StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

The Sudanese Girl, photographed by Kevin Carter - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Apart from the disturbing message that is visually manifested in the picture and captured the attention of people globally, the controversial story that haunted the photographer from the time the photograph was taken, up to the accolades received, intermittently interspersed with criticisms, and ultimately led to his suicide, only two months after. …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.8% of users find it useful
The Sudanese Girl, photographed by Kevin Carter
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The Sudanese Girl, photographed by Kevin Carter"

One was searching for the appropriate photograph to be the of a rhetorical analysis and found Kevin Carter’s “The Sudanese Girl” that won him a Pulitzer Prize in 1994. Apart from the disturbing message that is visually manifested in the picture and captured the attention of people globally, the controversial story that haunted the photographer from the time the photograph was taken, up to the accolades received, intermittently interspersed with criticisms, and ultimately led to his suicide, only two months after. There is more meaning to what is seen in the photography, much more than someone who was so close to the girl could take. At the time the photograph was taken, Sudan had been in the midst of a civil war that have led to prolonged famine that afflicted a wide range of the population necessitating international organizations like the United Nations to distribute aid in the form of food and other relief supplies. The strength of the rhetorical analysis comes in terms of requiring validating references from diverse secondary sources to confirm the credibility not only of the incidents crucial for the photograph, but also the story surrounding famine infested Sudan and Carter’s ultimate demise. The Sudanese Girl, photographed by Kevin Carter A young naked body cramped on the earth, with very thin limbs, and rib cage protruding. Face touching the earth from the forehead. The viewer could not even decipher the gender. Despite the face hidden, the gender could have been surmised due to the single white accessory around the neck. Most disturbing was the vulture intently eyeing a potential meal, not even three meters away. Everything else seemed to be oblivious of the scene. Aside from the green trees that set the background, all that viewers see is the disturbing reality of hunger, famine, eminent death. The meaning that the picture aims to relay is more than eliciting pity, empathy, fear – it generated diverse reactions and criticisms that created another tragic story for the photographer who was tagged as "The man adjusting his lens to take just the right frame of her suffering," said The Sudanese Girl, photographed by Kevin Carter Source: Toledo, 2010 the St. Petersburg (Florida) Times, "might just as well be a predator, another vulture on the scene” (Macleod, 1994, 5). The story of Kevin Carter was thereby featured in Time, published on September 12, 1994 entitled “The Life and Death of Kevin Carter” (Time, 1994) which proffered the kind of life the photographer led and the tendencies for drug addiction and susceptibility to suicide. Having previously attempted to take his life after losing his job, Macleod revealed Carter espousing a troubled personality exemplifying a rollercoaster prelude aggravated by the habit of taking marijuana and the ‘white-pipe’: “a mixture of dagga and Mandrax, a banned tranquilizer containing methaqualone” (Macleod, 1994, 3). Another opportunity to rationalize the tragic suicide of a recently acclaimed photographer, seeking to justify the outcome of his behavior, by fitting pieces of a puzzle, leaving the readers to conclude. The image ability to appeal to ethos is deemed eminent in its solicitation of diverse reactions focusing the plight of the victims of Sudan’s civil war and famine. The immediate fame it generated by winning a Pulitzer Prize was actually magnified by the event of the photographer’s death. According to Christensen (2010), “it is true that Kevin Carter won a Pulitzer Prize for his famous photograph. It is also true that Carter left the scene after taking the photograph without helping the child. However, it is too simplistic to suggest that he committed suicide as a direct result of his experience with this child as implied in the message. It is also unfair to judge his actions without having some understanding of the man's state of mine along with the terrible conditions in Sudan at the time the photograph was taken” (par. 2). The statement supports the appeal of the ethos perspective in reaching various audiences and eliciting diverse reactions. The use of color was likewise appropriate to depict the dry, arid, suffocating environment that has been instrumental in highlighting the weakness and almost near-death status of the girl’s body slumped on the earth. As no shadows were eminent from the figure, it could be surmised that the time the photograph was taken was at noontime which aggravates the stillness of the day, leaving the body alone in its agony – except for the metamorphosis of death at its back. More disturbing is the global response that resulted from publishing the photo. As cited by Christensen (2010), “the New York Times, looking for photographs of the Sudan famine, bought Carter's shot and ran it on 23 March. The newspaper was swamped with letters and telephone calls, many asking what had happened to the child. Within days, the photograph was a global icon. Syndicated around the world, it was an image that was worth a thousand telethons. However, Carter faced fierce criticism for abandoning the child” (par. 6). Aside from global inquiries on the state of the child, there has not been any concrete action that any international organization did to put an end to the civil war in Sudan. Apparently, the Sudan civil war only ended in 2005, as Oxfam (2011) clarified that “a UN peacekeeping mission can never be a long term solution, and ultimately the South Sudan government is responsible for protecting its own citizens. However, the stakes are so high that the UN must be able to support the state, and also provide protection to civilians where the state is unable to do so” (par. 8). Thereby, despite the vivid reality depicted in Carter’s picture, his personal acclaim failed to instigate international agencies to end the brutal war that famished Sudan’s population to death. Kevin Carter’s ‘The Sudanese Girl’ won 1994’s Pulitzer Prize award for Feature Photography that apparently “made the world weep” (Macleod, 1994), criticized the photographer for his insensitive and irresponsive stance and left Sudan in civil war and famine beyond help and assistance. The picture had the strong capability to incite vast emotions ranging from empathy, loneliness, despair, anger, fury, depression, hopelessness, indifference. But like the photographer who was too close for comfort, no positive action from the outside world could have prevented famine and war that remained within their midst for 21 long years. References Christensen, B.M. (2010). Kevin Carter Pulitzer Prize Photograph. Retrieved 10 June 2011. < http://www.hoax-slayer.com/kevin-carter-pulitzer.shtml> Macleod, S. (1994). “The Life and Death of Kevin Carter.” Time. Retrieved 10 June 2011. < http://www.time.com/time/magazine/article/0,9171,981431-3,00.html> Toledo, E.E. (2010). World’s Most Famous Photographs. Retrieved 10 June 2011. < http://www.enzotoledo.com/enzo/worlds-most-famous-photographs> Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“The Sudanese Girl, photographed by Kevin Carter Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/visual-arts-film-studies/1425203-the-sudanese-girl-photographed-by-kevin-carter
(The Sudanese Girl, Photographed by Kevin Carter Essay)
https://studentshare.org/visual-arts-film-studies/1425203-the-sudanese-girl-photographed-by-kevin-carter.
“The Sudanese Girl, Photographed by Kevin Carter Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/visual-arts-film-studies/1425203-the-sudanese-girl-photographed-by-kevin-carter.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Sudanese Girl, photographed by Kevin Carter

