StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Medical Assisted Suicide Case - Research Paper Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper "Medical Assisted Suicide Case" highlights that the Gonzalez vs. Oregon ruling was a landmark ruling that influences medical practice not only in the state of Oregon but also in other states. It gave the states more powers when it comes to the setting of medical health practice standard. …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.7% of users find it useful
Medical Assisted Suicide Case
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Medical Assisted Suicide Case"

Outline A. Introduction Overview of the case 2. Legalization of physician assisted suicide 3. ODWDA B. The Ruling of the Supreme Court 1. 9th Circuit Court ruling 2. Constitutional scope of the powers of the federal government 3. Powers of the federal government under CSA in enforcing standards C. Implication of the Ruling 1. How the US Supreme Court deals with controversial issues 2. Instructive ruling 3. Existing power sharing customs D. Positive Influence on Other States 1. Medical practice regulation 2. Push for state the regulatory power 3. Call for the amendment of the Controlled Substance Act E. Conclusion 1. Landmark ruling that influences medical practice 2. It helped in maintaining the custom of power separation Gonzalez vs. Oregon: Assisted Suicide Introduction The Gonzalez vs. Oregon ruling by the Supreme Court in 2006 was a decision which made it clear that that the United States Attorney General could not enforce federal laws against practitioners who prescribed drugs in accordance to the Oregon state laws in an attempt to initiate assisted suicide among those patients who were suffering from terminal illnesses. This issue of assisted suicide has elicited different opinions and views due to the impact that it has on medical practice and the life and safety of the patients. In the year 1994, the voters in Oregon supported and voted for the legalization of physician assisted suicide in given situations. This led to the enforcement of the Oregon Death With Dignity Act which allows those physicians who have valid licenses to prescribe lethal doses to those patients who under reasonable medical judgment have only six months to live. There is, however, a series of safeguards which are in place to help in avoiding abuse cases. One of the necessities is that the doctor must ensure that the request by the patient is voluntary and one which is well informed. When Attorney General John Ashford took office in 2001, he led efforts meant to overrule the ODWDA by giving and interpretive rule on the issue (Durke 78). In the rule, he declared that the use of controlled substances in assisted suicide was contrary to CSA and thus practitioners who practiced it would be held responsible under the law. The Ruling of the Supreme Court In the ruling made, the Supreme Court affirmed the decision which had been made by the 9th Circuit Court ruling. In the ruling, it was conclude that despite the fact that CSA gave the power of rulemaking to the attorney general; the same law prohibits the federal government from declaring a medical standard illegitimate including those standards which are authorized by the state laws. In making the decision, the court analyzed the constitutional scope of the powers of the federal government under CSA in enforcing standards. It established that there was no provision in the Act which gave the Attorney general the power to give a definition on what is considered to be the agreed or legalized medical practice. The Supreme Court judges concluded that the attorney general had the power to revoke and suspend the DEA registration of any physician if doing so will be in accordance with the interest of the public. This can happen when they are abusing prescriptions or using it in a way that is not consistent with state and federal laws. Moreover, they stated that the federal laws do not allows any member of the executive branch of the US government to criminalize the entire practice of prescribing the substance to aid assisted death when it is done in line with the state laws. Implication of the Ruling According to Sullivan and Hedberg, the Gonzalez v. Oregon ruling gave more light on how the US Supreme Court deals with controversial issues which touches on the exercise of powers between the federal agencies and the state agencies (41). Despite the breadth of the powers under the Commerce Clause, the US Supreme Court is always zealous about its authority in scrutinizing the legal basis of the claims made by state agencies on matters to do with the Commerce Clause. In this case, the court found that the Attorney general of the United States of America lacked any kind of legal authority when it comes to the regulation of medical practices. This ruling was in in line with the requirements of the CSA which somehow denies the executive the very powers that the attorney general was trying to exercise in this situation. Annas points out that the ruling by the judges in this case was instructive when it comes to the powers of the Congress in the regulation of medical health practices (23). The decision in Gonzales v. Oregon and in Gonzalez vs. Raich showed that the Supreme Court regards the Congress to possess more powers in the regulation of medical practices than the federal executive agencies. In addition, it suggests that the court will have to always review the existence of far reaching powers of enforcement by the congress. This struggle has always created some form of struggles between the federal and the state government with each striving to control and set the standards for public health practice. In practice, the Congress is always intimately involved in the protection of the welfare of the public when it comes to health and medical matters. They do this through the state spending, taxation and regulation of the practice. The Gonzalez vs. Oregon ruling will always serve as a reminder that the Supreme Court is mindful of the existing power sharing customs between the federal government and state government. It does not therefore treat the claims made by the federal government agencies on authority of preempting the laws made and enforced by the state laws. Positive Influence on Other States The ruling has not only had an impact on medical practice regulation in Oregon but also in other states. There have been increased efforts to allow states to regulate physician assisted suicide. California and Hawaii have stated similar push with the aim of giving the state the regulatory power over how doctors deal with assisted suicide request from the patients. Annas notes that this kind of push is an illustration and proof that the ruling was appropriate and applicable to all other states of the nation (22). Others have argued that there is a problem on how the Gonzalez ruling can be used in bringing back other US states on board. However, this has not stopped the call for the duplication of the Oregon laws in other states with California leading the line in efforts to achieve it. It is worth noting that the ruling has not given all the states a level playing field as was expected. Most practitioners in other states outside Oregon are still practicing under the rules as before. Medical groups called for the amendment of the Controlled Substance Act to allow for the use of federally regulated substances in assisted suicide when deemed necessary with each and every state giving guidance on the matter. The palliative Effect Gonzalez v Oregon Ruling During the proceeding, various medical groups led by the California Medical Association signed for the amicus brief to be on the side of the Oregon state. This does not mean that they supported assisted suicide but they did so out of the fear that a victory for Gonzalez would give the federal government and its agencies more powers to determine the standards and practices which are considered as legitimate. Physicians were quite aware that a ruling which empowered the federal agencies would have meant that it would be hard to give treatment for pain in palliative care. Before this decision, physician in some hospital and care facilities had fear when giving prescription for chronic pain. They carried out the practice even when deemed very necessary with a lot of fear since the prevailing practices and rules meant that they could be held accountable in the court of law as going against the CSA. With the verdict made by the Supreme Court, majority of physicians both in Oregon and in other states are now able to offer such prescriptions as long as they are not going against the state and federal laws. Conclusion The Gonzalez vs. Oregon ruling was a landmark ruling that influence medical practice not only in the state of Oregon but also in other states. It gave the states more powers when it comes to the setting of medical health practice standard. This decision was a positive move which helped in maintaining the custom of power separation between the state agencies and the federal agencies as per the requirements of the US Constitutions. Works Cited Annas, George. “Congress, Controlled Substances, and Physician-Assisted Suicide—Elephants in Mouseholes”. New Engl J Med 354.45(2006):10-45. Durke, Timothy. “The National Uniformity for Food Act: Implications for Public Health Policy and Practice. Public Health Rep 24.67(2006):15-100. Gonzalez v. Oregon, 126 S.Ct. 904 (2006) Sullivan Dan and Hedberg, Korlath. “Legalized Physician-Assisted Suicide in Oregon—The Second Year. New Engl J Med 342.43 (2012): 15-50. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“I will update the topic on the files, and you need choose it in a Research Paper”, n.d.)
I will update the topic on the files, and you need choose it in a Research Paper. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/social-science/1685017-i-will-update-the-topic-on-the-files-and-you-need-choose-it-in-a-files-quotchoose-a-subquot
(I Will Update the Topic on the Files, and You Need Choose It in a Research Paper)
I Will Update the Topic on the Files, and You Need Choose It in a Research Paper. https://studentshare.org/social-science/1685017-i-will-update-the-topic-on-the-files-and-you-need-choose-it-in-a-files-quotchoose-a-subquot.
“I Will Update the Topic on the Files, and You Need Choose It in a Research Paper”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/social-science/1685017-i-will-update-the-topic-on-the-files-and-you-need-choose-it-in-a-files-quotchoose-a-subquot.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Medical Assisted Suicide Case

