StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Critical writing skills - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Rotenberg’s text has proven to be viable resource to aid students become better writers.The book is based on an array of approaches that provides the reader with critical thinking techniques that could help them build a strong base for argument…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.8% of users find it useful
Critical writing skills
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Critical writing skills"

Critical Writing Skills Rotenberg’s text has proven to be viable resource to aid become betterwriters. The book is based on an array of approaches that provides the reader with critical thinking techniques that could help them build a strong base for argument. The author outlines various philosophical approaches from other scholars such as Roger and Aristotle, while also manipulating models that support the reason for these argumentative approaches. The first three chapters make up the first part that is the understanding of argument, while the fourth chapter is part of the second part that is the analysis of the elements of the argument.

In the first chapter, Rotenberg combines Aristotle’s rhetoric and Rogerian tactics to approaching an argument. She points out that although a rhetoric being is able to identify a critical point of persuasion, they are not always able to enlighten everybody with the correct point of view. “A physician knows what is required of them to heal a patient, but they are not always able to cure all their patients.” (Rotenberg, 2011, p. 3). The Rogerian argument aims towards persuasion of one party by asking one to open up their minds by getting in the shoes of the other.

She further points out the Toulmin Model, which provides some terms of argument that purport the claim, support and warrant as the guide to writing when tackling and analyzing an argument. In the second chapter, Rotenberg advocates for critical reading for the writer to have a good understanding of the argument they are about to make. In Let’s Have No More Monkey Trials, Krauthammer’s argument is based on the long debated argument between religion and science. On critical evaluation of the essay, Rotenberg asserts that it is important to examine the author of the article, the matter of discussion as well the literary material the author presents to the reader.

As a reader of such an essay, it is important to make a concise evaluation through critical thinking thus leading to a most viable argument. Rotenberg suggests clear comprehension of the essay, guiding through various strategies to understanding arguments made in the essay. The author of the essay shows a very strong attraction towards the scientific theory of evolution as the history of man as opposed to the creation story religion is drawn towards. He even claims that a significant and an influential person; that is the late Pope John Paul II, accepted the theory of evolution by Charles Darwin.

The Catholic Church disapproves thing claim but the author goes on to disregard Cardinal Christoph’s claim that this allegation was mistaken and absurd. By reading and re-reading this essay, it is quite clear that the author is inclined to the evolution theory and totally disregards religion. Rotenberg’s style involves clearly understanding the argument as well as the author of the material. Krauthammer claims that although there are some loopholes in the scientific theory, there is still room for them to be filled up by other emerging scholars.

Charles Darwin’s theory had gaps and unfilled pieces, but Einstein came along and provided some helpful information that made his theory even stronger. The argument between the author and the Cardinal goes on that in fact Christoph’s ancestor was one who disputed the discovery by Kepler's of the orbits of planets. Since now it has been proven that in deed there are planet orbits, then the Cardinal’s word could also be disputed and proven wrong. According to Rotenberg, the observer should critically go through the essay while trying to understand what the author wants to put down.

For instance, in this case of the claim against the priest and his ancestors that kind of thinking is illogical and is simply a fallacy. This is a conclusion that she went to after an evaluation of the literature. In critical thinking, one of the most important lessons involve one making logical arguments. Fallacies are illogical thinking when approaching an argument and should therefore be avoided. Throughout the book, the author tries to make the reader a critical thinker which is the most important tool in tackling an argument and in writing.

Through the third chapter, one is trained on how to write analytically that will involve structural planning, adequate and appropriately writing the source of the ideas and ensuring originality in order to avoid plagiarism. The fourth chapter focuses definition of the key terms used in the writing. This will help the reader understand the content of the argument. The ‘Elements of Argument’ is a masterpiece written to provide writers with critical thinking strategies that will help them in approaching arguments.

For this reason, the book has been used in literature classes in school as a credible tool to help students in tackling arguments and in making better writers. Reference Rotenberg, A. & Winchell, D. (2011). Elements of Argument: A Text and Reader, 10th Ed. New York: Bedford/St. Martin's

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Critical writing skills Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/english/1470197-critical-writing-skills
(Critical Writing Skills Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words)
https://studentshare.org/english/1470197-critical-writing-skills.
“Critical Writing Skills Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/english/1470197-critical-writing-skills.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Critical writing skills

Critical Evaluation and Analysis of Employability Skills

The researcher's personal development plan was to improve his report-writing skills which seem to meet the requirements of researcher's organization.... This research is being carried out to present critical evaluation and analysis of employability skills for professional development plan relating to career objectives.... hellip; The researcher states that having specific, measurable, achievable, relevant and timely objectives is important in assessing employability skills....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Critical writing skill

Positive relationships enable… The process of building favourable work relationships requires development of positive attitudes, embracing cultural and behavioural diversities, improving communication It is critical for organizations to monitor workplace relationships because they affect teamwork, worker motivation, employee retention, and worker productivity....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Acquiring Effective Writing Skills

From the discussion, in the essay "Acquiring effective writing skills" it may be concluded that only in the process of analysis of arguments, structuring, and correcting your own thoughts it is possible to get any inspiration.... hellip; Acquiring effective writing skills is a very complicated process because the progress is hardly distinguishable.... Acquiring Effective Writing SkillsAcquiring effective writing skills is a very complicated process because the progress is hardly distinguishable....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Academic Study Skills

This essay "Academic Study skills" looks into using the Internet for academic research is possible.... eferencesBedford, D & Wilson, E 2013, Study skills for Foundation Degrees, Routledge, New York.... Cottrell, S 2013, The Study skills Handbook, Palgrave Macmillan, UK.... Dillon, AG 2008, Get Connected: Study skills, Reading, And Writing, Cengage Learning, Boston.... ijlaarsdam, G, Bergh, HVD & Couzijn, M 2005, Effective Learning and Teaching of writing a Handbook Of writing In Education, Kluwer Academic Publishers, New York....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Teaching Writing Skills

This case study "Teaching writing skills" analyzes the teaching of writing, the effectiveness οf writing programs and testing whether the repeated practice in writing within a specific task domain actually results in improved writing skills.... nbsp;… Specifically, we investigated (a) whether repeated practice improves students' writing skills and (b) after controlling for repeated practice, whether writing within a specific task domain improves students' writing skills....
13 Pages (3250 words) Case Study

An Important Event In My Life

The paper "An Important Event In My Life" describes that I was struggling to write alternative words, which did not contain the excluded letters, while at the same time maintaining the original meaning of the sentences, I developed some Critical writing skills.... hellip; The process, as I may say, was a bit tricky as it was not very easy to find alternative words to replace others bearing the excluded letters....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Structure of IELTS Academic Writing

The following paper under the title 'Structure of IELTS Academic Writing' gives detailed information about an international standardized exam procedure used for the assessment of English language and academic writing skills of non-native speakers of the English language.... The process-genre approach is used to improve the academic writing skills related to IELTS.... IELTS academic writing is used to measure students' skills and ability to write essays in the academic context using the understandable, correct, and formal English language....
16 Pages (4000 words) Term Paper

Chinese Academic Group in English Study

We find out about the author's English skills, his opportunities in writing and reading.... This term paper "Chinese Academic Group in English Study" describes the peculiarities of writing course during the author's semester.... nbsp;… As such, writing and reading was a valuable opportunity.... In my opinion, we should respect writers and their books and take every chance to read their books now that writing and reading have become more popular and easier than ever before....
17 Pages (4250 words) Term Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us