result, the courts are reluctant to order a sale as decidedly as before. Much turns on the facts of the case and considerations are given to factors such as the purpose of creation of the trust, if the co-owners have any children, etc. Assuming David has not come of age, he is still a minor with an equitable interest in current occupation of the property, and the court may deny the sale on this basis (Edwards v Lloyds TSB (2004)). The trust instrument itself may be utilized, and since in this case it stipulated that the property be used as a “family home”, the courts would be further reluctant to order a sale (Barclay v Barclay (1970)). Since David has not reached full capacity yet, on balance, the court may order a postponement of sale till he becomes of age and is able to make a more conscious decision. Read More

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Land Law Assignment

Property Acquisition Land Law

and law assignment Tracey is a florist and has recently purchased some land which will enable her to build and open up her own shop.... The writer of the assignment "Property Acquisition land law" attempts to resolve a particular legal case concerning land law.... Dixon on land law.... Textbook on land law.... land law.... land law.... land law.... land law....
11 Pages (2750 words) Assignment

Land Law and How a Mortgage Is Created

From the paper "land law and How a Mortgage Is Created" it is clear that if the mortgagor defaults on repayment, the mortgagee can take possession of the property.... land law-Assignment 2 Introduction A mortgage is a registered security on possession that permits the mortgagee or lender to take and put up for sale the property if the mortgagor fails to repay the money.... Modern land law.... Mortgage in English law is resulted from two different influences....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

LAND LAW SUMMATIVE ASSIGNMENT DECEMBER 2012

land law SUMMATIVE ASSIGNMENT DECEMBER 2012 Name: Course: Date: (i) Adams did not meet Susan when purchasing the Columbus Farm from Edward Mullet.... Section 1(2) of the LPA 1925 has a provision, which states that, the only charges or interest in or over land that is capable of subsisting or of being created or conveyed at law is an easement, right, privilege in or over land for an interest that is equivalent to an estate or farm in fee simple absolute in possessions or a term of absolute years....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Issues Concerning Land Law

Land Law Assignment Section B: (a) A legal easement is one that has been acquired through being the freehold or registered owner of a piece of land.... The paper "Issues Concerning land law " discusses that generally speaking, since Martin wishes to sell the property, he may not be willing to take his share of the mortgage payments, therefore this presents the other owners of the house with a problem.... Sexton, Roger , 2004 land law Textbook....
9 Pages (2250 words) Assignment

Global Environmental Law

he assignment is based on the application of materials covered in the unit.... You will also need to do some extended personal research and self-directed learning in order to complete the assignment.... The assignment may be completed either INDIVIDUALLY or in a group of TWO.... If completed as an individual assignment, the length is 3,000 words.... If completed as a group assignment, the length is 4,500 words....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Characteristics of a Legal Lease

Land Law Assignment ... ccording to land law, Leslie Browne erred by repairing the old fence he found lying around without consulting the adjoining owner.... Although its is common for a lease agreement to last for several years, it is now evident in current application of law that the agreement may be for a shorter period such as a week, month or even a single day (Patton, 2005).... ccording to English law, a lease granted to any party has to be registered if the lease period exceeds seven years....
9 Pages (2250 words) Coursework

Land Law: Frank and Kramerica Case

Land Law Assignment 1 – FRANK AND KRAMERICA ... AND law assignment 2 – FRANK AND AUSTRALIA INTERACTIVE ... "land law: Frank and Kramerica Case" paper raises the question of whether or not a real property owner can stop the current lessee from assigning the lease to another and, if so, under what circumstances or conditions.... he main issue in the present controversy tackles about the assignment of a lease.... Absent that, there can be no valid sub-lease of the apartment or assignment of the contract....
6 Pages (1500 words) Case Study

The Application of Maxims of Equity as Guidelines for Equity Jurisdiction in the Irish Property and Laws

land law AssignmentIntroductionMaxims of Equity refers to the general legal principles that govern the manner in which equity operates.... In contrast to the common law, maxims of equity tend to illustrate the characteristics of equity as more flexible and a responsible approach to individual's needs and inclined to take into account the worthiness and conduct of the parties involved.... he history of the use of maxims of equity in property laws dates back to several centuries ago when they were first developed by the English Court of Chancery and other courts of the time to help in the administration of equity jurisdiction such as the law of trusts....
11 Pages (2750 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us