The Presumption of Innocence in English Law

Legislative changes and case law3 have resulted in modifying the requirement of malice aforethought4 such that the prosecution now only has a duty to prove an intention to kill5 or to cause serious bodily harm6.... This paper "The Presumption of Innocence in English Law" discusses Arnold who was a member of an anti-capitalist organization committed to the violent overthrow of society....
8 Pages (2000 words) Case Study

To What Extent is the Law Relating to Causation

The author of the current case study "To What Extent is the Law Relating to Causation" underlines that causation is an element of law which connects an act to a prohibited result.... Established in the case of R v White2, it simply asks: but for the defendant's act, would the outcome have occurred?...
10 Pages (2500 words) Case Study

Biopsychosocial Evaluation

This case study "Biopsychosocial Evaluation" focuses on an 18-year-old African American female at the local penitentiary convicted of attempted suicide and possession of drugs.... The patient should be assisted so that they are able to deal with the stressors in a healthy way....
6 Pages (1500 words) Case Study

Euthanasia: Philosophy and the Law

This case study "Euthanasia: Philosophy and the Law" presents Euthanasia can be defined as the bringing about the death of a being for humane reasons, or it is the killing of a person with the intent of ending his or her suffering.... achels states that a strong case can be made against the American Medical Association's doctrine.... He argues that ordinarily, intestinal obstruction can be fixed and is not a life or death matter but in the case of a baby with Down's syndrome who has an intestinal obstruction, the baby is allowed to die because of the Down's syndrome and not the intestinal obstruction....
5 Pages (1250 words) Case Study

Harold Shipman the Doctor Who Turned a Serial Killer

In this essay, I shall discuss the crimes he The paper “The Doctor Who Turned a Serial Killer" is a thrilling variant of a case study on social science.... He was later charged, fined, and his case was referred to the General Medical Council.... The council suspended him but after hearing the case by the psychiatrists, he reinstated him.... According to Dame Janette Smith, a member of one of the committees set to investigate the case of Shipman, the doctor killed at least one patient every ten days....
3 Pages (750 words) Case Study

Issues of Transphobia

Transgender faces intense discrimination across various sectors such as economic discrimination, harassment at home, school, or work, and discrimination y medical professionals, government agencies among others.... This paper "Issues of Transphobia" highlights the plight of the transgender community, the discrimination faced based on their gender identity and expression and steps to be taken to ensure equality among all members as provided for by legislation at national and international levels....
5 Pages (1250 words) Case Study

A Critical Incident During Attachment Session at the National Hospital

… The paper "A Critical Incident during My Attachment Session at the National Hospital" is an excellent example of a case study on psychology.... The paper "A Critical Incident during My Attachment Session at the National Hospital" is an excellent example of a case study on psychology.... Similarly, Eddie (2006) claims that among the most stressful episodes include deaths of people conducting their daily assignments, a close acquaintance committing suicide, or casualty related incidents among many others....
10 Pages (2500 words) Case Study

The Response of Depression to Therapy, Medication, and Lifestyle Changes

"The Response of Depression to Therapy, Medication, and Lifestyle Changes" paper examines the response of depression to various forms of management measures based on a case study of M.... Health promotion to enhance social inclusivity of the depressed individual is salient to the management of depression....
6 Pages (1500 words) Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us