StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Youth Delinquency in Relation to Gender and Shifting Representations in the Media - Literature review Example

Cite this document
Summary
The author of this paper "Youth Delinquency in Relation to Gender and Shifting Representations in the Media" will make an earnest attempt to explore the question of gender differences among juvenile delinquents, as well as the correlations between them. …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.3% of users find it useful

Extract of sample "Youth Delinquency in Relation to Gender and Shifting Representations in the Media"

Youth Delinquency in Relation to Gender and Shifting Representations in the Media and/or Popular Culture Student’s Name: Name of Institution: Instructor’s Name: Course Code: Date of Submission: Introduction ‘Delinquent’ behavior refers to that which deviates from the accepted values and norms (unspoken or defined by law) of society. Such behaviors may include simple offenses, e.g. disobeying curfews, or other serious crimes, e.g. rape, murder, theft, etc. Indeed, gender does affect people differently. Given the varying methods of socialization that boys and girls display, and thus experience life differently, ‘gender’ becomes a valid variable for discussing juvenile delinquency. Unfortunately, most research studies have focused their attention on male juveniles, somewhat ignoring, denying or even trivializing crimes amongst females. As a result, there has been little understanding on the differences between juvenile delinquency in males and females. This, of course, is largely attributable to the historical fact that it is the males who constitute the bigger percentage of delinquents (Trogdon, 2006). However, according to Chesney-Lind and Okamoto (2001), in the 1990s crime rate amongst female juveniles grew faster than amongst male juveniles. This paper aims to explore the question of gender differences among juvenile delinquents, as well as the correlations between them. Also, this paper will touch on the responsibility of the media and popular culture in shifting focus on this issue (i.e. accepting the existence of female juveniles). Discussion A number of correlations between male and female juveniles have need identified. For example, it has been found that, generally, children who suffer any kind of abuse are highly likely to run away that those who do not experience abuse. Other such correlates include drug abuse, gang affiliation, family structure and educational progress, amongst others. However, these factors (e.g. abuse) have not been studied in relation to gender. For example, it is possible that the female juveniles have faced more abuse that the boys (or even the vice versa). Child Abuse Trogdon (2006) notes the prevalence of child abuse in the US. According to US Department of Health and Human Services (2000, cited in Trogdon, 2006), of all the reported cases of child abuse, physical abuse was at 19.3 percent and sexual abuse was at 10.1 percent. While the rate of physical abuse victimization was found to be similar for both boys and girls, females were found to experience higher rate of sexual abuse than boys, i.e. 71 percent. A national research found that sexual and physical abuse played a role in a girl’s delinquency, i.e. adolescence disorders such as running away, truancy and conduct problems (Chesney-Lind & Sheldon, 2004). A related study conducted by Siegel and Williams (2003…..) found that women who suffer sexual abuse are twice likely to commit violent offenses that those who do not. These studies are in line with the argument of crime theorists that victimization breeds delinquency, which may be revealed in later years. Girls experience higher rate of sexual abuse as compared to their male counterparts, who experience higher rate of physical abuse than the girls (Trogdon, 2006). Importance of Education In 1988, Siegel and William (cited in Trogdon, 2006) conducted a research study which showed a correlation between failure in school and delinquency. These findings were found to run across all socioeconomic groups. In a related study, Chesney-Lind and Shelden (2004) found that the significance of such a relationship (school failure versus delinquency) differed in boys and girls, that it is more prominent in girls than boys. Perhaps this is in line with the assertion that girls are likely to quit school 7 times more than boys, e.g. for family purposes, which then predisposes them to delinquency ( Junger-Tas et al, 2004; Trogdon, 2006). Socioeconomic Status Research has found the correlation between socioeconomic status and delinquency. Infact, at the close of the 19th century, children from poor families were labeled ‘delinquent’. However, further research sought to examine the patterns of crime over time. As a result, many have come to understand that poverty does not cause delinquency per se. Still, it remains a crucial indicator (Willem Bonger 1916, cited in Trogdon 2006). Chesney-Lind and Shelden (2004) note that more girls are increasingly joining gangs in an effort to cope with the socioeconomic disadvantages in which they find themselves. Harper and Robinson (1999 cited in Chesney-Lind & Shelden, 2004) found that more than 95 percent of female juveniles who admitted to having been gang members came from families that received welfare or unemployment benefits. This shows that for females, economic hardship is highly likely to lead to gang membership. Family Structure Differences between male and female delinquents were also noted in relation to the family structures. For instance, in his study of juvenile delinquents in Texas, Trogdon (2006) noted that most female juvenile delinquents came from homes with two guardians. This deviated from the assertion of earlier research studies claiming delinquency was more likely in single-parent homes due to lack of supervision and role models. What this correlation implied is that perhaps family structure does not have as much influence on females as previously believed. On the other hand, most male juvenile delinquents were found to come from single-guardian homes. Gangs and Peer Groups Just like family, peers do influence the beliefs and