StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Incarceration Rates Disparity in Provincial and Federal Prisons - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper “Incarceration Rates Disparity in Provincial and Federal Prisons” will look at the disparity in incarceration rates, which have been witnessed in both provincial and federal prisons based on racial lines. This has been termed as unequal justice within the judicial process in the country…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.6% of users find it useful
Incarceration Rates Disparity in Provincial and Federal Prisons
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Incarceration Rates Disparity in Provincial and Federal Prisons"

Incarceration Rates Disparity in Provincial and Federal Prisons Introduction Disparity in incarceration rates have been witnessed in both provincial and federal prisons based on racial lines. This has been termed as unequal justice within the judicial process in the country. Prisons in Ontario have registered overrepresentation of prisoners from Black and Aboriginal people in comparison to other races within Canada. Actual statistics have indicated that aboriginal boys aged between 12 and 17 years form 2.9 percent of all the young male population under incarceration. The case is much higher among black boys undergoing jail admissions. Less representation is registered among the white boys and other ethnic groups. Among girls, only the aboriginal communities have registered increased misrepresentation in the jails which is rated at 10 percent higher than other ethnic groups in the Ontario prisons. Statistics have indicated that indicated that over-representation of the Aboriginal people in the prisons has been on the increasing trend over the past 30 years. The statistics escalated after the Second World War and the trend has accelerated over the years. If the current trend is to continue, then the number of Aboriginal people under incarceration is likely to be higher than those out of prisons which are in deed a worrying trend. Causes of overrepresentation in incarceration within the prisons Despite the introduction of the Youth Criminal Justice Act of 2003 that has seen a steady decrease in the number of incarcerations among the youths; the trend has not been witnessed among the aboriginal boys and girls. The provincial jails must rise and act on the increased number of deaths of black youths that has been witnessed lately through gun shots by police and other security agencies. This calls for a a change of tactics on how security issues are to be handled in the country and that massive incarcerations is not the solution. International bodies such as the United Nations have expressed their concern on the need to reduce the increased overrepresentation of aboriginal and black races in the federal and provincial prisons. In Manitoba, similar situations seem to exist based on how the Aboriginal people are treated in relation to incarcerations. Despite the fact that they only form 12% of the entire province population, they dominate the jails and account for more that 0ne-half of the people who are incarcerated in the correctional centers at any given time. It is indeed very shocking that in nation where justice is expected to be blind to racial differences only one ethnic group seem to dominate the prisons. It has been established that this situation can only be linked to one of the two factors which include the belief that the aboriginal people may be committing more crimes in comparison to other ethnic groups or they may just be innocent victims of a discriminatory judicial process. The two reasons are believed to be correct but need to be carefully analyzed. The aboriginal people may be linked to increasing cases of crime and that can be explained by the fact that there has been a long history of discrimination and inequality in terms of distribution of resources within the country that seem not to be in favor of the group. There are many credible evidences that can be used to prove that the aboriginal people have been marginalized. These cases prove that there is racism in the administration of justice within the entire nation of Canada. Radical steps need to be undertaken so as t ensure that cases of racism are confronted and condemned with utmost firmness. The aboriginal people have witnessed a long history of cultural oppression and social inequality that have led to poor treatment of the people by the federal government of Canada. These evidences make it clear that these factors are crucial in explaining the reasons why Aboriginal people are over-represented in Manitoba’s jails. It has been established that crime rates are indeed higher in Aboriginal communities which has been magnified by the difficulties that exist in defining the term crime and because different societies have different concepts of crime. For example, many Aboriginal peoples continue to exercise their rights to hunt and fish, although they risk prosecution under provincial and federal laws for doing so. In addition, society’s criminals are part of a larger group, some of which escape detection or conviction. It has been established beyond any reasonable doubt that being held before trial leads to more guilty pleas that may set people immediately free but count heavily against them with each subsequent encounter with the law. This has been the case especially when dealing with offenders of Black and Aboriginal origin. More conditions at release time mean more of a chance of breaching them, which brings one back to jail leading to over representation. Black people in Canada face almost similar challenges as those being faced by the Aboriginal people such as poverty, lack of basic amenities, unemployment and family struggles. These factors contribute to increase in criminal activities among them leading to incarceration. Conclusion The root causes of over-representation in the prisons is racism and discrimination that has existed since the beginning of human history. They are particularly likely to develop when there is close association of separate groups of people, especially if they have different cultures, religions or skin colors. Canada has a long and tragic history of discrimination and racism. It has been established that racism in Canada cannot be confined to one cultural group only as each of the local communities in Canada have witnessed discrimination in different measures. For true equality to be realized, the country need to consider the use of less incarceration, greater dignity in the treatment of the people, the elimination of mandatory penalties and measures aimed at decriminalizing some of the drugs in the country such as marijuana. These factors will further allow the diversion of spending on correctional activities and channeling them to investments in matters that will improve the living standards of the people (Roberts, 12-36). Work Cited Roberts, Julian V, and David P. Cole. Making Sense of Sentencing. Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 1998. Print. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Incarceration Rates Disparity in Provincial and Federal Prisons Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/history/1669796-native-final-paper
(Incarceration Rates Disparity in Provincial and Federal Prisons Essay)
https://studentshare.org/history/1669796-native-final-paper.
“Incarceration Rates Disparity in Provincial and Federal Prisons Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/history/1669796-native-final-paper.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Incarceration Rates Disparity in Provincial and Federal Prisons

