StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

The Iraq War: The Officials vs. The Soldiers - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Instructor Date The Iraqi war: Officials v Soldiers The Iraqi war is one of the most studied historical wars in modern history both in military colleges and in historical discourse due to the important lessons that can be derived from the conflict…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98% of users find it useful
The Iraq War: The Officials vs. The Soldiers
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The Iraq War: The Officials vs. The Soldiers"

Download file to see previous pages

Like any other war fought by foot soldiers on one end and the coordinating or commanding officials on the other, the Iraqi war was characterized by the bourgeoisie and proletariat relationship. This paper will thus discuss and analyze the Iraqi war from both Weber’s bureaucracy and Karl max’s wage labor capital approach that existed between the officials and the people. In doing this, the paper will seek to bring to fore the division of labor that existed within the united states military camp during this war in relations to Weber and Karl Max theories.

The relationships of soldiers at different ranks with different military roles and how they interacted during the Iraqi war can be best illustrated using Weber’s six major principles of bureaucracy and the legitimate domination principle. According to Weber, bureaucracy is way of administratively organizing a large number of people like soldiers who need to work together in a coordinated manner. Weber made critical elements of his bureaucratic principles that can be applied to the organization of people including the soldiers in a battle field.

During the Iraqi war, there existed clearly defined levels of labor and authority meaning that there existed lower cadres who were under the control and supervision of a higher administrative level (Wasim 108). In this kind of organization, authority resided in the positions of hierarchy and there existed clear vertical division of labor. Before any decision was made within a battalion, communication had to move vertically from officials higher in the pecking order. Under this principle, labor was also critically divided among the soldiers depending on their position in the power hierarchy.

The officials higher in the administrative pecking were tasked with communicating with the defense headquarter back in Washington. Such information was passed to the commanders of each battalion who would make the communications and decisions to the soldiers who are the ultimate implementers of the decisions. Just like evident in any army, rules guide the behaviors of each personnel and failure to follow instructions precisely leads to disciplinary action. Weber described this under his third principle in which he described how rules made at higher levels are executed by officials at the lower level.

The Iraqi war was no different if compared to this principle as advanced by Weber due to the fact that rules of engagement while in the country were either made in Washington or by the coordination office in Iraq and implemented by the soldiers at the lower level. Organization within the fighting and coordination units of the United States army was also done based on functional specialties where each assignment was done by specialists (Boyer 151). As a result, the United States army in Iraq had different units at different levels that were tasked with different roles depending on their specialization.

Responsibilities within the battle field were also assigned to positions and units but not to a specific individual according to the sixth principle of Weber’s bureaucracy. The Iraqi war terrain was quite foreign and unfamiliar to most United States army generals making it important to consider experience and qualification when assigning specific tasks that affected field operations to the army commanders (Eden, 213). The

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“The Iraq War: The Officials vs. The Soldiers Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/sociology/1484937-the-iraq-war-the-officials-vs-the-soldiers
(The Iraq War: The Officials Vs. The Soldiers Essay)
https://studentshare.org/sociology/1484937-the-iraq-war-the-officials-vs-the-soldiers.
“The Iraq War: The Officials Vs. The Soldiers Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/sociology/1484937-the-iraq-war-the-officials-vs-the-soldiers.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Iraq War: The Officials vs. The Soldiers

Our Soldiers in Iraq and Afghanistan War

Since her independence in 1931, the country's political arena has been characterized by a series of coups and other political upheavals that led to the coming to power of Saddam Hussein in 1979 (the iraq crisis, n.... A paper "Our soldiers in Iraq and Afghanistan War" outlines that several years after the fall of Taliban and Saddam Hussein regimes in Afghanistan and Iraq respectively, the coalition forces led by the US and Britain are still battling remnant forces of the two regimes....
7 Pages (1750 words) Term Paper

Cultural Awareness in an Average American Soldier

For this reason, the lack of cultural awareness in American soldiers acted as a detriment during the Iraqi war.... Culture is defined as “a collaboration of shared meanings or common beliefs among an organization's members” (Colbert).... Thus, culture can be… The sources of the belief system can be rooted into the shared values which may or may not be associated with the proximity of the area they reside in....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

The American Involvement in the Politics of Middle East

Experts blame prominent American Jews for escalating the iraq war.... the officials took part in making the decision to invade Iraq.... Even in Iraq, people on the streets referred to American soldiers as Jews.... High-ranking officials in Bush's administration were Jews.... When Bush declared war on Iraq, experts say he was supporting the Jews.... The war was like an activity of saving Israel ....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

Background to the U.S. Led War in Iraq

soldiers were killed and 300000 were left with wounds.... Led war in Iraq" describes the relationship between the United States and Israel.... hellip; Based on, the recent wars that have happened in Gaza, in December 2008 and early January 2009, as well as Lebanon in 2006, manifests that the Palestine-Israel conflict (1948) is among the leading source of war, oppression, and violence.... Since the United States government has kindly shown support to Israel towards this ongoing war, the Arabs and Muslims have been dissatisfied and angry with the position....
9 Pages (2250 words) Research Paper

Terror in Iraq

Right from striking the twin towers to the Afghan war and then the subsequent war in Iraq, this incident has proved one of the most decisive events in the history.... The history from the Crusades suggests the level of their hatred against White people and the issue of Middle East in the recent past and the first Gulf war can be attributed as few of the important reasons in the backdrop to understand the general Arab mindset in contemporary Arab World and its impact on the Iraqi military....
7 Pages (1750 words) Assignment

Quality Of Soldier Medical Care

the soldiers are sufferers of various injuries and some posttraumatic psychological strain.... The authority is quite aware of the nostalgia and the homesickness, which the soldiers suffer from.... hellip; Statistics say that among them almost 700 wounded soldiers have been released but they are still in a need of treatment or they cannot be discharged or sent again to the battlefield unless they get the order from the administration.... Now the warriors are fighting the battle in the territory of iraq by endangering their life and health but they are not treated well in their country....
16 Pages (4000 words) Research Paper

The Diplomatic Role of Residual US Forces in Iraq

Under the Status of Forces Agreement, all US troops will leave Iraq by the end of 2011 (“Responsibly Ending the war in Iraq” Whitehouse.... This research will begin with the statement that on February 27, 2009, President Barack Obama announced in a speech he made at a Marine Corps base, the withdrawal of most US troops in iraq by the end of August 2010....  He said the US combat mission in iraq would officially end by that time....
11 Pages (2750 words) Research Paper

Invasion of Iraq

There is a huge controversy surrounding the literature over the iraq war, whereby it is often concluded that the Iran War was a mere display of power and the issue could have been resolved by diplomacy.... There is a huge controversy surrounding the literature over the iraq war, whereby it is often concluded that the Iran War was a mere display of power and the issue could have been resolved by diplomacy.... The paper “Invasion of Iraq” will aim at analyzing not just the causes behind the invasion, but will also tend to explore the long term and the short term consequences reaped by the war....
8 Pages (2000 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us