behaviors of those with whom they interact. These peer influences are passed through actual behaviors or expressed attitudes. Of these two, actual behaviors are the most influential (Warr & Stafford, 1991 cited in Trogdon, 2006). Gangs are examples of peer groups. Infact, some gang members view other members as family. According to delinquency theorists, peers play a significant role in an individual’s socialization habits. Therefore, interacting with such a group shapes a person’s internalization of norms associated with behavior. Perhaps it is for this reason that gang membership has been found among many juveniles homicide cases (Trogdon, 2006). There has been much debate on the roles of females in gangs. Infact, many have disagreed on this matter. According to Jankowski (1991, cited in Trogdon, 2006), gangs are purely male occurrences and females are merely as ‘property’ or providers of sex. But Taylor (1993 cited in Trogdon, 2006) disputed this, arguing that females are also capable of ruthlessness as their male counterparts. Taylor’s study shows a shift in the traditional perception on gender repression. Chesney-Lind and Shelby (2004), while agreeing that girls have been gang members for a long time, also noted that the nature of violence conducted by them is determined by their genders. Drug or Alcohol Abuse Abuse of drugs and alcohol was found to be a significant cause of delinquency in both boys and girls. Female delinquents were found to be abused more frequently than male delinquents. According to Trogdon (2006), this trend is partly attributed to the internalization of traditional gender roles. Since females are generally socialized to be submissive, many of them do not speak of the abuses they may experience. Media & Popular Culture Representations The issue of juvenile delinquency in relation to gender has become a major academic concern. So far, this paper has shown how researchers have sought to answer certain questions in relation to gender and juvenile delinquency, including the possibility of delinquency amongst girls, causes of delinquency in both girls and boys and how they differ, the role of girls in gangs. Most researchers have come to accept that girls, although in lower numbers, are also as guilty. However, this debate has not really been the case in the public, with the media and popular culture being the key agenda-setters. In agreement, Reiner (2002) bemoans the ‘cause of concern’ that is the representation of deviance and crime by the mass media, especially as ‘discerned in public debate’. The question here surrounds the side that the mass media would like to paint as the ‘victim’. For years, and perhaps in accompaniment of feminism, the mass media has sought to project the females as victims. This stance bears a degree of validity as shown in research findings which have shown men to commit crimes more frequently than women. These statistics have provided the premise upon which the media has continually defended its ‘female victim’ stance. Indeed, research studies have shown that male delinquents commit crimes more frequently than female delinquents. But this is in no way an indication that women do not commit crime. In recent years, the mass media has attempted to adopt a girls-are-also-capable-of-crime stance. For example, while Chris Brown was condemned for beating Rihana, Rihana has also had her own share of ‘negative’ portrayal by the mass media. This is to accept that she is also capable of her own demons. We have equally seen the representations of Michael Jackson and Amy Winehouse. These elements, albeit subtle, mark a shift in the representations youth delinquency among the youth. Conclusion Although the factors that cause juvenile delinquency among young people have been found to be similar in both boys and girls, there are still differences in their significance depending on gender. For instance, while abuse played a bigger role in female delinquency, gang membership was found to figure mostly in males than females (Junger-Tas et al, 2004; Trogdon, 2006). Ultimately, the mass media has helped this ‘new’ reality by objectively turning focus to both male and female delinquents. Accepting this as a fact is not an effort to paint the females in a bad light, but a crucial step in finding a solution for them too. Bibliography Chesney-Lind, M & Okamoto, SK 2001. ‘Gender matters: patterns in girl’s delinquency and gender responsive programming’, Journal of Forensic Psychology Practice, vol. 1, pp. 1-28 Chesney-Lind, M & Shelden, RG 2004. Girls, delinquency, and juvenile justice. Toronto, Ontario, Canada: Wadsworth. Junger-Tas, J, Ribeaud, D & Cruyff, MJLF 2004. ‘Juvenile Delinquency and Gender’, European Journal of Criminology, vol. 1, no. 3, pp. 333-375 Reiner, R 2002. Media-made criminality: the representation of crime in the mass media. http://citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/viewdoc/download?doi=10.1.1.196.7742&rep=rep1&type=pdf, (accessed 04 June, 2012) Siegel, JA & Williams, LM 2003. ‘The relationship between child sexual abuse and female delinquency and crime: a prospective study’, Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency, vol. 40, pp. 71-94 Trogdon, S 2006. Gender related differences in correlations of juvenile delinquency in the state of Texas. Thesis. https://digital.library.txstate.edu/bitstream/handle/10877/3186/fulltext.pdf (accessed 03 June, 2012) Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Youth Delinquency in Relation to Gender and Shifting Representations Literature review, n.d.)
Youth Delinquency in Relation to Gender and Shifting Representations Literature review. https://studentshare.org/sociology/2060280-research-essay
(Youth Delinquency in Relation to Gender and Shifting Representations Literature Review)
Youth Delinquency in Relation to Gender and Shifting Representations Literature Review. https://studentshare.org/sociology/2060280-research-essay.
“Youth Delinquency in Relation to Gender and Shifting Representations Literature Review”. https://studentshare.org/sociology/2060280-research-essay.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Youth Delinquency in Relation to Gender and Shifting Representations in the Media

