StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Analysis of How Democratic Is the American Constitution by Robert A. Dahl - Book Report/Review Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper contains the analysis of "How Democratic Is the American Constitution" book by Robert A. Dahl which is very relevant since it really increases the readers’ knowledge of the American system of politics. It reveals the fact that the American political system lacks the multi-party politics…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.7% of users find it useful
Analysis of How Democratic Is the American Constitution Book by Robert A. Dahl
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Analysis of How Democratic Is the American Constitution by Robert A. Dahl"

 “How Democratic Is the American Constitution” by Robert A. Dahl It is obvious that this book presents a positive and a negative view, depending on the many reads that access the book. One of the positive aspects of the book is that it is readily accessible and is a brief summary of the reasons why the United States Constitution requires to be amended. Looking at the book for instance, only a few pages of the book talk about the debate between the parliamentary and presidential systems that may lead to a new democracy. It is possible that most electoral systems would have demanded for more information about the Constitution but if such a situation prevailed, I am convinced that most readers would be really bored. Its brief nature is indeed an added advantage to the readers as opposed to if the book tried to cover all aspects of the Constitution that are already reviewed in records. The shallowness of the book and the specificity of the topics may be argued to raise lots of suffering by the book, but Dahl still makes his point that the Constitution does not give attention to democracy and therefore it needs to be amended (Dahl, 2003). In as much as the book really discuses almost all reasons why the Senate and the Electoral College should abolished from the electoral system, it does not cover arguments that support the importance of such bodies. If for instance popular votes were casted at the national level, it would result to a very inefficient voting system and hence human errors would be rampant. Again, in the event that there requires being a recount at the national level, it would prove to be such a problematic thing in the entire nation; but these aspects go unaddressed. This part of the Constitutional discourse according to me is really supposed to have been included in the book for the readers to compare and contrast the pros and cons of the Constitutional system and make their own informed decisions. Having looked at the negative and positive aspects covered in the book, i strongly believe that Dahl at least made an effort of discussing both historical and contemporary issues in the states. This book increases the knowledge of the reader on the political systems of the U.S and I would recommend that every fresh man in every college should struggle to have a copy of this book or at least go through its review for their own benefit. This is beneficial especially when the reader is unable to describe the reasons as to why the American Constitution is not perfect as is considered by requires several amendments. The reader should however keep in mind the fact that that this book is not actually an absolute description of the amendments and possible solutions to the problem of democracy but rather just a brief summary. The amendments and possible solutions that Dahl makes in this book still requires further literature review and hence the reader should be prepared to go the extra step to find such literature. Critical Book Review of “A Magnificent Catastrophe” by Edward J. Larson This book presents lots of positive ideas regarding the political situation in the United States of America both in the past and shows a clear reflection of the present political dimensions. First and foremost, the book presents a vivid fight for the rights of journalists and the freedom of expression of the media during the times before the 1800 elections. Before then, the media was not granted freedom to air most of the events especially those that Adam’s government was striving to hide from the public which were of course a breach of the human rights to a just leadership. Larson shows his strong stand in the support of the media by freely using the media to back the Republican campaigns while still fighting for their rights grabbed by the government of that time. Larson definitely succeeds in his fight for the freedom of the journalists and the media at large following the changes he makes in Sedition Act even before his inauguration. Moreover, this book positively supports fair leadership and democracy; a leadership defined by justice and equal consideration of all people in the United States of America. He seems to refute utterances made by his election counterpart in the government Adams that the general public are not allowed to make political decisions for fear that they lacked enough information and would make wrong decisions. Larson supports Jefferson’s campaigns and through him lets the people to understand that they were the most useful assets in any electoral processand their views deserved to be taken into consideration while the Convention was making laws. The writer vies the 1800 elections as a fight between democracy and monarchy in which the democratic aspect was driven by Jefferson while the monarchical system of leadership was driven by the High Federalists such as Adams and Hamilton. There are however some negative aspects brought into light by the book through the leadership of High Federalists such as Adams and Hamilton. Such are like the support of one man’s leadership as demonstrated in the analogy of the Biblical Moses who alone was able to lead the Israelites to the Promised Land despite their rebelliousness. An example of such a leadership is seen in England and since it is also successful, the High Federalists feel that it deserved to be the same case for the United States of America. The worst thing about this kind of leadership is that the opinion of the leader who in this case is the president is viewed as absolutely right and final. It ignores the general knowledge that human beings are faulty and can make irrational decisions some of which may even result to the death of the innocent. On the contrary, a democratic government as symbolised by the Republicans allows for corrective measures and absolute scrutiny of situations before a fair judgement is granted. According to my own opinion, this book has been very successful in the coverage of the topic as it considers almost all the political aspects of life in the United States. These aspects range from the field of democracy through leadership wrangles to the freedom of the media which has been totally supported by the book. The successes of most of the aspects that are presented by this book have been expressed through the win of the 1800 election by the Republicans who actually won against the sitting government, writing history. Definitely this book has registered a perfect coverage of both the historical and contemporary view of the United States elections since it even goes ahead to predict the situation during the Americas election of 2008. Almost all aspects of the 1800 elections were represented in the political forum of the 2008 and this is therefore a confirmation that the book not only covers historical views of elections but contemporary views as well. This book would have ended in perhaps a better way if the death of Thomas Jefferson did not come into the picture. According to me, it is like it implies a loss of the war for the factors that the Republican Government was for fighting for. To make it worse, this hero Thomas Jefferson dies before his political rival in the political realm, Adams. This book is very relevant since it really increases the readers’ knowledge of the American system of politics. It reveals the fact that the American political system lacks the multi-party politics that are experience in most parts of the world and especially in the African governments. On reading the book, the reader will be able to judge for themselves whether the system is good in terms of its pros and cons and then would recommend that other governments struggling with peaceful politics would adopt it. Following this judgement, I would recommend this book to all readers in the world irrespective of their political background. Reference Dahl, A.(2008), How Democratic is the American Constitution? Yale University Press: New Haven Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Analysis of How Democratic Is the American Constitution Book by Robert Report/Review, n.d.)
Analysis of How Democratic Is the American Constitution Book by Robert Report/Review. https://studentshare.org/social-science/1877681-critical-book-review-how-democratic-is-the-american-constitution-by-robert-a-dahl
(Analysis of How Democratic Is the American Constitution Book by Robert Report/Review)
Analysis of How Democratic Is the American Constitution Book by Robert Report/Review. https://studentshare.org/social-science/1877681-critical-book-review-how-democratic-is-the-american-constitution-by-robert-a-dahl.
“Analysis of How Democratic Is the American Constitution Book by Robert Report/Review”. https://studentshare.org/social-science/1877681-critical-book-review-how-democratic-is-the-american-constitution-by-robert-a-dahl.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Analysis of How Democratic Is the American Constitution Book by Robert A. Dahl