Incarceration Rates in Juvenile Offenders

Third, juvenile incarceration would imitate those deemed appropriate for adult offenders; so the states with higher adult incarceration rates may incarcerate more juveniles.... Finally, if the juvenile incarcerations are culturally accepted then it would lead to higher rates of juvenile incarceration.... These violators can be subjected to a variety of punishments ranging from imposition of fines to the confinement of the individual to a jail (known as incarceration)....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Mothers in Federal Prison

Historically women who were mothers and sentenced to federal prisons were given lighter sentences.... The literature suggest that the large numbers of women in federal prisons has a social impact and supports the premise that many women are in federal prisons due to the unsuccessful war on drugs.... The current literature also reveals that mothers in federal prisons have difficulties with adolescents and the adolescents of incarcerated mothers are problematic....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Consequences of High Incarceration Rate

Fathers were less likely to report living with their children prior to incarceration than mother, (47% federal inmates versus 73%).... The paper “Consequences of High incarceration Rate” analyzes the impact of parental incarceration on children and identifies developmental, emotional, psychological, social, educational, and behavioral consequences for these children.... Research addressing the impact of parental incarceration on children has identified developmental, emotional, psychological, social, educational, and behavioral consequences for these children (Trice & Brewster, 2004)....
9 Pages (2250 words) Term Paper

Forces That Generated Mass Incarceration

Most prisons are located in the rural areas because prisons because they are regarded to have economic advantage.... Communities which face decline in, mining, farming, manufacturing and timberwork are opting for the building of prisons in their back yards because of the economic gains that are attached to the prison.... This is another factor that has led to the mass incarceration....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

US and Canada Incarceration Rate and the Costs

Evidently, the US spends a lot in maintaining their prisons as compared to Canada.... Many scholars have come up to criticize the hefty spending of the US in maintaining prisons.... Statistics indicate that the US has the highest mass incarceration rate in the world as compared to other nations.... Most… While this is a security measure, the US government should consider reducing the rate of incarceration to save on the economy and reduce the poverty level This essay compares US and Canada incarceration rate and the costs, in an attempt to provide viable recommendation on how the government should conduct its incarceration....
6 Pages (1500 words) Research Paper

Disparity in the prison system

For instance, African- Americans constitute 13% of the general U S population, yet they constitute 28% of all arrests, 40% of the inmates in jails and prisons, and 42% of the population on death row.... In terms of court processing, Hispanics were admitted to prisons at a rate twice that of White admissions.... Hatney & Voung (2009) define disparity as the probability of receiving a particular outcome that favors The contemporary United States of America consists of several racial groups and disparities in the justice system have resulted in an overrepresentation of given ethnic groups....
4 Pages (1000 words) Research Paper

Factors That Contribute to Incarceration Rates

This essay "Factors That Contribute to incarceration rates" discusses the reasons behind high incarceration rates and factors already related to incarceration, such as failure to reintegration after release and parental imprisonment as affecting juveniles.... With such high incarceration rates, it is important to look for the reasons behind these great numbers.... uch factors that will be considered to influence incarceration rates are education, race/ethnicity, socioeconomic status, as well as military service history....
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay

Incarceration Versus Rehabilitation in the United States

The prisons are built to keep as well as house the individuals for some longer periods of time which follows the conviction for such a serious offense.... In other words, the jails could as well be referred to as the detention centers while the prisons are called the correctional facilities or even the penitentiaries.... The rates were not just above any other in the world but as well were substantially higher than the long-standing experience in history....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us