Popular Culture Media Representation and the Construction of Social Reality

The author of the essay examines media and social consensus and concludes that societal consensus can be achieved in the media in various ways.... the media often not only tells the society what is expected of them but also acts as a representation of the ideas, views and standard wavelength of the society, in general.... There are call-in shows on both, television and radio, besides interviews and public opinion garnering, that reflect the popular consensus....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

Juvenile delinquents

314894 21 August 2009 Juvenile Delinquents Introduction The problemof juvenile delinquency is in its inherent nature to grow into full blown crime.... There is only so much that society can do informally to correct delinquency of an errant youth.... The reasons for juvenile delinquency other than lack of parental care such as choice of wrong company do exist.... A healthy society will have less problems of delinquency than a society where there is unacceptable level of ignorance (Thompson, William E & Bynum, Jack E)....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

The Media and Popular Culture

The paper "the media and Popular Culture" sheds light on the role of the media in popularizing various types of mass culture and involving young people in entertainment: movies, popular shows, and other activities that cultivate ethical values in youth through their acquaintance with works of art.... hellip; Modern popular culture is the representation of aesthetic elements of human life with a colored pattern of artistic essentials for promoting enthusiasm and activeness among people....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

Juvenile Delinquency

In delinquency cases, this is mostly the case as teenagers find themselves with a lot of freedom to commit crime and the absence of deterrents only serves to make an opportunity more viable.... onclusionThe routine activities theory is best suited to explain the delinquency behavior of John as he is opportunistic.... Being subjected to violence was a motivating factor and thus he became a youth at risk....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

The Creation of Youth Culture

An essay "The Creation of Youth culture" discusses that people of a given culture are never conscious of the influence their culture posses on them.... Therefore, the question about the impacts of a culture, both on the local people and foreigners, remains an interesting subject of investigation.... hellip; The definition of culture has always been considered in the context of music, arts, literature, architecture, and language....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Assignment 2- Juv. Delinquency

Children want to associate with them and at the end adopt a violent culture (Grossman, 2009).... Col.... Dave Grossman reviews the magnitude of the violence problem and what he feels are the causes.... He reviews the size and scope of the problem.... Grossman has also listed particular causes in his review of this violence problem (classical conditioning,… According to Grossman, the relationship between aggravated assault, murder, and imprisonment since 1957 in America astounds people....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Gender in Popular Culture

The Belly of the Atlantic, presents the story of Salie, a Senegalese woman who like other woman is forced to undergo humiliating experiences because of her gender and sex.... From that, it is clear that as a result of gender and sex, she is forced into servitude.... gender, in this regard, relates to the societal perception and expectation of both women and men and the different roles placed on both me and women.... The focus of this paper is to analyze the gender… In essence, both pieces of work have represented female gender as weaker to male gender, albeit differently. From the onset, the most significant difference een the two pieces is that in Blue eyes member of both gender (men and women) are under are discriminated against because of the prevalent racial discrimination....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Differences in Delinquent Behavior between the Sexes and Proposed Prevention and Intervention Programs

It has been reported that there are two major factors that contribute to escalating cases of juvenile delinquency in different parts of the world.... Some of the programs include hosting youth rallies whereby, youth may be taught about proper behaviors and at the same time provide them an opportunity to interact and share their problems with teachers....
7 Pages (1750 words) Coursework
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us