A Fraternity of Arms - American & France in the Great War

The installation of the Statue of Liberty in Ellis Island, off the banks of New York, as well as the adoption of the democratic ideals of 'Equality, Fraternity and Liberty' into the american constitution are enduring symbols of this shared heritage.... At the beginning of the Great War, most of the american public was aloof to events on the other side of the Atlantic.... robert Bruce's book titled The Fraternity of Arms: America and France in the Great War traces this alliance and places it in the historical, political, ideological and imperialist contexts....
8 Pages (2000 words) Book Report/Review

Men in Black How the Supreme Court is Destroying America

The author of this book review "Men in Black How the Supreme Court is Destroying America" casts light on the american constitution and the system of government.... But in this sophisticated and riveting book that is what Levin argues has happened in recent years.... hroughout this book, Levin describes many examples of judicial interference in the lives of Americans.... The book is largely written for an educated audience that is interested in law and politics....
4 Pages (1000 words) Book Report/Review

Analysis of the Book The Informed Argument Written by Robert Yagelski and Robert Miller

The paper "Analysis of the Book The Informed Argument Written by robert Yagelski and Robert Miller" states that the authors did a good job in arranging the contents of the book according to themes, starting from the basics to looking at classical arguments made throughout history.... hellip; The book tried to provide a complete and comprehensive solution in teaching how to make a solid, informed argument.... The second part of the book tried to illustrate the basic concepts of composing an argument....
3 Pages (750 words) Book Report/Review

Critique of the Book America's Constitution:A Biography by Akhil Amar

??(20) This observation is but one of the many such examples when the author uses the interpretative method to highlight his viewpoints on contentious issues that challenge the american society.... Subject: History and Political Science Date: March 30, 2012 Topic: Critique of book "America's Constitution: A Biography" by Akhil Amar Introduction This is the book with a difference, on America's Constitution.... What the book was about?...
3 Pages (750 words) Book Report/Review

American Democracy in Peril by Hudson

He highlights the eight principal challenges that are experienced by the american population as the office is taken by a new president.... The compounded outcome is for the political system to come up with an effective conceptual framework that will help in evaluating the political system of the american.... ANALYSIS/REACTION PAPER TO THE book, "AMERICAN DEMOCRACY IN PERIL" Name of institution: Date: Abstract Democracy is a concept that is highly complicated....
7 Pages (1750 words) Book Report/Review

Its even worse than it looks

Thomas and Norman published a book known as Broken Branch that analyzed congress problems.... The former speaker of the house Newt Gingrich was much interested in the book.... This book is a serious step in strengthening the congress (Dean, Pp 25).... Gingrich loved the book despite its critical scrutiny of his fellow republicans.... Thomas and Norman connected as political science students at the University of Michigan and later lived at Brooking Institution and american Enterprise institute....
5 Pages (1250 words) Book Report/Review

Management Thinker Robert Kaplan

His most celebrated work which has been co-authored with David Norton "The Balance Scorecard: Translating Strategy into Action", which won the 2001 Wildman Medal for its impact on accounting practices by the american Accounting Association.... He received the outstanding Accounting Educator Award in 1988 from the american Accounting Association and in 1994 CIMA award from the Chartered Institute of Management Accountants (UK) for "Outstanding Contribution to the Accountancy Profession"....
4 Pages (1000 words) Book Report/Review

Ronald Reagan and the Triumph of American Conservatism

This review discusses the book how Ronald Reagan was once an ardent democrat in the politics of America but finally reconsidered his position.... In the book, Reagan is demonstrated as having shown and demonstrated much allegiance to the teachings and the political maneuvers of Franklin D....  Ronald Reagan and the Triumph of American ConservatismIn the book, Tygiel informs the readers how Ronald Reagan was once an ardent democrat in the politics of America but finally reconsidered his position and transferred to what he terms as the right side of the political spectrum....
1 Pages (250 words) Book Report/Review
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us