StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Gilson v. Metropolitan Opera - Case Study Example

Cite this document
Summary
In the paper “Gilson v. Metropolitan Opera” the author analyzes the case of Estelle Gilson who sustained injuries while attending a performance at the Metropolitan Opera House at Lincoln Center. She incurred the injuries, when after the intermission and after the lights have been dimmed…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93% of users find it useful
Gilson v. Metropolitan Opera
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Gilson v. Metropolitan Opera"

Gilson v. Metropolitan Opera (15AD3d55) New York Appellate Division, First Department, 2005 Facts: Estelle Gilson sustained injuries while attending a performance at the Metropolitan Opera House at Lincoln Center. She incurred the injuries, when after the intermission and after the lights have been dimmed, Mr. Donald Taitts, with his wife returned tot heir seats. Mr. Taitts is said to be suffering physical disability and it is inopportune that upon their return to their seats which was down the roe from Ms. Gilson, Mr. Taitts lost his balance and thereafter fell into Ms. Gilson, who in turn fell down the stairs and as a result, she obtained injuries on her body. Procedural History and Posture: Gilson initiated an action against the Metropolitan Opera as well as the Lincoln Center for negligence and for violation of certain provisions of the City Building Code. Consequently, the trial court set aside the allegation against Lincoln Center, it being an out of possession lessor. On appeal, the Appellate Court reversed the ruling of the trial court which denied the Metropolitan opera's motion for summary judgment pronouncing that there were questions of fact "including, but not limited to whether defendant maintained the stairs aisles in dangerous manner thereby causing a dangerous condition which caused the plaintiff's accident." Issue: Whether or not the Metropolitan Opera House can be held liable for negligence for the injury sustained by Estelle Gilson, by allowing Donald Taitts to return to his seat after the performance had resumed without an escort or usher Decision: The Court ruled in the negative. Based on the facts as alleged, there is no foundation which existed for a possible negligence claim. Reasoning: The Court pointed out that herein plaintiff Gilson did not asset a breach of any common law duty expected to the Opera House. The Court further elucidated that imposing a duty on the Opera House based on its house rules "would in effect, be punishing it for attempting to ensure an exceptional level of courtesy to the audience and the performers" which correspondingly will lead to a new and detailed standard of care for all theatrical venues. Similarly, the Court ruled that despite of the deficiency in the compliance with the City Building Code, the loss of balance and the fall of Mr. Taitts cannot be attributed to it. IT does not appear that it has been related to his inability to see his seat due to the inadequate lighting but it can be recognized as his difficulty in movement. Morgan Vertical Consultants, Inc. v. Arco Wentworth Mgmt. (2007 NY Slip Op 50554(U)) Supreme Court Queens County, New York. 2007 Facts: Plaintiff Morgan Vertical Consultants, Inc is a service provider for elevator maintenance and repair works, commences an action for the recovery of sum money for goods, labor and services among others pursuant to contracts with the sixteen cooperative which the defendant Arco Wentworth Mgmt. is the managing agent. It likewise includes allegation of unjust enrichment. Procedural History and Posture: Defendant Arco moves for a motion to dismiss the causes of action on the ground that there is no privity of contract between herein defendant Arco and Morgan. On the other hand, herein plaintiff alleges that herein defendant is estopped from asserting lack of privity of contract as an argument. Issues: 1. Is there a privity of contract between Morgan Vertical Consultants and Arco Wentworth Mgmt 2. Can Morgan interpose the defense of estoppel against Arco Decision: 1. The Court ruled in the negative. There is no privity of contract between the parties as evidenced by the separate contracts and the bills and invoices by Morgan Vertical Consultants. 2. The Court ruled in the negative. Plaintiff has failed to identify any representations or conduct of the defendant which caused the plaintiff to act to its detriments. Reasoning: The Court provides that obligations arising out of the contract are usually limited to the parties and only the parties to a contract are liable for its breach. In the instant case, there are distinct and independent contracts between Morgan and the cooperative corporations. When an agent undertakes an action for and in behalf of a disclosed principal, the said agent will not be legally responsible for such a breach unless it can be proven that there is a stipulation to the contrary or the agent personally obliged himself to be liable. Similarly, the bills and invoices showed that it was the various cooperative corporations who received the services and goods provided for by Morgan. Correspondingly, Morgan failed to identify that it was induced by Arco to act to its disadvantage. Aside from this, it also failed to allege its lack of knowledge as to the circumstances of the contract. As such, the principle of estoppel cannot be made to apply. The People of the State of New York v. Richard Aiken (6Ad3d 236) Court of Appeals, New York. 2005 Facts: Defendant Aiken and his victim were next door neighbors in the same apartment in Bronx for almost forty years. Their families were close until disputes and misunderstanding arise between them which included telephone and cable wirings among others. Sometime in 1997, after a heated verbal argument, the victim stabbed the accused in the back. In the following years, the victim repeatedly threatened to cause injury to the defendant. In December of 1999, the defendant and the victim had a disagreement because of shared bedroom wall of their apartments. Herein defendant hit his side of the wall. While the defendant was still holding his metal pipe, another argument proceeded between them. When the victim reached into his pocket, the defendant assumed that he was to be stabbed again, he attacked the victim in the head using his metal pipe and eventually killing him. Procedural History and Posture: The defendant interposes the defense of justification. The jury exonerated the defendant for murder, but it found the defendant guilty of first degree manslaughter. The Appellate Division confirmed the decision of the lower court. Issue: Does a defendant have a duty to retreat into his home when he can safely do so Decision: The Court of Appeals ruled in the affirmative and likewise affirmed the ruling of the Trial Court and the Appellate Division. Reasoning: The Court consistently ruled that the defense of one's person and family as well as the defense of one's home is inviolable. Similarly, if the assault transpires in the dwelling, retreat is not required, but one may use reasonable force to prevent it. Evidence shows that herein defendant does not have a duty to retreat for the door way where he is alleged to be at the time of the occurrence of the offense. This is for the reason that the doorway serves as the mixture of the public a private place wherein the law provides for different refuge and defenses. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Gilson v. Metropolitan Opera Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words, n.d.)
Gilson v. Metropolitan Opera Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/sociology/1526881-case-briefs
(Gilson V. Metropolitan Opera Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words)
Gilson V. Metropolitan Opera Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words. https://studentshare.org/sociology/1526881-case-briefs.
“Gilson V. Metropolitan Opera Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words”. https://studentshare.org/sociology/1526881-case-briefs.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Gilson v. Metropolitan Opera