Trailblazers in Photography

Furthermore, he engaged the people he photographed on the subject of his interest (Eder 258).... Trailblazers in Photography Name: Course: College: Tutor: Date: Introduction Photography as an art and science started when people discovered that focusing light on an object could produce an image....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Kevin Carter's 1993 Pulitzer Prize Winning Photograph

It was this struggle and suffering that South African photojournalist kevin carter managed to capture with his camera lens back in 1993.... However, none of them were able to come to par when it came to the lucky shot that kevin carter was lucky enough to have witnessed and captured on film the day that he came to visit Sudan in 1993.... This picture was the embodiment of the struggle that the sudanese people faced on a daily basis.... Mr carter's picture asked the onlooker to question his own morality, mortality, and humanity as depicted within the photograph....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Richard Avedon's Life and Photography

“A photographic portrait is a picture of someone who knows he's being photographed and what he does with this knowledge is as much a part of the photograph as what he's wearing or how he looks” (Avedon cited in Craven).... The images are often imperfect in that the person being photographed is only partly shown, and this imperfection in turn makes the images magical.... During his career, Richard Avedon has photographed people belonging to different professions, including the carnival workers, drifters, and the American people in general....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

'Photographic seeing: what, if anything, could be meant by this concept

Photographic seeing if it exists allows a photographer to capture a moment in history.... That captured moment can entertain us, horrify us or educate and enlighten us.... The more talented the photographer, the more we are made aware of the world around us.... Photographic vision not only allows us to see more of the world, but allows us to see through different eyes....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

American Photographic Journalist Susan Meiselas' Art

 In 1981, she photographed a village in San Salvador which had been destroyed by the armed forces and also took photographs of the El Mozote massacre which took place in the same year when Salvadorean soldiers, who had been trained  by the military of the United States, killed some 1000 civilians  in the name of an anti-guerilla campaign....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

Portrait photographer interview

I am also a professional Portrait Photographer discovered as a little girl.... The interview aims at gaining more knowledge about the photographer in terms of career, style and technique in photography, as well as, her perception about the current and future trends in… Annie Leibovitz was chosen as the preferred portrait photographer for this interview, as she is one of the most sought after photographers in the industry today....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Jerry Ueslmann, a Photographer

The essay "Jerry Ueslmann, a Photographer" focuses on discussing Jerry Ueslmann's photography, highlighting the varied techniques which this photographer utilizes in a move to come up with such outstanding masterpieces.... nbsp;Most photographers' pictures depict real-life aspects and events.... hellip; Unlike others, his pictures depict fantasies....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

The Growth of Photography in Graphic Arts: from Black-and-White Photography to Modern Photography

"The Growth of Photography in Graphic Arts: from Black-and-White Photography to Modern Photography" paper states that the growth and development of Photography from Black-and-White Photography to digital photography is related to the human passion to attain immortality through solid visualization....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us