StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

The Elements of Different Motivation Theories - Term Paper Example

Cite this document
Summary
The author examines motivation, one of the main individual phenomenon which influences productivity and performance, relations and communication between employees. In order to improve performance, the HR consultant should take into account motivational theories and human needs, and desires…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.1% of users find it useful
The Elements of Different Motivation Theories
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The Elements of Different Motivation Theories"

WORKFORCE MOTIVATION Motivation is one of the main individual phenomenon which influences productivity and performance, relations and communication between employees. In order to improve performance and productivity, the HR consultant should take into account motivational theories and human needs, desires and personal values of employees. This is because of individual differences and perceptions, which are highly personalized. Different employees will perceive the nature of a given prescription in different ways. Likewise, a given prescription may affect a given employee in different ways at different points in time because conditions, needs, moods, and personal goals, for example, change over time Maslows Theory of Motivation and Its Application Maslows theory of motivation claims that human motives develop in sequence according to five levels of needs. These needs are: psychological (hunger, thirst), safety (protection), social (be accepted, belong to a certain group), esteem (self-confidence, achievements, respect, status, recognition), and self-actualization (realizing one’s potential for continued self-development) (Maslow, 1970). For employees to be productive in an organization, they need to hold positive attitudes toward the elements of organizational life. For example, one should view such factors as work, authority, taking risks in decision making, the need for control, and the need for change in a positive way. A negative attitudinal posture toward these factors will keep ones job satisfaction continually low as well as stimulate considerable resistance to many normal organizational processes and activities. Someone with the wrong attitudes shies away from high effort because the performance it yields is not perceived as worthy. It is not "real" performance from the viewpoint of the employee (Armstrong, 2003). Expectancy Theory and its Application For employees to exert high effort, they must see that it makes a difference in their performance. Employees must sense that effort will pay off in terms of performance--that it is highly correlated with performance and that higher effort will yield better performance. The stronger the perceived correlation, the stronger the motivation. Employee-job performance is a function of ability, job design, and motivation. If the employee has adequate ability and the job is designed well, then performance is solely dependent on the level of motivation. Assuming ability and job design are in order, high motivation becomes a necessary and sufficient condition for high performance. If employees know their ability is high and the design of their job is "top notch," then high performance is perceived as indeed possible and perceived to depend on their efforts. On the other hand, low ability and faulty job design limit the effect of effort on performance. They reduce the perceived correlation between effort and performance and, thus, the slope of the effort-reward function. When the slope of the reward curve decreases, motivation decreases (Simon, 1997). One of the most popular motivation theories is expectancy theory. Following expectancy theory of motivation, people act only when they have reasonable expectation that their actions will lead to desired goals (Simon, 1997). They will perform better if they believe that money will follow effective performance, so if money has a positive value for an individual, higher performance will follow. This theory places emphasis on perfor­mance noting that there must be a clearly recognized goal and relationship between performance and result. In general, this theory explains that motivation is a function of the expectancy of attaining a certain outcome in performing a certain act mul­tiplied by the value of the outcome for the performer (Armstrong, 2003). Outcomes that are highly valued and having higher expectations of being realized will direct a person to make a greater effort in his task. Outcomes with high expectations which are less highly valued (or even disliked) will reduce effort expended. Other studies on expectations and job performance emphasize the greater importance of intrinsic motivation factors. (Robbins, 2002). Employees must sense that the costs (negative outcomes) they experience at work do not encourage low effort expenditure. Negative outcomes from work can overshadow rewards and render a high-quality reward system relatively useless for employee motivational purposes. The less the positive correlation between effort and costs or the stronger the perceived inverse relation between effort and costs, the stronger the motivation (Reed 2001). The implicit assumption is that the eventual self-view has a basis in the persons relation to the environment. It would be hard to imagine that society would form its perspectives about individuals in a totally random manner, but rather, society waits until there is some basis for forming its perspective. Then, once the individual understands that perspective, the eventual selfview will correspond to his own accomplished, behavioral history. Should the system break down, that would be due to faulty perspective taking, or perhaps to the fact that a particular group would have come to the incorrect conclusion by faulty observations of the individuals behavior. X and Y Theory of Motivation For employees to perceive that effort will in fact result in performance, they must sense they either have the ability or can easily get it. Providing readily available help, or guidance, makes them feel they can easily gain the required skills and knowledge, if they do not already possess it ( Reed 2001). They must know that when they run into difficulties because of a skill or knowledge deficiency, they have ready access to a source that can resolve the deficiency. Accessible help allows them to sense that the lacking ability is not a "block" to performance. X and