StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

In Support of Olympic Games Judging Objectivity - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Name: Instructor: Course: Sociology Date: June 15, 2011 In Support of Olympic Judging Objectivity This paper will argue in support of the proposition that: Because of the intrusion of politics in judging such events as gymnastics, the Olympic games should consist only of sports decided objectively, by times, goals, and points…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.9% of users find it useful
In Support of Olympic Games Judging Objectivity
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "In Support of Olympic Games Judging Objectivity"

Download file to see previous pages

The fourth assumption is that more objective judging is better than more subjective judging at Olympic events. This paper will treat each of these four assumptions as sequential arguments which, once explained, will provide a case for the support of this proposition. Politics has been intruding into the judging of some Olympic events. Straight Dope’s message board (Adams, 2011) asked posters for mentions of particularly controversial Olympic judging subjectivity. The posted responses were international in scope and covered a number of sporting events, with considerable repetition.

Examples of cited controversies with political allegations included; the Gold medal basketball game between Americans and Soviets, at the 1972 Summer Olympics, in which officials repeatedly re-set the clock in alleged bias against the Americans an Olympic fighting event in which obvious bias by bribed judges (later suspended) was shown against the Americans and in favor of the South Koreans, in the 1988 Summer Olympics in Seoul an ice-dancing event in 1998, in which bias against the Canadians, due to corruption and collusion among 3 judges, was proven judging scandals in the 2002 pairs figure skating event and in the women’s ice hockey final a 2004 men’s gymnastics controversy Research examining Olympic judge bias in figure-skating events from 1948 to 2002, during and after the Cold War, found that three factors influenced scoring: performance quality based on shared standards, national identity and patriotic self-interest, and the status of skater national identities (friend, rival, enemy) (Sala, Scott, Spriggs, 2007).

Our first argument, that politics has been intruding into the judging of some Olympic events, clearly has merit. Our second argument is that this political intrusion is something that should be corrected. This preference is clearly expressed on message board postings, but is also expressed by sporting experts who are responsible for formally managing event judging. News accounts abound about the embarrassment caused by politically biased judging, and there have been inquiries and suspensions in various scandals, obviously aimed at discouraging nationalistic bias.

In one particularly memorable case, the whole entire Soviet judging core was suspended for nationalistic bias, in 1978-79 (Sala, Scott, Spriggs, 2007). Another type of example is the report by the FEI Dressage Task Force (DTF). The DTF was founded with international representation, in response to judging controversies at the 2008 Olympics. The 50 page report refers to judging as the “most emotional issue in the sport”, and they recommend assessment, evaluation, education, clear position guidelines, and check and balance for judges, in order to maximize ethical judging of their sport (Braddick, 2009).

The third argument of our proposition is that the emphasis of times, goals, and points, in judging Olympic events, will lead to less subjective, more objective judging. Certainly this argument is a sensible one for the modern era, in which the greatest respect is reserved for science. The baseline mythology of modern science is that subjective truth is not consensual, non-replicable, disorganized, inaccurate, too often based on emotion and superstition. The scientific method is embraced as a way to struggle toward objectivity and consensus. We

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“In Support of Olympic Games Judging Objectivity Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/sociology/1425099-because-of-the-intrusion-of-politics-in-judging
(In Support of Olympic Games Judging Objectivity Essay)
https://studentshare.org/sociology/1425099-because-of-the-intrusion-of-politics-in-judging.
“In Support of Olympic Games Judging Objectivity Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/sociology/1425099-because-of-the-intrusion-of-politics-in-judging.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF In Support of Olympic Games Judging Objectivity

Highlights of the Olympics

olympic games founder was the son of Zeus.... Herakles initiated the olympic games so as to reunite warring nations.... Dedication of these games was to the Olympian gods and staged at the ancient plains of Olympia.... The games were every four years, in a span called the Olympiad.... There were no rules in this games and most focused on proving masculinity.... games in this period concentrated only on single races....
6 Pages (1500 words) Term Paper

History of the Olympic Games

The narration of the history of olympic games can be regarded as somehow complex owing to the contradictions and paradox which relate to the origin of these games.... A son of Zeus by the name Heracles is credited to be the father of olympic games.... olympic games serve to portray the talents of various players and athletes all over the world.... These games also… Since they started, olympic games have contributed to peace, tranquility, and equality in the world....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Olympia, ancient game effect art and religion and vice versa

However, according to a fable, the origin of olympic games revolves around the Greek god Zeus, who fought a… Fighting vigorously, Zeus defeated his father and took control of the affairs of the world.... Nothing exactly can be said about the occurrence of the first olympic games.... However, it is believed that olympic games were held first time in 776 B.... To some extent, olympic games helped to change the war-like situation among the city states into a temporary peace as Sparta, the most aggressive city state, used to lull sending its warriors into battle until the games are over....
6 Pages (1500 words) Research Paper

Transforming of Olympic Games

The concept of olympic games was taken by Baron Coubertin from the British history of gaming festivals, namely the Wenlock Olympian Society Annual Games.... The then president of IOC, Avery Brundage was quite aggressive in his approach not to allow commercial stakes to play a role in olympic games.... All sports historians acknowledge the impact of the Wenlock games on the modern Olympic movement.... … The word ‘Olympian Class' was first used in the Wenlock games to show the overall betterment of the people of the Town and its neighbourhood....
4 Pages (1000 words) Assignment

The history of winter olympic games

At the 1920 History of Winter olympic games al Affiliation) In 1896, five years after the introduction of the modern Olympics, there was the launch of winter sports competition.... In 1924, winter olympic games occurred for the first time under the name “International Winter Sports Week.... ?The olympic games and the environment.... Since then winter games occur every four years from 1928.... Since then winter games occur every four years from 1928....
1 Pages (250 words) Term Paper

What Distinguished the Olympic Games from other Games of Ancient Greece

The paper "What Distinguished the olympic games from other Games of Ancient Greece" states that the olympic games served very important political roles solely because of their prestige.... hellip; Ancient Greeks, along with modern historians, all acknowledge that the olympic games were the oldest games of their kind and that in fact, all other games were merely reflections and copies of the Olympics.... The age was the olympic games served as an important reason they were held in the primacy over all of the other very similar Panhellenic games....
13 Pages (3250 words) Assignment

Can Feminist Athletes Use Their Hegemony to Change the Social Norms for Women

The paper "Can Feminist Athletes Use Their Hegemony to Change the Social Norms for Women" discusses that women who have a passion for sports have been up for a battle trying to gain appreciation in the means field.... Despite their effort, there still exists a huge gap.... hellip; How women athletics and women coaches could use hegemony and Gramsci theory change the terms of the social norms and inform the success and the performance of the successful women same as men in any sports area and atmosphere and women could have the same role and right as men in a sports environment....
14 Pages (3500 words) Coursework

The Health and Physical Education

games held in ancient times on the plain of Olympia in Greece every four years.... "The Health and Physical Education" paper states that the Olympics is a premier athletic meeting of ancient Greece, and, in modern times, series of international sports contests.... hellip; .... We would have trouble reading because we could not see the letters in their correct relation to each other and to the page....
28 Pages (7000 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us