Beijing Opera as a Representation of Chinese Culture

… Beijing opera Culture relates to the specific way of life of a given group of people.... Also known as, Peking opera, Beijing opera represents the finest combination of literature, music, mime, dance, martial arts, fine arts, in China.... This traditional Chinese theatre differs from opera, pantomime, and drama and puts more emphasis to 'Chang (Singing)', 'Nian (Speaking)', 'Zuo (Acting), and 'Da (Fighting)'.... The Beijing opera originated from the middle period of the Qing Dynasty (1644-1911) and entails four performances that include Anhui – Sanqing Troupe, Sixi Troupe, Chungong Troupe, and Chun Troupe that reside in Beijing, Tianjin, and Shanghai China1....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Compare Musical and Opera

This paper is going to compare two genres of musical expression - opera and musical.... … In the present time, people fail to provide a clear distinction between the two, and instead define any form of entertainment performance with music as musicals, and some famous music singers confuse their musicals with opera (http://www.... In comparing Musical and opera, one can base the argument relating to their source, historical background, development and their evolution....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

The Body, Gender and Sexuality: What the Skin, Hair and body stature Say

The attempts of reconstructing the relationship between gender issues, body and sexuality is well documented in literature.... hellip; In some cases, such attempts have only created the allowance for the origination of the debates regarding the subject.... The dominant approaches regarding the topics have revolved to the racial, social and even cultural politics....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Soap Opera and Its Evolution

Wherever there is a television and wherever there are viewers, soap opera is also an ever-present element.... hellip; This may go on for days and even months. Some people just find themselves looking forward to going home or finding a television set when the "time" comes for their favourite soap opera.... The soap opera has indeed been given a place and significance that it did not have in the beginning and in certain places like the United States....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Mozart Operas and Pre-Revolution Chinese Operas Contain Surprising Relationship

The paper investigates the relationship between two music genres, Mozart operas between pre revolution Chinese opera in the form of a newspaper article.... hellip; While there have not yet been any reasons discovered for this relationship developing, it has been proven that both styles of opera are politically driven by what was occurring in those particular places during those time periods.... Finally, both styles of opera have an understated simplicity, making the viewer of the opera believe that he or she could have come up with the plot, which allows for more enjoyment of the music and the experience as a whole....
6 Pages (1500 words) Article

Who is the audience for Metropolitan Opera

The main target audience for the metropolitan opera has been composed of the older adults aged 65 and above making up 60% of the audience (Shugoll Report, 2009).... However, currently the opera is… As for the new Met Opera's product known as “The Met: Live in HD” which transmits shows over HD signal, the audience comprises of mostly What's target audience for metropolitan opera?... The main target audience for the metropolitan opera has been composed of the older adults aged 65 and above making up 60% of the audience (Shugoll Report, 2009)....
1 Pages (250 words) Assignment

Opera Means a Drama Set to Music

This essay "opera Rough Guide" presents opera that means a drama set to music.... hellip; Traditional opera comprises of two modes of singing, the first is recitative, and the second is the aria.... Claudio Monteverdi is regarded as the father of opera.... This beautiful form then spread all over Europe and Italian opera became dominant in Europe in the eighteen century.... To know more about the opera it is essential to study the different styles of operas as well as different composers....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Forerunners of the Opera

The author of this paper "Forerunners of the opera" discusses opera music in an ancient Greek as a passionate art form.... The paper also includes information about the development of opera music in France and Greek, Spain, more detailed in Chezch Rebuplik, Hungary, Italy.... hellip; The term opera is an Italian word meaning work.... The first opera verse was written in 1597 by Jacopo Peri.... Dafne is an Italian opera which was an attempt by Jacopo to revive the classical Greek drama that was quickly fading out....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us