Y theory was formulated by Douglas McGregor in the book "The Human Side of Enterprise" appeared in 1960. X theory, based on direction and control, explains that: “the average person inherently dislikes work and will avoid it if at all possible; as a result, most people have to be coerced, controlled and threatened if they are to put in enough effort to achieve the organization’s goals; the average person prefers to be directed, avoids responsibility, isnt ambitious and simply seeks security” (McGregor, 2005). Within this theory management approaches involve hard and soft ones. The hard approach emphasizes the quantitative, calculative and business strategic aspects of managing the headcount resource in as rational as way as for any other economic factor. Another approach is called the soft model and traces its roots to the human-relations school; it emphasizes communication, motivation and leadership. The main limitation of this theory is that “the only way employees can attempt to satisfy their high level needs, … is by seeking more compensation” (McGregor, 2005). In terms of this theory, a supervisor, available to willingly provide help when such is needed, is one key source (Brown, 1971), An unstated principle of the above two schools, as well as an assumption of psychology in general, is that ones objective "success" in the environment and ones self-conceptions are closely intertwined. If we focus just for a moment on characteristics that society values, such as diligence, creativity, intelligence, generosity, reliability, and others, the conceptions lead one to suppose that a positive self-conception, in any given specific respect, represents a positive or successful relation to some facet of the environment (Armstrong, 2003). The implementation of Theory Y assumptions could at the very least result in a truce in the conflict between management and labor. In any case, surely it is evident that an enormous amount of debilitating stress, for both workers and managers, would be eliminated and trust would become a possibility. Group dynamics techniques help individuals develop awareness of the extent to which they are open about themselves and their relations to group members, the kind of facade they use to keep group members from knowing who they are, and the ways in which they accept and use feedback from group members about their interactions. The changing nature of the economy from an industrial mix that accommodated persons with relatively little skill and education to one that has become a knowledge economy requiring considerable basic reasoning, math, and language skills. Equity Theory Equity theory of motivation states that peoples feelings depend upon how fairly they have been treated in comparison with the treatment received by others. It is based on exchange theory (Armstrong, 2003). Feelings about the equity of the exchange are affected by the treatment they receive when compared with what happens to other people (Robbins, 2002). Permissiveness, or the absence of structure, encourages the unmediated operation of drives or affects, whereas informational environments encourage self-determination (Armstrong, 2003). They decrease intrinsic motivation and interest, increase pressure and tension, create a dynamic such that people either comply with the controls or rebel against them, and have a generally negative effect on the quality of performance which requires autonomy and independence. For practical purposes, however, it is important to keep in mind that any of the events that are sometimes controlling can also be made to be informational, and in that case will not have the deleterious effect Often autonomy is confused with permissiveness or the complete absence of structure (Porter 1978). Conclusion In order to achieve the best results, the HR consultant should take into account elements of different motivation theories and their practical application. What is occurring in business and industry is a historic upheaval and inevitable painful transition, especially for those who lose their jobs. It is unlikely that management will ever be able to offer lifetime jobs to those who work hard and play by the rules. Global competition is too intense for that. What can be hoped for is that management will handle the transition with honesty and integrity so that it can still be trusted in the conditions that seem to be shaping the future. The employees would gain a clearer picture of the organization in which they are risking their vulnerability and a more informed basis for fostering their independence--their responsibility for themselves. Some commentators suggest that younger workers are already adopting these values of independence, counting only on their own skills for employment security. BIBLIOGRAPHY 1. Armstrong, M. 2003, Human Resource Management. Kogan Page 2. Brown, J. A. C. 1971, Social Psychology of Industry. Business Library, Penguin. 3. Porter, L. Managerial Attitudes and Performance, 1978, Irwin. 4. Maslow, A. H. 1970, Motivation and Personality edn, Harper & Row. 5. McGregor, D. X and Y theory. Retrieved 30 July 2008 from http://www.netmba.com/mgmt/ob/motivation/mcgregor/ 6. Reed A. 2001, Innovation in Human Resource Management. Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development. 7. Robbins, S. 2002, Organizational Behavior. Pearson Higher. 8. Simon, H.A. 1997, Administrative Behavior. Free Press; 4 Sub edition. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(The Elements of Different Motivation Theories Term Paper - 1, n.d.)
The Elements of Different Motivation Theories Term Paper - 1. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/human-resources/1547549-you-have-been-recently-appointed-as-human-resource-managment-hrm-director-of-a-company-which-has-recognized-that-it-has-a-problem-with-low-workforce-motivati
(The Elements of Different Motivation Theories Term Paper - 1)
The Elements of Different Motivation Theories Term Paper - 1. https://studentshare.org/human-resources/1547549-you-have-been-recently-appointed-as-human-resource-managment-hrm-director-of-a-company-which-has-recognized-that-it-has-a-problem-with-low-workforce-motivati.
“The Elements of Different Motivation Theories Term Paper - 1”. https://studentshare.org/human-resources/1547549-you-have-been-recently-appointed-as-human-resource-managment-hrm-director-of-a-company-which-has-recognized-that-it-has-a-problem-with-low-workforce-motivati.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Elements of Different Motivation Theories

Motivations For Attendance At Notting Hill Festival

Why Recent research has focused on visitor motivation and they experience they seek within music festival (Pegg & Patterson, 2010, p.... This research is important because it will bring awareness and critical understanding for the reason behind tourists or individuals attending the famous ‘hallmark event'; Notting Hill Carnival....
15 Pages (3750 words) Literature review

Organizations Employing and Motivation Theories

This paper examines the organization's employing and motivation theories.... A number of motivation theories have been developed, beginning with the work of Abraham Maslow.... Maslow and Alderfer's theories are so similar it is sometimes difficult to understand the differences.... One of the major differences between the theories is that Alderfer's concept of growth needs is more ambiguous than Maslow's, allowing more flexibility and defining more facets of motivations....
7 Pages (1750 words) Literature review

Applying Motivational Theories

This paper "Applying Motivational theories" discusses managers that are required to understand the motivational theories and then apply them at the workplace.... If the managers empower their employees in such ways they can assist by heightening employee motivation.... If the efficiency of an organization is to be promoted there has to be the provision of motivation.... However, merely a combination of superior products and resources cannot lead to the best consequences: there is a need for motivation as well if a company aims to be successful (Strategic Direction 22)....
9 Pages (2250 words) Case Study

An Application on the Theories of Motivation: Understanding the Hierarchy of Needs and ERG Theory

Consequently, the conceptualization of motivation had arrived at different understanding from different experts in order to integrate the principles of different theories.... The paper will also differentiate the two theories in terms of its principles and application within the organizational context.... hellip; The conclusion from this study states that the motivational theories established by Maslow and Alderfer have served a substantial element for organizational management in understanding the needs of their employees....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Theories of Motivation Within Organisations

The paper "Theories of Motivation Within Organisations" describes that organizations utilise a difference in the focus on the disparate elements of motivation, by a combination of two or more motivational theories to arrive at a motivation solution that is appropriate for the workforce.... This complexity has led to motivation is the subject of rigorous study for a long period of time from which have sprung several theories that try to explain the framework of motivation and how they can be used to mould employee behaviour toward the goals and objectives of an organization....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Psychological Theories of Work Motivation

The paper "Psychological theories of Work Motivation" highlights that empirical research has shown that employee motivation and performance is highest when the goal is difficult; when employees have easy goals or have no goals at all, motivation and performance is lower.... What the need-based theories of motivation share are the concept that human beings are driven to accomplish physiological and psychological needs.... cClelland's Need for Achievement is a need-motive-value theory of employee motivation, similar in nature to other need-based models such as Maslow's Hierarchy of Needs or Alderfer's ERG theory (Levy, 2003)....
6 Pages (1500 words) Research Paper

Motivational Theories

The current paper highlights that motivation means to inspire people in order to make them achieve their personal or organizational goals.... nbsp;In the case of employees, motivation is the key to success in their professional lives.... nbsp;… Managers give extreme importance towards increasing employee motivation because motivation not only improves employee performance but also increases the overall productivity of the companies....
5 Pages (1250 words) Research Paper

How to Motivate Employees

motivation theories The presence of programs that aim at recognizing employees, “benefit packages and stock ownership plans” and many more is a proof that the internal and external needs of humans are primarily considered to be the motivating factors at the workplace which can be explained by the following theorists through their respective ideas (Nelson & Quick, 2011, p.... This paper tries to integrate motivational theories and their link with addressing people's various needs....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us